No more tackling alg for OT? no more throwing for HB?
Dpride59
offline
offline
Originally posted by Mat McBriar
You have to realize that defensive builds will end up getting a huge boost from these changes. I mean, consider this. Natural growth on a LB pretty much sucks. But if you had DE-like (4 majors) natural growth on a LB, he'd be pretty damn good, no?
It works both ways.
Works better for linebackers IMO. They don't need sa's to be dominant, hb's do... Also now that they can pick sa, I am sure every linebacker in the game will be going break through, so they can fend off the double teams and make a play...
Defense wins IMO
You have to realize that defensive builds will end up getting a huge boost from these changes. I mean, consider this. Natural growth on a LB pretty much sucks. But if you had DE-like (4 majors) natural growth on a LB, he'd be pretty damn good, no?
It works both ways.
Works better for linebackers IMO. They don't need sa's to be dominant, hb's do... Also now that they can pick sa, I am sure every linebacker in the game will be going break through, so they can fend off the double teams and make a play...
Defense wins IMO
Originally posted by Mat McBriar
Originally posted by Longhornfan1024
Has there been any thought given to the fact that this has the possibility of weighting the game even more in favor of the offense? Defensive players for the most part have to be built to stop anything that comes their way. Build diversity benefits the offense much more than it does the defense. With the current version it is somewhat possible to build a defense that can stop both power backs and speed backs, both possesion receivers and speed receivers, etc. Since they are different build plans but are still limited by the same ALGs and SAs, the defense can at least go towards the median and have a possiblity of stopping both types. With build archetypes, the difference between the builds will be even larger, making the difference that the defense has to adjust to even greater.
You have to realize that defensive builds will end up getting a huge boost as well from these changes. I mean, consider this. Natural growth on a LB pretty much sucks. But if you had DE-like (4 majors) natural growth on a LB, he'd be pretty damn good, no?
It works both ways.
dammit i was in the middle of posting when you did haha.....+1
Originally posted by Longhornfan1024
Has there been any thought given to the fact that this has the possibility of weighting the game even more in favor of the offense? Defensive players for the most part have to be built to stop anything that comes their way. Build diversity benefits the offense much more than it does the defense. With the current version it is somewhat possible to build a defense that can stop both power backs and speed backs, both possesion receivers and speed receivers, etc. Since they are different build plans but are still limited by the same ALGs and SAs, the defense can at least go towards the median and have a possiblity of stopping both types. With build archetypes, the difference between the builds will be even larger, making the difference that the defense has to adjust to even greater.
You have to realize that defensive builds will end up getting a huge boost as well from these changes. I mean, consider this. Natural growth on a LB pretty much sucks. But if you had DE-like (4 majors) natural growth on a LB, he'd be pretty damn good, no?
It works both ways.
dammit i was in the middle of posting when you did haha.....+1
Hagalaz
offline
offline
Originally posted by pottsman
It's better this season, isn't it?
Depends on your point of view. In the past, when my QB had good agility and speed, having him on scramble often, throw away only of everyone is heavilly covered and don't dump to hb/fb meant he scrambled like 5 times a season. Now with scramble on almost never, throw away in middle setting and dump often I am scrambling 5 times per game and getting sacked.
Does bort not know what "almost never" and "often" mean or something ?
It's better this season, isn't it?
Depends on your point of view. In the past, when my QB had good agility and speed, having him on scramble often, throw away only of everyone is heavilly covered and don't dump to hb/fb meant he scrambled like 5 times a season. Now with scramble on almost never, throw away in middle setting and dump often I am scrambling 5 times per game and getting sacked.
Does bort not know what "almost never" and "often" mean or something ?
Originally posted by David Stern
. Also now that they can pick sa, I am sure every linebacker in the game will be going break through, so they can fend off the double teams and make a play...
I call this the double reverse.
. Also now that they can pick sa, I am sure every linebacker in the game will be going break through, so they can fend off the double teams and make a play...
I call this the double reverse.
PLAYMAKERS
offline
offline
Originally posted by David Stern
Works better for linebackers IMO. They don't need sa's to be dominant, hb's do... Also now that they can pick sa, I am sure every linebacker in the game will be going break through, so they can fend off the double teams and make a play...
Defense wins IMO
wtf
Works better for linebackers IMO. They don't need sa's to be dominant, hb's do... Also now that they can pick sa, I am sure every linebacker in the game will be going break through, so they can fend off the double teams and make a play...
Defense wins IMO
wtf
Staz
offline
offline
So in other words, this archetype stuff is similar to:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=2582723
That suggestion?
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=2582723
That suggestion?
confab
offline
offline
One thing I would like to see but won't happen: instead of getting refunded flex, players retired during the offseason when all this is implemented have the option of getting a player creation token that allows them to immediately speed build a player of the same position up to the value/level of the retired player.
Bleeds
offline
offline
Originally posted by Staz
So in other words, this archetype stuff is similar to:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=2582723
That suggestion?
Hey dude, just a head's up: If you're going to insinuate that you should receive credit for this idea, make sure you edit this out of your suggestion thread:
Originally posted by Staz
I do not claim these ideas as my own. The only 'ownership' I have of this idea is that my name is on the OP. That's it.
It's cool. No thanks needed.
So in other words, this archetype stuff is similar to:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=2582723
That suggestion?
Hey dude, just a head's up: If you're going to insinuate that you should receive credit for this idea, make sure you edit this out of your suggestion thread:
Originally posted by Staz
I do not claim these ideas as my own. The only 'ownership' I have of this idea is that my name is on the OP. That's it.
