You can fool opponents I guess by being one dimensional, and this might open up more runs by the FB's since you could have your elusive in facing speedy outside runners and you slam the FB up the middle.
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Tagging players is ready
maizenhops
offline
offline
the main problem right now is trying to make it less time consuming for dcs....not sure it is possible
Originally posted by butler312
So does this mean that all those 1 dimensional TEs who used to dominate will now suck and all the balanced TEs that used to be lolbuilds will now rule the game? At least if you are in a league with a DC who will spend the time on it.
No.
Balanced TE will still suck.
TEs will need more confidence, to overcome morale hits when they are playing as decoys.
So does this mean that all those 1 dimensional TEs who used to dominate will now suck and all the balanced TEs that used to be lolbuilds will now rule the game? At least if you are in a league with a DC who will spend the time on it.
No.
Balanced TE will still suck.
TEs will need more confidence, to overcome morale hits when they are playing as decoys.
Originally posted by drakeborn
This is just the wrong implementation. Period.
With the permutations of HB tags, TE tags, and QB tags alone, you're talking about a DAI 8x to 50x as long as it is now, depending on how specific you want to be.
Even discounting FBs (a mistake) and only covering the basics, we're talking a eightfold increase in the DAI:
Power HB + Pass QB + Block TE
Elusive HB + Pass QB + Block TE
Scat HB + Pass QB + Bock TE
Power HB + Rush QB + Block TE
Elusive HB + Rush QB + Block TE
Power HB + Pass QB + Receiving TE
Elusive HB + Pass QB + Receiving TE
Scat HB + Pass QB + Receiving TE
Ugh. If this is the solution to the silly OAI personnel selections, I won't be sticking around GLB long-term.
You forgot the FBs : Blocking , rushing, catching
This is just the wrong implementation. Period.
With the permutations of HB tags, TE tags, and QB tags alone, you're talking about a DAI 8x to 50x as long as it is now, depending on how specific you want to be.
Even discounting FBs (a mistake) and only covering the basics, we're talking a eightfold increase in the DAI:
Power HB + Pass QB + Block TE
Elusive HB + Pass QB + Block TE
Scat HB + Pass QB + Bock TE
Power HB + Rush QB + Block TE
Elusive HB + Rush QB + Block TE
Power HB + Pass QB + Receiving TE
Elusive HB + Pass QB + Receiving TE
Scat HB + Pass QB + Receiving TE
Ugh. If this is the solution to the silly OAI personnel selections, I won't be sticking around GLB long-term.
You forgot the FBs : Blocking , rushing, catching
taurran
offline
offline
Originally posted by DL24
Originally posted by taurran
Bye bye any offensive threat.
I bet all the piss poor DC's will still be bitching that they're at a disadvantage and that an OPC would totally off balance the game...
Fuck you, Bort.
I lol'd
Any defensive additions sucks, and will totally unbalance the game amirite?
Don't be a dimwit.
As it will stand, there is little to no reason to gameplan as an OC. A well built defense will be able to cover any and every situation with the proper recruiting and personell. It was already hard enough to find a single hole in a well planned defense, now it will be near impossible.
The game is currently very unrealistic as your opponent has access to 100% of your playbook. It's like an NFL OC walking over to the DC before a game and handing them the plans to his offense. How the fuck is that balanced? Half of the plays in the playbook are worthless as-is and aren't even worth calling.
Now, we've basically reverted back to OC's simply calling the highest % plays over, and over, and over, and over, because there is absolutely zero creativity to a completely predictable offense. The strategy element is diminished for the offense because defense can control the entire field without much adjustment whatsoever.
Now that DC's have what they want. The offense NEEDS an OPC!
The defense has every single advantage in the game now, including the ridiculous coverage that makes WRs next to worthless. Now, on top of that, we've got to water down our builds again to even attempt to keep the DC on their toes. The selective slots we had as our only real tool to strategize is worthless. All HB's will now require catching, and all TE's once again require blocking and catching skills. Meanwhile, the defense can field whatever specialized builds they want as they are totally reactive to the offense.
