User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Sorting promoting teams by record this season?
Page:
 
trentw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jamz
Originally posted by TehKyou

Originally posted by jamz


Originally posted by trentw



The one thing I see happening is if there are any leagues that somehow did not have a SSB winner. That regular 20-0 team that gets put in with 31 SSB's is gonna cry something fierce.


This is why Bort needs to take the SSB teams off the teet, and make it impossible to SSB.

There have been plenty of legitimate ways suggested to kill SSB.


Make spending SP's madatory withing a reasonable time frame. With and SP bank/bar as attributes start costing multiple points to increase


SSB doesn't rely on sps, it relied on not receiving game XP for 2.5-4 seasons.


Nice work Jamz
 
CTGuyton
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Once we shuffle it once like this, another one based on the same criteria wouldn't work. You'd have the teams from league #20 who won facing the teams from league #2 who won. This only works as a leadup to something better.


any ideas for the something better yet?? I suggested (or rather piggy backed on another suggestion) that we do this same thing, but base it on average levels of the team, or maybe some weight given to starters(as decided by the top 22 levels).. And do the horizontal shuffle on day -6 after all the recruiting is done, and before the schedules are done. this will give you the most accurate picture of the teams for that season.
 
headsigh
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Nuge20
I think you shouldnt just put all the best teams together though, because it would cause a great team to go 9-7 and not get promoted, while a worse team could go 15-1 + championship


I don't understand your line of thinking?

-Eventually these guys are gonna end up in the same place
-Great team's getting promoted anyway, because of promotion being all weird and shit.
-It's either this or putting all the shitty teams with good teams and still having no competition.
 
Godzirra
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Once we shuffle it once like this, another one based on the same criteria wouldn't work. You'd have the teams from league #20 who won facing the teams from league #2 who won. This only works as a leadup to something better.


So you really wont solve anything. Just a temporary fix to a not that broken system. Those teams that intentionally tanked this season will benefit even more when they get paired up with shitty teams. Rewarding them even more.

And yes for the people who whine about SSB teams, this will help them even more as they no doubt suck hard in their first couple seasons... wouldn't that make them pair up with all the sucky regular teams... then when the SSB team decides to kick it into gear, they'll be in the leagues of all the "crappier" teams.

Of course I'm just talking about the lower leagues. There shouldn't be new SSB teams in AA
 
jcross
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Once we shuffle it once like this, another one based on the same criteria wouldn't work. You'd have the teams from league #20 who won facing the teams from league #2 who won. This only works as a leadup to something better.


Have another based on some sort of BCS formula like strength of schedule, quality of wins and things like that. I am pretty sure you could clone one of the ranking scripts off of greasemonkey to sort this for you.

Bringing up the BCS brings to thinking of a whole different idea that goes along with a set up to the NCAA sub divisions and conferences like the Big 10, SEC, etc but with a playoff system. A whole other thread for that.
 
headsigh
offline
Link
 
And if a team is gutting, CPU filled or CPU-owned, they shouldn't be in league play. If it needs be create a "parked" league for noncompetitive teams similar to the d-leagues. CPU teams in the parked leagues can be bought during the offseason. If a team goes CPU during the season, at least mark it to be moved to the parked leagues for the upcoming season.
 
Redrover
offline
Link
 
Sorting by record only HELPS SSB teams.

My cap 14 team won the title with almost no players over 100 days old. Just 2 guards and a free safety without custom are over 100 days old.

I will be grouped with some SSB teams... you realize how difficult it is to recruit with an 8-8 record? Without home playoff game revenue?
 
Crixtala
offline
Link
 
Good idea or not, TERRIBLE timing.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Plankton
Maybe this has been addressed. I skimmed though 8 pages of this and saw some people voice the concerns but no answers.

Let's take the cap 34 teams from Season 13. If you take the top 32 records, the top league cap 42 league for season 14 will be made up of teams that finished anywhere from 16-0 to 14-2. Under the current system, every single one of these teams would most likely be playoff teams in Season 14 and get the chance to go to AA. However, with the new system, 16 of the best 32 teams in cap 42 will only get promoted to cap 46 since only half the teams can make the playoffs.

For most teams, the whole point of the minors is to get out and promote up to the majors. This new system will promote more parity in the leagues, but will hurt alot of teams' long term progression to the Pros.


Tbh, based on the requests I get all the time, many teams would prefer that. If we do something like faster promotions for Gold, we're going to get more of the best teams coming up and actually ready to compete.
 
NY
offline
Link
 
does this count for casual leagues as well?
 
headsigh
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Godzirra
Originally posted by Bort

Once we shuffle it once like this, another one based on the same criteria wouldn't work. You'd have the teams from league #20 who won facing the teams from league #2 who won. This only works as a leadup to something better.


So you really wont solve anything. Just a temporary fix to a not that broken system.


l o fucking l.
 
Godzirra
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Nuge20
I think you shouldnt just put all the best teams together though, because it would cause a great team to go 9-7 and not get promoted, while a worse team could go 15-1 + championship


this too
 
TehKyou
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jamz
SSB doesn't rely on sps, it relied on not receiving game XP for 2.5-4 seasons.


How about nightly XP by age?
Edited by TehKyou on Jan 20, 2010 18:37:45
 
Godzirra
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by headsigh
l o fucking l.


?
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by CTGuyton
any ideas for the something better yet?? I suggested (or rather piggy backed on another suggestion) that we do this same thing, but base it on average levels of the team, or maybe some weight given to starters(as decided by the top 22 levels).. And do the horizontal shuffle on day -6 after all the recruiting is done, and before the schedules are done. this will give you the most accurate picture of the teams for that season.


There's a lot of ideas like that in the suggestion thread.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.