User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > World Pro Championship Tournament
Page:
 
the man of doom
Miracles happen
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sunsfan
Originally posted by MxPx3oh!3fan

Here, vote:
3 vote for WPL
0 votes for WP tourney




 
.spider.
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by rmiller517

WPL wouldn't have been balanced at all.


And likely would cause:

- Some owners to get promoted and quit after getting beat more than they are used to (can't handle losing syndrome - I've seen it over and over).

jbleich - Then freaking let em....More FA's for the owners that dont punk out like pussies, and more teams more than ready to take their spot

- Continued endless debate about how the wrong teams made it because we'd go with equal rep from each league

jbleich - There needs to be a system for promo/releg...that could be ironed out in the next 10 days...the first season would NOT have the right teams in there, hence a lot of the minors leagues...but the right plan will iron it out in the longer run 2-3 seasons.

- Dilution of Pro league talent

jbleich - So you are saying AAA leagues suck?

- Extra teams to get promoted who aren't ready, with a ripple effect ALL THE WAY DOWN

jbleich - If they are at the top of their league currently, HOW ARE THEY NOT READY?

- Extra teams to be demoted even if they didn't come in last place (due to dropdowns from WPL) which sucks for them, gives them less media revenue, etc

jbleich - If they are 13th/14th they would probobly welcome the shift down, would lessen the 13th and 14th ranked CPU teams at the end of the season that you are so worried about.



bump LOL
 
Sunsfan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jbleich
Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by rmiller517


WPL wouldn't have been balanced at all.


And likely would cause:

- Some owners to get promoted and quit after getting beat more than they are used to (can't handle losing syndrome - I've seen it over and over).

jbleich - Then freaking let em....More FA's for the owners that dont punk out like pussies, and more teams more than ready to take their spot

- Continued endless debate about how the wrong teams made it because we'd go with equal rep from each league

jbleich - There needs to be a system for promo/releg...that could be ironed out in the next 10 days...the first season would NOT have the right teams in there, hence a lot of the minors leagues...but the right plan will iron it out in the longer run 2-3 seasons.

- Dilution of Pro league talent

jbleich - So you are saying AAA leagues suck?

- Extra teams to get promoted who aren't ready, with a ripple effect ALL THE WAY DOWN

jbleich - If they are at the top of their league currently, HOW ARE THEY NOT READY?

- Extra teams to be demoted even if they didn't come in last place (due to dropdowns from WPL) which sucks for them, gives them less media revenue, etc

jbleich - If they are 13th/14th they would probobly welcome the shift down, would lessen the 13th and 14th ranked CPU teams at the end of the season that you are so worried about.



bump LOL


with bold yay
 
SpreadThePink
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by superpunk
please rank this idea on a scale of horrible to not fixing Islam when it was obvious it needed to be fixed.


On a scale of 10, I give it over 9000.
 
jxgator33
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by James128
Originally posted by robponce

Wow.

Gart's idea was well liked and well respected among all the top teams.

This...

Was just stupid. Hell I'm in the PWT committee, and this is an absolute let down. WL was an opportunity to better GLB, and it didn't get better.


Originally posted by Bort


Originally posted by rmiller517



WPL wouldn't have been balanced at all.


And likely would cause:

- Some owners to get promoted and quit after getting beat more than they are used to (can't handle losing syndrome - I've seen it over and over).
- Continued endless debate about how the wrong teams made it because we'd go with equal rep from each league
- Dilution of Pro league talent
- Extra teams to get promoted who aren't ready, with a ripple effect ALL THE WAY DOWN
- Extra teams to be demoted even if they didn't come in last place (due to dropdowns from WPL) which sucks for them, gives them less media revenue, etc


Please explain how this is different than swapping WSI over to USA.


It's easy to say you you liked the idea coming out of EEPL.... For the teams that didn't make it from usapl it wasn't fair. I'm just going to use your team as a example. You guys didn't have to go through anyone until stewart. If your a team like Washington, Minn, and ***O*** you had to win 2 games against top 25 teams just to get into the World league. How is that fair for the lesser leagues who just had to beat teams who were barely ranked in the top 50.


its not, leagues will dillute though, powers will change
 
jazzedpap1028
offline
Link
 
As a team that was looking forward to WPL I am disappointed, new teams would have been a nice new addition. Over the last 5 season Emmaus has been 97-2 in East Europe and 4 Straight Championships. The competition has grown VERY VERY much this past season, but I was looking forward to a new 16 games.

Either way, I understand the positives and negatives, but why no vote? Decline was up for a vote so why not the WPL? And I know people complained about some of the teams "that should" be in WPL not getting there. But until last year (WSI) was anyone allowed to complain that they weren't able to get into USAPL and get there way? Personally, I think if you ask some Non-USA teams if they would like to go to USAPro they would. Yes, I am NOT saying they would run the table, but I am sure they would take a few more losses partnered with a more competitive league.
 
blln4lyf
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by rmiller517

WPL wouldn't have been balanced at all.


