User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Free for All > How is JohnnyDollar not an admin of this site yet?
Page:
 
datongw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Darkus Black
Originally posted by pottsman

Then there are none. Since everything is stoppable. Hell, even season 8 I Slam was stoppable by the right guys.


There you go. Unless people are suggesting that finding ways to increase your probability of winning is an exploit? I hope they aren't because that would suggest people don't understand the concept of strategy games. Football is a strategy game.



Football is more than strategy, there is a reason why D&G players are not dominating the NFL.
 
OttawaShane
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by datongw
Originally posted by Darkus Black

Originally posted by pottsman


Then there are none. Since everything is stoppable. Hell, even season 8 I Slam was stoppable by the right guys.


There you go. Unless people are suggesting that finding ways to increase your probability of winning is an exploit? I hope they aren't because that would suggest people don't understand the concept of strategy games. Football is a strategy game.



Football is more than strategy, there is a reason why D&G players are not dominating the NFL.


The people who think its all x's and o's have never worn a helmet, IMO.
 
jamz
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Painmaker
Originally posted by Tony Dungy

the problem with the word "exploit" is that everyone has a different definition of what that word means to them.


Every once in a while he says something I can agree with.


# In the realm of online games, an exploit is usually a software bug, hack or bot that contributes to the user's prosperity in a manner not intended by the developers.
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Exploit_(online_gaming)
 
jamz
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jamz
Originally posted by Painmaker

Originally posted by Tony Dungy


the problem with the word "exploit" is that everyone has a different definition of what that word means to them.


Every once in a while he says something I can agree with.


# In the realm of online games, an exploit is usually a software bug, hack or bot that contributes to the user's prosperity in a manner not intended by the developers.
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Exploit_(online_gaming)


So the only really question is whether or not using something the way it's being used was / is the intention of the Almighty Bortron.
 
datongw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by islander1
Originally posted by datongw

Originally posted by Sik Wit It


Originally posted by datongw



Obviously there are several, what is the biggest?

I feel that manipulating the DC so that have running QBs only in on rushing plays and not have to pass is the biggest right now. In RL as soon as those guys come on the field, the defense would know a run is coming, but in GLB defenses can't adjust to that. Add on the fact that the any defender that is not set to blitz will practically stand there and pick their noses until the QB crosses the LOS makes this the biggest exploit in the game at the moment imo.

Sure they can be shut down, and really shut down, but that would basically mean that your defense will be exposed to a lot of other plays. I seriously hope Bort fixes this during the off season. It's really an easy fix too, just fix the DC order then everything is solved.


On the eve of the Wolfpack game. Having trouble gameplanning, daton?


Not really, we have faced quite a few running QBs this season, including our last two opponents (Lincoln and Marblehead). Just a bit frustrated as a DC to have my hands tied.


I understand where you are coming from though. Although we actually let Copeland pass some.


Make him pass he whole game against us And not just throw HB screens
 
Link
 
Originally posted by RTJakarta
Originally posted by Tony Dungy

Originally posted by Chaos Knight




It's more because you were too stupid to put 2 and 2 together and pay attention who had access to your forum.


I'm not going to get into it here, but anytime I've had a possible conflict of interests, I immediately stepped down and resigned as GM.

I did it when I was on the Steel and moved to OTR. I also resigned from another USAPL forum I was in before going to the Steel.

I just thought it was the honorable thing to do. Both were immediate and no one had to double check what other forums or GM titles I had.

There is no way that you can know that every single one of your agents isn't a spy for another team. Especially with the decline coming soon and more turnover on each roster, this is going to be more and more of a problem.


I'm not going to do this, but if I wanted to, I'm sure I could offer some cash to a Halifax GM to pass along some info.


I guess Laggo is just dumb for assuming his friend wasn't going to stab him in the back. It isn't my team and I didn't add the GM who spied.



You assume a lot of things.



I have to assume because you won't talk about it.

You care to clear up if you were the spy or not?

 
steellithium
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Tony Dungy


the problem with the word "exploit" is that everyone has a different definition of what that word means to them.


The term exploit shouldn't be that hard to understand. Anything done that wasn't intended by the developer is an exploit.

