User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > South America > Renaming Conferences to Satchmo/Dizzy
Page:
 
RagingBoredom
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Iversen5771
Originally posted by Necroscope7

Originally posted by Iversen5771


Originally posted by Necroscope7



I love SA, but this almost makes me want to request my team to be moved out. I have nothing against the guy, but quite frankly I don't feel like being in either a Satchmo or Dizzy conference. If it were something that made sense for a conference name, either like some leagues with East/West, or by having football connections, then great, but this.... There's got to be something you can do to honor the guy without screwing up the conference names worse than you already have by using Zeta instead of Omega.


Why don't ya?


Because despite this horrible idea and the annoyance of possibly playing in one of those conferences, my team has been here since the expansion teams were added in season 3 and I have a lot of respect for the teams I've played against in that time and I enjoy competing with them as each new season comes around. Trying offering a proper response to my post next time instead of just trying to help push me into leaving because I disagree with your suggestion. All that will do is make me more determined to fight against you.


I just found your post to be totally disrespectful, that's all.

And do you really think alpha and zeta sounds cool? I mean really?

No Satchmo and Dizzy has nothing to do with football, but this is not football you know? This is dotball!


Nothing he said was disrespectful at all. He didn't come in here and say that Satchmo was a terrible person and should not, in any way, be recognized for his contributions to the game. He just said that naming the conferences after him doesn't make any sense. And I completely agree with him about that. Perhaps you should take a step back and realize that everyone who disagrees with you isn't disgracing the impact that Satchmo had on this game.
 
Necroscope7
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Iversen5771
Originally posted by Necroscope7

Originally posted by Iversen5771


Originally posted by Necroscope7



I love SA, but this almost makes me want to request my team to be moved out. I have nothing against the guy, but quite frankly I don't feel like being in either a Satchmo or Dizzy conference. If it were something that made sense for a conference name, either like some leagues with East/West, or by having football connections, then great, but this.... There's got to be something you can do to honor the guy without screwing up the conference names worse than you already have by using Zeta instead of Omega.


Why don't ya?


Because despite this horrible idea and the annoyance of possibly playing in one of those conferences, my team has been here since the expansion teams were added in season 3 and I have a lot of respect for the teams I've played against in that time and I enjoy competing with them as each new season comes around. Trying offering a proper response to my post next time instead of just trying to help push me into leaving because I disagree with your suggestion. All that will do is make me more determined to fight against you.


I just found your post to be totally disrespectful, that's all.

And do you really think alpha and zeta sounds cool? I mean really?

No Satchmo and Dizzy has nothing to do with football, but this is not football you know? This is dotball!


Did I say I liked Alpha and Zeta? No, I called it a mistake as well. I did state that I think Satchmo and Dizzy as conference names is worse than the current ones, though. I tried to point out in my two posts before yours that I just plain don't know anything about the guy, he didn't have an impact on me personally, and I can guarantee you I'm not the only one who is in the same boat. I'm not trying to disrespect him, but trying to explain that his name and actions are not 100% universally known and though many will understand and appreciate the name change, many will be scratching their head as well. That is why I also tried to present an idea for honoring him that would not only give him a position of prominence but help those who don't know who he is to understand what his legacy is that you're trying to preserve.
Last edited Jan 7, 2009 16:46:21
 
Link
 
I have no problem with having hundreds of people mute their requests and submit their will to one person who said he would leave the league if conference names were changed to ones not of his choosing. No problem with it at all.

After all, the good of the few must be sacrificed for the good of the many, and how many people deserve to be exposed to such a joyless person with such limited perspective? We have to bite the bullet on this one, folks....

Aw, screw it. He's an ass. I just hope he doesn't move to Oceania.
 
Necroscope7
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by JuniorMcSpiffy
I have no problem with having hundreds of people mute their requests and submit their will to one person who said he would leave the league if conference names were changed to ones not of his choosing. No problem with it at all.

After all, the good of the few must be sacrificed for the good of the many, and how many people deserve to be exposed to such a joyless person with such limited perspective? We have to bite the bullet on this one, folks....

Aw, screw it. He's an ass. I just hope he doesn't move to Oceania.


