User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > XP bonus for playing at or above your level
Page:
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by FairForever
Originally posted by Ken1

Originally posted by FairForever


This would be viable if there were more than 1 team per conference promoted.

The way it is now, you're stuck with menial competition? Get a menial team.

Ideally, as Serenity said, a small XP boost for playing better opponents with no XP penalty for playing worse ones would be good.

The fact is that the Silverymoon Elves had two players leave, and two players join (or something to that extent). Continuity should be rewarded, not punished.


The idea is to give the players who are too high level for their league incentive to leave.

People who've put together teams with many players way above their opponents' levels will, of course, be really angry about this; but they should realize they managed to use a very flawed system extremely well (to their credit), but now they have to suck it up and compete on a fairer playing field.

Without the exp penalty, there's nothing to keep teams from continuing to stockpile players well above league levels. With it, most top players won't sign and take the 10% exp hit (though they still would be allowed to).

There should be a pretty generous fudge factor for players who've been on a team for more than a season, but even that should have some limit.


That's stupid. The level cap was a much better idea, because it promoted continuity. Stick with your team for the long haul.

And there is something to keep teams from stockpiling high level talent. The fact that there's only so many high-leveled guys in the game, and the fact that the level gap shrinks every season quite significantly.

The Level cap allows for long-term development. The truth is that many of the Elves started out as level 1s or 4s last season. Punish them now because they've stuck together and played well?


The level cap for new signings is another good solution.

The problem is that any solution Bort puts forward will be shot down by the "I don't care about parity" Power Gamers. I really want to pick one, as long as it doesn't truly force anyone to leave a team they're on, and implement it, Power Gamers be damned.

A key to what I support here is that it doesn't force anyone to leave anywhere. It does incentivize it, but even then I suggested a higher fudge factor of 30% for those who've been with the team for over a year.

Those who are more than 30% above over 2/3 of the used players in the league likely were ringers when they were brought in, not just ringers now.
 
Piemaster
offline
Link
 
I agree that the one problem with this idea is players who have been on the team a long time and still find themselves over-levelled. My solution would be that the XP reduction is cut by 25% for each year the player has been witht he team.

So imagine a player who would receive 24XP usually but would only receive 12XP if he played on a particular team because his level is too high. That is a difference of 12XP. This would be reduced by 3 for every full year he had been on the team.

So if he had been on the team under a season he would get 12XP
1-2 season, 15XP
2-3 seasons, 18XP
3-4 seasons, 21Xp
>4 seasons the full 24XP
 
FairForever
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1

A key to what I support here is that it doesn't force anyone to leave anywhere. It does incentivize it, but even then I suggested a higher fudge factor of 30% for those who've been with the team for over a year.

Those who are more than 30% above over 2/3 of the used players in the league likely were ringers when they were brought in, not just ringers now.


The thing is that many aren't ringers. The lv 14 and 15 guys made at the end of season 1 were level 4 when they joined the BBB teams. Now if they boost at the start of the season, they'll be considered too strong for their league and get reduced XP.

See the problem?
 
Painmaker
offline
Link
 
I mentioned this in one of the many other threads on this, but it's getting buried. An economical alternative to the XP idea is to put teeth into the economics:

Originally posted by Painmaker
How about an equipment maintenance fee that is level-based? Say, each point of equipment bonus has a daily cost of $2 x player level? A level 10 player with 8 points of equipment bonus has to pay an additional $160 a day, while a level 20 with +12 needs to pay an extra $480 a day to keep playing up to his potential. That puts more economic pressure on teams than is currently in place.


Equipment that hasn't been maintained would cost 3x the daily maintenance fee to return to working condition. Numbers obviously subject to tweaking for ideal balance.



Add that to a significant difference in income between leagues (make "expected prices" vary significantly, so that a Pro League team makes about 10x what a BBB team makes) and players will quickly sort themselves out according to what leagues can afford them. Every time a team is promoted, they can afford to seek higher-level talent, and the relegated teams will be pressured to unload their overpriced stars or find other ways to cut costs.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by FairForever
Originally posted by Ken1


A key to what I support here is that it doesn't force anyone to leave anywhere. It does incentivize it, but even then I suggested a higher fudge factor of 30% for those who've been with the team for over a year.

