User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Thoughts on Borts new post about XP changes in the announcements forum.
Page:
 
Bigmo6967
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Maksim
This is complete BS, I built my player up and have stayed on the same team. So if I get better than them I am punished, complete crap. Ive had enough of all this. Its because of a few idiots that Bort has had to implement changes that ruin the game for me.

Congrats.

Also The poster above is competely right, gameplanning and tactics play more of a factor than levels. Bring in more tactics and game planning and we will see these idiots who stack high level players and know nothing about football get what they deserve, upsets!


Bort already said that it will not affect players who have remained on the same team building players up. Who it affects will be the guys who build up then get released and go sign there Level 22 DE in a new Africa conference where the normal guy there is like a level 8. I think +14 is a little high.
 
djfivenine
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Unconquered
Originally posted by djfivenine

Originally posted by Unconquered




Just curious as to how this will affect my team. My team medium is certainly much higher then everyone in BBB 12 but it's because the GM's and I have done a hell of a job recruiting for two seasons now.


Yea man, you and your coordinators were working hard on the trading block forums this whole offseason. I gotta give you guys props for that.

Would hate to see your hard work get affected by this.


I traded 3 players (belonged to 2 agents) because they asked to be traded. Maybe you should look into things before you talk.

I SIGNED

Level 20 QB
Level 18 SS
Level 20 FS


I was complimenting you and your coordinators on your hard work this offseason. Did you take it as an insult?
 
chad13
offline
Link
 
This is like forcing Tom Brady to throw with his left hand when he plays against the Dolphins.

Please Bort, stop penalizing the good teams/players/owners just because the bad teams/players/owners are whining about getting beat!
Last edited Jun 10, 2008 01:51:38
 
jvacc26
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jad6175
Originally posted by tciss

Originally posted by jad6175


I love all the guys who are for this, didn't see one with a winning record. Guess that explains why they love the idea, now they get even with the guys who ourecruited them.
Also the guys who spent money every season boosting their guys, will let guys catch up to them who spent nothing at all. Real nice system ya got there. Maybe the NCAA will follow in GLB's footsteps, for now on USC, Floria, Texas, and Ohio St players will have to sit their blue chip prospects because Stanford, Baylor, Vanderbilt and Northwestern were complaining about getting killed every season.



You missed me.



Do you not understand the concept that the good teams in college football have to recruit those players that make them so good from high school, competing with every school in the country?

Do you see the NCAA pentalizing those teams for recruiting powerhouses because teams like Northwestern, Stanford, Vanderbilt, and Baylor don't stand a chance against them?


I think you are missing the fact that it's a hell of a lot easier to bring a kid to Florida than it ever will to get him to come play football at Vandy. I can promise someone a full ride at Vandy, but chances are they will go to Florida because of the national exposure...
 
FBGProfessor
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by CroBot
Seriously, there goes everybody's recruiting efforts. There's such a thing as too much parity and this is it. Just because a player is in BBB and is level 19 DOES NOT mean that they're cheating, or that they're there to pad their stats. What's the fun in the game when all your recruiting work goes for naught and Bort is forcing everybody to be equal and boring?


No. He is just prodding you, ever so slightly, to play against comparable competition. That does not equate to "forcing everybody to be equal."
 
FairForever
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by chad13
This is like forcing Tom Brady to throw with his left hand when he plays against the Dolphins.

Please Bort, stop penalizing the good teams/players/owners just because the bad teams/players/owners are whining about getting beat!


This is a ridiculous idea. The Hard level cap was a better idea because it promoted retentivity amongst teams. This just dissuades that.
 
El_Windex
Baby Executive
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by MrMoose
Originally posted by Dudeamis

Originally posted by Bort


Originally posted by hexone



Adding the rule for new signings is fine with me and I have no problem with that. This will actually help level out the playing field in 2 seasons. But enforcing it for everyone will just hurt loyal owners and players that put alot of money into this game, now instead of seeing a return on investment they are being punished for it.


Like I said in the post, if you are playing "within the spirit of the game" you will see little to no effect from this update. Things such as length of time with the team and in the league are all part of the formula I have worked out.

The whole point of this update: Don't gut and stack your team, and you won't have any problems!

Ye of little faith, yeesh.

Seriously, though, all this concern really does prove to me that XP is the proper target. Things like cash and chemistry have little effect on the problem.


So the spirit of the game is to not try and field the best team? Should my oppoent's players get penalized because he out recruited me? No not at all. There are other ways to deal with this problem. You're cutting off your face, to spite your nose.


Your team? Spirit of the game.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/team.pl?team_id=2835 are the types of teams I believe Bort is targeting


And good god THIS.
 
atmays
offline
Link
 
K with these new XP changes

I was with my team since like LVL 6. Now im hitting 18.

Question. So if my team never moves up out of AA. Me LVLing up will be a bad thing?

ANd is they suggesting leaving your current team so that the guy you created and SPENT MONEY ON can actually grow like he was attended to.

Not all teams can make it to pro. Not all teams can make it to AAA.

What about the teams that fall a League. From PRo to BBB or AAA.
 