I never said everyone should mute their requests, but this is a thread for everyone to point out their thoughts on the subject, and "hundreds" of people have not posted in support of this, so don't get ahead of yourself. I also did not say I would leave the league, I said it made the thought come to my mind, but that in the end I would rather be here with worse names for the conferences than move somewhere else with better names. It has nothing to do with joy, and as far as limited perspective, perhaps all of those who don't want to account for those of us who don't have any interest in a rename should stop limiting their own perspectives. If all you want to do is call names and misinterpret the apparently small portions of my posts that you've read have at it, but I think you'd show yourself in a better light, and do your cause more justice, if you actually truly read everything I've said so far and made an intelligent post on the subject.
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by JuniorMcSpiffy
I have no problem with having hundreds of people mute their requests and submit their will to one person who said he would leave the league if conference names were changed to ones not of his choosing. No problem with it at all.
After all, the good of the few must be sacrificed for the good of the many, and how many people deserve to be exposed to such a joyless person with such limited perspective? We have to bite the bullet on this one, folks....
Aw, screw it. He's an ass. I just hope he doesn't move to Oceania.


is invective the only card in your hand? do you have any real points?

 
Link
 
I love people who say things without saying them... and then comes back with "I never said that." And following that up with swamping everyone with minutia in hopes that the larger picture gets drowned out... a nice touch.

We are in the middle of page 13. At 15 posts per page, that's 180+. And at least 95% of them are in favor. Yes... there are multiple posts by the same group of people. I guess you can count each and every one if you want. It seems your style. But this thread was started after many pages of other attempts at renaming conferences. This is the one that struck a chord with the most people. Now, feel free to suggest alternatives. (Let me guess... a couple of animals native to the continent?) And as to your idea of stickying the tale of Satchmo-n-Dizzy and his role in the ROIT!s, I just figured that would accompany the conference name change to help the newcomers know why they are what they are, even before you suggested it as an alternative rather than a supplement to the change.

I would say "best of luck" to you, but I rather hope that an idea that shows people over the internet can connect and respect rather than most of what usually goes on.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Catullus 16
Originally posted by JuniorMcSpiffy

I have no problem with having hundreds of people mute their requests and submit their will to one person who said he would leave the league if conference names were changed to ones not of his choosing. No problem with it at all.
After all, the good of the few must be sacrificed for the good of the many, and how many people deserve to be exposed to such a joyless person with such limited perspective? We have to bite the bullet on this one, folks....
Aw, screw it. He's an ass. I just hope he doesn't move to Oceania.


is invective the only card in your hand? do you have any real points?



I guess I assumed the 12 pages previous stood as its own evidence. The invectives are just the parsley.
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by JuniorMcSpiffy
I love people who say things without saying them... and then comes back with "I never said that." And following that up with swamping everyone with minutia in hopes that the larger picture gets drowned out... a nice touch.
We are in the middle of page 13. At 15 posts per page, that's 180+. And at least 95% of them are in favor. Yes... there are multiple posts by the same group of people. I guess you can count each and every one if you want. It seems your style. But this thread was started after many pages of other attempts at renaming conferences. This is the one that struck a chord with the most people. Now, feel free to suggest alternatives. (Let me guess... a couple of animals native to the continent?) And as to your idea of stickying the tale of Satchmo-n-Dizzy and his role in the ROIT!s, I just figured that would accompany the conference name change to help the newcomers know why they are what they are, even before you suggested it as an alternative rather than a supplement to the change.
I would say "best of luck" to you, but I rather hope that an idea that shows people over the internet can connect and respect rather than most of what usually goes on.


you're acting like this is already a done deal. aren't we still in the process of airing thoughts and listening to arguments?

just because someone dares to hold an unpopular opinion doesn't mean they should be barred from the polls...
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by JuniorMcSpiffy
Originally posted by Catullus 16
is invective the only card in your hand? do you have any real points?

I guess I assumed the 12 pages previous stood as its own evidence. The invectives are just the parsley.


evidence of what exactly?

resorting to invective makes me wonder if you don't have any argument at all and are now just desperately casting about.
 
