User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Serious Question: How much strength/tackling do you think SHOULD be required to stop a very strong power back?
Page:
 
Nuge20
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Iceman16

The running game already has a success rate that is way too high. Why make it even harder to stop it?


I am asking about the current state of it TBH.


Go Bort
 
maizenhops
offline
Link
 
I say let the rest of the sims play out...right now the people complaining in bugs are low level, unbalanced teams. once they get higher up i bet they will miss less tackles because theyll have higher than 20 tackling vs a 70 strength rb..heck, not even a pro league game has simmed yet.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Air18
IMO, I think you guys are lumping Strength + Tackling together when they should really be set apart. Lets use an anology - say Bort's Power Back somewhat resembles Brandon Jacobs.

Tackling = your tackling technique - how adept you are at actually making a tackle.

Strength = the Strength of your actual tackle.

Think of most CB's, they have pretty decent tackling but low strength. Thus, when they go to tackle Jacobs, they wrap him up but he can still plow forward / fall forward for a few extra yards, because they don't have the strength to stop him in his tracks. However, on the flip side, if you have a guy with ridiculous strength running full speed at Jacobs, he may have the strength to take him down but not the art and will miss his tackle.

Therefore, I propose that Defenders should require a decent balance of both if they want to consistently stop backs in their tacks. With the way this game is structured and the realistic peak of your skills, it's unrealistic to force defenders to get 80+ Strength and Tackling to make a consistent tackle. However, I do believe that defenders who have 80 + tackling and very low strength should be able to make a tackles consistently because, in reality, they would be the types of players to "Wrap-up" the legs - sure the Back would plow/fall forward for 3 or 4 extra yards but the tackle would still be made. Strength should determine the "Force" of the tackle, not the effectiveness of the tackle itself. If a back with 60 Str and 60 Speed goes up against a defender with 60 Str and 60 Speed and the tackle is successful, the RB shouldn't be able to fall forward for a few extra yards, but would rather be stopped dead in his tracks. That, in essense, is what Power Backs do - always fall forward.

That being said, Bort, I think what you should do is make 2 checks when a Defender attempts a tackle - a Tackling check (to see if the tackle will be successful) and then some sort of "Force" check (combining strength + speed) to determine whether the back is able to fall forward or trudge for an extra yard or so.

Before you all yell at me and flame me, think of this idea realisticly in the game. How many defenders actually have 80 + tackling? Most people soft-cap it and leave it at that. With 48 tackling, a Defender going up against Bort's RB should only have, say a 60-65% chance of making the tackle if he is first contact, with the 2nd having a higher chance due to some sort of "dimishing returns" factor. That way Power Backs are still able to break the first tackle 40% of the time, but won't be able to consistently break 3-4 tackles every down.

I know this post is long, even for me, and I find what happens is that you're inital thought gets warped a bit during the explanation... lol.


It actually made a lot of sense..

And in your example of a soft-cap tackling (48) only getting a 60-65% chance and as that gets to the 2nd level 65-70%, then 3rd level 70-75%.
Last edited Dec 29, 2008 19:35:06
 
Knicksfan20
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Air18
IMO, I think you guys are lumping Strength + Tackling together when they should really be set apart. Lets use an anology - say Bort's Power Back somewhat resembles Brandon Jacobs.

Tackling = your tackling technique - how adept you are at actually making a tackle.

Strength = the Strength of your actual tackle.

Think of most CB's, they have pretty decent tackling but low strength. Thus, when they go to tackle Jacobs, they wrap him up but he can still plow forward / fall forward for a few extra yards, because they don't have the strength to stop him in his tracks. However, on the flip side, if you have a guy with ridiculous strength running full speed at Jacobs, he may have the strength to take him down but not the art and will miss his tackle.

Therefore, I propose that Defenders should require a decent balance of both if they want to consistently stop backs in their tacks. With the way this game is structured and the realistic peak of your skills, it's unrealistic to force defenders to get 80+ Strength and Tackling to make a consistent tackle. However, I do believe that defenders who have 80 + tackling and very low strength should be able to make tackles consistently because, in reality, they would be the types of players to "Wrap-up" the legs - sure the Back would plow/fall forward for 3 or 4 extra yards but the tackle would still be made. Strength should determine the "Force" of the tackle, not the effectiveness of the tackle itself. If a back with 60 Str and 60 Speed goes up against a defender with 60 Str and 60 Speed and the tackle is successful, the RB shouldn't be able to fall forward for a few extra yards, but would rather be stopped dead in his tracks. That, in essense, is what Power Backs do - always fall forward.

That being said, Bort, I think what you should do is make 2 checks when a Defender attempts a tackle - a Tackling check (to see if the tackle will be successful) and then some sort of "Force" check (combining strength + speed) to determine whether the back is able to fall forward or trudge for an extra yard or so.