I've had to deal with a ton of people saying, PunkBuster isn't allowing me to adjust my max packets. They used the logic that if they could do it, it was legal, and hence not a exploit. That is wrong. The developers never planned client/server packets to be used for a competitive advantage, therefore it was an exploit. Once that exploit is used repeatedly, it is cheating. Once everyone starts cheating, the developer loses control of the game.
 
datongw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Tony Dungy
Originally posted by steellithium

Here is how you fix the QB rushing. You can still make rushing QB's. You can still sub the TE. But when QB1 plays TE, he loses massive energy. So it will cost you the performance of your main QB to do this. The TE sub was obviously not intended by the developer, so by definition it is an exploit.


The problem with this is that you are now taking running QBs out of the game.

There are no top 100 teams in the game that I know of that only have a running QB running the show. It is too easy to shut down if you don't have a passing QB. Believe me, I know better than anyone about that. It doesn't work.

If there is a top 100 team in the game who only uses a running QB, let me know...I haven't seen it.

Things are fine the way they are now. QB at TE is a significant penalty and makes it fair. I haven't seen too many QBs with over 8 yard per carry against Pro League playoff teams like there were the last couple seasons. The defensive play creator has eliminated alot of that.


The QB run is a powerful weapon, but since the defense creator began, I haven't seen an offensive play that is unstoppable. Defense is always about stopping certain things but being vulnerable to something else.



Well, if you have no passing QB you are really one dimensional, unless you are really dominating at running the ball, you are not going to win.
 
Painmaker
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by steellithium

Originally posted by Darkus Black



In other news, I agree that there should be some system to allow defenses to adjust to the offensive personnel. Maybe we should come up with a solution for that which is not too convoluted?


I used to be on board with this, but here is what changed. If I have that ability as a DC, I can do a few things. If I see the blocking TE come in, I eliminate passing to the TE, if not altogether. So you give me a LB back.

Next if I see the Rushing QB is in and QB1 at TE, I can just blitz both Safeties off the edges, and play zone a deeper zone.

Last I can spot an elusive back, and just plan outside runs, and double cover him.

The problem is there are only so many offensive plays. It would be pretty easy to figure out a list of plays for each player. That list shrinks when you see the formation. The DC should never be able to eliminate possibilities, to the point you can know the exact play called. You can tell the offense to mix it up, but then the offense is using the wrong players on the wrong plays, which an equal leveled defense will defend anyway.


I don't see that as a problem tbh. Building a roster of one-dimensional players should come with a price.

My biggest issue with allowing defenses to plan in response to different offensive players is that it would add to the already-ridiculous workload on DCs. I'd rather see something done to simplify the defensive AI interface (maybe with complex, fuzzy, and/or adaptive algorithms) before adding new features. And yes, I recognize that's asking a lot from a 'free' browser game... which is why you don't see me beating the drum for more major changes right now.

 
datongw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by McGruffHawk
Originally posted by datongw

Originally posted by sjmay


Originally posted by datongw



Obviously there are several, what is the biggest?

I feel that manipulating the DC so that have running QBs only in on rushing plays and not have to pass is the biggest right now. In RL as soon as those guys come on the field, the defense would know a run is coming, but in GLB defenses can't adjust to that. Add on the fact that the any defender that is not set to blitz will practically stand there and pick their noses until the QB crosses the LOS makes this the biggest exploit in the game at the moment imo.

Sure they can be shut down, and really shut down, but that would basically mean that your defense will be exposed to a lot of other plays. I seriously hope Bort fixes this during the off season. It's really an easy fix too, just fix the DC order then everything is solved.


Wait,

You mean having to game plan to stop something is an exploit? Having to choose to sell out against a play or not is an exploit?

Wow, really??


It's not hard to stop it. But that's not the point, the point is that if a QB that runs fast but can't pass come into the game, the defense should know a run is coming. But right now not only defense can't adjust to that, they basically won't react to him running until he crosses the LOS. Vision has nothing to do with it, it's the coding. Defenders will 1 million in vision will not go after him until the QB crosses the LOS, that's just the way it's coded in the game.

If the offense has the option to put the rushing QB in only to run, never need to pass, then the defense should have an option in the AI that select a different play if that QB is in the game. Big part of football is strategy, but tough to do that when your hands are tied.


