Originally posted by FairForever
Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by FairForever
This would be viable if there were more than 1 team per conference promoted.
The way it is now, you're stuck with menial competition? Get a menial team.
Ideally, as Serenity said, a small XP boost for playing better opponents with no XP penalty for playing worse ones would be good.
The fact is that the Silverymoon Elves had two players leave, and two players join (or something to that extent). Continuity should be rewarded, not punished.
The idea is to give the players who are too high level for their league incentive to leave.
People who've put together teams with many players way above their opponents' levels will, of course, be really angry about this; but they should realize they managed to use a very flawed system extremely well (to their credit), but now they have to suck it up and compete on a fairer playing field.
Without the exp penalty, there's nothing to keep teams from continuing to stockpile players well above league levels. With it, most top players won't sign and take the 10% exp hit (though they still would be allowed to).
There should be a pretty generous fudge factor for players who've been on a team for more than a season, but even that should have some limit.
That's stupid. The level cap was a much better idea, because it promoted continuity. Stick with your team for the long haul.
And there is something to keep teams from stockpiling high level talent. The fact that there's only so many high-leveled guys in the game, and the fact that the level gap shrinks every season quite significantly.
The Level cap allows for long-term development. The truth is that many of the Elves started out as level 1s or 4s last season. Punish them now because they've stuck together and played well?
The level cap for new signings is another good solution.
The problem is that any solution Bort puts forward will be shot down by the "I don't care about parity" Power Gamers. I really want to pick one, as long as it doesn't truly force anyone to leave a team they're on, and implement it, Power Gamers be damned.
A key to what I support here is that it doesn't force anyone to leave anywhere. It does incentivize it, but even then I suggested a higher fudge factor of 30% for those who've been with the team for over a year.
Those who are more than 30% above over 2/3 of the used players in the league likely were ringers when they were brought in, not just ringers now.
Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by FairForever
This would be viable if there were more than 1 team per conference promoted.
The way it is now, you're stuck with menial competition? Get a menial team.
Ideally, as Serenity said, a small XP boost for playing better opponents with no XP penalty for playing worse ones would be good.
The fact is that the Silverymoon Elves had two players leave, and two players join (or something to that extent). Continuity should be rewarded, not punished.
The idea is to give the players who are too high level for their league incentive to leave.
People who've put together teams with many players way above their opponents' levels will, of course, be really angry about this; but they should realize they managed to use a very flawed system extremely well (to their credit), but now they have to suck it up and compete on a fairer playing field.
Without the exp penalty, there's nothing to keep teams from continuing to stockpile players well above league levels. With it, most top players won't sign and take the 10% exp hit (though they still would be allowed to).
There should be a pretty generous fudge factor for players who've been on a team for more than a season, but even that should have some limit.
That's stupid. The level cap was a much better idea, because it promoted continuity. Stick with your team for the long haul.
And there is something to keep teams from stockpiling high level talent. The fact that there's only so many high-leveled guys in the game, and the fact that the level gap shrinks every season quite significantly.
The Level cap allows for long-term development. The truth is that many of the Elves started out as level 1s or 4s last season. Punish them now because they've stuck together and played well?
The level cap for new signings is another good solution.
The problem is that any solution Bort puts forward will be shot down by the "I don't care about parity" Power Gamers. I really want to pick one, as long as it doesn't truly force anyone to leave a team they're on, and implement it, Power Gamers be damned.
A key to what I support here is that it doesn't force anyone to leave anywhere. It does incentivize it, but even then I suggested a higher fudge factor of 30% for those who've been with the team for over a year.
Those who are more than 30% above over 2/3 of the used players in the league likely were ringers when they were brought in, not just ringers now.






