Before you all yell at me and flame me, think of this idea realisticly in the game. How many defenders actually have 80 + tackling? Most people soft-cap it and leave it at that. With 48 tackling, a Defender going up against Bort's RB should only have, say a 60-65% chance of making the tackle if he is first contact, with the 2nd having a higher chance due to some sort of "dimishing returns" factor. That way Power Backs are still able to break the first tackle 40% of the time, but won't be able to consistently break 3-4 tackles every down.

I know this post is long, even for me, and I find what happens is that you're inital thought gets warped a bit during the explanation... lol.




+1000


this is the point i have been trying to make but nobody has been quoting me lol.



Speed MUST be a factor for power backs breaking tackles...and iti also MUST be a factor in tackling players...a player with no momentum or slow momentum...should not be an adept tackler.



strength doesnt play a huge role in tackling...VISION and TECHNIQUE DOES (vision would be like awareness in this game i guess) then speed and strength are like secondarys to that...being able to read where a back or player is going to go..or what they will do...and how to down them...along with the skill of tackling should be important.



a player still needs a decent amount of strength in order to tackle a bigger player....but it shouldnt be the first skill...and it shouldnt be NEARLY as high as people are asking for it to be
 
boondocksaint
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Iceman16
Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by Iceman16


The running game already has a success rate that is way too high. Why make it even harder to stop it?


I am asking about the current state of it TBH.


It's still too successful.


THAT'S WHAT HE'S SAYING
 
nick_w
offline
Link
 
Tackle like this imo.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KzXeWHdOr7o
 
iMan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by flames54
Originally posted by iMan

Originally posted by flames54


And for the record, your're all ass backwards on this power vs. wrap up tackling thing.

The best way to stop an elusive back in real life? plow his brains in with a big hit so he gets happy feet and is less likely to cut back or make that spin move that got him killed next time.

The best way to stop a power back? cut him low as a corner or hit him up high because the bigger power backs you just can't get your hands around in real life.


to be able to "plow a elusive backs brain" you will need a teammate to wrap him up and then you can go for the kill shot.
best way to tackle an elusive back is to get in front of him, break down, and lower your shoulders adn explode at the point of attack.



No because the second you break down he'll be past you before you can accelerate again. How many clips of Barry Sanders have you seen where a guy breaks down and looks like an ass-hole because of it. The best way to stop them is to be in control but be downhill on them and lay a big shot. If you try to break down and be ready for them you'll just end up doing the prayer.


by breaking down you have much more control to counter his cuts as opposed to not breaking down.
once broken down, your knees are in a bent position, your body under control which allows you to explode in any direction
 
n:iceman:16
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by iMan
Originally posted by Iceman16

Originally posted by flames54


And for the record, your're all ass backwards on this power vs. wrap up tackling thing.

The best way to stop an elusive back in real life? plow his brains in with a big hit so he gets happy feet and is less likely to cut back or make that spin move that got him killed next time.

The best way to stop a power back? cut him low as a corner or hit him up high because the bigger power backs you just can't get your hands around in real life.


Fact.


you cant go for the kill shot on a elusive back without a wrap up. anyone that plays football will know that if you go for the kill shot on a elusive back and miss you will get an ear full from the coaches


I'm not saying to dive at his face aimlessly. If you have any positioning you should be able to blow the guy up though. You don't wrap up if you're 6 inches taller and weigh another 70 pounds.
 
Saris
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kalkmanc
the +3% break tackle va when on 50% power running probably helped power backs a ton..while all defenses probably spent vas on speed and agility stuff...


I'd guess this is what Bort is getting at. They probably ran multiple sim games following the changes and new VA's and saw a ton of broken tackles. I took the question to mean, whether all these broken tackles would be justified. I could be wrong though.
 
n:iceman:16
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by boondocksaint
Originally posted by Iceman16

Originally posted by Bort


Originally posted by Iceman16



The running game already has a success rate that is way too high. Why make it even harder to stop it?


I am asking about the current state of it TBH.


It's still too successful.


THAT'S WHAT HE'S SAYING


Pretty sure he thought I was talking about last season. He asked about the current state. And I said it was the same thing. It sounds like he implied that it's not too successful now.
 
flames54
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by flames54
There just needs to be a big stamina hit on players without quality tackling trying to tackle a power back in the open field. This will simulate the ability of a power back to wear down smaller defenders over the course of the game.

In a 1on1 situation head to head the power back will lay down some big punishment but in many cases the weaker player will cut him down or at the very least get him down to a stand still 95% of the time allowing other players to clean up after him.

Poor tacklers coming in from a side angle though are going to have a very difficult time dealing with the power back and he'd break a lot of those tackles, just like in real life especially if he can't get in good position to tackle.

From behind the power back can be tackled in a lot of cases by the faster player catching up and essentially tripping him up.

