User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Provide a Refund to the Nashville Team in USA AA#1
Page:
 
LordEvil
offline
Link
 
Yes you can set limitation of we are talking about randomizers
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Zurai
Originally posted by LordEvil

As a member of the team, WTF was Slim thinking? lol Just kidding, Really 10 , wow and we are pretty good, love Borts Statement about the randomizer, why the hell was a 10 even in the randomizer list to begin with? should be no higher than 4. I code a little as well and you can set limitations on how high and low numbers go. No matter how anyone tries to defend the reasoning behind 10 INTs, it just shouldn't of happened. I'm not bitter we lost either, hell I play on two teams that are a combined 2-38 so losing I can deal with.


Did I seriously just see someone suggest setting a hard cap on the number of interceptions allowed in a game? Or someone that claims to be a coder suggest that there's some kind of magical list that determines how times a random event occurs in a game?


He may misunderstand the whole nature of the sim and thinks it generates results and then the plays to create them?

What makes this an ambitious sim, and one I stick around in hopes of improvement, is that it actually simulates the plays action by action.
 
Zurai
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader
I do that to differentiate THIS game from the 116-ZERO walkovers that seem to constitute the regular season in some leagues. These were two good teams.


No, you do it because you think that there's some kind of magical change that occurs because you're in a playoff game - at least, judging by all your posts about it previous to this one.

Playoff games are just games. There's no evidence of any different code being applied to the sims between playoff games and normal games. "PLAYOFF!!!!11!oneoneeleven!" is a strawman. Good teams can play badly. Good teams can have bad days. Bad builds exacerbate this.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by edwardwscollins



But as said, this isn't the way blowouts happen. I doubt Larry would have been nearly so angry had his team lost 45-0 because his team's defense couldn't stop the opposing offense while his offense had a bunch of three and outs and 3 interceptions.



Exactly. Instead, we're handed this RIDICULOUS 10 interception stat line. That stat alone invalidates anything about the game itself resembling a football sim.

And the same warning I've given several times earlier this year was just as evident on the WINNING team's side of the football--they won by 45 points despite averaging only 5 yards per pass attempt and only 3.4 yards per rush attempt.

 
LordEvil
offline
Link
 
Here is a freebie
Sub Randomizer()
Dim x As Long, y As Long, z As Long, tempnum As Long
Dim flag As Boolean
Dim i As Integer
Dim foundCell As Range
Application.ScreenUpdating = False
x = Application.InputBox("Enter starting Random Number" _
, "Random Number Generation", 1, , , , , 1)
y = Application.InputBox("Enter ending Random Number" _
, "Random Number Generation", 1000, , , , , 1)
z = Application.InputBox("How many random numbers would" _
& "you like to generate (<15000)?" _
, "Random Number Generation", 100, , , , , 1)
If z = 0 Then Exit Sub
If z > 15000 Then z = 15000
If z > y - x + 1 Then
MsgBox "You specified more numbers to return than " _
& "are possible in the range!"
Exit Sub
End If
Randomize
Cells(1, 1) = Int((y - x + 1) * Rnd + x)
For i = 2 To z
Do
flag = False
Randomize
tempnum = Int((y - x + 1) * Rnd + x)
Set foundCell = Range("a1", _
Range("a1").End(xlDown).Address).Find(tempnum)
If Not (foundCell Is Nothing) Then
flag = True
End If
Loop Until Not flag
Cells(i, 1) = tempnum
Next
End Sub
 
Zurai
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
He may misunderstand the whole nature of the sim and thinks it generates results and then the plays to create them?


That's the only conclusion I can come to, but my head hurts trying to think of how you'd even go about coding a monstrosity like that. It'd be more complex than doing it play-by-play, by a significant amount.
 
MichN18
offline
Link
 
I just can't get over the fact that someone who hasn't spent more than $20 total over the last several months could possibly be so bent out of shape over this.

From the tone of this thread I thought that Larry was at least a GM, if not the owner of the team in question.

Nope, a FB. His one and only player. $20 worth of outrage goes a long way, apparently.

If Larry had spent even half as much as I have he would probably have blown his brains out over today's loss.

Larry: Next time you get your hands on twenty whole dollars, do us all a favor and invest in some Valium.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Zurai
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader

I do that to differentiate THIS game from the 116-ZERO walkovers that seem to constitute the regular season in some leagues. These were two good teams.