Being an OC in this game sucks balls. It already takes 1-2 hours to gameplan for a competitive game, now it's just going to be that much more of a waste of time.
Originally posted by taurran
Bye bye any offensive threat.
I bet all the piss poor DC's will still be bitching that they're at a disadvantage and that an OPC would totally off balance the game...
Fuck you, Bort.
I lol'd
Any defensive additions sucks, and will totally unbalance the game amirite?
Don't be a dimwit.
As it will stand, there is little to no reason to gameplan as an OC. A well built defense will be able to cover any and every situation with the proper recruiting and personell. It was already hard enough to find a single hole in a well planned defense, now it will be near impossible.
The game is currently very unrealistic as your opponent has access to 100% of your playbook. It's like an NFL OC walking over to the DC before a game and handing them the plans to his offense. How the fuck is that balanced? Half of the plays in the playbook are worthless as-is and aren't even worth calling.
Now, we've basically reverted back to OC's simply calling the highest % plays over, and over, and over, and over, because there is absolutely zero creativity to a completely predictable offense. The strategy element is diminished for the offense because defense can control the entire field without much adjustment whatsoever.
Now that DC's have what they want. The offense NEEDS an OPC!
The defense has every single advantage in the game now, including the ridiculous coverage that makes WRs next to worthless. Now, on top of that, we've got to water down our builds again to even attempt to keep the DC on their toes. The selective slots we had as our only real tool to strategize is worthless. All HB's will now require catching, and all TE's once again require blocking and catching skills. Meanwhile, the defense can field whatever specialized builds they want as they are totally reactive to the offense.
Being an OC in this game sucks balls. It already takes 1-2 hours to gameplan for a competitive game, now it's just going to be that much more of a waste of time.
taurran
offline
offline
Originally posted by kalkmanc
the main problem right now is trying to make it less time consuming for dcs....not sure it is possible
Who the fuck are you kidding? It takes 5x as long for an OC to plan than it does a DC. The offensive AI requires a level of detail far and above anything DCs have ever had to put up with.
A DC will still be able to set up a blanket defense at the start of the season, and get by only making minimal adjustments/shifts based on rushing defense.
The passing game is just set-it-and-forget-it. You've got all our plays, and know exactly when they're coming. Why bother even changing them when you've got godly pass coverage with inferior builds, and now you can cover every single HB route with ease?
the main problem right now is trying to make it less time consuming for dcs....not sure it is possible
Who the fuck are you kidding? It takes 5x as long for an OC to plan than it does a DC. The offensive AI requires a level of detail far and above anything DCs have ever had to put up with.
A DC will still be able to set up a blanket defense at the start of the season, and get by only making minimal adjustments/shifts based on rushing defense.
The passing game is just set-it-and-forget-it. You've got all our plays, and know exactly when they're coming. Why bother even changing them when you've got godly pass coverage with inferior builds, and now you can cover every single HB route with ease?
taurran
offline
offline
Originally posted by Mightyhalo
To go from "Hey Bort do something about the way the defense reacts to QB runs" to tagging players was a ridiculous jump.
I agree. We can't even swap out QB's without exploiting a TE slot.
These same whining/crying DCs are the ones that want to be able to cover ANYTHING and EVERYTHING on the field with a single AI. Forget about actually gameplanning - they want an Easy button.
Talk about making a mountain out of a mole hill...
To go from "Hey Bort do something about the way the defense reacts to QB runs" to tagging players was a ridiculous jump.
I agree. We can't even swap out QB's without exploiting a TE slot.
These same whining/crying DCs are the ones that want to be able to cover ANYTHING and EVERYTHING on the field with a single AI. Forget about actually gameplanning - they want an Easy button.
Talk about making a mountain out of a mole hill...
Mightyhalo
offline
offline
I spend much more time on the defensive side of the ball. Probably 3 hours to every 1 I spend on the offensive side of the ball.
taurran
offline
offline
Originally posted by Mightyhalo
I spend much more time on the defensive side of the ball. Probably 3 hours to every 1 I spend on the offensive side of the ball.
