User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
RAPB
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick
"The UNIVERSAL speech"
(Insult everyone dissenting. Don't be too offensive, but rather make them look a bit silly. Then continue like...)

Because one team may not have trouble with the (insert play/issue here) does not mean that there's nothing wrong with the (insert play/issue here). Something being overpowered doesn't mean that it's unstoppable for everyone.

Teams that have (insert what fixes the issue here) can generally cover the play without (insert what work around has been suggested), but when the two sides are equal, that's when you see that the (insert play/issue here) is unusually effective. In that situation, even (insert what you've tried / failed) does not necessarily mean that you'll contain the (insert play/issue here). That's what people are complaining about. The solution to stopping (insert play/issue here) is not the defense you call, but just having superior players. If they're just equal to the opponent, you will still get exposed.


I made this now fit for every play someone doesn't like. Please use this as standart-text. It will sound as reasonable as a whine can be.

Strong I, long passes, short passes, inside runs, outside runs, HB screens or whatever someone happens to have problems with... use this standart text to just say "No" to the obvious solution.
Last edited Dec 18, 2008 10:40:50
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kckings
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=277062&pbp_id=12698634

Ironically I think you're actually supporting the idea of the WR screen being overpowered. If you choose to dedicate three corners and a safety just to stop one particular play, then you're indicating a belief that the play is out of balance and requires extreme measures. Plus I doubt that your formation would be able to cope with single back runs to the right, especially the pitch.


Originally posted by RAPB
I made this now fit for every play someone doesn't like.

You'd have a point if the argument was applicable to other plays, but it isn't.
 
Raid
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kckings

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=277062&pbp_id=12698634

You can adjust for it and still stop the run. I don't think that the play is a "bug", but I do agree with some in saying that if a team runs the same play from the same formation more than X times in a game, that the defense should be able to "adjust" and be able to stop the play more easily as they would in real life.

I have no problem with offenses running it, but when it is run multiple times per game it gets to be a bit like the Normal/Reverse Option in John Elway QB.



if you think that play would stop a gut run you are terribly mistaken, that is a TD if they would have run HB smash or OT right.
 
RAPB
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick
Originally posted by RAPB

I made this now fit for every play someone doesn't like.

You'd have a point if the argument was applicable to other plays, but it isn't.


See, you have to add where the text is bold:

----------------------------------
To those that still think the strong I off-tackle isn't overpowered: I don't know if it ever came to mind to actually think about the plays in GLB.

Because one team may not have trouble with the Strong I Off-Tackle does not mean that there's nothing wrong with the Strong I Off-Tackle. Something being overpowered doesn't mean that it's unstoppable for everyone.

Teams that have run stopping lineman and LBs with high strength, agility and vision can generally cover the play without having to blitz like 2 or 3 guys or play goalline defense, but when the two sides are equal, that's when you see that the Strong I Off-Tackle is unusually effective. In that situation, even run focus does not necessarily mean that you'll contain the Strong I Off-Tackle. That's what people are complaining about. The solution to stopping Strong I Off-Tackle is not the defense you call, but just having superior players. If they're just equal to the opponent, you will still get exposed.

_____________________________________________

I'm can hardly believe everyone here is turning into some crazy speed freak when it comes to the ridicilous long passing.

Because one team may not have trouble with the deep pass completions does not mean that there's nothing wrong with the deep pass completions. Something being overpowered doesn't mean that it's unstoppable for everyone.

Teams that have DBs with speed and agility above 85 can generally cover the play without having to play their corners on medium or far coverage distance, but when the two sides are equal, that's when you see that the deep pass is unusually effective. In that situation, even cover 4 and pass focus does not necessarily mean that you'll contain the deep pass. That's what people are complaining about. The solution to stopping the deep pass is not the defense you call, but just having superior players. If they're just equal to the opponent, you will still get exposed.



See? It's just the perfect form to whine!
 
Raid
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by RAPB
Originally posted by jdbolick

Originally posted by RAPB


I made this now fit for every play someone doesn't like.

You'd have a point if the argument was applicable to other plays, but it isn't.


See, you have to add where the text is bold:

----------------------------------
To those that still think the strong I off-tackle isn't overpowered: I don't know if it ever came to mind to actually think about the plays in GLB.

Because one team may not have trouble with the Strong I Off-Tackle does not mean that there's nothing wrong with the Strong I Off-Tackle. Something being overpowered doesn't mean that it's unstoppable for everyone.

