User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Endorsements - What I am thinking
Page:
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Hikariu

Originally posted by Bort


Originally posted by Capaneus



Originally posted by Bort





You're probably right, actually. I could do a MVP list based on last season stats per league from the live site, output in in a text file or something, and post results until it looks good?


Sounds great, and I'd love to see the results.


I'll have to set something up. I doubt it will be hard to set up. The formula will be the hard part.


For the MVP award what are you thoughts about just letting the playoff team owners vote like a poll. One vote for O/D/ST per playoff team owner after the championship game and one Superbowl MVP award based on raw stats in that game.


I am wary of any purely vote based systems. They are likely to be gamed and campaigned for.

However, what if votes were included as part of weighting of an MVP calculation?


No voting please...recipe for multiple disasters.

 
Luzod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by britdevine316
Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by Hikariu


Originally posted by Bort



Originally posted by Capaneus




Originally posted by Bort






You're probably right, actually. I could do a MVP list based on last season stats per league from the live site, output in in a text file or something, and post results until it looks good?


Sounds great, and I'd love to see the results.


I'll have to set something up. I doubt it will be hard to set up. The formula will be the hard part.


For the MVP award what are you thoughts about just letting the playoff team owners vote like a poll. One vote for O/D/ST per playoff team owner after the championship game and one Superbowl MVP award based on raw stats in that game.


I am wary of any purely vote based systems. They are likely to be gamed and campaigned for.

However, what if votes were included as part of weighting of an MVP calculation?


Anything with player/owner voting is too exploity.


... so a bad idea.
 
DrkSandman
Baseballs
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kretchfoop
Originally posted by DrkSandman

Originally posted by RTJakarta


SWEET. BONUS TOKENS. /rolleyes


Contribute to the conversation.


He was...just indirectly. Input was asked for and input was given. He thinks bonus tokens are a joke for something so hard to get. I agree.


Okay, and that's fine. I'd just like to see reasons given rather than sarcasm.
 
Rezlov
offline
Link
 
Finding an MVP using a formula is not going to merit any success. You will have guys who are slightly better lose, guys who aren't actually the best in the top and so on.

If fame is truly based on playing within suggested levels and performing against fairly matched teams, Fame should be an adequate decider.

Don't base it on the amount of gain in fame, make it total fame at season end. Give fame a % value [like 1000 fame is worth .10%], toss the balls in the lottery and let it decide. Make it so the lowest fame in the league has nearly no chance, while the highest has the best chance.
 
nthomas
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by smizzy
- strip the old ones away
- compensate the guys who have been stripped of the ones they got
- rerun the script to double the amount of endorsements per league ( 32 per conference , 64 per league)
- limit the teams to 5 Endorsements per team ( 2-offensive, 2 defensive,1 ST)
- limit it to 5 endorsements can be active at once
- Minimum of 2 endorsements per team ( Random)
- No player can get endorsements in back2back seasons
- You can't trade/ release a player with an endorsement unless he is willing to waive his endorsement

Instead of making things more complicated Bort, why not just simplify it and make more of them?


There is a lot of sense in this. Not perfect, but good.
 
Nuge20
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by nthomas
Originally posted by smizzy

- strip the old ones away
- compensate the guys who have been stripped of the ones they got
- rerun the script to double the amount of endorsements per league ( 32 per conference , 64 per league)
- limit the teams to 5 Endorsements per team ( 2-offensive, 2 defensive,1 ST)
- limit it to 5 endorsements can be active at once
- Minimum of 2 endorsements per team ( Random)
- No player can get endorsements in back2back seasons
- You can't trade/ release a player with an endorsement unless he is willing to waive his endorsement

Instead of making things more complicated Bort, why not just simplify it and make more of them?


There is a lot of sense in this. Not perfect, but good.


 
zbuckley
offline
Link
 
Generally the NFL has at most 5 legit MVP candidates, I think any formula should try to duplicate this. I also agree using previous season stats over a testing server makes more sense. MVP should also have to come from a playoff team.
 
DrkSandman
Baseballs
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Nuge20
Originally posted by Mightyhalo

I would think RB's, WR's and QB's would always end up being the MVP's?


and this is different from real life?


This isn't real life. We don't have to be ignorant like the media.
 
Weather
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mightyhalo
I would think RB's, WR's and QB's would always end up being the MVP's?


Maybe we could have two sets of endorsements.
One for Offensive side of the ball, one for defensive/STs?
 
Alcapown
offline
Link
 
MVP idea is amazing, I would love it!
 
RTJakarta
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by DrkSandman
Originally posted by kretchfoop

Originally posted by DrkSandman


Originally posted by RTJakarta



SWEET. BONUS TOKENS. /rolleyes


Contribute to the conversation.


He was...just indirectly. Input was asked for and input was given. He thinks bonus tokens are a joke for something so hard to get. I agree.


Okay, and that's fine. I'd just like to see reasons given rather than sarcasm.


More or less. Everyone knows this is/was a no-win situation. People who came out empty-handed are just going to QQ because they didn't get anything, and people like me are gonna rage because instead on some decent free equipment, we get some fucking bonus tokens. Ugh.
 
Capaneus
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort

However, what if votes were included as part of weighting of an MVP calculation?


I'm not reflexively opposed to it, but I agree that it will likely just skew things; I mean heck, just look at real life all star games.
 
EagleOtto
offline
Link
 
-If the formula used is like the one for top threats, it really leaves a lot of positions without a chance to become MVP, as certain positions always lead the top threat players (Wr/HB/QB are only ones with a chance).

-We need some love somehow for the non-glory positions.....There really is no way to use their stats to pick the best one.

-I don't think the top player should automatically win the MVP...it would cause too many players tanking final games down the stretch just to eek out an MVP race, by giving the ball to a certain player every play or something stupid like that. I think you should take the top 5 to 10 players and then randomly assign a MVP winner from the top guys via a lottery, even in real life the 'best' player does not always win MVP, it comes down to media bias, voter bias, aka random selection of the top guys.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Hikariu

Originally posted by Bort


Originally posted by Capaneus



Originally posted by Bort





You're probably right, actually. I could do a MVP list based on last season stats per league from the live site, output in in a text file or something, and post results until it looks good?


Sounds great, and I'd love to see the results.


I'll have to set something up. I doubt it will be hard to set up. The formula will be the hard part.


For the MVP award what are you thoughts about just letting the playoff team owners vote like a poll. One vote for O/D/ST per playoff team owner after the championship game and one Superbowl MVP award based on raw stats in that game.


I am wary of any purely vote based systems. They are likely to be gamed and campaigned for.

However, what if votes were included as part of weighting of an MVP calculation?



What if you did something where the calculation, produces the top 5 or 10 and then from there you go in and allow a vote. (kind of how college football does) And the top vote-getter wins?
 
Jughead
Fork 'Em
offline
Link
 
Bort - Is it possible to run the MVP calculations only if the teams have players that average within the "Permitted Player Levels" (exp: Lv 25-100) and if the MVP candidate is within the "Suggested" levels?

This would do two things:

Take out those CPU and gutted/slowbuild teams from skewing stats

and

discourage those ultra higher level players moving down into the "A" and "BBB" leagues to dominate.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.