User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Opponent Scouting Page - need ideas
Page:
 
yello1
Preacher
offline
Link
 
NEW Suggestion

This one is kinda cool.

In whatever section you create to give info on a player, and tag him for use in your playbook, who not ALSO put in a default coverage man option, a Spy button.

Say a Formation, Play, Defender drag down boxes. Choose formation, then choose either Any Play in that formation or a specific play type (and let them do more than one, say up to three or four before having to do it in the DAI UI), then choose the roster slot to spy on him. Then in the game whenever there is a play of specified formation and play type, and your defense from your DAI has the defensive slot you selected (ie if you chose ILB then you wont get it in a 4-3 defense set) the specified slot will usurp the DAI and run that position to Spy that offensive player.

Hmm. As I type this the idea seems less likely to work than it did when I first thought of it, working it up as I type.

Well I will hit submit anyway, dont want to waste all these electrons.
 
We_Rule
offline
Link
 
The rub lies with several agents having learned how to be better scouts and tacticians being now damaged if they "dumb" down the system. I'm all for a scouting page that adds some things, but the majority of that page needs to be user implemented. I like the idea of having a page to put notes & make things like this cleaner, but making an "easy button" for scouting will lessen the experience for those who have and do take the time, in leu of those who want trickle up naivity........
 
Zumbo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by @pp1e
I think that you should just have the top 5 plays in order. And include the team's season stats compared to league, i.e.

-----Passing-----
Passing: 3,000 Yds (3)
TD/INT Ratio: 6.8/1 (5)
Yards per Attempt: 7.0 (6)
Plays per Game: 60 (8)

-----Rushing-----
Rushing: 1,500 Yds (20)
Rushing TDs: 18 (10)
Yards per Rush: 5.6 (11)
Plays per Game: 48 (14)

-----Pass Defense-----
etc.

-----Rush Defense-----
etc.


 
TrevJo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by OvechkinSCORES
Originally posted by TrevJo

I don't think you should bother. It will be too much work for marginally useful results. Focus on the sim IMO.


Did you ever scout in your life? It's a big pain in the ass at the moment.


I've done tons of GLB scouting, thanks for asking. It is a big pain in the ass, but I can't imagine anything Bort would do that would make it easier. Everyone has their own way of doing it, and every opponent presents a different challenge for which numbers only tell a small part of the story.
 
tragula
title
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by yello1
First off your first statement would be equally true of a scouting page. Anyone can read it, but only some one who understands the game and the implications of what they are reading can break it down and discern what it is. So you should really have NO problem with this - unless what you really desire for some perverse reason is that all your GMs be college kids skipping classes or friendless OCDers sitting at the PC breaking down film and crafting playbooks 8 hours a day after work.

I do know how to break down films (on defense, I suck at OC) and I do spend OCD kinda hours at gaming. But due to RL constraints that means I usually only get a few hours to work on any given game and therefore do not have the time to fully break down the film AND implement the findings. Can't tell you how many times I am cramming in the last bit of film and then rushing to field a plan to meet it and the clock runs out before I am done, or I put in a play with a glaring hole in it because I do not have the time to properly "proof read" what I have done before kick off.

A scouting system that takes out the mundane repetition of data gathering would help me and presumably the many hundreds or thousands of others who have only as much time as I do, or more likely far less.


I am with yello1, saving users time they spend in breaking down game films can only help the game. Speaking as an OC, if a defense managed to pick up something from previous games and stop me then it is praises for the DC and boos for me. Quality scouting tools will help me save time, so I can make my opponents scouting even more useless. Not to talk about the improved relationship with my wife.

 
uttam246
offline
Link
 
for all marvelous madmen: the pee people have all lv1 people on team .In last game they lost 84 to 3 with 3 points they lost dangouresly. they also like to kick and rush. poor recieving record . against new england knockouts they lost 10 zip overall preety bad team easy win for us. oppuntent scouting for game on8/13
 
Link
 
Originally posted by We_Rule
The rub lies with several agents having learned how to be better scouts and tacticians being now damaged if they "dumb" down the system. I'm all for a scouting page that adds some things, but the majority of that page needs to be user implemented. I like the idea of having a page to put notes & make things like this cleaner, but making an "easy button" for scouting will lessen the experience for those who have and do take the time, in leu of those who want trickle up naivity........


