User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > League Moving Based on Median and Max Level of Players on Team
Page:
 
Octowned
offline
Link
 
edit - nevermind, already answered
Last edited Apr 1, 2009 20:35:33
 
JcWildcat
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Okay another question, what day is this reshuffle going to happen? Wouldn't mind all this if we could get our season 9 roster together before the re-shuffle. I don't want my team to get its ass handed to it either if we're in a league that has rosters of level 50s stocked full on it.
Last edited Apr 1, 2009 18:26:23
 
JCJayhawk
Achoothulhu
offline
Link
 
Bort,

Let's say our levels on the team range from lvl 20 to level 46. For our purposes here let's say the median level would be lvl 33. If we can sign players before the reshuffle would that allow us to be in a 35 capped league (if there is such a thing)?

Also, if the reshuffle happens before we are able to sign new players, are we allowed to sign players higher than the cap as long as the median level stays below the cap?

Thanks for any help you can provide
 
Dpride59
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by JCJayhawk
Bort,

Let's say our levels on the team range from lvl 20 to level 46. For our purposes here let's say the median level would be lvl 33. If we can sign players before the reshuffle would that allow us to be in a 35 capped league (if there is such a thing)?

Also, if the reshuffle happens before we are able to sign new players, are we allowed to sign players higher than the cap as long as the median level stays below the cap?

Thanks for any help you can provide


Dude hell no. You would have to go to the bottom uncapped league. Otherwise teams are just going to sign a bunch of level "20 guys who have horrible builds, and never play them, and then stack roster with 45's. Make "median" 24 and dominate. This is the entire point. If you have over level 34 players you should not be playing under 34 players. 31/34 capped teams are going to be composed of way lower than 31 avg. so if he sets it to work this way. I am going to get get 25 level 50 guys and just sign 50 level 1 guys to balance it out and then get into a 24 cap.
Last edited Apr 1, 2009 18:34:38
 
JCJayhawk
Achoothulhu
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dpride59
Originally posted by JCJayhawk

Bort,

Let's say our levels on the team range from lvl 20 to level 46. For our purposes here let's say the median level would be lvl 33. If we can sign players before the reshuffle would that allow us to be in a 35 capped league (if there is such a thing)?

Also, if the reshuffle happens before we are able to sign new players, are we allowed to sign players higher than the cap as long as the median level stays below the cap?

Thanks for any help you can provide


Dude hell no. You would have to go to the bottom uncapped league. Otherwise teams are just going to sign a bunch of level "20 guys who have horrible builds, and never play them, and then stack roster with 45's. Make "median" 24 and dominate. This is the entire point. If you have over level 34 players you should not be playing under 34 players. 31/34 capped teams are going to be composed of way lower than 31 avg. so if he sets it to work this way. I am going to get get 25 level 50 guys and just sign 50 level 1 guys to balance it out and then get into a 24 cap.


/sigh

So basically what you're saying is that in order to remain competitive we have to jettison all of the friends and cohorts we've made on glb and sign a full roster of guys of the same level or have everyone retire their players and start from scratch.

I guess the question that I have is will the "uncapped" league that we end up in consist of teams with a similar median level to ours? If that's the case what's to stop any of those teams from then going out and grabbing a bunch of level 50+'s to dominate the league? Seems kind of counter productive.
Last edited Apr 1, 2009 18:49:50
 
Dpride59
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by JCJayhawk
Originally posted by dpride59

Originally posted by JCJayhawk


Bort,

Let's say our levels on the team range from lvl 20 to level 46. For our purposes here let's say the median level would be lvl 33. If we can sign players before the reshuffle would that allow us to be in a 35 capped league (if there is such a thing)?

Also, if the reshuffle happens before we are able to sign new players, are we allowed to sign players higher than the cap as long as the median level stays below the cap?

Thanks for any help you can provide


Dude hell no. You would have to go to the bottom uncapped league. Otherwise teams are just going to sign a bunch of level "20 guys who have horrible builds, and never play them, and then stack roster with 45's. Make "median" 24 and dominate. This is the entire point. If you have over level 34 players you should not be playing under 34 players. 31/34 capped teams are going to be composed of way lower than 31 avg. so if he sets it to work this way. I am going to get get 25 level 50 guys and just sign 50 level 1 guys to balance it out and then get into a 24 cap.


/sigh

So basically what you're saying is that in order to remain competitive we have to jettison all of the friends and cohorts we've made on glb and sign a full roster of guys of the same level or have everyone retire their players and start from scratch.



No. How come your level 50 friends didn't make level 1 guys 2 seasons ago. They would already be level 20+. You can't expect to get into a fucking "capped league" with level 50 players. How is it fun for 25-30 players to play vs a level 50? Give me a break. And if you are not in a BBB league, or Oceania SEA A, or Africa this change isn't going to affect you. I hope your not talking about that EE A squad you have BC nothing is going to change there
 
JCJayhawk
Achoothulhu
offline
Link
 
I must have misunderstood then. I was under the impression that this was a complete reshuffle. If that actually is the case I have no further questions.
 
