Maybe instead of players being predestined to be far superior...maybe some players are predestined to be better IN CERTAIN AREAS, but due to the lolbalanced sim, some are way more useless? Like, maybe all of the "terrible" LB's are supposed to be really good at Trash Talk and The Glare, but due to those SA's being useless, so are the LB's. Or maybe slow WR's are supposed to be really good with jumping/diving catch, but since those happen once every other season, they are bad/
Originally posted by Deathblade Maybe instead of players being predestined to be far superior...maybe some players are predestined to be better IN CERTAIN AREAS, but due to the lolbalanced sim, some are way more useless? Like, maybe all of the "terrible" LB's are supposed to be really good at Trash Talk and The Glare, but due to those SA's being useless, so are the LB's. Or maybe slow WR's are supposed to be really good with jumping/diving catch, but since those happen once every other season, they are bad/
I think you're on to something here. I've built and retired a bunch of CB/SS. Some of them just seem to be naturally better in coverage, while others seem to be better at tackling. I assumed it was variance, but perhaps some players get an inherent +10 to certain attribute(s).
I never thought it was possible there wasn't an x-factor. Some dudes have fumbilitis, some dudes are tougher to tackle. I like it - if you aren't bitching about the randomness of every other aspect of the game, why are you bitching about this one?
Originally posted by fallingmercury Originally posted by TyrannyVaunt
Bort needs to clear the air on this shit.
He's stated before that there is no X factor, but it's really hard to believe that right now. Im sure he doesnt *intend* to have it in the code, but it's there somewhere.
Originally posted by Deathblade Maybe instead of players being predestined to be far superior...maybe some players are predestined to be better IN CERTAIN AREAS, but due to the lolbalanced sim, some are way more useless? Like, maybe all of the "terrible" LB's are supposed to be really good at Trash Talk and The Glare, but due to those SA's being useless, so are the LB's. Or maybe slow WR's are supposed to be really good with jumping/diving catch, but since those happen once every other season, they are bad/
That's sort of the way I always thought hidden attributes or x-factor would work. I guess I always felt like players got a bonus in one area, and maybe a slight penalty in another area. I guess some people would hate this, but to me it almost seems necessary in order to differentiate builds/performance a bit.
Originally posted by raiderdav I never thought it was possible there wasn't an x-factor. Some dudes have fumbilitis, some dudes are tougher to tackle. I like it - if you aren't bitching about the randomness of every other aspect of the game, why are you bitching about this one?
X-Factor for President in 2012
I agree. In fact, we should take it a step farther. Teams should have x-factors and should win games despite bad builds and tactics. We should also have x-factor games where a great team can be upset by a rebuilding team in a freak win kind of like win the Dolphins upset the Pats a few seasons ago.
Better yet, we should just let the computer assign us pre-made players instead of rolling, building and training them. We should also do away with tactics so the luckiest team can win. It can be kind of like that brute game everyone played for about a week before they lost interest because they had zero control.