No, you do it because you think that there's some kind of magical change that occurs because you're in a playoff game - at least, judging by all your posts about it previous to this one.

Playoff games are just games. There's no evidence of any different code being applied to the sims between playoff games and normal games. "PLAYOFF!!!!11!oneoneeleven!" is a strawman. Good teams can play badly. Good teams can have bad days. Bad builds exacerbate this.



I don't need you guessing as to why I do anything. I've made it very clear that I find it completely unreasonable that any reputable "football sim" would include even the possibility that a PLAYOFF team tosses 10 picks in a single playoff game, period. No voodoo, no hidden messages, no nonsense. Its never been done, its never going to be done, and it doesn't belong here if we're pretending that we're simulating a meeting between 2 playoff teams.

 
LordEvil
offline
Link
 
I would say how I think it's done but I don't want to ruin it for you. I've trusted in this site that it's not like I think it is and thats why I invested time and money but when my WR can go two season without equiptment and win awards and be the lead Wr , Kind of hard to convince me that Attributes, training and equiptment really mean all that much.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by MichN18
I just can't get over the fact that someone who hasn't spent more than $20 total over the last several months could possibly be so bent out of shape over this.

From the tone of this thread I thought that Larry was at least a GM, if not the owner of the team in question.

Nope, a FB. His one and only player. $20 worth of outrage goes a long way, apparently.

If Larry had spent even half as much as I have he would probably have blown his brains out over today's loss.

Larry: Next time you get your hands on twenty whole dollars, do us all a favor and invest in some Valium.



You're missing the point. Myself and some others pointed out around midseason that the offensive side of the sim was "broken". We were in effect told "wait til next season" despite pointing out that the playoffs would go a LONG way towards shaping attitudes towards the game itself.

Today's outcome was the "worst case scenario" regarding the warning that we gave. Even a 45-0 loss would have been "acceptable" had there been some reasonable way to review the performance. But there isn't a sane and reasonable way to believe that a QB who was good enough to help a team to a 11-5 record and a 6th seed in a strong league (check the league reports--USA AA#1 is highly ranked) would toss TEN picks in one single game--particularly when he had thrown only 15 all season).

This isn't about losing a game. This isn't even about losing a playoff game.
 
reklea
offline
Link
 
"Playoffs? Who's talking about playoffs? You kiddin me? Playoffs, I just hope we can win a game"--Jim Mora

OK boys and girls the word of the day is PLAYOFFS, anytime you read the word playoffs in this thread stand up and scream at the top of your lungs.

Play-offs--AHHHHHH!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
 
Zurai
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by LordEvil
Here is a freebie


No one said you couldn't put a range on a random number. Mainly because anyone who knows even vaguely what they're talking about knows you HAVE to put a range on a random number for it to be meaningful; random numbers are usually generated as incredibly massive numbers (in the trillions and higher) and are reduced in size by a variety of methods (modulus being one common method) to yield a useful number.

The idiocy in your statement is the suggestions that A) anything in a simulation should be hardcapped, and B) the game decides ahead of time how many times a random event is going to occur.

Harcapping a simulation defeats the entire purpose. If you limit the bounds to "reasonable" numbers, you'll never be able to draw meaningful data from the simulation.
 
LordEvil
offline
Link
 
No no , Love the Denny Green one,

They are who we thought they are, The Perfection Are who we thought they are!
 
reklea
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by LordEvil
No no , Love the Denny Green one,

They are who we thought they are, The Perfection Are who we thought they are!


But we're talking play-offs.

Now if we were just talking practice, of course AI takes the cake there.
 
Dee
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader
Originally posted by Zurai

I agree that not being able to sub out players based on performance is a problem and was a definite factor here. I'm certain that's on Bort's long list of things to add to the game.

I'm just not so certain that the game was some fucked-up statistical impossibility



Despite the fact that 10 interceptions in one game by one team has never occured in the entirety of NFL Playoff and NCAA College Bowl history? (Ditto for NFL and NCAA regular season history--but that's part of the point, this was a meeting between two PLAYOFF teams.)



Just because you made the playoffs doesn't mean that your QBs build is good.

People have said it so plain and simple here. He's a level 18 QB in the body of a level 25, and even then, his confidence sucks.
One mistake, hes more likely to make another...Death spiral.

Live and learn.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.