Those who are more than 30% above over 2/3 of the used players in the league likely were ringers when they were brought in, not just ringers now.


The thing is that many aren't ringers. The lv 14 and 15 guys made at the end of season 1 were level 4 when they joined the BBB teams. Now if they boost at the start of the season, they'll be considered too strong for their league and get reduced XP.

See the problem?


I see what you're saying, but:

1) Remember, the levels move with the league, and

2) I don't think 14-15 is that high for USA BBB leagues now. The 70th percentile of used players (20+ snaps), plus the 30% fudge factor for being on a team over one season should easily cover them. Heck, I have level 14-15 players on a BBB team, so if the players you're speaking of feel the pain, so would I. Mine might, once they boost. I'll pay that price for a fairer game.

However, my first thought was a 10% automatic fudge factor. What if the fudge factor kept growing by 20% each season with the same team? So, in the first season with a team, 10%; second season, 30%; third season, 50%, etc.?

Eventually players who'd been with a team long-term would have such a high fudge factor they could be almost any level.
 
notthegint
offline
Link
 
Okay, take each individual league level average, weighted toward the top players (not toward starters to eliminate depth chart tampering.)

Players 5-6 levels below this receive +10% to XP. Players 5-6 levels above this receive -10% XP.

This is not scalable. 5-6 below you get +10%, 5-6 above you get -10%.

Put together a team of level 1s in pro, they will level 10% faster than they otherwise would've. I doubt that's particularly exploitable.

If you have a higher level team that for some reason keeps choking in the playoffs, this introduces a slight "window" pressure... get over the hump sooner as people will be catching you on a level basis faster (leaving you to compete sheerly on the level of tactics and build... the HORROR!)

Besides, if you're only a couple levels higher than the rest of the league the bonus falls out of effect anyway.

The biggest thing wrong about this game is the giant blowouts. We shouldn't be seeing 100+ point games. There shouldn't be a lineman with 270 pancakes for the year, etc.

This plus higher minimum salaries plus a slightly more agressive relegation/promotion approach should help teams level out levelwise... shifting importance to tactics and build, which are the best parts of this game anyway.
 
Piemaster
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by notthegint
Okay, take each individual league level average, weighted toward the top players (not toward starters to eliminate depth chart tampering.)

Players 5-6 levels below this receive +10% to XP. Players 5-6 levels above this receive -10% XP.

This is not scalable. 5-6 below you get +10%, 5-6 above you get -10%.

Put together a team of level 1s in pro, they will level 10% faster than they otherwise would've. I doubt that's particularly exploitable.


The problem is that a 10% penalty is not nearly enough of a deterent to prevent the behaviour Bort is talking about. It would probably need a scalable penalty going up to 75%+. Obviously if you mirrored this at the bottom end then levelling 75% faster is hugely exploitable.

That's why we need to get away from the idea of making the carrot as big as the stick and just focus on the stick for now.
 
notthegint
offline
Link
 
That would be why I mentioned this as part of a larger strategy. Pair this with higher minimum salaries (to make it harder for teams to pay ringer type players) and more agressive relegation / promotion (to sort out team quality faster) and you solve the problem quickly with none of the residue you'd get from cranking any of the individual solutions too hard.
Last edited Jun 7, 2008 15:09:44
 
thunderdoozer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1

However, my first thought was a 10% automatic fudge factor. What if the fudge factor kept growing by 20% each season with the same team? So, in the first season with a team, 10%; second season, 30%; third season, 50%, etc.?

Eventually players who'd been with a team long-term would have such a high fudge factor they could be almost any level.


Your idea reminds me of this: http://youtube.com/watch?v=lj3iNxZ8Dww
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by thunderdoozer
Originally posted by Ken1


However, my first thought was a 10% automatic fudge factor. What if the fudge factor kept growing by 20% each season with the same team? So, in the first season with a team, 10%; second season, 30%; third season, 50%, etc.?

