Originally posted by fallingmercury
I think it's time to give up on the promotion/demotion idea as well. League structure/competitiveness deteriorates further every season, despite the "give it time to even out" calls we hear every season.
What we need is a league creation system that's not dependent on levels. And it needs to be made impossible to gut/abandon at the beginning of a season.
The best way to fix league structure, though not perfect, is to have GLB-expert admins manually construct leagues. Promotions/demotions would be done manually by a person who has some sense. Sure they wont be perfect, but I guarantee that leagues would look MUCH better than the bull pucky we have now.
I just don't think that (other than the 16 cap, which is a joke) the league structure is as terrible as everyone is making it out to be.
Why not reinforce the caps like this:
If your team requests demotion into a specific cap, any player over that cap range when the demotion is processed is automatically cut, no questions asked.
On day zero, a sweep is performed of each cap. Any player more than 3 levels over that cap (give them the +3 for boosting) gets cut automatically, no questions asked. Owners that want to cry about their players being cut right before the start of the season can go suck eggs, because they were trying to abuse the system and got caught.
(edit)
This is also why the 16 cap needs to be moved up to either 18-19 or removed completely, because it's a joke that a team that went 7-9 by slacking in 13 cap can go to 16 cap with an entire roster well over the cap prior to boosting....