Exactly. Not to mention. If you give out all the information without having to do any scouting, then a lot of DC's/OC's would be out of work in this game. Some from quitting as evident in this thread but others from being "fired" from their position since the owner will then be able to do it all themselves and have no need for a OC/DC.
Hell, why would a owner ever need a DC/OC if all the games are brokn down for them?
Why would a OC/DC ever need a scout again if the games are all broken down for them?
Simplifing scouting to where it requires no work at all will take a lot of people out of this game.
 
beeve17
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Wouldn't want it to be too specific, and take all the scouting away from scouts, so it'd need to be limited somewhat as to what it showed.

I could easily analyze the playcalling from the team's last 3-4 games and get percentages for:

pass/run
inside/outside rushes
HB vs FB vs QB rushes
HB vs FB vs TE vs WR passes
Screen pass %
long/medium/short pass %
each play's % (too much info IMO)
probably other stuff

I think maybe some combination of those would be good?


make it a broad generalize estimate. because a fan doesn't know how exact your percentage of qb scrambling is.
something more like QB scrambles often, never, etc.
as for hbs running, how often the backups run.
who the hot receiver is on third down, how often screen passes are, and shots down the field (long passes)

so like often never sometimes, always seems better than percentages.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by We_Rule
The rub lies with several agents having learned how to be better scouts and tacticians being now damaged if they "dumb" down the system. I'm all for a scouting page that adds some things, but the majority of that page needs to be user implemented. I like the idea of having a page to put notes & make things like this cleaner, but making an "easy button" for scouting will lessen the experience for those who have and do take the time, in leu of those who want trickle up naivity........


packages already do this. it cleans up the AI, and allows even a relative novice the ability to set up a fairly complex AI in less than an hour. so why not make it easier to scout? if it wasnt such a pain in the ass, then more people would probably be inclined to do it. especially for DC's because it takes a lot more time to be a DC then it does to OC.
Edited by happylittletrees on Aug 13, 2009 16:49:05
 
tragula
title
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by We_Rule
The rub lies with several agents having learned how to be better scouts and tacticians being now damaged if they "dumb" down the system. I'm all for a scouting page that adds some things, but the majority of that page needs to be user implemented. I like the idea of having a page to put notes & make things like this cleaner, but making an "easy button" for scouting will lessen the experience for those who have and do take the time, in leu of those who want trickle up naivity........


Originally posted by driftinggrifter
Exactly. Not to mention. If you give out all the information without having to do any scouting, then a lot of DC's/OC's would be out of work in this game. Some from quitting as evident in this thread but others from being "fired" from their position since the owner will then be able to do it all themselves and have no need for a OC/DC.
Hell, why would a owner ever need a DC/OC if all the games are brokn down for them?
Why would a OC/DC ever need a scout again if the games are all broken down for them?
Simplifing scouting to where it requires no work at all will take a lot of people out of this game.


Scouting has two parts: The technical part of collecting the data. The smart part deciding what to look at. Generating scouting tools can only remove the annoying time consuming part. Removing the technical part will make the good GMs even better since now they can dig deeper. The gap between smart and stupid GMs will only get larger.
 
We_Rule
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by happylittletrees
Originally posted by We_Rule

The rub lies with several agents having learned how to be better scouts and tacticians being now damaged if they "dumb" down the system. I'm all for a scouting page that adds some things, but the majority of that page needs to be user implemented. I like the idea of having a page to put notes & make things like this cleaner, but making an "easy button" for scouting will lessen the experience for those who have and do take the time, in leu of those who want trickle up naivity........


packages already do this. it cleans up the AI, and allows even a relative novice the ability to set up a fairly complex AI in less than an hour. so why not make it easier to scout? if it wasnt such a pain in the ass, then more people would probably be inclined to do it. especially for DC's because it takes a lot more time to be a DC then it does to OC.


