User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Coaches - ideas for them to spend money on (and other ideas)
Page:
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Mat McBriar


I don't like coaches changing a player's growth (boosting training percentages and such).



Thank you.
 
whitewolf
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mat McBriar
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader

I just can't stress this enough: "Coaches" should have ZERO effect on a player's long-term build.


I agree.


I third this motion.
 
jearly
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mat McBriar
I agree.


I 100% don't.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Saris
Yeah under that system once a trainer was bought for a player there would be no refunds and the player would have the bonus for the designated period of time.


However, there is a different mechanic I've seen used in a few games called Concentration. Basically in a concentration system if each +5 strength bonus had a cost of 10% of a coach's concentration bar, he could give 10 players at one time that bonus. If later on he were to remove the bonus from 4 players his bar would return to 40%, since he'd regained that much concentration.

In theory it makes sense since a coach can only focus on so many players at a time.


Seems like it would be better for there to be a penalty of some sort for making switches willy-nilly. Either a limit to the number of switches, or it costs something every time you switch.
 
Dpride59
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Saris

That's where a coaching points system or a coaches fund bar might come into play.

For maybe 5% of his seasonal bar, he could hire a medium strength trainer for a specific DT for the remainder of the season. For the rest of the season that DT would have +3 Strength. It could also be possible to hire a shorter term trainer for a player for a cheaper cost, or a Superior Trainer giving say a +5 strength bonus for a steeper cost.


Ok, let's say each coach has a set amount of training points per season.

What if the could assign one of his unlocked trainable options to a particular player by spending some, and it give that guy a +X bonus to whatever the attribute is. Then if he wants to change it to somebody else, it costs him more training points. Eventually he'd run out if he kept changing it around.


You need to make sure we don't get any more boosts to speed/agi/str. At level 56 http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=1316839 I am going to have a 130speed wr with 80 agility. IF you make a coach that can give say +5 speed boost to a player, mix in track star//streaky/slow starter/clutch we could be looking at 150-160 speed wr's running down the field. NO BOOSTS TO speed/agi str, or your sim is going to need massive nerfs all over the board. You need to understand there are 100000+ amazingly built players, and if you go around giving more attribute boosts to these already well built players, people are going to abuse it.

Lets be fair, teams aren't going to move around these +x bonuses from player to player, they are going to stick it on there featured studs, and rip all the balance out of the sim

 
DavidD458
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort


You gave me an idea, though, that I don't know why I hadn't thought of already: targeting players of the same position the player played for coaching could give better bonuses, or there could be an additional skill only available for use with same-position players. I don't know what it would be, but it sounds good to me.


I originally thought this as well, but I think it's a bad idea. For example, why would anyone hire a Kicking coach that effects one kicker instead of a CB coach that effects five CBs? You'd then have certain positions be better to be coaches, and I don't think that should be. It should be a general bonus to help to offense, defense, or special teams.
 
Dpride59
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader
Originally posted by Mat McBriar



I don't like coaches changing a player's growth (boosting training percentages and such).



Thank you.


Coaches should never be able to boost percentages, or teams in AA, AAA, Pro or WPl, will fill these rosters with coaches and immediately trade for cash, and bring in level 1-7 players and make super players with sick training percentages. Would be a terrible Idea.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by David Stern
Coaches should never be able to boost percentages, or teams in AA, AAA, Pro or WPl, will fill these rosters with coaches and immediately trade for cash, and bring in level 1-7 players and make super players with sick training percentages. Would be a terrible Idea.


 
jearly
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by DavidD458
I originally thought this as well, but I think it's a bad idea. For example, why would anyone hire a Kicking coach that effects one kicker instead of a CB coach that effects five CBs? You'd then have certain positions be better to be coaches, and I don't think that should be. It should be a general bonus to help to offense, defense, or special teams.


well, you could have a kicking coach as one slot to fill. It doesn't have to take away from other slots.
 