And likely would cause:

- Some owners to get promoted and quit after getting beat more than they are used to (can't handle losing syndrome - I've seen it over and over).
- Continued endless debate about how the wrong teams made it because we'd go with equal rep from each league
- Dilution of Pro league talent
- Extra teams to get promoted who aren't ready, with a ripple effect ALL THE WAY DOWN
- Extra teams to be demoted even if they didn't come in last place (due to dropdowns from WPL) which sucks for them, gives them less media revenue, etc

We are still not getting the best teams in this tourney though, not even close to it imo.
Edited by blln4lyf on Jul 27, 2009 16:12:19
 
robponce
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by James128
Originally posted by robponce

Wow.

Gart's idea was well liked and well respected among all the top teams.

This...

Was just stupid. Hell I'm in the PWT committee, and this is an absolute let down. WL was an opportunity to better GLB, and it didn't get better.


Originally posted by Bort


Originally posted by rmiller517



WPL wouldn't have been balanced at all.


And likely would cause:

- Some owners to get promoted and quit after getting beat more than they are used to (can't handle losing syndrome - I've seen it over and over).
- Continued endless debate about how the wrong teams made it because we'd go with equal rep from each league
- Dilution of Pro league talent
- Extra teams to get promoted who aren't ready, with a ripple effect ALL THE WAY DOWN
- Extra teams to be demoted even if they didn't come in last place (due to dropdowns from WPL) which sucks for them, gives them less media revenue, etc


Please explain how this is different than swapping WSI over to USA.


It's easy to say you you liked the idea coming out of EEPL.... For the teams that didn't make it from usapl it wasn't fair. I'm just going to use your team as a example. You guys didn't have to go through anyone until stewart. If your a team like Washington, Minn, and ***O*** you had to win 2 games against top 25 teams just to get into the World league. How is that fair for the lesser leagues who just had to beat teams who were barely ranked in the top 50.


I'm talking as a representative of 3 leagues, one including USA (OTR), and it's still bullshit.

OTR is a worse team than Emmaus (but better gameplanning)

Bank on it.

It's absolute shit and even you know that.
 
RMiller517
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jxgator33
Originally posted by rmiller517

How about an extra set of friendlies, done tournament round robin, where GLBers vote on their top 4 teams. the best 16 would each play each other once.


yes...


fyp
 
Vando
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by Octowned


Just don't put people back where they came from, only give priority to the highest seed from a given conference, and put the rest back randomly



I fail to see a major issue here


No. Teams would HAVE to go back to where they came from. That was the entire dealbreaker of the world league idea in the first place, and one of the main reasons why the world league is problematic.


Allow me to solve this problem for you. You relegate the lower 2 sides of the 4 from each region in the World League, one to each conference.

LOOK HOW SIMPLE THAT WAS.


 
thehazyone
NFL Replacement Refs SUCK
offline
Link
 
I can already see teams boycotting the WP tournament and/or not giving a crap about it.

And yes, I am a fan of the WPL. Is it problematic sending teams back to the league they came from? Yes, but there are enough bad teams in the Pro leagues that you can just demote extra teams back to AAA... really not that hard.
 
Michael Vick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ATL_DirtyBird
So Bort, tell me why I should boost my WR for next season? I really don't have any reason to now that there will be no WPL.


 
Saris
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Firenze
Originally posted by Sunsfan

Originally posted by Timetoshine-Beta


I would rather have WPL even with it's flaws than a loltournament.






I agree, I think a lot of the complaints were directed at specific parts of the world league, not the overall concept.

It's like bitching about having to fly to Maui in coach instead of first class and the solution being to go to Omaha instead...
Edited by Saris on Jul 27, 2009 16:14:19
 
Crawly
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by James128
It's easy to say you you liked the idea coming out of EEPL.... For the teams that didn't make it from usapl it wasn't fair. I'm just going to use your team as a example. You guys didn't have to go through anyone until stewart. If your a team like Washington, Minn, and ***O*** you had to win 2 games against top 25 teams just to get into the World league. How is that fair for the lesser leagues who just had to beat teams who were barely ranked in the top 50.

In a season or two, that'll work itself out. And in the meanwhile, those teams can dominate US Pro instead of being middle-of-the-pack teams. I don't see much of a problem.

I'd much rather follow a world league than a meaningless tournament, myself, for what it's worth.
 
henne
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by robponce


I'm talking as a representative of 3 leagues, one including USA (OTR), and it's still bullshit.

OTR is a worse team than Emmaus (but better gameplanning)

Bank on it.

It's absolute shit and even you know that.


Say what?!?!

 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.