Dpride59
offline
Link
 
This offseason, we'll be shuffling the uncapped bottom tiers to get teams of similar level together, and all CPU's in their own leagues. This means tiers like USA BBB will get shuffled up, Oceania A will get shuffled up, etc. We'll sort teams based on the median and max level of players on the team.
- For the leagues that have lower level teams shuffled into them (or CPUs), we will be capping them at 13/16/21/24/28/31/34 based on the teams that get shuffled there. Leagues with teams in the higher 30's, 40's, etc. will remain uncapped.

So the bottom tiers of all leagues like he saids are getting shuffled. Your league already has a BBB so your good. Since you have already been promoted everything stays the same. I Think you get it judging by your post.

Do you understand tho if you had level 50's on a team that had never been promoted you would not deserve to receive a cap?
 
JCJayhawk
Achoothulhu
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dpride59
This offseason, we'll be shuffling the uncapped bottom tiers to get teams of similar level together, and all CPU's in their own leagues. This means tiers like USA BBB will get shuffled up, Oceania A will get shuffled up, etc. We'll sort teams based on the median and max level of players on the team.
- For the leagues that have lower level teams shuffled into them (or CPUs), we will be capping them at 13/16/21/24/28/31/34 based on the teams that get shuffled there. Leagues with teams in the higher 30's, 40's, etc. will remain uncapped.

So the bottom tiers of all leagues like he saids are getting shuffled. Your league already has a BBB so your good. Since you have already been promoted everything stays the same. I Think you get it judging by your post.

Do you understand tho if you had level 50's on a team that had never been promoted you would not deserve to receive a cap?


I get it and we won't be signing any level 50's anyway. We do have a couple of level 40-45 guys. And my concern was being put into an uncapped 50+ league with the roster we have.
Last edited Apr 1, 2009 19:06:23
 
mantis7
offline
Link
 
Why not make more caps?


Why not have hard caps all the way up?

I am just a little confused as to why this system doesn't go all the way up....

I would like to end up in a league that is capped that I can keep my players in for a few seasons and eventually make the playoffs....

sigh
 
merenoise
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dpride59
Originally posted by Snakebite99

So in other words, this isnt going to help teams with players in the 35-40 range, as theyll still be in an uncapped league with plenty of teams with 45-52 players? How is this any different than what we have now with capped 34 leagues being the max? Would be nice to have a 40 capped league after the 34 capped league, then maybe a 48, then finally uncapped, and adjust these on a season to season basis relative to the median level in Pro leagues.

Example:
Season 9
SA BBB - level 21 cap (28 at midseason)
SA A - level 34
SA AA - level 40
SA AAA - Level 48
SA Pro - Uncapped (median of say 50?)

Then in season 10, youd change to -
SA BBB - Level 34
SA A - Level 40
SA AA - Level 48
SA AAA - Level 52
SA Pro - Uncapped (median of say 54-55)

Season 11
SA BBB - Level 40
SA A - Level 48
SA AA - Level 52
SA AAA - Level 58
SA Pro - Uncapped

So on and so forth. Of course players would be grandfathered so that no one would ever be kicked off a team if theyve been with them since the previous cap allowed, but at some point, those teams SHOULD be promoting to the next level. A good example of what it would look like after 4-5 seasons would be the USA league. Right now, youd have BBB teams capped at 40 (other than grandfathered players obviously), A would be 48 cap, etc. USA pro now has a lot of level 54-56 guys in it so that's kind of the model im looking at. Of course itd need some fine tuning, but this would assure relatively balanced competition each season, as well as makign sure you have enough players to go around for the AAA and Pro leagues, rather than seeing teams move their high level guys to lower leagues like you see now. Just a thought, flame away


Bad idea imo. No BBB should be over 50 +, and if they are something is seriously flawed. A team with a avg group of level 44 players can win in A, I have a few over 34 players and I am flat out getting rid of them. The core of my team is level 28, and we were able to compete with the level 40 guys (who are built horribly) only losing by 10 pts. The biggest defeat we got all season was by another slow build squad of level 35's.

Basically well built 35-40 teams should dominate and get promoted within 1-2 seasons. The group of level 35 players in our league "college town" Went 15-1 in the most competitive division of usa BBB. You will play the higher teams but as this stage there is no reason you can't compete and get promoted.


These caps would be raised each season though so promotion wouldn't really be the issue. It would keep people from bringing in players over the cap of league promoting even more competitive games. Eventually if teams keep getting added I'm assuming that there will be BB leagues and even B leagues. Having them all capped within a range would ensure that everyone is playing on a somewhat level field with the difference being builds.

For instance take any of the uncapped A leagues, many have teams with players in the high 40s and low 50s going up against the level 30s of the more recently promoted teams. If you created tiers in the middle of that there wouldn't be any way for owners to throw off the balance of the league simply by bringing in their season 1 players to an A league. This would promote the natural gravitation of the higher level players to the higher leagues and insulate the lower leagues from having to play opposition that is 15 levels higher than them. The best built teams would still promote, the games would just be more competitive since players would be all within a similar window of levels of one another.
 
