User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Playable Cheerleaders Compiled Suggestion
Page:
 
Laggo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by wombat killer

I have no idea what the first part of your post means.

When not enough chearleaders are being made, then people will make their own just to keep up.


O-Line are arguably the most boring position in the game. People make o-line every day.

Its the same argument really.

 
Link
 
Originally posted by Checkmate187
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader

Originally posted by Checkmate187


Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader




Not particularly. The only realistic way of doing so would be to program in a "Home Field Advantage" feature--but its NEVER going to include "Boosting a Cheerleaders cup size 3 times" no matter how tingly that makes you little boys feel.



Show me the exact place in the summary post where Laggo suggests that.


Show me the exact place where ANY NFL athlete has EVER credited a cheerleader and/or cheerleading squad for effecting a turn-around in a NFL game.



I can find plenty that would say the crowd affects the game. Think of it like this (like it hasn't been said a dozen times). The cheerleaders will affect the crowd, thereby affecting morale.


But at neither the college nor Pro level do "cheerleaders" influence the crowd--they are EYE CANDY, nothing more.

Once again, IF you'd like to pretend that "Home Field Advantage" is what you're advocating, you'll surely acknowledge that you're ready to JETTISON any fantasy that folks will "build" cheerleaders and instead focus on a realistic proposal for what factors influence crowd intensity. I'll give you a tip for free: ITS NOT "Cheerleaders".
 
awesome
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by the man of doom
its funny how people hating on it are running out of excueses

why dont you just admit it would work already


Because we are getting tired of refuting the same exact argument time and again does not equate to "running out of excueses" [sic].
 
Laggo
offline
Link
 
Cheerleaders are hired in real life to influence the crowd. That is the job of a cheer. Im proposing we have the same thing in GLB.
 
wombat killer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Checkmate187
Originally posted by wombat killer

Originally posted by Laggo


Originally posted by wombat killer





Wrong. It will hurt those that don't make them if they actually have an impact on the game. Then people will do it only to have a level playing field. Having a situation where people are doing something solely for the purpose of keeping equal and getting no enjoyment out of it seems like a bad idea to me.


Wombat I see you have 2 HB's. Are you hurt that you don't have a QB because they have an impact on the game?

And about "Having a situation where people are doing something solely for the purpose of keeping equal and getting no enjoyment out of it seems like a bad idea to me." I think Ken addressed that he is not making one solely for "keeping equal" and getting "no enjoyment out of it". Nobody is forced to make a cheerleader to "keep equal". They don't affect your own players equally, they affect the team and can be hired. It's like making a WR and saying you have to have a QB or else you have nobody to pass to you. Thats not how it works.



I have no idea what the first part of your post means.

When not enough chearleaders are being made, then people will make their own just to keep up.


Dude, there would be CPU cheerleaders just like there are CPU positional players that fill out teams

What don't you get about that?


"just like there are CPU positional players that fill out teams"

Unless you are saying they will be just as good as human "players", that doesn't mean a whole lot. How many people are keeping CPU players on their team right now?
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Laggo
Originally posted by SyedAshrafulla

serious note: to uh, put in my 15 cents ('cause i'm 7.5 times the person), i think this is a game within the game that would require as much work as the game itself, which is why i wouldn't like for it to be implemented.


I do quite a bit of Java programming, and from a programming standpoint it doesn't take as much work as the game itself (since it is based off an already coded foundation). Like I said earlier

If you pseudocode it effectively beforehand, you can finish this idea in an afternoon. Theres no pbp to mess with, etc.



Again, "bullshit". You haven't seen one line of Bort's coding algos--it is blatant hubris to pretend that YOU have any ability to comprehend what it would take to implement this CRAPPY idea without wrecking the balance of the remaining coding already in place.

 
Laggo
offline
Link
 
So people will hire human cheerleaders.....
 
Packer Fan
offline
Link
 
Although I do not condone the cheerleader idea...

If I were serious about this idea, that 6 person team really should be increased to 7 with the addition of a mascot. I'd create a mascot. I'm silly like that!
 
Checkmate187
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by wombat killer

Unless you are saying they will be just as good as human "players", that doesn't mean a whole lot. How many people are keeping CPU players on their team right now?



Thats because there are more human players. Eventually people will have more human run cheerleaders.
Last edited Jun 23, 2008 15:20:58
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Laggo
Cheerleaders are hired in real life to influence the crowd. That is the job of a cheer. Im proposing we have the same thing in GLB.



You are wrong. They are hired to appear at civic functions and raise money for the team and its various charities. The Sunday afternoon sideline work is a mere formality that has NO bearing on crowd behavior.
 
wombat killer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Laggo
So people will hire human cheerleaders.....


Glad to see we have come full circle. And what happens when there are enough to go around? People will make them just for the sake of making them. That is not fun. You can try all you want to compare that to offensive lineman, but that is a horrible analogy.
 
Laggo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader
Originally posted by Laggo

Cheerleaders are hired in real life to influence the crowd. That is the job of a cheer. Im proposing we have the same thing in GLB.



You are wrong. They are hired to appear at civic functions and raise money for the team and its various charities. The Sunday afternoon sideline work is a mere formality that has NO bearing on crowd behavior.


If that was the case why would they appear at games making cheers towards the fans?
 
Packer Fan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader
Originally posted by Laggo

Originally posted by SyedAshrafulla


serious note: to uh, put in my 15 cents ('cause i'm 7.5 times the person), i think this is a game within the game that would require as much work as the game itself, which is why i wouldn't like for it to be implemented.


I do quite a bit of Java programming, and from a programming standpoint it doesn't take as much work as the game itself (since it is based off an already coded foundation). Like I said earlier

If you pseudocode it effectively beforehand, you can finish this idea in an afternoon. Theres no pbp to mess with, etc.



Again, "bullshit". You haven't seen one line of Bort's coding algos--it is blatant hubris to pretend that YOU have any ability to comprehend what it would take to implement this CRAPPY idea without wrecking the balance of the remaining coding already in place.



I saw the line of code added for playoff overtimes. Not that that really has any bearing on the overall discussion here.
 
awesome
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Laggo
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader

Originally posted by Laggo


Cheerleaders are hired in real life to influence the crowd. That is the job of a cheer. Im proposing we have the same thing in GLB.



You are wrong. They are hired to appear at civic functions and raise money for the team and its various charities. The Sunday afternoon sideline work is a mere formality that has NO bearing on crowd behavior.


If that was the case why would they appear at games making cheers towards the fans?


Have you ever actually BEEN to a football game?
 
JeffSteele
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader
Originally posted by Laggo

Cheerleaders are hired in real life to influence the crowd. That is the job of a cheer. Im proposing we have the same thing in GLB.



You are wrong. They are hired to appear at civic functions and raise money for the team and its various charities. The Sunday afternoon sideline work is a mere formality that has NO bearing on crowd behavior.
this is 100% correct in the NFL. cheerleaders are there to sell tickets and money; the crowd is revved up through the speaker system and graphics. every NFL team also has cheerleaders double as ambassadors of the team.

in college and high school, they are used to influence a crowd, however.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.