Well, in that case, the biggest exploit is loading the strong side with 7 defenders against the strong I slam, and the offense not being able to audible into a pass or weakside run. I mean, any QB or coach with half a brain would do that as soon as they see the strongside shift by the defense, but in GLB offenses can't. Offenses should be able to audible to an alternative play call when an obvious shift is made. Big part of football is strategy, but tough to do that when your hands are tied.


Defense will only do that if you run to the strong side all the time, if you mix it up with your running game, no defense is dumb enough to do that. These type of problems can be resolved with scouting.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by datongw
Originally posted by Tony Dungy

Originally posted by steellithium


Here is how you fix the QB rushing. You can still make rushing QB's. You can still sub the TE. But when QB1 plays TE, he loses massive energy. So it will cost you the performance of your main QB to do this. The TE sub was obviously not intended by the developer, so by definition it is an exploit.


The problem with this is that you are now taking running QBs out of the game.

There are no top 100 teams in the game that I know of that only have a running QB running the show. It is too easy to shut down if you don't have a passing QB. Believe me, I know better than anyone about that. It doesn't work.

If there is a top 100 team in the game who only uses a running QB, let me know...I haven't seen it.

Things are fine the way they are now. QB at TE is a significant penalty and makes it fair. I haven't seen too many QBs with over 8 yard per carry against Pro League playoff teams like there were the last couple seasons. The defensive play creator has eliminated alot of that.


The QB run is a powerful weapon, but since the defense creator began, I haven't seen an offensive play that is unstoppable. Defense is always about stopping certain things but being vulnerable to something else.



Well, if you have no passing QB you are really one dimensional, unless you are really dominating at running the ball, you are not going to win.



We won in Season 9, but that was because passing sucked so bad with all the deflections bouncing around. When passing was fixed in season 10, I knew we were in trouble.

 
datongw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by steellithium
Originally posted by Tony Dungy



the problem with the word "exploit" is that everyone has a different definition of what that word means to them.


The term exploit shouldn't be that hard to understand. Anything done that wasn't intended by the developer is an exploit.



I agree, if Bort wanted to have running QB only in for running plays he could easily just put in a QB1 slot, rather than the current put your passing QB at TE slot to get your running QB into the game.
 
PackMan97
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Painmaker
My biggest issue with allowing defenses to plan in response to different offensive players is that it would add to the already-ridiculous workload on DCs.


+1

I quit as a DC just because I don't have the time to scout, plan and adjust the DAI. I would also challenge the statement that this game is "free". I've spent a lot of money on it.

It would be nice if there were a way to "audible" defenses and set things up generically.

For example:
Audible: If this QB has run more than twice to the left, call these set of plays.
Audible: If this TE has never run a route, call these plays.
Audible: If this FB has run routes more than 50% this game, call these plays.

Part of the fun of this would be that you could set up your FB early in the game to pass block and then in the 4th Q break him out in a receiving role and catch a defense asleep. or whatever....

of course, setting up the logic to do something like that is the tricky part...but I'd think it would definitely be something that is NOT tied to a specific player or depth chart spot, but based on in-game results.
 
manx
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by DrunkenCowboy
The biggest exploit in the game is th


oh no, not ag
 
Link
 
Originally posted by PackMan97
Originally posted by Painmaker

My biggest issue with allowing defenses to plan in response to different offensive players is that it would add to the already-ridiculous workload on DCs.


+1

I quit as a DC just because I don't have the time to scout, plan and adjust the DAI. I would also challenge the statement that this game is "free". I've spent a lot of money on it.

It would be nice if there were a way to "audible" defenses and set things up generically.

For example:
Audible: If this QB has run more than twice to the left, call these set of plays.
Audible: If this TE has never run a route, call these plays.
Audible: If this FB has run routes more than 50% this game, call these plays.

Part of the fun of this would be that you could set up your FB early in the game to pass block and then in the 4th Q break him out in a receiving role and catch a defense asleep. or whatever....


of course, setting up the logic to do something like that is the tricky part...but I'd think it would definitely be something that is NOT tied to a specific player or depth chart spot, but based on in-game results.


i like that. might actually help push more well rounded players (at some positions anyway).
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.