I think his point is that there seem to be more negative reports than positive, and that the negatives are extremely negative more often than the positives are extremely positive, in a matter that would not be aligned with the ratio of QB's your level & qb's around the more average glb level. You'll be able to find anecdotal evidence to support either claim.
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > UGLY GAME 4s - We think something is wrong with the passing in the sims
panther17
offline
offline
Defensive secondary is important in stopping the run. WR are important for run blocking, TE's are important for run blocking, QB's are useless when tired (according to Bort saying that most of this is due to stamina being increased) and low level. Apparently at higher levels, QB's are doing ok, not great. Just would have to tough it out till they are useful.
daysend
offline
offline
Originally posted by rj414
Originally posted by Will2k
Originally posted by NewEnglandCoach
Originally posted by Curufin
Originally posted by NewEnglandCoach
You guys are overreacting.. it's not even that big of a deal, seriously.
Have you looked at some of the replays? The passes aren't anywhere within a 10 yard radius of a WR.
Okay, yet my QB is a higher level, and had a decent pass pct. Even though it was 51.2, he went 7/13, I'm still going to call that successful.
It's ok guys. Because his player did well, means nothing else is wrong.
Yeah, and more to the point - his high level qb threw all of 13 passes. My guy's first 13 passes were high percentage too. I wish the few people who's QBs had decent games would admit that it's possible that whatever the perfect storm of changes that screwed up the vast majority of QBs in the league obviously will not affect a few lucky qbs who happened to have certain builds or play in certain circumstances.
Just looking through the first couple series. My guy was 4/7. Beyond that, he was 6/35 with terrible passes to wide open receivers.
Originally posted by Will2k
Originally posted by NewEnglandCoach
Originally posted by Curufin
Originally posted by NewEnglandCoach
You guys are overreacting.. it's not even that big of a deal, seriously.
Have you looked at some of the replays? The passes aren't anywhere within a 10 yard radius of a WR.
Okay, yet my QB is a higher level, and had a decent pass pct. Even though it was 51.2, he went 7/13, I'm still going to call that successful.
It's ok guys. Because his player did well, means nothing else is wrong.
Yeah, and more to the point - his high level qb threw all of 13 passes. My guy's first 13 passes were high percentage too. I wish the few people who's QBs had decent games would admit that it's possible that whatever the perfect storm of changes that screwed up the vast majority of QBs in the league obviously will not affect a few lucky qbs who happened to have certain builds or play in certain circumstances.
Just looking through the first couple series. My guy was 4/7. Beyond that, he was 6/35 with terrible passes to wide open receivers.
NewEnglandCoach
offline
offline
Originally posted by panther17
Defensive secondary is important in stopping the run. WR are important for run blocking, TE's are important for run blocking, QB's are useless when tired (according to Bort saying that most of this is due to stamina being increased) and low level. Apparently at higher levels, QB's are doing ok, not great. Just would have to tough it out till they are useful.
Thank you.
Defensive secondary is important in stopping the run. WR are important for run blocking, TE's are important for run blocking, QB's are useless when tired (according to Bort saying that most of this is due to stamina being increased) and low level. Apparently at higher levels, QB's are doing ok, not great. Just would have to tough it out till they are useful.
Thank you.
Rossmc
offline
offline
Originally posted by panther17
Defensive secondary is important in stopping the run. WR are important for run blocking, TE's are important for run blocking, QB's are useless when tired (according to Bort saying that most of this is due to stamina being increased) and low level. Apparently at higher levels, QB's are doing ok, not great. Just would have to tough it out till they are useful.
Im sorry but a level 12 qb v level 12 DBs will put up similar numbers to a level 50 qb against level 50 dbs.
Defensive secondary is important in stopping the run. WR are important for run blocking, TE's are important for run blocking, QB's are useless when tired (according to Bort saying that most of this is due to stamina being increased) and low level. Apparently at higher levels, QB's are doing ok, not great. Just would have to tough it out till they are useful.