Necroscope7
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by JuniorMcSpiffy
I love people who say things without saying them... and then comes back with "I never said that." And following that up with swamping everyone with minutia in hopes that the larger picture gets drowned out... a nice touch.

We are in the middle of page 13. At 15 posts per page, that's 180+. And at least 95% of them are in favor. Yes... there are multiple posts by the same group of people. I guess you can count each and every one if you want. It seems your style. But this thread was started after many pages of other attempts at renaming conferences. This is the one that struck a chord with the most people. Now, feel free to suggest alternatives. (Let me guess... a couple of animals native to the continent?) And as to your idea of stickying the tale of Satchmo-n-Dizzy and his role in the ROIT!s, I just figured that would accompany the conference name change to help the newcomers know why they are what they are, even before you suggested it as an alternative rather than a supplement to the change.

I would say "best of luck" to you, but I rather hope that an idea that shows people over the internet can connect and respect rather than most of what usually goes on.


I didn't say anything without saying it. I said in my first post that though the bad choice of names would be a temptation to leave it did not beat out my love of playing in SA, I did not say in any way that I liked Alpha/Zeta I said that using Zeta instead of Omega was stupid, which if it says anything without saying it, it says that I think using Zeta is stupid. I don't want to swamp people in minutiae, on the contrary, I want people to look at the bigger picture instead of just jumping on the bandwagon of the latest GLB cause without really thinking through what their doing. I'm not trying to say that everyone for this is a bandwagon person, but what I am saying is that I haven't really seen anything in the way of real, intelligent conversation on the subject to help people make up their minds in an educated manner. Instead every time someone pops up to say they're against it people like you jump down our throats like we're trying to ruin the game. Do I have a suggestion to change the names right now? No. I'd like to see them changed when something good is presented, I just don't think this option is the one to go with. Animals from the part of the world we're playing in sounds like a pretty lame idea, though, to be quite honest.

Originally posted by JuniorMcSpiffy
Originally posted by Catullus 16

Originally posted by JuniorMcSpiffy


I have no problem with having hundreds of people mute their requests and submit their will to one person who said he would leave the league if conference names were changed to ones not of his choosing. No problem with it at all.
After all, the good of the few must be sacrificed for the good of the many, and how many people deserve to be exposed to such a joyless person with such limited perspective? We have to bite the bullet on this one, folks....
Aw, screw it. He's an ass. I just hope he doesn't move to Oceania.


is invective the only card in your hand? do you have any real points?



I guess I assumed the 12 pages previous stood as its own evidence. The invectives are just the parsley.


There are 13 pages, with this post added 190 posts in those pages, so less than 200 possible votes for just by that bit of things. Then you take out anything beyond the initial voting post by any person and you lose at least 20 posts, so down to 170 out of the 190 possible (I'm trying to be generous), and right now only three definite nay votes (Catullus has tried to bring reason to the arguing between but not stated yea or nay), so 167-3 definitely does mean the majority of people in this thread are for it, I'm not arguing that, but the argument isn't over yet, so trying to call it a win already and silence those who don't agree with you still remains a tactic of ignorance. With 15 leagues each holding 32 teams, even if every person fielded every player for their own team there would be 480 possible votes on the subject, but that is a pretty unrealistically small number. Besides that, we'd also have to look and see how many people like you, who don't even have a player in South America are voting and skewing the numbers. I'm not trying to say things should absolutely go the way I want, I am merely taking the opportunity given to present my viewpoint and saying give everyone who has a stake in this a chance to make their own decisions on the matter before the decision is made for them by a bunch of really active people from SA Pro.
 
tordman
offline
Link
 
Wow, seriously wow. Arguing against re-naming the conferences that have pretty much anonymous names to begin with in favor of naming them against a guy who contributed to this league a ton and is now in poor health, makes me wonder about humanity.