You must have an amazingly simple AI. I'm pretty sure most top coordinators would agree that the offensive AI is much more cumbersome and difficult to work with if you cover all situations.
I spend much more time on the defensive side of the ball. Probably 3 hours to every 1 I spend on the offensive side of the ball.
You must have an amazingly simple AI. I'm pretty sure most top coordinators would agree that the offensive AI is much more cumbersome and difficult to work with if you cover all situations.
Mightyhalo
offline
offline
Originally posted by taurran
You must have an amazingly simple AI. I'm pretty sure most top coordinators would agree that the offensive AI is much more cumbersome and difficult to work with if you cover all situations.
No believe me my AI is obscene. I really need to trim it down, I think it's a little out of control.
Defense keeps my lower level team in the game after a season being out leveled by everyone. Most of the time teams had a 6-10 level difference on my team so that is probably why I focus so much on the defensive side of the ball.
You must have an amazingly simple AI. I'm pretty sure most top coordinators would agree that the offensive AI is much more cumbersome and difficult to work with if you cover all situations.
No believe me my AI is obscene. I really need to trim it down, I think it's a little out of control.
Defense keeps my lower level team in the game after a season being out leveled by everyone. Most of the time teams had a 6-10 level difference on my team so that is probably why I focus so much on the defensive side of the ball.
Chris LeDoux
offline
offline
This is going to annoy me I think.
Defense shouldn't be able to react nearly as well as this will let them to. Especially if both QBs are on the field. If it's just the rusher out there, then you can sell out, but when you have the rusher and passer in the huddle together you can't automagically know which will line up where. Even though motion isn't represented visually (except the testing TE stuff), I should be allowed to suffer OOP in order to create mismatches.
"BUT WAIT!" The haters cry! "You have a rushing qb! This is obviously biased self interest!"
Some is self interest, most is just interest in getting this game working well - his lolbar is dark green, which means I put more into vision than any pure rusher needs to - his passing attributes are being built now and he'll be a threat on short passes soon enough.
But if I want to have Sonic in the game at the same time as the passing QB and split Hedgehog out to WR, you shouldn't be able to react to him being at WR until he actually goes in motion. Same deal for the passer - him moving from shotgun to slot shouldn't let you magic into your safety blitz + DE flats.
Defense shouldn't be able to react nearly as well as this will let them to. Especially if both QBs are on the field. If it's just the rusher out there, then you can sell out, but when you have the rusher and passer in the huddle together you can't automagically know which will line up where. Even though motion isn't represented visually (except the testing TE stuff), I should be allowed to suffer OOP in order to create mismatches.
"BUT WAIT!" The haters cry! "You have a rushing qb! This is obviously biased self interest!"
Some is self interest, most is just interest in getting this game working well - his lolbar is dark green, which means I put more into vision than any pure rusher needs to - his passing attributes are being built now and he'll be a threat on short passes soon enough.
But if I want to have Sonic in the game at the same time as the passing QB and split Hedgehog out to WR, you shouldn't be able to react to him being at WR until he actually goes in motion. Same deal for the passer - him moving from shotgun to slot shouldn't let you magic into your safety blitz + DE flats.
drakeborn
offline
offline
Originally posted by tragula
You forgot the FBs : Blocking , rushing, catching
No, I didn't:
Originally posted by drakeborn
Even discounting FBs (a mistake)
You forgot the FBs : Blocking , rushing, catching
No, I didn't:
Originally posted by drakeborn
Even discounting FBs (a mistake)
Jaxon Voom
offline
offline
Why must we make everything in this game more complicated?! What, running a team doesn't take enough time already?
coach
offline
offline
Originally posted by phthalatemagic
This is a bad idea.
Yep. So again we are letting the defense adjust to the offense, but not letting the offense adjust to the defense? Awesome.
This is a bad idea.
Yep. So again we are letting the defense adjust to the offense, but not letting the offense adjust to the defense? Awesome.

You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.





























