User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Why the hell should I HAVE to remember to have my Punter return kicks against gutjobs?!?
Page:
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by foofighter24
Yes. I have trouble believing a good Pro owner can't evaluate about where his team stands. You are either non-competitive, competitive, or elite in your league. Are you telling me you don't know that before the preseason even starts?


I am saying, I damn sure hope that every owner in that 32 league, believes they are competitive.

Some could very well be wrong, but why the hell should it be for lack of trying?
 
foofighter24
jumpin da snark
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sjmay
Originally posted by foofighter24

I totally agree, and I also agree with the consequence, except they should be able to own again after a two season colling off period.


LMAO yes, because customers who you pretty much take money from for doing what they think is right for their team, are actually going to come back and try it again after 2 and a half months?????

Really?


Bort is doing no one a favor by having some paying customers wreck the game for other paying customers.
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by foofighter24
Bort is doing no one a favor by having some paying customers wreck the game for other paying customers.


Pretty sure Bort doesn't like it either,

Again, the problem is, there is no surefire way to prevent it.
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Octowned
On day -4 (after 2 preseason games), the staff should view all 25 AAA+ leagues.

If any team has lost a game by 100+ points, take a closer look.

If they don't belong in the league (easy judgement call to make... there are very rarely any border cases where a team tries and loses by 100+), MOVE THEM DOWN TO THE MINORS

Have AA owners put the option of "would accept AAA promotion." For every team you flag to move down, go review a "would accept promotion" and move the ones up who would do fine in AAA

Now you have open AA slots - but we had trouble filling these already.

To solve the problem of empty AA, we need to collapse a few regions into having only two AA leagues.

----

This would take a few hours, but completely clean up the AAA+ leagues when they should be cleaned up - stop looking on day 42. Go look in the preseason, see how rosters actually filled out, and who simply can't hang. Stop running the silly scripts and relying on owners to send you PMs to denote. NEWSFLASH: Owners who gut but don't sell are the same type who are very unlikely to request demotion.


Posted to a better spot to be read,

Pretty solid idea.
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Octowned
On day -4 (after 2 preseason games), the staff should view all 25 AAA+ leagues.

If any team has lost a game by 100+ points, take a closer look.

If they don't belong in the league (easy judgement call to make... there are very rarely any border cases where a team tries and loses by 100+), MOVE THEM DOWN TO THE MINORS

Have AA owners put the option of "would accept AAA promotion." For every team you flag to move down, go review a "would accept promotion" and move the ones up who would do fine in AAA

Now you have open AA slots - but we had trouble filling these already.

To solve the problem of empty AA, we need to collapse a few regions into having only two AA leagues.

----

This would take a few hours, but completely clean up the AAA+ leagues when they should be cleaned up - stop looking on day 42. Go look in the preseason, see how rosters actually filled out, and who simply can't hang. Stop running the silly scripts and relying on owners to send you PMs to denote. NEWSFLASH: Owners who gut but don't sell are the same type who are very unlikely to request demotion.


Solid idea, except for the last excerpt, I don't know if we want admin's determining who can compete and who can't based on builds etc,

It should strictly be based on the amount of CPU players on the team.
 
foofighter24
jumpin da snark
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Octowned


This would take a few hours, but completely clean up the AAA+ leagues when they should be cleaned up - stop looking on day 42. Go look in the preseason, see how rosters actually filled out, and who simply can't hang. Stop running the silly scripts and relying on owners to send you PMs to denote. NEWSFLASH: Owners who gut but don't sell are the same type who are very unlikely to request demotion.


With the number of admins and mods, it would not even take that long to do this.
 
Novus
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sjmay
Let's put it this way, uncapped team, goes to AA, does damn well, gets promoted to AAA, has to recruit 25 players they feel, in order to compete, so the owner recruits those 25 players, works his ass off, gets them, and his first 5 games in AAA gets absolutely crushed by an AVERAGE of 70,

You wanted him to know that BEFORE the season, that that was going to happen?

Really?


You're leaving out the rest of the scenario.

In response to losing his first 5 games by 70 each, he decides "Fuck this," and guts his roster so that he can go back to AA next season. That immediately damages the competitive balance of that AAA league and damages the gaming experience for the other 31 owners in that league.

I want him to be punished for that. He's putting his own happiness ahead of the happiness of 31 other people. Fuck that, and fuck him.

