Bort already said that he's looking into toning down the speed boost from breaking blocks. From what I can tell, it appears to only be a "problem" if the defensive lineman wins the very first blocking roll. If he does so and can burst forward before the offensive lineman has completed his drop, then he can quickly get beyond the angle at which blocking is allowed. If he doesn't win that initial roll, then the LG is usually able to drop back enough to prevent instant penetration even if the DE or DT wins a subsequent roll.
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > The time has come to remove the Click and Drag of the Defensive Line in the DPC
kurieg
offline
offline
Originally posted by fallingmercury
Originally posted by steellithium
Originally posted by kurieg
So I lined my DT up between the LG and the C, and he beat the double team http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=587112&pbp_id=14881073
Fix bug plz
He has 2 sacks all season. The DT's SA's are designed for double teams. There are 5 Oline men and 4 Dline men. Someone is going to get double teamed.
He's just trying to distort things. /ignore IMO.
No u.
Seriously, a bare handful of the best pass rushing DEs are beasting it up against LG's, and you think it's an exploit.
Point of the post is that even without TV/FS, beating double teams happens. Given even more pass-rushing SAs, beating double teams SHOULD happen more often.
There's no problem. There's certainly no problem with a 200+ combined Speed/Agility DE that's actually gotten his Str to the 4th cap and racked up a pile of pass rushing SAs like William Davis going to town sometimes.
Originally posted by steellithium
Originally posted by kurieg
So I lined my DT up between the LG and the C, and he beat the double team http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=587112&pbp_id=14881073
Fix bug plz
He has 2 sacks all season. The DT's SA's are designed for double teams. There are 5 Oline men and 4 Dline men. Someone is going to get double teamed.
He's just trying to distort things. /ignore IMO.
No u.
Seriously, a bare handful of the best pass rushing DEs are beasting it up against LG's, and you think it's an exploit.
Point of the post is that even without TV/FS, beating double teams happens. Given even more pass-rushing SAs, beating double teams SHOULD happen more often.
There's no problem. There's certainly no problem with a 200+ combined Speed/Agility DE that's actually gotten his Str to the 4th cap and racked up a pile of pass rushing SAs like William Davis going to town sometimes.
Edited by kurieg on Jul 17, 2009 12:47:59
jdbolick
offline
offline
It's not an exploit and it's not a bug, but it is a little overpowered and could use some correction.
kurieg
offline
offline
Originally posted by jdbolick
It's not an exploit and it's not a bug, but it is a little overpowered and could use some correction.
I can understand why some might think it's a bit OP, but I don't agree wtih that, either. Right now, the only ones racking up really good stats are the absolute best pass rushing DEs, even lined up against the LG or whatever. There might be 2-3 DEs per Pro league that would worry me as an OC with this.
Let G builds adjust. There are a lot of them that are more Run block focused.
It's not an exploit and it's not a bug, but it is a little overpowered and could use some correction.
I can understand why some might think it's a bit OP, but I don't agree wtih that, either. Right now, the only ones racking up really good stats are the absolute best pass rushing DEs, even lined up against the LG or whatever. There might be 2-3 DEs per Pro league that would worry me as an OC with this.
Let G builds adjust. There are a lot of them that are more Run block focused.
headsigh
offline
offline
What started this issue? It seemed like everything was working fine. I was looking at some test blog posts and I didn't find much. Guys were placing dots in similar alignments before and there was no problem.
All I can think of is
Originally posted by hurr
└Blitzers not picking up on handoffs or QB runs (general consensus is that it is failed vision checks)
└High level CPU players in low-level capped leagues
└Players running out of the back of the endzone
└Coverage on high hang time/short punts
└FB blocking logic a little off, especially for fast FBs
and
Originally posted by durr
└High level CPU players in lower level leagues. (Bort ran a script to take care of these, if you still see any, let us know)
└QBs running out of the back of the endzone (Added code on June 17th)
└Gunners running past the PR on Punt Returns
└Plays running too long, possibly related to QBs with no open targets not running like they should
└Individual/Conference statistics were running behind for awhile after the crash. Should be all caught up by now.