Teams that have run stopping lineman and LBs with high strength, agility and vision can generally cover the play without having to blitz like 2 or 3 guys or play goalline defense, but when the two sides are equal, that's when you see that the Strong I Off-Tackle is unusually effective. In that situation, even run focus does not necessarily mean that you'll contain the Strong I Off-Tackle. That's what people are complaining about. The solution to stopping Strong I Off-Tackle is not the defense you call, but just having superior players. If they're just equal to the opponent, you will still get exposed.

_____________________________________________

I'm can hardly believe everyone here is turning into some crazy speed freak when it comes to the ridicilous long passing.

Because one team may not have trouble with the deep pass completions does not mean that there's nothing wrong with the deep pass completions. Something being overpowered doesn't mean that it's unstoppable for everyone.

Teams that have DBs with speed and agility above 85 can generally cover the play without having to play their corners on medium or far coverage distance, but when the two sides are equal, that's when you see that the deep pass is unusually effective. In that situation, even cover 4 and pass focus does not necessarily mean that you'll contain the deep pass. That's what people are complaining about. The solution to stopping the deep pass is not the defense you call, but just having superior players. If they're just equal to the opponent, you will still get exposed.



See? It's just the perfect form to whine!


4-3 cover 1 SS blitz = kills OT strong I
Last edited Dec 18, 2008 11:57:04
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by RAPB
See, you have to add where the text is bold:

Honestly, I still can't tell if you're embarrassing yourself due to an inability to comprehend the distinction or if you actually do get it but are just dishonest enough to pretend otherwise. Regardless of which one it is, your best course of action is to stop.

The Strong I Off Tackle runs and corner routes are both popular because they are effective and require particular game-planning to contain, but neither are remotely as unbalanced as the WR screen. Neither of those plays will result in a touchdown where no players even got close enough to attempt a tackle if the offensive and defensive players are relatively equal. Neither of those plays feature one receiver blocking (whether actually or just by getting in the way) two or three defenders. They're challenging but they're not plays where you need to have significantly better players than the opposition just to stop it without devoting an inordinate number of defenders.

I understand that it's a favorite past-time of some people on GLB to do absolutely nothing but bitch at anyone who has a complaint, regardless of what that complaint happens to be, but I would strongly suggest that you at least try to get a life. If you have an actual rebuttal to the complaint and care to explain why you don't believe it's valid, then that's relevant and productive. But if you don't, then why waste anyone's time with your sad attempts at cleverness? I'm moderately curious as to whether you respond the way you do because you really feel like you're doing the staff a favor by sucking up to them and bashing anyone who has a complaint, or if it has nothing to do with them and you're just incredibly bitter by nature.
Last edited Dec 18, 2008 12:04:25
 
RAPB
offline
Link
 
Now you got it. Another perfect example of insult-empty bubble-whine!

Originally posted by jdbolick
Originally posted by RAPB

See, you have to add where the text is bold:

Honestly, I still can't tell if you're embarrassing yourself due to an inability to comprehend the distinction or if you actually do get it but are just dishonest enough to pretend otherwise. Regardless of which one it is, your best course of action is to stop. (great job! That was easy, wasn't it?)

The WR and HB screens are both popular because they are effective and require particular game-planning to contain, but neither are remotely as unbalanced as the Strong I Off Tackle runs and corner routes. Neither of those plays will result such a constant, unstoppable gain of yardage where no players even got (an) attempt (to) tackle for no gain or loss if the offensive and defensive players are relatively equal. Neither of those plays feature lineman/LBs or CBs beeing constantly taken out of the play to make it a 100% gainer for first downs. They're challenging but they're not plays where you need to have significantly better players than the opposition just to stop it without devoting an inordinate number of defenders.

I understand that it's a favorite past-time of some people on GLB to do absolutely nothing but bitch at anyone who has a complaint, regardless of what that complaint happens to be, but I would strongly suggest that you at least try to get a life. If you have an actual rebuttal to the complaint and care to explain why you don't believe it's valid, then that's relevant and productive. But if you don't, then why waste anyone's time with your sad attempts at cleverness? I'm moderately curious as to whether you respond the way you do because you really feel like you're doing the staff a favor by sucking up to them and bashing anyone who has a complaint, or if it has nothing to do with them and you're just incredibly bitter by nature.

(You extended the standart-whine by another insult at the end. Of course that makes the whiner look even more stupid. You might think this over, for usually whiners like to think as of themselfes having a legit issue.)


Great process of learning!

Now as you have shown to be able to learn, go fix your tactics or CB builds. I know you can do it. Otherwise shoot me a PM and I'll drop you some hints.
Last edited Dec 18, 2008 12:31:23
 
KingDan23
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Kingdan23
What's WR screen's power level?


Originally posted by Monk4HOF
Over 9000!


 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by RAPB
Now as you have shown to be able to learn, go fix your tactics or CB builds.