He had a choice at the end of his AA season: promote up to the challenge of AAA and give it his best shot, or gut and drop down to a lower league to keep his precious ego intact. If he promotes up to AAA, he does so knowing full-well that there's a very realistic chance that he will fail miserably for the first season. If he doesn't already know that, he's an idiot. And I don't like to cater to idiots.
 
foofighter24
jumpin da snark
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sjmay


Solid idea, except for the last excerpt, I don't know if we want admin's determining who can compete and who can't based on builds etc,

It should strictly be based on the amount of CPU players on the team.


You also have the previous seasons to look at. I don't think anyone is advocating someone lose a team because they go 0-16. They are saying there should be consequences and forced demotions of teams that shouldn't even be there.
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Novus
You're leaving out the rest of the scenario.

I want him to be punished for that. He's putting his own happiness ahead of the happiness of 31 other people. Fuck that, and fuck him.



Welcome to life.
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Novus
You're leaving out the rest of the scenario.

In response to losing his first 5 games by 70 each, he decides "Fuck this," and guts his roster so that he can go back to AA next season. That immediately damages the competitive balance of that AAA league and damages the gaming experience for the other 31 owners in that league.

I want him to be punished for that. He's putting his own happiness ahead of the happiness of 31 other people. Fuck that, and fuck him.

He had a choice at the end of his AA season: promote up to the challenge of AAA and give it his best shot, or gut and drop down to a lower league to keep his precious ego intact. If he promotes up to AAA, he does so knowing full-well that there's a very realistic chance that he will fail miserably for the first season. If he doesn't already know that, he's an idiot. And I don't like to cater to idiots.


You're right, so he gives it his best shot, and falls incredibly short, and then says, hey, maybe a smarter idea is to start over, maybe not go all the way down to 13, but let's go back down to AA, these guys on the team won't wanna do that, so let's look at picking up some LVL 40's instead of LVL 60's, let's move these guys for some cash, so we can afford equipment, and we should be ready the next time we try this,

You want to a punish a guy for this???? Really?
 
Novus
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sjmay
Definitely, but on a subject that is based purely on opinion, calling one side wrong or right is idiotic at best.


That's funny, because you're sure spending an awful lot of effort on not telling me how wrong I am.

If you didn't believe that you were right and that I was wrong, you wouldn't be having this debate with me at all.



Also, try telling an 18th-century slave in Charleston, South Carolina that the slavery debate is based purely on opinion, and that calling someone who wants slavery to be legal "wrong" is idiotic at best.




One of us is right. You think it's you. I think it's me. That's why we're debating.
 
Dub J
offline
Link
 
sjmay just misses Mal and you are now filling that role for him, Novus.
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Novus
That's funny, because you're sure spending an awful lot of effort on not telling me how wrong I am.

If you didn't believe that you were right and that I was wrong, you wouldn't be having this debate with me at all.



Also, try telling an 18th-century slave in Charleston, South Carolina that the slavery debate is based purely on opinion, and that calling someone who wants slavery to be legal "wrong" is idiotic at best.




One of us is right. You think it's you. I think it's me. That's why we're debating.


First of all,

You make yourself look like an idiot by trying to compare this to slavery, I would stop, you surely are not an idiot.

Second of all,

I am bored at work for the next 12 hours, so I am not spending that much effort at all, debating a subject that is clearly not as black and white as you would like others to think.
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Dub J
sjmay just misses Mal and you are now filling that role for him, Novus.


LMAO yes, like a hole in the head.
 
Novus
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sjmay
You're right, so he gives it his best shot, and falls incredibly short, and then says, hey, maybe a smarter idea is to start over, maybe not go all the way down to 13, but let's go back down to AA, these guys on the team won't wanna do that, so let's look at picking up some LVL 40's instead of LVL 60's, let's move these guys for some cash, so we can afford equipment, and we should be ready the next time we try this,

You want to a punish a guy for this???? Really?


When is he doing this?

If he's doing this during the offseason, then hey, great! He's actually being a smart and considerate owner.

If he's doing this mid-season, then yes, I do want to punish a guy for this.






Changing the oil in my car is good.

Changing the oil in my car while I'm driving 70 mph on the interstate is bad.

There's a time and a place for everything. The time to gut and retool your roster is during the OFFSEASON.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.