These two teams were in the same league, albeit different conferences last year. It was a 22 cap.
This team (my team, fwiw) went 8-8 in its conference and made the playoffs.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/roster.pl?team_id=6657 (Current: Avg Player Value: 382.98 (Effective Lv 21))
Average margin of loss: 82 pts. Average margin of win: 71
This team went 7-9 in the other conference, missed the playoffs.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/roster.pl?team_id=6311 (Current: Avg Player Value: 486.65 (Effective Lv 28))
Average margin of loss: 26 pts. Average margin of win: 103
The first team (effective level 21) promoted two levels to a 30 cap. The second (effective level 28) promoted one level to a 26.
One fewer win, 7 more effective levels, 1 cap lower.
Working as intended.