If the player is able to get in good position to tackle the power back then he'll bring him down 95% of the time, if he's in poor position to start his tackle though he's going to get him maybe 10% of the time.

The more tackling the easier the tackle from good positioning but to drag a guy down from a bad spot it should be all about strength. Corners should only need 40 or 50 tackling at MOST and it should be factored in better that they are usually in a great spot to make the tackle. Strength here really isn't an issue unless you want a corner lighting up the power back. However a linebacker or defensive lineman is often involved with a blocker or dealing with bodies all over forcing him to rely on his strength and ability to hang on/wrap up so a good tackler at linebacker would be 70/70 and a good tackler at defensive line could be 90/55 or 80/60 where as a good tackler at corner is at 20/40 because he's in the open field and has the advantage there because of his agility and speed.

The real question mark are safeties, because a lot of the great ones in real life can tackle like a linebacker but I'd rate them at 50/60 to really drag down a ball carrier, the main reason being that the safety plugs the hole running at full speed leading to a huge impact because the power back won't be nearly at top speed yet.


Rebump and to the TLR

Tackling = Technique when in position as well as success.

Strength = Increases the power of big hits as well as is a major role in tackling from a bad position to tackle.
 
swoosh22
offline
Link
 
Bort is there anything in the system that checks for the position/angle which defenders are making the tackle?

Because that would solve a lot of this.

Any player who is being blocked or that has a bad angle should be required to have higher tackling and strength.

Any player who is not being blocked or that has a good angle at the ball carrier (a straight shot to him) should be required to have less tackle and strength.

This would then make the required tackling and strength for DLine 70-80, Linebackers 60-70, CBs 40-50, FS/SS 40/50 most of the time. Because Dline generally doesn't have the best angle or they are getting blocked. Linebackers have better angles but get blocked a good amount. The secondary always have the best angle at the ball carrier because they are furthest away.
 
Polorl69
offline
Link
 
I think that strength and tackling need to be more important to defensive player builds...there are so many defenders out there that are just speed and agility...make them pay!
 
Air18
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ken-in-rockwall
Originally posted by Air18

IMO, I think you guys are lumping Strength + Tackling together when they should really be set apart. Lets use an anology - say Bort's Power Back somewhat resembles Brandon Jacobs.

Tackling = your tackling technique - how adept you are at actually making a tackle.

Strength = the Strength of your actual tackle.

Think of most CB's, they have pretty decent tackling but low strength. Thus, when they go to tackle Jacobs, they wrap him up but he can still plow forward / fall forward for a few extra yards, because they don't have the strength to stop him in his tracks. However, on the flip side, if you have a guy with ridiculous strength running full speed at Jacobs, he may have the strength to take him down but not the art and will miss his tackle.

Therefore, I propose that Defenders should require a decent balance of both if they want to consistently stop backs in their tacks. With the way this game is structured and the realistic peak of your skills, it's unrealistic to force defenders to get 80+ Strength and Tackling to make a consistent tackle. However, I do believe that defenders who have 80 + tackling and very low strength should be able to make a tackles consistently because, in reality, they would be the types of players to "Wrap-up" the legs - sure the Back would plow/fall forward for 3 or 4 extra yards but the tackle would still be made. Strength should determine the "Force" of the tackle, not the effectiveness of the tackle itself. If a back with 60 Str and 60 Speed goes up against a defender with 60 Str and 60 Speed and the tackle is successful, the RB shouldn't be able to fall forward for a few extra yards, but would rather be stopped dead in his tracks. That, in essense, is what Power Backs do - always fall forward.

That being said, Bort, I think what you should do is make 2 checks when a Defender attempts a tackle - a Tackling check (to see if the tackle will be successful) and then some sort of "Force" check (combining strength + speed) to determine whether the back is able to fall forward or trudge for an extra yard or so.

Before you all yell at me and flame me, think of this idea realisticly in the game. How many defenders actually have 80 + tackling? Most people soft-cap it and leave it at that. With 48 tackling, a Defender going up against Bort's RB should only have, say a 60-65% chance of making the tackle if he is first contact, with the 2nd having a higher chance due to some sort of "dimishing returns" factor. That way Power Backs are still able to break the first tackle 40% of the time, but won't be able to consistently break 3-4 tackles every down.

I know this post is long, even for me, and I find what happens is that you're inital thought gets warped a bit during the explanation... lol.


It actually made a lot of sense..

And in your example of a soft-cap tackling (48) only getting a 60-65% chance and as that gets to the 2nd level 65-70%, then 3rd level 70-75%.



I don't know exactly what percent it should be though..
 
n:iceman:16
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by flames54
Rebump and to the TLR

Tackling = Technique when in position as well as success.

Strength = Increases the power of big hits as well as is a major role in tackling from a bad position to tackle.


This, and strength should be more important for tackling power backs than for tackling elusive backs.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.