AngryDragon
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by whitewolf
In your example, the blocking bonus is effectively 67%. That is huge. As I said earlier, I think there is more than enough neat stuff being thrown around to avoid the can of worms permanent build help would be.


Meh..

If I really wanted to train blocking at such a low percent of a training bonus and got a bonus from a coach. We would probably be talking about gaining 1 point in 20 trainings rather than 34. So yes that is kind of big but still very time consuming. I would mean I could gain 1 point from training in a season rather than two.

Still I agree there are many other bonuses to be gained from coaches that can affect the strategy of the sim rather than player builds. Player builds should probably be equal for all players like you are saying.

Someone mentioned buying plays that might cause more bugs since the testing group would be limited. I was thinking that buying player tactics might be pretty cool. Again this might also lead to more bugs due to a limited testing group.
 
pottsman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by David Stern


You need to make sure we don't get any more boosts to speed/agi/str. At level 56 http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=1316839 I am going to have a 130speed wr with 80 agility. IF you make a coach that can give say +5 speed boost to a player, mix in track star//streaky/slow starter/clutch we could be looking at 150-160 speed wr's running down the field. NO BOOSTS TO speed/agi str, or your sim is going to need massive nerfs all over the board. You need to understand there are 100000+ amazingly built players, and if you go around giving more attribute boosts to these already well built players, people are going to abuse it.



Any attribute bonuses should stick to football and mental skills, definitely. Coaches should be able to give decent sized bumps to them, though, since that's what coaching's all about. Making someone a better tackler, showing them how to block, etc.
 
whitewolf
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by pottsman
Originally posted by David Stern



You need to make sure we don't get any more boosts to speed/agi/str. At level 56 http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=1316839 I am going to have a 130speed wr with 80 agility. IF you make a coach that can give say +5 speed boost to a player, mix in track star//streaky/slow starter/clutch we could be looking at 150-160 speed wr's running down the field. NO BOOSTS TO speed/agi str, or your sim is going to need massive nerfs all over the board. You need to understand there are 100000+ amazingly built players, and if you go around giving more attribute boosts to these already well built players, people are going to abuse it.



Any attribute bonuses should stick to football and mental skills, definitely. Coaches should be able to give decent sized bumps to them, though, since that's what coaching's all about. Making someone a better tackler, showing them how to block, etc.


Yeah I agree here.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by AngryDragon
Meh..

If I really wanted to train blocking at such a low percent of a training bonus and got a bonus from a coach. We would probably be talking about gaining 1 point in 20 trainings rather than 34. So yes that is kind of big but still very time consuming. I would mean I could gain 1 point from training in a season rather than two.

Still I agree there are many other bonuses to be gained from coaches that can affect the strategy of the sim rather than player builds. Player builds should probably be equal for all players like you are saying.

Someone mentioned buying plays that might cause more bugs since the testing group would be limited. I was thinking that buying player tactics might be pretty cool. Again this might also lead to more bugs due to a limited testing group.


We had definitely discussed the idea of having coaches unlock new tactics options. However, we don't have all that many more tactics options on tap, so it might not really be worth it unless some options get removed only to be re-enabled by coaches. I'm focusing more on the gameplanning and other tactical ideas.
 
fbfan18
offline
Link
 
Any thoughts on having Coaches move up in ranks as well? Say they must spend a season in the Cloud and could only move up to AA after a full season in the cloud? And so on to Pro after 4 seasons of Coaching minimum? Would be an interesting concept to create a "career" for a Coach.
 
pottsman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
We had definitely discussed the idea of having coaches unlock new tactics options. However, we don't have all that many more tactics options on tap, so it might not really be worth it unless some options get removed only to be re-enabled by coaches. I'm focusing more on the gameplanning and other tactical ideas.


Advanced Individual AI please.

Not necesserially through coaching. But in general, give us advanced AI for when we want to be on power tackling, semi-aggressive pass defense, pass blocking.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.