Im sorry but a level 12 qb v level 12 DBs will put up similar numbers to a level 50 qb against level 50 dbs.
panther17
offline
offline
If the game changes, adjust to the game. I definitely think the increase to stamina's effect should stay the same. Adjusting up QB effectiveness is a possiblity. But I'm tired of seeing under staffed teams. I know depth is hard to find right now but it shouldn't mean teams should take advantage of being able to have a small roster and give everyone full amount of plays for exp without a hit to their energy and effectiveness.
D-will
offline
offline
you just gotta know how to use him look at my owned teams guy -http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=29392
Will2k
offline
offline
Originally posted by NewEnglandCoach
Originally posted by Will2k
Originally posted by NewEnglandCoach
Originally posted by Curufin
Originally posted by NewEnglandCoach
You guys are overreacting.. it's not even that big of a deal, seriously.
Have you looked at some of the replays? The passes aren't anywhere within a 10 yard radius of a WR.
Okay, yet my QB is a higher level, and had a decent pass pct. Even though it was 51.2, he went 7/13, I'm still going to call that successful.
It's ok guys. Because his player did well, means nothing else is wrong.
That's not what I said. I'm supporting Bort's claim that higher level QBs are prone to do better. Meyton Panning had a REALLY good game, leading his team to a 112-0 victory in the same league. He's also the same level as mine. There's more evidence supporting the claim. I can deal with the realism, I'm not tripping about it.
No, basically you said you don't understand why 80-90% of the people here are complaining about bad QB % because your QB had a good game. Your QB got the luck of the draw in the simming.
I understand that low lvl guys are not going to be lighting up the field, but for lvl 10 and up to have crappy games like this isn't right (unless the D is really good). If he wants to make it real rating style then they need to re work XP and LVL.
Originally posted by Will2k
Originally posted by NewEnglandCoach
Originally posted by Curufin
Originally posted by NewEnglandCoach
You guys are overreacting.. it's not even that big of a deal, seriously.
Have you looked at some of the replays? The passes aren't anywhere within a 10 yard radius of a WR.
Okay, yet my QB is a higher level, and had a decent pass pct. Even though it was 51.2, he went 7/13, I'm still going to call that successful.
It's ok guys. Because his player did well, means nothing else is wrong.
That's not what I said. I'm supporting Bort's claim that higher level QBs are prone to do better. Meyton Panning had a REALLY good game, leading his team to a 112-0 victory in the same league. He's also the same level as mine. There's more evidence supporting the claim. I can deal with the realism, I'm not tripping about it.
No, basically you said you don't understand why 80-90% of the people here are complaining about bad QB % because your QB had a good game. Your QB got the luck of the draw in the simming.
I understand that low lvl guys are not going to be lighting up the field, but for lvl 10 and up to have crappy games like this isn't right (unless the D is really good). If he wants to make it real rating style then they need to re work XP and LVL.
hostyle
offline
offline
Originally posted by Rossmc
Originally posted by panther17
Defensive secondary is important in stopping the run. WR are important for run blocking, TE's are important for run blocking, QB's are useless when tired (according to Bort saying that most of this is due to stamina being increased) and low level. Apparently at higher levels, QB's are doing ok, not great. Just would have to tough it out till they are useful.
Im sorry but a level 12 qb v level 12 DBs will put up similar numbers to a level 50 qb against level 50 dbs.
Then what exactly is the point of leveling to 50? I thought it was to get stronger, not to stay even.
Originally posted by panther17
Defensive secondary is important in stopping the run. WR are important for run blocking, TE's are important for run blocking, QB's are useless when tired (according to Bort saying that most of this is due to stamina being increased) and low level. Apparently at higher levels, QB's are doing ok, not great. Just would have to tough it out till they are useful.
Im sorry but a level 12 qb v level 12 DBs will put up similar numbers to a level 50 qb against level 50 dbs.
Then what exactly is the point of leveling to 50? I thought it was to get stronger, not to stay even.
Last edited May 2, 2008 17:28:51
E-A-G-L-E-S
offline
offline
Well, not to sound greedy or anything, but a TE doesn't get a "blocking" stat column, nor does a WR. While secondary is useful in stopping the run, it isn't vital. Too many plays where the Safety or the CB got totally trucked or juked out. LBs make the tackles, CBs don't.