Seriously, would this change make your life that much more difficult? I am totally for the change, and you should be ashamed of yourself for arguing against it for any reason.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Catullus 16
Originally posted by JuniorMcSpiffy

I love people who say things without saying them... and then comes back with "I never said that." And following that up with swamping everyone with minutia in hopes that the larger picture gets drowned out... a nice touch.
We are in the middle of page 13. At 15 posts per page, that's 180+. And at least 95% of them are in favor. Yes... there are multiple posts by the same group of people. I guess you can count each and every one if you want. It seems your style. But this thread was started after many pages of other attempts at renaming conferences. This is the one that struck a chord with the most people. Now, feel free to suggest alternatives. (Let me guess... a couple of animals native to the continent?) And as to your idea of stickying the tale of Satchmo-n-Dizzy and his role in the ROIT!s, I just figured that would accompany the conference name change to help the newcomers know why they are what they are, even before you suggested it as an alternative rather than a supplement to the change.
I would say "best of luck" to you, but I rather hope that an idea that shows people over the internet can connect and respect rather than most of what usually goes on.


you're acting like this is already a done deal. aren't we still in the process of airing thoughts and listening to arguments?

just because someone dares to hold an unpopular opinion doesn't mean they should be barred from the polls...


I'm not asking him to be barred or banned or anything. But he is expressing, and these are your words, an unpopular opinion. His choice, and apparently yours as well, to express them. And I'm all in favor of that. Have your say, and if anyone tries to shut you up, you'll have me in your corner in that regard. But unpopular opinions are going to bring responses. You can choose to speak up, but you can't choose the consequence of that action, including others expressing theirs.

So.... alternatives to Satchmo and Dizzy?
 
Necroscope7
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tordman
Wow, seriously wow. Arguing against re-naming the conferences that have pretty much anonymous names to begin with in favor of naming them against a guy who contributed to this league a ton and is now in poor health, makes me wonder about humanity.

Seriously, would this change make your life that much more difficult? I am totally for the change, and you should be ashamed of yourself for arguing against it for any reason.


Have your opinion on the naming, that's perfectly fine, but don't try to make me ashamed of something there is no reason for me to be ashamed of. I don't know the guy, have had no contact or influence from him, and have no reason to want to have my conference named after him. I'm sorry that he's ill and wish him the best and hope that he can recover from whatever it is that he is dealing with, and I would support ways to honor him that don't effect my team, but I will not be sorry just because I don't like using that name. It has nothing to do with my or anyone else's humanity, there are different ways to care and show your respect, and I just do not choose this one. If there wasn't to be any argument on the subject they should have just changed the names without asking what anyone thought, but they didn't.
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by JuniorMcSpiffy
I'm not asking him to be barred or banned or anything. But he is expressing, and these are your words, an unpopular opinion. His choice, and apparently yours as well, to express them. And I'm all in favor of that. Have your say, and if anyone tries to shut you up, you'll have me in your corner in that regard. But unpopular opinions are going to bring responses. You can choose to speak up, but you can't choose the consequence of that action, including others expressing theirs.
So.... alternatives to Satchmo and Dizzy?


ok, that's fair and i respect your stance. i was just a little confused at first why someone who didn't even have a single player in south america had randomly inserted themselves into a conversation that didn't concern them and was bashing people for voicing their thoughts.

for the record, i don't really have an opinion yet about all this. i have the utmost respect for satchmo, enjoyed my few conversations with him, was one of those protesting his ban during the SAPRO riots, and was the very first one (in that main thread at least) to congratulate him on becoming mod. i suppose renaming the conferences after him is a thoughtful gesture... although i'm still trying to decide whether it's genuine sentiment or mere tokenism.

i'm also worried about any knee-jerk or overly maudlin moves in this game, because poor precedent is dangerous. for example, when hud let slip that one of satchmo's GMs was watching over his account, it set off a firestorm of complaints from those who wondered why satchmo was getting preferential treatment... which then later shifted into a discussion of whether or not the satchmo thread should be stickied at all. when it was eventually unstickied, there was yet another highly politicized discussion even in the satchmo thread itself (until hud put a stop to it), which seemed in very poor taste.

i'm confident that satchmo never wanted to be the centerpiece of such conflicts... but if forced to vote here, i would say sure, rename the conferences. but let's not cloud this process with hysterical hand-raising, mob mentality, or (above all) self-righteousness.
 
Hornfan93
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Firenze
Do it.


 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.