User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Bort answered Questions/Concerns about restructure here (after a few pages of complaints about thread-locking)
Page:
 
JeffSteele
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Adderfist

Well, in baseball, the yank's had to pay a 40% luxury tax.

Would you do that for the full team roster or just the individual player?


Maybe just something like some amount per level you have over, per player, or something along those lines.

It really would put a strain on those teams who have higher level players, but just can't seem to put it together and win, though. I've seen quite a few of those teams out there.
The only way to fix that problem is to reshuffle the uncapped Minors every season based on median-of-top-25% level. That way those teams who just can't make it can duke it out to try and make it, and fall within their own suggested levels. This would only occur in the uncapped Minors, so it's a bit easier to handle.

I still think the strain won't be a problem for exploiters, as they'll just garner a cash cow of $100m+ (I saw it on BBB teams this year) and then ignore the tax. As a result, the tax will inadvertently promote dead franchises for years while a reserve is set up for a push to the Pyramid.
 
Link
 
Bort, I still think the total level cap is the best way to go.


That would bring so much more strategy into the game (deciding where to put your level 39 guys and where you could play level 59 guys).


For instance have 2 leagues:


50 players x 50 level average = 2500 total levels max league

Teams would be made up of guys level: 25, 47, 52, 60, 57, 55, 47, etc etc

and a.....


50 players x 25 average level = 1250 level max league

Teams would be made up of guys level: 14, 17, 25, 27, 31, 19, 24, 27, 28, 19, etc etc



Then you wouldn't have such a demand for players at the max under the cap and a vacuum of unwanted players at levels below.


This way of doing things also stops the ugly slow build teams and useless players. Any player of any level could be a part of a championship team.

Right now, most people don't even watch their slow build players until they reach the top levels (ie 7 seasons of boredom)



 
presvedder
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by SyedAshrafulla

Originally posted by Bort


Originally posted by SyedAshrafulla



I don't think a tax would work then because teams (as was seen in the Gutted Pro thread) are very willing to lose and lose and lose in order to create a giant bank account and then spend like the Angels do (I'm a Yankees fan, shut up). The penalty has to be in-game somehow, and I do believe that you have afforded leniency by making the suggested levels very far apart in comparison to what most teams have in the league. There's no reason to add leniency by taxes, etc. when those players should. just. be. cut.


I have always been very against forcing teams to break up just due to leveling up, though. If you start out under the required levels, and then gain enough levels to go over the suggested level for the league, maybe just because your team sucks and can't get promoted, you should have to leave your friends behind? If may seem fair, but it's also not very fun.
That can't happen, because of the nature of the suggested levels. You update the median every day, pretty much, and heap a giant window on top of that. So when a team levels up, the rest of the teams will level up within a few days of that, behind or forward. As a result, the median window will shift and capture that team's levels again if they were on the precipice.

In addition, if you are continually held back and as a result are say a L38 punter in a L24 league, then this level discrepancy hurts the league more than it would hurt the individual to be removed from the team. I contend the rights of fair play in the league are more important than the rights of the individual to stay with his friends (a strong right, indeed, but not strong enough).

As for a possible middle ground, I think stopping VAs and fame for being above suggested levels is a decent start. I think an even better scenario is to stop XP as well. That would force the player to make one of two decisions: stunt growth a bit until you are on the level with your team or leave the team to find real competition. That way the player has a choice: he can stay with his friends and have them catch up to him (because his growth is stunted) OR he can go ahead and play on his own if he really didn't care about that team to begin with. To implement this, that player would just have a "release myself" link at the top (which IMO players on teams whose owners are inactive for more than a week should have as well). Then the player says "ok I'll let them come up to me since we're buds" or "ehh I want to develop my player, I'll go elsewhere."


Sounds like sportsmanship that people went batshit insane over.

I suppose the suggested levels could just be de-facto signing caps as well, if they were set a little lower. Sort of a "floating" soft level cap for the technically uncapped leagues.


I don't get the whole "cap" thing. Currently there is no cap with the given structure. With the way things have been restructured, a 16 "cap" means anyone can join. Why even use the word cap? A cap would mean that no one above that level is allowed in that league. Might as well go back to the pyramid structure if you are going to allow anyone to be in these leagues.
 
JeffSteele
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
Bort, I still think the total level cap is the best way to go.


That would bring so much more strategy into the game (deciding where to put your level 39 guys and where you could play level 59 guys).


For instance have 2 leagues:


50 players x 50 level average = 2500 total levels max league

Teams would be made up of guys level: 25, 47, 52, 60, 57, 55, 47, etc etc

and a.....


50 players x 25 average level = 1250 level max league

Teams would be made up of guys level: 14, 17, 25, 27, 31, 19, 24, 27, 28, 19, etc etc



Then you wouldn't have such a demand for players at the max under the cap and a vacuum of unwanted players at levels below.


This way of doing things also stops the ugly slow build teams and useless players. Any player of any level could be a part of a championship team.