Clearly you're too busy being annoying to be bothered with anything as silly as reading comprehension. As has already been explained, tactics won't stop the WR screen. You need to have better (and not just equal either) CBs than their WRs. If you do, the WR screen will do nothing against you. If you don't, you're s.o.l. because the screen can still go for an 80+ yard touchdown even if you shift the ROLB and free safety to that area.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick
I understand that a lot of teenagers do play this game, so I don't know how many people still have some intellectual development to experience and how many are just simplistic. Because one team may not have trouble with the WR screen does not mean that there's nothing wrong with the play. Something being overpowered doesn't mean that it's unstoppable for everyone.

Teams that have better CBs than the WRs they're facing can generally cover the play without even adding an extra corner or safety, but when the two sides are equal, that's when you see that the play is unusually effective. In that situation, even running a defense with a weakside linebacker shift and an extra defensive back to that side does not necessarily mean that you'll contain the play. That's what people are complaining about. The solution to stopping the WR screen is not the defense you call, but just having significantly better CBs. If they're just equal to the WRs, you will still get exposed.


See predesigned plays: DE Contain, LB Contain, Man Flats. Put an extra non-CB into those flat areas, and the WR Screen won't work. I've had it stopped against my team with extra CB's as well.

You just don't like that you have to use specific defenses to stop it.

Again, any play used too often should be penalized in that game; but there's nothing wrong with the play.
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
See predesigned plays: DE Contain, LB Contain, Man Flats.

The pre-designed defenses are beyond awful. I can't count the number of touchdowns I've seen because of those plays. If the WR screen was the only play being run out of the single back formation, then sure, I'd hold my nose and use one of those, but what's the point in using something that might stop the screen only to be a major weakness against something else?

Originally posted by
Put an extra non-CB into those flat areas, and the WR Screen won't work.

Incorrect. I already explained that my team gave up an untouched 84.5 yard touchdown on a wide receiver screen even though I had the ROLB (with 90.19 speed) weak shifted and a FS on medium coverage distance playing over the top of the CB3. That happened because the WR3 blocked the CB3, CB1, and FS, while the ROLB wasn't able to catch up since the WR didn't even need a fraction of a second to catch the ball, but instead immediately broke to the outside and upfield.

Whether or not you stop the WR screen depends on two and only two things:

#1) Do your CBs have significantly more (not just equal) agility than the wide receivers?

#2) Does the wide receiver catch the ball cleanly and immediately accelerate to the outside?

Almost all the examples people have used of successfully stopping the WR screen feature either the CB getting around the block because they're just better than the WR3 blocking them, or because the WR1 didn't take that outside path and instead got hung up in traffic.

Originally posted by
You just don't like that you have to use specific defenses to stop it.

Again, read before you post. I wasn't playing just a nickel defense. I had the FS over the top and the ROLB shifted to that side specifically to try and contain the WR screen. It's a pathing and blocking problem, not a game-planning problem.
Last edited Dec 18, 2008 12:57:54
 
Sulfadias
offline
Link
 
My team defends the WR screen just fine.

 
RAPB
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick
Originally posted by RAPB

Now as you have shown to be able to learn, go fix your tactics or CB builds.

Clearly you're too busy being annoying to be bothered with anything as silly as reading comprehension. As has already been explained, tactics won't stop the WR screen. You need to have better (and not just equal either) CBs than their WRs. If you do, the WR screen will do nothing against you. If you don't, you're s.o.l. because the screen can still go for an 80+ yard touchdown even if you shift the ROLB and free safety to that area.


It sure is Christmas time, but no need to tell fairy tales. Stop telling lies and fix your tactics or CB builds - it's not that hard!
 
mat warrior
offline
Link
 
all the proof you need that its too powerful is the number of teams that have only it and maybe 1 other play they use in a whole game. when you run it no matter what down and distance, and the defense still cant stop it. thats oo powerful
 
Black Peter
offline
Link
 
Results getting better. From todays scrimmage:

Try 1: http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=285408&pbp_id=12891924 (23.5 yds)
Try 2: http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=285408&pbp_id=12892113 (16.5 yds)
Try 3: http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=285408&pbp_id=12892229 (int!!)
Try 4: http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=285408&pbp_id=12895379 (3.5 yds)
Try 5: http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=285408&pbp_id=12895706 (no gain)
Try 6: http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=285408&pbp_id=12896194 (0.5 yds)
Try 7: http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=285408&pbp_id=12896465 (RE PD)
Try 8: http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=285408&pbp_id=12896504 (RE PD)

Didn't try it again in the game. So, guess it worked out pretty well. The int and 2 RE PDs were nice to see on it at least.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.