└Referral banners linked to a .gif when the image was a .jpg. Fixed.
those were the most recent ones before the issues started.
All I can think of is
Originally posted by hurr
└Blitzers not picking up on handoffs or QB runs (general consensus is that it is failed vision checks)
└High level CPU players in low-level capped leagues
└Players running out of the back of the endzone
└Coverage on high hang time/short punts
└FB blocking logic a little off, especially for fast FBs
and
Originally posted by durr
└High level CPU players in lower level leagues. (Bort ran a script to take care of these, if you still see any, let us know)
└QBs running out of the back of the endzone (Added code on June 17th)
└Gunners running past the PR on Punt Returns
└Plays running too long, possibly related to QBs with no open targets not running like they should
└Individual/Conference statistics were running behind for awhile after the crash. Should be all caught up by now.
└Referral banners linked to a .gif when the image was a .jpg. Fixed.
those were the most recent ones before the issues started.
Sik Wit It
offline
offline
I don't really care about this DPC nonsense...just FIX THE O-LINE BLOCKING PLEASE
These guys don't know what they're doing out there.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=587046&pbp_id=14860523 wtf?
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=587046&pbp_id=14861179 again
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=587046&pbp_id=14861882
"fix your builds" "needs more vision". The G in that play has 72 vision.
These guys don't know what they're doing out there.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=587046&pbp_id=14860523 wtf?
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=587046&pbp_id=14861179 again
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=587046&pbp_id=14861882
"fix your builds" "needs more vision". The G in that play has 72 vision.
headsigh
offline
offline
Originally posted by Sik Wit It
I don't really care about this DPC nonsense...just FIX THE O-LINE BLOCKING PLEASE
These guys don't know what they're doing out there.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=587046&pbp_id=14860523 wtf?
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=587046&pbp_id=14861179 again
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=587046&pbp_id=14861882
"fix your builds" "needs more vision". The G in that play has 72 vision.
http://test.goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=1276
They are, afaik.
I don't really care about this DPC nonsense...just FIX THE O-LINE BLOCKING PLEASE
These guys don't know what they're doing out there.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=587046&pbp_id=14860523 wtf?
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=587046&pbp_id=14861179 again
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=587046&pbp_id=14861882
"fix your builds" "needs more vision". The G in that play has 72 vision.
http://test.goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=1276
They are, afaik.
jdbolick
offline
offline
Originally posted by lolMurp
What started this issue?
Bort added a speed boost when you break a block. The idea was to prevent the old bumper-cars OT/DE interaction where the DE would just get immediately blocked again after shedding a previous block, but the issue now is that the boost is getting defensive linemen past the offensive line's allowed angle for blocking if those defenders are positioned in gaps.
What started this issue?
Bort added a speed boost when you break a block. The idea was to prevent the old bumper-cars OT/DE interaction where the DE would just get immediately blocked again after shedding a previous block, but the issue now is that the boost is getting defensive linemen past the offensive line's allowed angle for blocking if those defenders are positioned in gaps.
kurieg
offline
offline
Originally posted by jdbolick
Originally posted by lolMurp
What started this issue?
Bort added a speed boost when you break a block. The idea was to prevent the old bumper-cars OT/DE interaction where the DE would just get immediately blocked again after shedding a previous block, but the issue now is that the boost is getting defensive linemen past the offensive line's allowed angle for blocking if those defenders are positioned in gaps.
Why is that a problem?
Why, exactly, is it a problem for a failed block attempt to result in the DE shooting through the line and killing the QB?
We're down to worrying exactly what particularly turn in the spreadsheet caused it?
The root cause is - the LG gets owned super-fast.
Originally posted by lolMurp
What started this issue?
Bort added a speed boost when you break a block. The idea was to prevent the old bumper-cars OT/DE interaction where the DE would just get immediately blocked again after shedding a previous block, but the issue now is that the boost is getting defensive linemen past the offensive line's allowed angle for blocking if those defenders are positioned in gaps.