Right now, most people don't even watch their slow build players until they reach the top levels (ie 7 seasons of boredom)



Really? I started watching my slow builds in season 3. All of them.
 
presvedder
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SyedAshrafulla
Originally posted by SteelersInsider

Bort, I still think the total level cap is the best way to go.


That would bring so much more strategy into the game (deciding where to put your level 39 guys and where you could play level 59 guys).


For instance have 2 leagues:


50 players x 50 level average = 2500 total levels max league

Teams would be made up of guys level: 25, 47, 52, 60, 57, 55, 47, etc etc

and a.....


50 players x 25 average level = 1250 level max league

Teams would be made up of guys level: 14, 17, 25, 27, 31, 19, 24, 27, 28, 19, etc etc



Then you wouldn't have such a demand for players at the max under the cap and a vacuum of unwanted players at levels below.


This way of doing things also stops the ugly slow build teams and useless players. Any player of any level could be a part of a championship team.

Right now, most people don't even watch their slow build players until they reach the top levels (ie 7 seasons of boredom)



Really? I started watching my slow builds in season 3. All of them.


I was going to start watching mine in season 2, but our level 16 cap league is filled with team in their 20's while we are 13, so I guess I will have to wait until season 7 now.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by SyedAshrafulla
Originally posted by SteelersInsider

Bort, I still think the total level cap is the best way to go.


That would bring so much more strategy into the game (deciding where to put your level 39 guys and where you could play level 59 guys).


For instance have 2 leagues:


50 players x 50 level average = 2500 total levels max league

Teams would be made up of guys level: 25, 47, 52, 60, 57, 55, 47, etc etc

and a.....


50 players x 25 average level = 1250 level max league

Teams would be made up of guys level: 14, 17, 25, 27, 31, 19, 24, 27, 28, 19, etc etc



Then you wouldn't have such a demand for players at the max under the cap and a vacuum of unwanted players at levels below.


This way of doing things also stops the ugly slow build teams and useless players. Any player of any level could be a part of a championship team.

Right now, most people don't even watch their slow build players until they reach the top levels (ie 7 seasons of boredom)



Really? I started watching my slow builds in season 3. All of them.



You are one of the few. Most people don't even bother and put them on 0-16 teams.

You will take this as an insult, but it isn't:


If you were involved with high level players on Pro level teams then you wouldn't care about low level players so much.





Edited by SteelersInsider on Jun 5, 2009 19:21:14
 
jmsne
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by SyedAshrafulla

I don't think a tax would work then because teams (as was seen in the Gutted Pro thread) are very willing to lose and lose and lose in order to create a giant bank account and then spend like the Angels do (I'm a Yankees fan, shut up). The penalty has to be in-game somehow, and I do believe that you have afforded leniency by making the suggested levels very far apart in comparison to what most teams have in the league. There's no reason to add leniency by taxes, etc. when those players should. just. be. cut.


I have always been very against forcing teams to break up just due to leveling up, though. If you start out under the required levels, and then gain enough levels to go over the suggested level for the league, maybe just because your team sucks and can't get promoted, you should have to leave your friends behind? If may seem fair, but it's also not very fun.


Then the team should play in a league more fitting the higher level players not the lower level ones.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by presvedder
I don't get the whole "cap" thing. Currently there is no cap with the given structure. With the way things have been restructured, a 16 "cap" means anyone can join. Why even use the word cap? A cap would mean that no one above that level is allowed in that league. Might as well go back to the pyramid structure if you are going to allow anyone to be in these leagues.


It is a cap for new signings only. If you have players on the team who go over the cap, they aren't forced off. It's a pretty simple concept.

Or are you just lamenting that you wish the higher level players were forced off?
 
Link
 
my team now has to pay higher level players with stadium that isn't ready for them--I have gone from being ahead to even on stadium progress to holy S how to I pay for these guys--every time I think about it going from level 34 to uncapped gets worse.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jmsne
Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by SyedAshrafulla


I don't think a tax would work then because teams (as was seen in the Gutted Pro thread) are very willing to lose and lose and lose in order to create a giant bank account and then spend like the Angels do (I'm a Yankees fan, shut up). The penalty has to be in-game somehow, and I do believe that you have afforded leniency by making the suggested levels very far apart in comparison to what most teams have in the league. There's no reason to add leniency by taxes, etc. when those players should. just. be. cut.


I have always been very against forcing teams to break up just due to leveling up, though. If you start out under the required levels, and then gain enough levels to go over the suggested level for the league, maybe just because your team sucks and can't get promoted, you should have to leave your friends behind? If may seem fair, but it's also not very fun.


Then the team should play in a league more fitting the higher level players not the lower level ones.


I think the problem is that not all levels are equal. You can have a team of level 50 players who get beat by a team of level 40's, because of tactics, or terrible build decisions, etc. Levels are sort of an indication of team strength, but aren't the whole picture, which is why a couple guys going over the cap because the team is losing isn't really a big deal in the end. People see "OMG THEY HAVE LEVEL 30's" but they don't bother to look at the fact that the team went 3-13 last season vs teams with level 16's.

