User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Medium Coverage pushes me over the edge
Page:
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Dacolts
Originally posted by sirallan

Originally posted by Dacolts


Couldn't the style be simplified to:

-Go for the Int
-Go for the Int when help over the top
-Go for the PD


What would be the reason to ever use go for the INT or go for the PD?


Percent success rate changes. Int is lower, PD is higher.


I realize that but you by far get the best of both worlds using the middle setting. You in theory will never get beat deep (only a couple extra yards since there is help over top) + a chance to get a pick, and you will never give up a big play because you will always go for the PD on the deep passes.
I just feel like you guys are trying to make the passing game even more useless then it already is.
Just name it- "Go for the INT when you know you won't get beat and go for the PD when you want to prevent jumping the route and giving up a TD"
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
So maybe a 4th option is the best idea? It'd be easy enough to add; just adjust the same if statement to include it.

"Blanket - try to break up the pass every time, but not for the INT."

Something like that?


yes please!
 
Link
 
Not all Bort, not all!!!
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Yellow
Bort i really have to say that you're wrong on this.

Look at my CB playing on Medium/Aggressive compared to Medium/Medium, both before you changed the Medium coverage style code.

Medium/Medium:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=224710&pbp_id=5380381
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=224710&pbp_id=5378031
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=224680&pbp_id=3461400
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=224680&pbp_id=3462990

Medium/Aggressive:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=224712&pbp_id=6667359
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=224712&pbp_id=6665889


My CB behaves entirely different under each setting. On Medium/Medium, he hangs back on the ball and stays close to the WR, to get the PD, whereas on Medium/Aggressive, he darts forward to make a play on the ball, often leaving separation between himself and the WR.

I really don't see how you can say that CBs were behaving the same on Aggressive as they were on Medium, as i've seen a ton of evidence to prove otherwise. I have 3 CBs and i have experimented with just about every different coverage combination, and Aggressive and Medium have always performed differently.


Dunno, all I know is the single if statement I modified, which I posted earlier. It was definitely not as intended as it was.
 
vrshah
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
So maybe a 4th option is the best idea? It'd be easy enough to add; just adjust the same if statement to include it.

"Blanket - try to break up the pass every time, but not for the INT."

Something like that?


Wouldn't going for the PBUs require the same attributes that factor into the INT calculations now? OR would it somehow be an option where the CB doesn't get toasted as badly on a bad read?
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
So maybe a 4th option is the best idea? It'd be easy enough to add; just adjust the same if statement to include it.

"Blanket - try to break up the pass every time, but not for the INT."

Something like that?


I think that is your best choice Bort.
Just expect people to whine when they had an easy pick and got a PD instead.
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort

Dunno, all I know is the single if statement I modified, which I posted earlier. It was definitely not as intended as it was.


"Working, but not as intended."


 
Dacolts
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by The Lurker
Originally posted by sirallan

Originally posted by Dacolts


Couldn't the style be simplified to:

-Go for the Int
-Go for the Int when help over the top
-Go for the PD


What would be the reason to ever use go for the INT or go for the PD?


+ INT bonus, - PD penalty
No bonus, no penalty
+ PD bonus, - INT penalty


This seems to fit the game mechanics the best

 
vrshah
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sirallan
Originally posted by Bort

So maybe a 4th option is the best idea? It'd be easy enough to add; just adjust the same if statement to include it.

"Blanket - try to break up the pass every time, but not for the INT."

Something like that?


I think that is your best choice Bort.
Just expect people to whine when they had an easy pick and got a PD instead.


Exactly. You'll get mroe whiners and "bug" reports than before. I don't think this is a good option, personally because the way you intended coverages to work, is already inherent in the options currently available. People just have to find the right combination for their builds.
Last edited Nov 28, 2008 21:11:21
 
Yellow
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Now that I think about it, It really sounds like people want to be able to go in and try to break up passes every time without the risk of getting beat, which isn't necessarily the best option for game balance. There does need to be a risk/reward kinda thing.



Except that before, on Medium, you still had the potential to get beat, but you also had the ability to make a play on the ball if your CB was built well enough.

Now, on Medium, your CB just watches the WR make the catch.

 
Adderfist
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Now that I think about it, It really sounds like people want to be able to go in and try to break up passes every time without the risk of getting beat, which isn't necessarily the best option for game balance. There does need to be a risk/reward kinda thing.



First Off. Lesser the difference in speed settings. If I choose to play close, Medium, or Far to a WR 20 speed faster then me, I should get the results. Don't force me to play off. They have nothing to do with going for interceptions.

Have a setting per each WR they go against the next game be in a drop down. Let them set their coverage style for each one.

Let the "go for int" chances be just a slider 1-100%. and have that be a base +/- to going for Int's and PD's.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sirallan
Originally posted by Bort

So maybe a 4th option is the best idea? It'd be easy enough to add; just adjust the same if statement to include it.

"Blanket - try to break up the pass every time, but not for the INT."

Something like that?


I think that is your best choice Bort.
Just expect people to whine when they had an easy pick and got a PD instead.


It'd still be possible to get the INT, especially if the WR bobbles it or something.

Maybe I'll try testing a "move close to the receiver" setting for it instead: it could be the same exact code block but just add a couple feet off his outside shoulder as for positioning.
 
vrshah
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Yellow
Originally posted by Bort

Now that I think about it, It really sounds like people want to be able to go in and try to break up passes every time without the risk of getting beat, which isn't necessarily the best option for game balance. There does need to be a risk/reward kinda thing.



Except that before, on Medium, you still had the potential to get beat, but you also had the ability to make a play on the ball if your CB was built well enough.

Now, on Medium, your CB just watches the WR make the catch.



There should def. be something that addresses this on both medium and tight coverage distances. This is not a "coverage style" issue.
 
The Lurker
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sirallan
Originally posted by Bort

So maybe a 4th option is the best idea? It'd be easy enough to add; just adjust the same if statement to include it.

"Blanket - try to break up the pass every time, but not for the INT."

Something like that?


I think that is your best choice Bort.
Just expect people to whine when they had an easy pick and got a PD instead.


Yeah, that's why I thought your % idea was a good one. You should be able to dictate when to go for it (never/rarely vs. with help over the top vs. all the time), and then you set the percentages of how often you play for an INT or play for a PD. You'd have a lot more control over your DB this way.
Last edited Nov 28, 2008 21:13:38
 
MRIGUY
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Dacolts
Couldn't the style be simplified to:

-Go for the Int
-Go for the Int when help over the top
-Go for the PD


i like this.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.