Why is that a problem?
Why, exactly, is it a problem for a failed block attempt to result in the DE shooting through the line and killing the QB?
We're down to worrying exactly what particularly turn in the spreadsheet caused it?
The root cause is - the LG gets owned super-fast.
kurieg
offline
offline
Originally posted by kurieg
Why is that a problem?
Why, exactly, is it a problem for a failed block attempt to result in the DE shooting through the line and killing the QB?
We're down to worrying exactly what particularly turn in the spreadsheet caused it?
The root cause is - the LG gets owned super-fast.
The answer is:
1) Nerf
2) Allow the meta-game to actually get a chance to evolve.
Why is that a problem?
Why, exactly, is it a problem for a failed block attempt to result in the DE shooting through the line and killing the QB?
We're down to worrying exactly what particularly turn in the spreadsheet caused it?
The root cause is - the LG gets owned super-fast.
The answer is:
1) Nerf
2) Allow the meta-game to actually get a chance to evolve.
fallingmercury
offline
offline
Originally posted by kurieg
Originally posted by kurieg
Why is that a problem?
Why, exactly, is it a problem for a failed block attempt to result in the DE shooting through the line and killing the QB?
We're down to worrying exactly what particularly turn in the spreadsheet caused it?
The root cause is - the LG gets owned super-fast.
The answer is:
1) Nerf
2) Allow the meta-game to actually get a chance to evolve.
Fixing unintended side effects is not a nerf, by definition. This bug/exploit/etc was never intentionally put into the game. It was never supposed to work like this.
It's just like the mentor fix - it was never meant to stack so high so Bort fixed it work like it was intended. Same thing
Originally posted by kurieg
Why is that a problem?
Why, exactly, is it a problem for a failed block attempt to result in the DE shooting through the line and killing the QB?
We're down to worrying exactly what particularly turn in the spreadsheet caused it?
The root cause is - the LG gets owned super-fast.
The answer is:
1) Nerf
2) Allow the meta-game to actually get a chance to evolve.
Fixing unintended side effects is not a nerf, by definition. This bug/exploit/etc was never intentionally put into the game. It was never supposed to work like this.
It's just like the mentor fix - it was never meant to stack so high so Bort fixed it work like it was intended. Same thing
Edited by fallingmercury on Jul 17, 2009 13:04:43
jdbolick
offline
offline
Originally posted by kurieg
Why is that a problem?
Because even the best defensive linemen don't get instant sacks, which is what the "win first roll -> speed boost -> SACK!" essentially amounts to.
Originally posted by kurieg
The answer is:
1) Nerf
2) Allow the meta-game to actually get a chance to evolve.
I get so tired of every flaw in the sim being labeled an "exploit," and every attempt to address those flaws being labeled a "nerf." When a problem is caused by something Bort changed in the sim, then Bort changing something to address it is not a nerf, it's simply correcting an unintended consequence. I want defensive linemen to be capable of breaking a double team or splitting a gap, but it is a little too potent right now because of the speed boost and the limit on blocking angles.
Why is that a problem?
Because even the best defensive linemen don't get instant sacks, which is what the "win first roll -> speed boost -> SACK!" essentially amounts to.
Originally posted by kurieg
The answer is:
1) Nerf
2) Allow the meta-game to actually get a chance to evolve.
I get so tired of every flaw in the sim being labeled an "exploit," and every attempt to address those flaws being labeled a "nerf." When a problem is caused by something Bort changed in the sim, then Bort changing something to address it is not a nerf, it's simply correcting an unintended consequence. I want defensive linemen to be capable of breaking a double team or splitting a gap, but it is a little too potent right now because of the speed boost and the limit on blocking angles.
tdm13
offline
offline
Originally posted by kurieg
If you don't get the diff between this and Mentor, there's no hope for you tbh.
If you don't get the diff between this and Mentor, there's no hope for you tbh.
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.






