The original structure the game had tried to not take level into account at all - we just figured that the cream would rise to the top, and the dregs would fall to the bottom. It worked, but it did it very slowly, and a few too many team sales and it took even longer. It was really originally built with the idea of having smaller leagues, not 9000 teams like we have now.
 
presvedder
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by presvedder

I don't get the whole "cap" thing. Currently there is no cap with the given structure. With the way things have been restructured, a 16 "cap" means anyone can join. Why even use the word cap? A cap would mean that no one above that level is allowed in that league. Might as well go back to the pyramid structure if you are going to allow anyone to be in these leagues.


It is a cap for new signings only. If you have players on the team who go over the cap, they aren't forced off. It's a pretty simple concept.

Or are you just lamenting that you wish the higher level players were forced off?


If we are doing a complete restructure right now, why not just do it right? If a team is full of players over a level 16 why not put them into the level 21 cap right now and so on? The effort was put out to restructure the entire league system, teams can stay together, but play with teams in their "cap".
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Landrys Legacy
my team now has to pay higher level players with stadium that isn't ready for them--I have gone from being ahead to even on stadium progress to holy S how to I pay for these guys--every time I think about it going from level 34 to uncapped gets worse.


Uganda is all set now, the owner found somebody who REALLY wanted to go uncapped.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by presvedder
Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by presvedder


I don't get the whole "cap" thing. Currently there is no cap with the given structure. With the way things have been restructured, a 16 "cap" means anyone can join. Why even use the word cap? A cap would mean that no one above that level is allowed in that league. Might as well go back to the pyramid structure if you are going to allow anyone to be in these leagues.


It is a cap for new signings only. If you have players on the team who go over the cap, they aren't forced off. It's a pretty simple concept.

Or are you just lamenting that you wish the higher level players were forced off?


If we are doing a complete restructure right now, why not just do it right? If a team is full of players over a level 16 why not put them into the level 21 cap right now and so on? The effort was put out to restructure the entire league system, teams can stay together, but play with teams in their "cap".


Depends on where they were. If they were in a capped league last season, they just promoted based on the rules I laid out, the same way they will for each season moving forward.
 
presvedder
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by presvedder

Originally posted by Bort


Originally posted by presvedder



I don't get the whole "cap" thing. Currently there is no cap with the given structure. With the way things have been restructured, a 16 "cap" means anyone can join. Why even use the word cap? A cap would mean that no one above that level is allowed in that league. Might as well go back to the pyramid structure if you are going to allow anyone to be in these leagues.


It is a cap for new signings only. If you have players on the team who go over the cap, they aren't forced off. It's a pretty simple concept.

Or are you just lamenting that you wish the higher level players were forced off?


If we are doing a complete restructure right now, why not just do it right? If a team is full of players over a level 16 why not put them into the level 21 cap right now and so on? The effort was put out to restructure the entire league system, teams can stay together, but play with teams in their "cap".


Depends on where they were. If they were in a capped league last season, they just promoted based on the rules I laid out, the same way they will for each season moving forward.


That makes no sense. If I am a team in a 16 cap and my team is currently made up of 19-21 level players, how am I supposed to build a team for the long run by adding guys consistently who are under leveled for the "cap" that my team is in?

ETA:

For example, this team is very limited in its recruiting http://goallineblitz.com/game/roster.pl?team_id=2700 Level 16 cap and not one player under level 17. If they needed someone it will only be a one year deal. Hard to build a dynasty with the high rate of turnover on the roster and the grind of recruiting.
Edited by presvedder on Jun 5, 2009 19:44:09
 
Whatsdafus
offline
Link
 
Wow... 13 pages. read em all. and everyone knows im not the guy who sides with LOLMODS (i hate the mods we have, well a few of them) But seriously, there has been nothing but crying in this thread..

I can fight for the mods cause:
You guys realize that lower level players level faster then higher level players, right? and that over time, they catch up.... so if you have to recruit a lvl 16 cause someone has lvl 19 players... big fucking deal. You try your best to beat them, if not, hope they get promoted and you try your best next season. I dont get all the bitching. Does everyone want a trophy at the end of the season? Do you not expect to make it to a title game to be fucking hard?

At the same time i can fight for the people:
Lvl caps take time to settle. last season we had morons who were level 56 signing in A level leagues... Just for lolstats. The higher level players arent being forced up as well as it should be. i blaim poor caps.
2 examples....


USA Pro League
Lv 25-100, 42-100 Suggested

USA AAA #1
Lv 20-100, 41-72 Suggested

USA AA #1
Lv 1-100, 39-68 Suggested

Do those make any fucking sense? no one is hitting 72 for another 2 seasons if at all. AA should not have 68 as its cap. it should be 50. AAA should be 60... Pro should have 50+. there is no bottle necking up....

i could do the same for all the other leagues.... you have lolstat players who dont care about anything but beating on guts and slowbuild teams in lower level leagues.

I would have another example but cant find S9 league tree to use the lvl caps dont work example to make fair play and parity.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.