Unconquered
offline
Link
 
On a funnier note guys. Owners are already trying to use this to their advantage. I just received a trade offer for my 18 OT from a Owner offering a level 16 inactive OT claiming he should be traded since he won't get any XP. Hahaha...
 
jvacc26
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by El_Windex
I'm still not understanding why teams that are stacked, rich and intelligent won't still dominate and win the playoffs? If they catch up to you, what will it matter? Your team will have gotten a huge lead and still most likely dominate the playoffs which I'm pretty sure is the goal.


Its basically to prevent a "dynasty team"

Teams that have all level 20s now will eventually be caught up to with teams full of level 15s. Thats all this really is.
 
hexone
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by MrMoose
Originally posted by Dudeamis

Originally posted by Bort


Originally posted by hexone



Adding the rule for new signings is fine with me and I have no problem with that. This will actually help level out the playing field in 2 seasons. But enforcing it for everyone will just hurt loyal owners and players that put alot of money into this game, now instead of seeing a return on investment they are being punished for it.


Like I said in the post, if you are playing "within the spirit of the game" you will see little to no effect from this update. Things such as length of time with the team and in the league are all part of the formula I have worked out.

The whole point of this update: Don't gut and stack your team, and you won't have any problems!

Ye of little faith, yeesh.

Seriously, though, all this concern really does prove to me that XP is the proper target. Things like cash and chemistry have little effect on the problem.


So the spirit of the game is to not try and field the best team? Should my oppoent's players get penalized because he out recruited me? No not at all. There are other ways to deal with this problem. You're cutting off your face, to spite your nose.


Your team? Spirit of the game.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/team.pl?team_id=2835 are the types of teams I believe Bort is targeting


I was also relegated this past season after recieving a gutted team. Like I mentioned to another player, go look at my game to game log and tell me that all these players on my team were signed all at once. They grew with the team and went through my losing records in hopes of a better season. And now that I recruited hard and brought in pieces to bring us back up to the AAA I can be hurt for it. So go over the team, take notes on recruiting and get back to me later.
 
lalonghorn
offline
Link
 
Two comments:

1) What if team A has every player on its roster boost for 3 or 4 seasons, but the average team in team A's league only has 40% or 50% of its players boost? This is going to lead to a big disparity in levels between team A's players and the median after that 3rd or 4th season. Assuming Team A doesn't get promoted during this time, is Team A going to get punished? If so, the new rule will provide a disincentive for boosting.

2) No matter how little of an impact you say it will have, the unknown aspect of the formula will cause a disproportionate effect on higher-level players' willingness to go to leagues if they're above the median level. For instance, is a level 16 player going to want to play in a level 13 median league? Even if the formula costs that player 1 XP a game (or even 0 XP per game), there's no way for them to know that since they don't know the formula. As far as they can tell, it could cost them double digit XP per game, which could add up over the course of a long season.
 
seven7
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Dudeamis
Originally posted by djfivenine

This is not the right area to target Bort!
I know this game has a big problem with the higher level team always winning. But averaging out the levels of the teams is NOT the answer.
It is the ability to give us more options for TACTICS!
3-4 defense, cover 2 defense, spread offense, power running offense, option offense.
Blitz options, special substitutions, better predictions for the other team's strategy.

If those things are implemented, teams will start winning because their owner and coordinators are smarter and they out witted the other team.

I, for one, will not feel good beating a higher level team if I knew this rule was the reason.


seriously this new rule is a waste of your time. Try making the game better instead of nerfing good recruiters.

so you think a lv 8 going up against a lv 19 is fair? just because you recruited better? i don't own a team yet , all i have is players and i want to see an even playing field for us all , no sense in higher players beating up on the low league guys at all =( lets keep this game balanced and maybe it'll be more fun for us all.
 
tciss
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jad6175
Originally posted by tciss

Originally posted by jad6175


I love all the guys who are for this, didn't see one with a winning record. Guess that explains why they love the idea, now they get even with the guys who ourecruited them.
Also the guys who spent money every season boosting their guys, will let guys catch up to them who spent nothing at all. Real nice system ya got there. Maybe the NCAA will follow in GLB's footsteps, for now on USC, Floria, Texas, and Ohio St players will have to sit their blue chip prospects because Stanford, Baylor, Vanderbilt and Northwestern were complaining about getting killed every season.



You missed me.



Do you not understand the concept that the good teams in college football have to recruit those players that make them so good from high school, competing with every school in the country?

Do you see the NCAA pentalizing those teams for recruiting powerhouses because teams like Northwestern, Stanford, Vanderbilt, and Baylor don't stand a chance against them?


Totally agree with your point. But what we are talking about here is the equivalent of NFL players coming down to NCAA. They will play great as the GLB players will, but they will not improve as quickly as the NCAA players they play against.
 
Link
 
Atleast give every team 2 player exemptions so it is easier to keep 2 star players. They are hard to come by and it sucks if they can't get their XP they'll never want to stay therefore costing a team that once had a great player to have to settle for a below average guy because that's all that was a available or would sign
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.