It's cool. No thanks needed.
ljsefton
offline
offline
Originally posted by foshizzel17
Then rushing FB and receiving TE will be 300?
Personally I think they should just make all positions cost the same flex to create, like 200, there really isn't any reason to charge 300 for some and 100 for a few others when the majority of positions all cost 200. If your daily salaries in all leagues were based on the amount of flex it cost to create the player then fine, but this isn't reflected in the current pay structure so why have the cost variations?
Then rushing FB and receiving TE will be 300?
Personally I think they should just make all positions cost the same flex to create, like 200, there really isn't any reason to charge 300 for some and 100 for a few others when the majority of positions all cost 200. If your daily salaries in all leagues were based on the amount of flex it cost to create the player then fine, but this isn't reflected in the current pay structure so why have the cost variations?
Staz
offline
offline
Originally posted by BleedsOrangeAndBlue
It's cool. No thanks needed.
Nope. You assume that's the goal, but I just find it a
moment that I suggested something like this 6+ months ago, and it's just now getting developed as some 'revolutionary' idea. Just kind of one of those, "Seriously...?" sort of things.
It's cool. No thanks needed.
Nope. You assume that's the goal, but I just find it a
moment that I suggested something like this 6+ months ago, and it's just now getting developed as some 'revolutionary' idea. Just kind of one of those, "Seriously...?" sort of things.Hagalaz
offline
offline
Originally posted by ljsefton
Personally I think they should just make all positions cost the same flex to create, like 200, there really isn't any reason to charge 300 for some and 100 for a few others when the majority of positions all cost 200. If your daily salaries in all leagues were based on the amount of flex it cost to create the player then fine, but this isn't reflected in the current pay structure so why have the cost variations?
You clearly don't understand why the difference in flex exists or how making daily salaries match position flex cost is a bad idea.
Bort charges more for high-fame positions simply because everyone and their mothers would be making those and not the others if everything cost the same. We're already swamped with QBs and HBs as it is, so who would make an OT if it cost 300 flex?
And salary, I mean, like, who the heck cares, that is almost a non-issue in the game (in my opinion it shouldn't BE an issue at all).
Personally I think they should just make all positions cost the same flex to create, like 200, there really isn't any reason to charge 300 for some and 100 for a few others when the majority of positions all cost 200. If your daily salaries in all leagues were based on the amount of flex it cost to create the player then fine, but this isn't reflected in the current pay structure so why have the cost variations?
You clearly don't understand why the difference in flex exists or how making daily salaries match position flex cost is a bad idea.
Bort charges more for high-fame positions simply because everyone and their mothers would be making those and not the others if everything cost the same. We're already swamped with QBs and HBs as it is, so who would make an OT if it cost 300 flex?
And salary, I mean, like, who the heck cares, that is almost a non-issue in the game (in my opinion it shouldn't BE an issue at all).
Originally posted by Staz
Nope. You assume that's the goal, but I just find it a
moment that I suggested something like this 6+ months ago, and it's just now getting developed as some 'revolutionary' idea. Just kind of one of those, "Seriously...?" sort of things.
variations of this idea have been posted many, many, many times over the last 18 months or so....by many, many players...
I'm not sure what your complaint is - you just think it should have been done sooner?
In either case - I think this is a very positive step - and will hopefully be done in such a way that it begins to promote more build diversity.
Nope. You assume that's the goal, but I just find it a
moment that I suggested something like this 6+ months ago, and it's just now getting developed as some 'revolutionary' idea. Just kind of one of those, "Seriously...?" sort of things.variations of this idea have been posted many, many, many times over the last 18 months or so....by many, many players...
I'm not sure what your complaint is - you just think it should have been done sooner?
In either case - I think this is a very positive step - and will hopefully be done in such a way that it begins to promote more build diversity.
Staz
offline
offline
Originally posted by TxSteve
variations of this idea have been posted many, many, many times over the last 18 months or so....by many, many players...
I'm not sure what your complaint is - you just think it should have been done sooner?
In either case - I think this is a very positive step - and will hopefully be done in such a way that it begins to promote more build diversity.
Yeah, I just get frustrated (if that's the right word) with the fact that an idea can get a bunch of support, can be a game changing suggestion (for the better) and then be lost because none of the higher ups get wind of it (due to not really paying attention). Then, 6 months later or so, BOOM, this revolutionary idea comes out of nowhere.
It's like when you try to explain a better way to do something to somebody, and they ignore you time and time again, then a few days later they all of a sudden "figure out" a new way to do things which happens to be the way you tried to get them to do it in the first place. Definitely makes you want to
variations of this idea have been posted many, many, many times over the last 18 months or so....by many, many players...
I'm not sure what your complaint is - you just think it should have been done sooner?
In either case - I think this is a very positive step - and will hopefully be done in such a way that it begins to promote more build diversity.
Yeah, I just get frustrated (if that's the right word) with the fact that an idea can get a bunch of support, can be a game changing suggestion (for the better) and then be lost because none of the higher ups get wind of it (due to not really paying attention). Then, 6 months later or so, BOOM, this revolutionary idea comes out of nowhere.
It's like when you try to explain a better way to do something to somebody, and they ignore you time and time again, then a few days later they all of a sudden "figure out" a new way to do things which happens to be the way you tried to get them to do it in the first place. Definitely makes you want to

KJDCanefan
offline
offline
Originally posted by ImTheScientist
If you build it....they will come.
If you build what?? who will come?? :o
If you build it....they will come.
If you build what?? who will come?? :o
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.





