I honestly don't feel like basically sitting on the bench for 5 seasons, and the only people that approve of this are already level 10+. This isn't fair to lower level players and it totally unbalances the league(s).
I honestly don't feel like basically sitting on the bench for 5 seasons, and the only people that approve of this are already level 10+. This isn't fair to lower level players and it totally unbalances the league(s).
panther17
offline
offline
Originally posted by Rossmc
Originally posted by panther17
Defensive secondary is important in stopping the run. WR are important for run blocking, TE's are important for run blocking, QB's are useless when tired (according to Bort saying that most of this is due to stamina being increased) and low level. Apparently at higher levels, QB's are doing ok, not great. Just would have to tough it out till they are useful.
Im sorry but a level 12 qb v level 12 DBs will put up similar numbers to a level 50 qb against level 50 dbs.
Apparently it is not all relative anymore. level 4 plays like shit whether its in BBB league against level 4 players who also play like shit or level 4 player in Pro playing like shit against level 15 who are playing a notch up from shit.
Originally posted by panther17
Defensive secondary is important in stopping the run. WR are important for run blocking, TE's are important for run blocking, QB's are useless when tired (according to Bort saying that most of this is due to stamina being increased) and low level. Apparently at higher levels, QB's are doing ok, not great. Just would have to tough it out till they are useful.
Im sorry but a level 12 qb v level 12 DBs will put up similar numbers to a level 50 qb against level 50 dbs.
Apparently it is not all relative anymore. level 4 plays like shit whether its in BBB league against level 4 players who also play like shit or level 4 player in Pro playing like shit against level 15 who are playing a notch up from shit.
NewEnglandCoach
offline
offline
Originally posted by Will2k
Originally posted by NewEnglandCoach
Originally posted by Will2k
Originally posted by NewEnglandCoach
Originally posted by Curufin
Originally posted by NewEnglandCoach
You guys are overreacting.. it's not even that big of a deal, seriously.
Have you looked at some of the replays? The passes aren't anywhere within a 10 yard radius of a WR.
Okay, yet my QB is a higher level, and had a decent pass pct. Even though it was 51.2, he went 7/13, I'm still going to call that successful.
It's ok guys. Because his player did well, means nothing else is wrong.
That's not what I said. I'm supporting Bort's claim that higher level QBs are prone to do better. Meyton Panning had a REALLY good game, leading his team to a 112-0 victory in the same league. He's also the same level as mine. There's more evidence supporting the claim. I can deal with the realism, I'm not tripping about it.
No, basically you said you don't understand why 80-90% of the people here are complaining about bad QB % because your QB had a good game. Your QB got the luck of the draw in the simming.
I understand that low lvl guys are not going to be lighting up the field, but for lvl 10 and up to have crappy games like this isn't right (unless the D is really good). If he wants to make it real rating style then they need to re work XP and LVL.
This is extremely retarded, I perfectly understand why. Every level 10+ I've seen has had a decent/good game. 50% Pass Pct doesn't always relate to the outcome of the game bro. Notice I said mine even had 51.1. Too many things factor into PASS PCT, therefore, you should NOT incorporate play directly with the Pct..
Originally posted by NewEnglandCoach
Originally posted by Will2k
Originally posted by NewEnglandCoach
Originally posted by Curufin
Originally posted by NewEnglandCoach
You guys are overreacting.. it's not even that big of a deal, seriously.
Have you looked at some of the replays? The passes aren't anywhere within a 10 yard radius of a WR.
Okay, yet my QB is a higher level, and had a decent pass pct. Even though it was 51.2, he went 7/13, I'm still going to call that successful.
It's ok guys. Because his player did well, means nothing else is wrong.
That's not what I said. I'm supporting Bort's claim that higher level QBs are prone to do better. Meyton Panning had a REALLY good game, leading his team to a 112-0 victory in the same league. He's also the same level as mine. There's more evidence supporting the claim. I can deal with the realism, I'm not tripping about it.
