User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
keedon
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fate3283
Originally posted by musky5

returns for TDs are all based on blocking. then making 1 guy miss (sometimes you don't even have to)


Someone should tell Devin Hester this


That's why he became a WR.

Yeah this does suck because our KR is a CB...
 
Doug_Plank
offline
Link
 
Is Return Specialist SA even activated in the code?
 
GenoBong
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Rod Long
My cornerback that led Europ in kick return TDs now just runs straight into people.

Last season vs. the Top team
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=11016613

That was a typical looking return.


This season, this is the typical result
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=110222&pbp_id=1529396

71.97 speed
48.45 agility

Even return CBs I've seen with better blocking are still staying in their primary lane straight up the middle.


I can tell you right away that the first return for a TD you had 3 pancakes on that play, the second you had none. Perhaps teams are adding some strength to their kick coverage versus you? Did your team change their kick return blocking personnel/depth?
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Doug_Plank
Is Return Specialist SA even activated in the code?


there shouldn't even be such a thing. Most good NFL returners are RB's or WR's. To give CB's an advantage over RB's and WR's was dumb.

Bort needs to add a return specialist SA for the REAL positions that return specialists actually play
 
Doug_Plank
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
Originally posted by Doug_Plank

Is Return Specialist SA even activated in the code?


there shouldn't even be such a thing. Most good NFL returners are RB's or WR's. To give CB's an advantage over RB's and WR's was dumb.

Bort needs to add a return specialist SA for the REAL positions that return specialists actually play


I'd agree to that.. that would call for a respec of those CBs who invested though I would think. There are CBs who return though, I would just tend to think it would be part of both WR and CB trees.. and possibly RB
Last edited Aug 12, 2008 12:04:54
 
spap
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
Originally posted by Doug_Plank

Is Return Specialist SA even activated in the code?


there shouldn't even be such a thing. Most good NFL returners are RB's or WR's. To give CB's an advantage over RB's and WR's was dumb.

Bort needs to add a return specialist SA for the REAL positions that return specialists actually play


I don't see it as an advantage so much as a balancing. WRs and HBs benefit from having avoidance SAs.
 
Adderfist
offline
Link
 
Have Return Specialist boost blocking of the special teams and make Return specialist as a Pre-req for the start of those "move" trees.


First step - Change Direction - Return Specialist

Return Specialist - Blitz - Closing speed
Return Specialist - Headfake - Spin - Juke
Return Specialist - Lower shoulder - Stiff Arm - Power Through

Last edited Aug 12, 2008 12:29:30
 
sxewesley
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
Originally posted by Doug_Plank

Is Return Specialist SA even activated in the code?


there shouldn't even be such a thing. Most good NFL returners are RB's or WR's. To give CB's an advantage over RB's and WR's was dumb.

Bort needs to add a return specialist SA for the REAL positions that return specialists actually play


Allthough there are plenty of CBs who DO return kicks, I would be perfectly happy if they got rid of the skill, (not that it even works now), but as stated above we would all then need our points back.

I think it would be cool if the skill actually worked and was then put into the RBs elusive tree and WRs speedster.
Last edited Aug 12, 2008 12:59:20
 
Rod Long
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GenoBong
Originally posted by Rod Long

My cornerback that led Europ in kick return TDs now just runs straight into people.

Last season vs. the Top team
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=11016613

That was a typical looking return.


This season, this is the typical result
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=110222&pbp_id=1529396

71.97 speed
48.45 agility

Even return CBs I've seen with better blocking are still staying in their primary lane straight up the middle.


I can tell you right away that the first return for a TD you had 3 pancakes on that play, the second you had none. Perhaps teams are adding some strength to their kick coverage versus you? Did your team change their kick return blocking personnel/depth?


Our guys are upgraded or the same and boosted. The return guys are a mixture of similar positions yet on a team not near as good.

Its not working.
 
The Dominator
offline
Link
 
I hope a fix is being worked for this, because a lot of guys invested a lot of points into the return specialist SA. I can't complain too much, cause my guy has at least one return for a TD every season. 2 this season so far. But then, as soon as we put our starting HB in at returner, he busts a kick return for a TD, so it really makes me think all these points at the SA are worthless. My guy has a 9 for return specialist.
 
FBGProfessor
offline
Link
 
This is the sort of post to which I think a mod or dev would respond. The guy has put a lot of time and money into building this player and has done what most intelligent football people would think would work, and it hasn't. So, I think folks should know:
a) is Return Specialist SA working?
b) is the perception that there is a problem with KR/PR real or is there some other explanation to the anecdoates shared in this thread?
Originally posted by d1sregard
Wow, I thought I was the only one. My PURE return spec CB is horrible:

Strength: 16.18 Blocking: 9
Speed: 81.12 Tackling: 15.38
Agility: 48.69 Throwing: 10
Jumping: 21.12 Catching: 21.12
Stamina: 30 Carrying: 31.86
Vision: 35.96 Kicking: 7
Confidence: 17.08 Punting: 8

Shutdown: 0-0-0-0-0

Speedster: 3-5-6-0-0

I was going to get Return Spec to 10, but after I realized how worthless it is I stopped putting points into last season. Yes, I could use more vision, but my priority was agility due to the changes made this season. He still runs in a straight line, right at a tackler. So worthless: can't play defense as well as a regular CB and isn't better than an offensive/defensive lineman at returning. GG $15 down the toilet.


 
1VBChaos
offline
Link
 
You would think it would be important, wouldn't you.

I've got a CB that is pretty useless on KRs this season so far, with lots of points in SA and a pretty decent build :

Strength: 20.92 Blocking: 8
Speed: 59.97 Tackling: 20.79
Agility: 45.97 Throwing: 9
Jumping: 19.28 Catching: 16.97
Stamina: 19.33 Carrying: 13.75
Vision: 39.97 Kicking: 8
Confidence: 19.45 Punting: 8

With 3 in First Step and Change Direction and 5 in Return Specialist.

He may not be the strongest, but that's because, as others have said, his aim is to AVOID tacklers, not run through them. He's plenty agile enough, so it's not all about pure speed - and his vision is also pretty high in comparison to the rest of the stats and his level.

Last season he was just starting to show his worth and make some moves. This year I concentrated his boost points more into the SA tree and he got worse.

I've wasted a LOT of SA points that could have gone elsewhere and now everyone is realising that a slow, strong HB/TE/OT/G/etc (add BS position here) is better than the players built for the job, I may as well just retire the guy - although that will mean losing out on nearly 30% of the money I've put in, just because of yet another flaw in the game (ie outside of my control)

Yet another request to PLEASE FIX THIS!!

 
Strokke
offline
Link
 
If only kick returners could run diagonally...
 
themadhobbit
offline
Link
 
I was looking to see if maybe there was something I could do to change how my CB returns the ball and I went all the way back to basics and found this...

"Carrying - Don't want to fumble the ball? You better practice your holding ability. The better your Carrying skill, the less you will lose the ball from a good hit. Carrying will also help you make moves to avoid or break tackles."

http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=125

It is the last line - "Carrying will also help you make moves to AVOID or break tackles" - that got me thinking (and being a newb I could be way off) that maybe Carrying is at least of equal importance to Vision (if not more) when it comes to avoiding tackles on a return.

So, veterans, please chime in and confirm or deny, please.
 
Yellow
offline
Link
 
Almost 200 replies and no official acknowledgement
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.