Um, the last part is not correct.........

 
butler312
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tragula
Scouting has two parts: The technical part of collecting the data. The smart part deciding what to look at. Generating scouting tools can only remove the annoying time consuming part. Removing the technical part will make the good GMs even better since now they can dig deeper. The gap between smart and stupid GMs will only get larger.


I agree for the most part. I don't think the gap really gets larger though. But right now how good of a coordinator you are is highly correlated to how much time you put into it. This proposed method would change that. Now it would be based on how good you are at using the information, not how much time you are willing to spend to get it. I prefer it that way.
 
We_Rule
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by We_Rule
Originally posted by happylittletrees

Originally posted by We_Rule


The rub lies with several agents having learned how to be better scouts and tacticians being now damaged if they "dumb" down the system. I'm all for a scouting page that adds some things, but the majority of that page needs to be user implemented. I like the idea of having a page to put notes & make things like this cleaner, but making an "easy button" for scouting will lessen the experience for those who have and do take the time, in leu of those who want trickle up naivity........


packages already do this. it cleans up the AI, and allows even a relative novice the ability to set up a fairly complex AI in less than an hour. so why not make it easier to scout? if it wasnt such a pain in the ass, then more people would probably be inclined to do it. especially for DC's because it takes a lot more time to be a DC then it does to OC.


Um, the last part is not correct......... I do agree that the packages do speed things up, but its more like an in-between.



 
razor9
offline
Link
 
Additional suggestion:

I've done this in the past via spreadsheet and if someone said something in this post, I'm sorry, but I'm not going through 12 pages to find it.

Team vs. Team comparison

Unlike the standard matchup, this would rate individual units of the offensive unit vs. the corresponding defensive unit and vice versa.

EX:

Offensive line vs Defensive Line
Backfield vs. Linebackers
7 on 7 passing matchup, etc.

The most obvious number to use would be the number associated with player scouting bars. Offensive line would compare their pass blocking vs. the D lines pass rushing, run block vs. tackling (ie run stopping). It could be a combined average of the two or broken down individually. The numbers are already there, its just a matter of setting a program to collect the information and do the math.

I know the scouting bar isn't always reliable, but its the most known number.

This would allow teams to decide where they may have advantages or where their opponent may have an advantage.

Did this with a spreadsheet a while back and it was amazingly accurate. The game got too complicated for my tiny brain, but the GLB elite I'm sure can come up with something.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by tragula
Originally posted by We_Rule

The rub lies with several agents having learned how to be better scouts and tacticians being now damaged if they "dumb" down the system. I'm all for a scouting page that adds some things, but the majority of that page needs to be user implemented. I like the idea of having a page to put notes & make things like this cleaner, but making an "easy button" for scouting will lessen the experience for those who have and do take the time, in leu of those who want trickle up naivity........


Originally posted by driftinggrifter

Exactly. Not to mention. If you give out all the information without having to do any scouting, then a lot of DC's/OC's would be out of work in this game. Some from quitting as evident in this thread but others from being "fired" from their position since the owner will then be able to do it all themselves and have no need for a OC/DC.
Hell, why would a owner ever need a DC/OC if all the games are brokn down for them?
Why would a OC/DC ever need a scout again if the games are all broken down for them?
Simplifing scouting to where it requires no work at all will take a lot of people out of this game.


Scouting has two parts: The technical part of collecting the data. The smart part deciding what to look at. Generating scouting tools can only remove the annoying time consuming part. Removing the technical part will make the good GMs even better since now they can dig deeper. The gap between smart and stupid GMs will only get larger.


I have to disagree that the gap will get bigger between smart and stupid GM's. If you give all GM's the same material, you just did half the battle which closes the gap between the GM's.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.