Octowned
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by JcWildcat

Originally posted by JcWildcat


Originally posted by Bort




Yes, having level 40+ players is going to exclude you from the lower caps. However, having say, 1 level 32 player along with a bunch of lv 12 players won't exclude you from the 31 capped league, since I'm basing it on median and a bit of fudge factor for the upper end.

Also, CPU's don't count if you have humans on your team.


Hmmm, okay say my median level is around 28. I have level 40+ players and 30+ players as well. I recruited and have commitments from level 40 and level 30+ players so I want to make SURE I won't be capped.

Think I remember there is going to be a 34 cap also, I just want to be CERTAIN that won't be the case

I know I'm sounding redundant and all, I just am one owner who does NOT want to go back on my word to folks I've got lined up already


Bort, can you clarify that last question for me?


Well, lets say your median level is 28. If I add an option where you can say "put me in uncapped," when I do the shuffle run, it will look and say "this team's set for uncapped and their median level's lower, go for uncapped."


The only problem I see with this is that you're allowing people to lie and get in a good league.

As an owner of a legit level 28-38 team I want to play against other players of that level next season!

If I've got people who are level 20s and clicked a box "uncapped league" and they end up in my league and don't recruit at a high level... well that defeats the entire purpose of this shuffle.

A few suggestions jumbled into one paragraph:
I think you should do a league promotion/relegation like usual... Then give us 3-4 days for recruiting and general offseason. Then shuffle the BBB, add caps, and go straight to the preseason. If a player is currently on a day 1/2 contract and had a team lined up, IMO you should drop those contracts to day 40 anyway... or allow a day 1/2 contract player to drop themselves after day 40, for example. Or, some sort of option where they can "commit" to another team, which is taken into account in the median level calculation, and when their contract expires, they are automatically signed to their new contract.

Actually, that last line is a good suggestion in general, IMO. Allow an agent to sign a new contract, but isn't honored until their current one expires. When that one does expire, they are automatically signed over to the new contract.... then you could use pending contract signings to calculate the median/max level on day 44 to day -8 crossover to shuffle things and give people recruiting time AND take into acount day 1/2 contracts
 
mantis7
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dpride59
Originally posted by mantis7

How will this work if most of my players are level 34 or lower but I have a couple around level 38 and one in his 40's?

We are all friends but I really don't want to be reshuffled into a super hard league just because of a couple of players...


I am nervous about this!


You are in "A" with a BBB structure underneath you. Nothing will change.


thats what I was afraid of....

Oh well.....

IMO there should be caps all the way up, like A sould have higher caps than BBB and AA higher.....

This "change" means nothing to me, as I will be stuck with my level 35 team facing uncapped teams....like I have been this season and last season....I would love to have my team be comprised of 35's and play in a 35 cap league or even a 40 cap league and play 2 seasons and be good next season...

Maybe I am pessimistic, but I am very disappointed with this.
 
merenoise
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by mantis7
Originally posted by dpride59

Originally posted by mantis7


How will this work if most of my players are level 34 or lower but I have a couple around level 38 and one in his 40's?

We are all friends but I really don't want to be reshuffled into a super hard league just because of a couple of players...


I am nervous about this!


You are in "A" with a BBB structure underneath you. Nothing will change.


thats what I was afraid of....

Oh well.....

IMO there should be caps all the way up, like A sould have higher caps than BBB and AA higher.....

This "change" means nothing to me, as I will be stuck with my level 35 team facing uncapped teams....like I have been this season and last season....I would love to have my team be comprised of 35's and play in a 35 cap league or even a 40 cap league and play 2 seasons and be good next season...

Maybe I am pessimistic, but I am very disappointed with this.


I agree. I think hard caps that shift as the make up of the league shifts are a crucial element that is missing. And I'm a firm believer that those caps should exist in every level but Pro which should naturally be uncapped. This way the level 45-50 level players are playing other 45-50 level players, the 35-40 level players are on even ground etc.
 
Dpride59
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by mantis7
Originally posted by dpride59

Originally posted by mantis7


How will this work if most of my players are level 34 or lower but I have a couple around level 38 and one in his 40's?

We are all friends but I really don't want to be reshuffled into a super hard league just because of a couple of players...


I am nervous about this!


You are in "A" with a BBB structure underneath you. Nothing will change.


thats what I was afraid of....

Oh well.....

IMO there should be caps all the way up, like A sould have higher caps than BBB and AA higher.....

This "change" means nothing to me, as I will be stuck with my level 35 team facing uncapped teams....like I have been this season and last season....I would love to have my team be comprised of 35's and play in a 35 cap league or even a 40 cap league and play 2 seasons and be good next season...

Maybe I am pessimistic, but I am very disappointed with this.

Why are you disappointed? You have a solid roster 4-6 teams will get promoted, and 4-6 teams from BBB will fill there shoes. You are looking at 10-12 wins w/o any changes to the teams infront of you or to your roster. You will be closing the gap, and with hard work could end up 14-2 next season. So going 10-6, - 14-2 is disappointing to you? Do you want bort to move your squad into some sort of capped league so you can go 16-0 and demolish everyone? What are you looking for as a solution?
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.