Eventually players who'd been with a team long-term would have such a high fudge factor they could be almost any level.


Your idea reminds me of this: http://youtube.com/watch?v=lj3iNxZ8Dww


Your response makes me think: Power Gamer. Ignore. Next?
 
thunderdoozer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by thunderdoozer

Originally posted by Ken1



However, my first thought was a 10% automatic fudge factor. What if the fudge factor kept growing by 20% each season with the same team? So, in the first season with a team, 10%; second season, 30%; third season, 50%, etc.?

Eventually players who'd been with a team long-term would have such a high fudge factor they could be almost any level.


Your idea reminds me of this: http://youtube.com/watch?v=lj3iNxZ8Dww


Your response makes me think: Power Gamer. Ignore. Next?


Your idea is so blantantly exploitable by power gamers that I have no choice but to call you a hypocrite.
 
siquu
offline
Link
 
No No NO. Horrible idea.

What do you think the guys at level 28-30 at the start of season 4 will do? Stay in the Pro league and gain 1.5 levels, or drop down to BBB Africa and only gain 1/2 level?

They could go to BBB Africa and help their friend and return to the Pros a year or 2 later with a very minimal hit to experience.

A hard cap is not a good idea.

You need a implement the "Variable Level Restrictor"® with the help of your league average chart.

For example:

The D-League averages level 4-5.
After 1 year, BBB averages 10-11.

So Africa should average around 6-7.

Give Africa a Max Day 1 Season 3 level of 10.

The average level increases as the season progresses, so by the end of Season 3, the average level of Africa is 10-11, with a Max Day 1 Season 4 level at 14.

I would also allow the player to resign with the team he originally signed with even if he exceeds the cap. However, if he is traded away or released, then he cannot resign with them if he is over the cap.
 
kostitsyn
offline
Link
 
Alright.

Let's say, my guy is level 21, I want to make the playoffs, but good team in USA pro league arent interested in my guy cause they are already deep at my position. I gotta sign in a lower league, but in lower league especially you cant trust many GM's. I signed for a guy that i didnt know once and he screwed me over so I'm not interested in trying my luck any time soon. I want to play on a team i know the manager a little. Most are like USA BBB, Canada AAA, EE AAA and stuff. Those league level are lower.

My guy gets better slower soi next time my contract expires my guy will have an even harder time finding room in USA Pro. What are my options? I pay to help the game and develope my guys, but suddenly my ceiling are lower because I cant find a team that suits my needs in USA Pro.

And on the other side, a guy could just buy a team in USA pro, get only level 1 on it, make the league elss competitive and up his ceiling by like 15%. I dont see why it should happen. The guy instead of getting 12000 XP(12 levels) pre boost he gets 13800. That's like 2 more levels so he's be level 17 instead of being level 15.

The level 15, will have to start in D-league so even elss XP before finding a low levl league that will want his player so no big XP boost and stuff. Reacing level 14-15 will be evn harder to reach after a season while the guy that screws a league up will reach level 17. It doesnt really work...
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by thunderdoozer
Originally posted by Ken1

Originally posted by thunderdoozer


Originally posted by Ken1




However, my first thought was a 10% automatic fudge factor. What if the fudge factor kept growing by 20% each season with the same team? So, in the first season with a team, 10%; second season, 30%; third season, 50%, etc.?

Eventually players who'd been with a team long-term would have such a high fudge factor they could be almost any level.


Your idea reminds me of this: http://youtube.com/watch?v=lj3iNxZ8Dww


Your response makes me think: Power Gamer. Ignore. Next?


Your idea is so blantantly exploitable by power gamers that I have no choice but to call you a hypocrite.


Explain how, then.
 
AgentTBC
offline
Link
 
Bort: The problem with this sort of thing is that it only makes sense to institute it after the leagues have run for a few seasons to promote/demote teams. Otherwise you'd have to go in and manually move teams around before instituting it or a lot of teams in the lower leagues would get screwed. Let's say that out of the 16 teams in a BBB conference there are 4 that are really good. It'll take 4 seasons to promote all of those into the next higher league; until that happens it isn't realy fair to start penalizing people.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.