No, basically you said you don't understand why 80-90% of the people here are complaining about bad QB % because your QB had a good game. Your QB got the luck of the draw in the simming.
I understand that low lvl guys are not going to be lighting up the field, but for lvl 10 and up to have crappy games like this isn't right (unless the D is really good). If he wants to make it real rating style then they need to re work XP and LVL.
This is extremely retarded, I perfectly understand why. Every level 10+ I've seen has had a decent/good game. 50% Pass Pct doesn't always relate to the outcome of the game bro. Notice I said mine even had 51.1. Too many things factor into PASS PCT, therefore, you should NOT incorporate play directly with the Pct..
E-A-G-L-E-S
offline
offline
So, basically, what you're saying, is that only RBs should get any play time aside from blocking for the next 2 seasons?
Hmm, good idea!
Hmm, good idea!
UK_Giant_Steve
offline
offline
Originally posted by NewEnglandCoach
Originally posted by Will2k
Originally posted by NewEnglandCoach
Originally posted by Will2k
Originally posted by NewEnglandCoach
Originally posted by Curufin
Originally posted by NewEnglandCoach
You guys are overreacting.. it's not even that big of a deal, seriously.
Have you looked at some of the replays? The passes aren't anywhere within a 10 yard radius of a WR.
Okay, yet my QB is a higher level, and had a decent pass pct. Even though it was 51.2, he went 7/13, I'm still going to call that successful.
It's ok guys. Because his player did well, means nothing else is wrong.
That's not what I said. I'm supporting Bort's claim that higher level QBs are prone to do better. Meyton Panning had a REALLY good game, leading his team to a 112-0 victory in the same league. He's also the same level as mine. There's more evidence supporting the claim. I can deal with the realism, I'm not tripping about it.
No, basically you said you don't understand why 80-90% of the people here are complaining about bad QB % because your QB had a good game. Your QB got the luck of the draw in the simming.
I understand that low lvl guys are not going to be lighting up the field, but for lvl 10 and up to have crappy games like this isn't right (unless the D is really good). If he wants to make it real rating style then they need to re work XP and LVL.
This is extremely retarded, I perfectly understand why. Every level 10+ I've seen has had a decent/good game. 50% Pass Pct doesn't always relate to the outcome of the game bro. Notice I said mine even had 51.1. Too many things factor into PASS PCT, therefore, you should NOT incorporate play directly with the Pct..
Game: http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=11353
QB: http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=32974
Originally posted by Will2k
Originally posted by NewEnglandCoach
Originally posted by Will2k
Originally posted by NewEnglandCoach
Originally posted by Curufin
Originally posted by NewEnglandCoach
You guys are overreacting.. it's not even that big of a deal, seriously.
Have you looked at some of the replays? The passes aren't anywhere within a 10 yard radius of a WR.
Okay, yet my QB is a higher level, and had a decent pass pct. Even though it was 51.2, he went 7/13, I'm still going to call that successful.
It's ok guys. Because his player did well, means nothing else is wrong.
That's not what I said. I'm supporting Bort's claim that higher level QBs are prone to do better. Meyton Panning had a REALLY good game, leading his team to a 112-0 victory in the same league. He's also the same level as mine. There's more evidence supporting the claim. I can deal with the realism, I'm not tripping about it.
No, basically you said you don't understand why 80-90% of the people here are complaining about bad QB % because your QB had a good game. Your QB got the luck of the draw in the simming.
I understand that low lvl guys are not going to be lighting up the field, but for lvl 10 and up to have crappy games like this isn't right (unless the D is really good). If he wants to make it real rating style then they need to re work XP and LVL.
This is extremely retarded, I perfectly understand why. Every level 10+ I've seen has had a decent/good game. 50% Pass Pct doesn't always relate to the outcome of the game bro. Notice I said mine even had 51.1. Too many things factor into PASS PCT, therefore, you should NOT incorporate play directly with the Pct..
Game: http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=11353
QB: http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=32974
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.






























