User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Advanced Play Calling Tactics
Page:
 
Vindictus
offline
Link
 
In case it hasn't been mentioned, it would be nice for a basic starter if you can do per quarter defense and offense settings.

So same exact as now, but set it per quarter to take advantage of opponents depth or lack there of, assumption of lead, etc.
 
Exumbra
offline
Link
 
I'd like to see a confidence system installed for kicking FG's, Punting, or going for it on 4th down. I envision it working in the following way.

A 4th down confidence table per 10 yards.
If my options are Kick a Field Goal (K), Punt (P), or Go for it (G), the table would look something like this.

Yardline - K/P/G %
10 -0 (50/0/50)
20 - 10 (70/0/30)
30 - 20 (90/0/10)
40 - 30 (100/0/0)
50 - 40 (80/20/0)
60 - 50 (10/90/0)
70 - 60 (0/100/0)

and so forth... would also probably need a suplimental field, just to consider going for it. Gauging your confidence on how many yards to go on 4th.
Like...
Consider playing 4th down on X yards or less.
Where X is a dropdown box or even better, two boxes. One for yards (0-99), and one for inches (0-36).
 
Amyrlin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by
Some of the other stuff you might want to do, such as using bump & run, spies, etc., would be done with individual player tactics.


On the player or owner side? I see having some of these on the player side as being a bit difficult to work with.

What I'd envision is a "Formation Management" screen. Here, all formations in the game are listed. With each formation you can set the position/player at each slot (i.e. "When playing the nickle I want my SS-2 in the nickelback slot") or leave them at default. Additionally, with each formation you can choose your defensive shell (cover 2, cover 3, etc). Finally, you can assign individual player roles (i.e. "The MLB should spy the QB") (and perhaps percentages as well? "The MLB should spy the QB 30% of the time, blitz 25% of the time, and drop into coverage 45% of the time"). Of course, the defaults for each formation would reflect the most typical case.

Then, once you've fiddled with that to your liking, you can turn formations on/off for each down and distance group and per game situation, and specify percentage use for each formation. Perhaps the best way to do that without requiring massive input on the part of the user would be to have one "base" case and the option to specify additional cases based on down, distance, and game situation criteria. This allows the user to select the amount of control he wishes to exert over his defense.

I tried to think of the simplest solution to the user experience here, not the simplest to program :-p.
 
tsherr
offline
Link
 
Not sure if this has been mentioned (the search function being down) but here's an option that would make tactics better:

Max number of players to sub at a time. It would be nice to say "no more than X starters get subbed out at any given time." It would be especially nice if it could be broken into sections - o-line, receivers, secondary, d-line and LBs, so that you'd always have a starter or two playing (if you wanted.)

T
 
HANDSaLIVE
offline
Link
 
I would like to see way more defensive sets to choose from. Nickel, Dime, Quarter, 46, 3-5-5, 1-5-5, 2-4-6, 4-4, etc. I read the post about defensive tactics and discussing having 3-4nickel and 3-4dime defenses. That would be great but there isn't such thing as those. Nickel and Dime refers to the amount of CB's on the field. You add a CB and take away a LB it's no longer a 3-4 or 4-3.
 
tjsexkitten82
offline
Link
 
It concerns me that defense is put in before offense. I really wish they had been put in at the same time so offenses could counter new defenses. It's not a fair fight.
 
Apple Dapple
offline
Link
 
At least it's fairly unfair.

It's not like one team gets their advanced tactics and another doesn't. All teams have a defense.
 
Link
 
and the settings aren't turned on, and we don't know when they will be, they are merely there to show the interface so we can get used to it before it goes live. Since the Offensive interface will be similar we are learning both at the same time. Possibly this won't go live until the offense is ready, we don't have that information yet.
 
Donner
offline
Link
 
I'd like to see formation specific depth chart settings.
 
tjsexkitten82
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Finnious Cretin
and the settings aren't turned on, and we don't know when they will be, they are merely there to show the interface so we can get used to it before it goes live. Since the Offensive interface will be similar we are learning both at the same time. Possibly this won't go live until the offense is ready, we don't have that information yet.


That would be really be the only proper way to do this. If teams have the tactics to throw a 3-4 out there, it disadvantages passing teams. If teams can stack the box, it disadvantages running teams. Not all teams are 50-50 run-pass balanced. These teams need advanced offensive tactics to attempt to combat the newly allowed specialization of defenses to their favored method of moving the ball.
Last edited Jun 17, 2008 11:00:16
 
Link
 
But like said before, the other team has a def to do the same.
 
tjsexkitten82
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by driftinggrifter
But like said before, the other team has a def to do the same.


But like made clear in my post, if one team has a balanced off and the other favors either the run or the pass, the defense tactics > offense tactics situation will help the former team more than the latter
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Donner
I'd like to see formation specific depth chart settings.


This is a must in my opinion.
 
Link
 
I agree with you, but I wouldn't mind seeing it up soon anyways. That would give them atleast a trial period with it set up while they fine tune the offensive side. I don't think it would throw off the game to much since both def can do it which gives both teams the unfair advantage. To semi avoid your scenario all a team would have to do is not be so predictable for scouting and switch up the basic options before the game. I would like nothing more than to see both set in at the same time, but from what I read earlier in the thread it didn't sound like it would happen.
 
johnkyblue
offline
Link
 
I want to be able to set my DE to be a pass rush specialist.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.