User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Weight Classes
Page:
 
notthegint
offline
Link
 
It might make sense to integrate a couple other weight based modifiers... (this is obviously assuming the speed change that's already in place.)

Higher Weight

+Block
+Tackle
-Stamina

+Break Block
+Break Tackle

Lower Weight

-Block
-Tackle
+Stamina

-Break Block
-Break Tackle

Hopefully the pure speed HBs/WRs/DEs/LBs will be reigned in a little when they're being insta-tackled/pancaked.

(Nods to those who already suggested similar ideas in this thread or elsewhere.)
Last edited Nov 24, 2008 10:57:44
 
TheInfinity
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by notthegint
It might make sense to integrate a couple other weight based modifiers... (this is obviously assuming the speed change that's already in place.)

Higher Weight

+Block
+Tackle
-Stamina

+Break Block
+Break Tackle

Lower Weight

-Block
-Tackle
+Stamina

-Break Block
-Break Tackle

Hopefully the pure speed HBs/WRs/DEs/LBs will be reigned in a little when they're being insta-tackled/pancaked.

(Nods to those who already suggested similar ideas in this thread or elsewhere.)


Minus stamina for high weight? Dude, linemen and big power backs get the most work out of anyone in the NFL, if we're doing this for realism, thats off. Second, assigning attributes like tackling is off, safeties are some of the best tacklers on a team, definitely better than the big power back or the offensive lineman. They may not have the same strength level but their technique tends to be very good.

Putting this weight thing into so many things is going to make it insane to understand whats going on fully. In my opinion its a bad idea to begin with but I'll live with it if Bort goes with it, but if it expands as far as people in this thread want it to, the game is going to get ruined. To begin with not everyone is going to conform to their weight in life, 260lb. guys are sometimes freaks and can be faster than a 220lb. guy, it happens. They can also sometimes jump higher, LeBron James is 260lb., tell me that he doesn't have an insane vertical leap. And some smaller dudes can be very strong for their size, Terrell Owens is a bit slower than a dude like Randy Moss but much stronger and more physical. Larry Fitzgerald is the same way.

If strength meant anything in this game we wouldn't be worrying about this. Make strength matter in block breaking/blocking/carrying/etc and you'll have your solution without this crazy system. Hate to put it this way but Bort, you're dodging the problem that is plaguing this game, you need to revamp the mechanics, not institute more customization abilities in the hopes that it covers up the real problems.
Last edited Nov 24, 2008 11:41:28
 
kretchfoop
offline
Link
 
I agree with infinity. Tackling is a "football skill" and not a "physical attribute."

I always considered it form (which has nothing to do with size - an 8-year old could have better tackling form than Galactus). Keep in mind that strength is already factored into tackling (especially for taking down those power backs) and this will be modified in Bort's framework.

KISS
 
VenomCoach
offline
Link
 
In general the idea is good however the height weight and position should both be factored in.

For example for speed (just an example)

WR / CB +20%
SS / FS / RB +10%
TE +5%
LB Par
FB -5%
QB / DE -10%
DT / OL -20%

Now within the OL you would have 3 to 5 weight classes. Say 250-299 Lightweight +speed, agility, stamina, - STR. 300-325 Base. 326+ +Str -SPE, AGI, STA
 
al0x
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by VenomCoach
In general the idea is good however the height weight and position should both be factored in.

For example for speed (just an example)

WR / CB +20%
SS / FS / RB +10%
TE +5%
LB Par
FB -5%
QB / DE -10%
DT / OL -20%

Now within the OL you would have 3 to 5 weight classes. Say 250-299 Lightweight +speed, agility, stamina, - STR. 300-325 Base. 326+ +Str -SPE, AGI, STA


I disagree with the positional percentages, it should all be done by weight. Imo, if someone wishes to build a pure speed DE that weighs 160lbs or a 260lb strength WR then they should be able to. The speed DE would have no really low strength, but should be able to do it.
 
Cryptotich
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by
I disagree with the positional percentages, it should all be done by weight. Imo, if someone wishes to build a pure speed DE that weighs 160lbs or a 260lb strength WR then they should be able to. The speed DE would have no really low strength, but should be able to do it.


At that point he would pretty much cease to be a DE. Which would be fine if people who broke their builds like this were able to change their position. If a real person showed up for training camp weighing 160lbs saying "I'm a DE", the coach will chuckle a little, and tell him to go see the WR/CB coach.
Last edited Nov 24, 2008 12:24:20
 
Knick
Sknickers
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Cryptotich
Originally posted by Bort

Just thought up this random idea while driving in the car, so I thought I'd post it here so as not to forget and see what people thought:

Currently, everybody basically has the same base speed value for what 100 speed will get you. It's modified by height/weight a little, along with acceleration, but not a huge amount.


I would rather see base speed/strength be position based rather than be an absolute. For example a 100 ST fullback, will be stronger than a 100 ST half back, or a 100 speed CB is going to be faster than a 100 speed LB.


This idea goes well.

/sarcasm
 
robelder
offline
Link
 
I like it, especially sense I made a similar suggestion last week.

I think that no fast DT should ever be able to compete in a foot race with a fast HB, WR, or CB.

 
SwagOnLock
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by robelder
I think that no fast DT should ever be able to compete in a foot race with a fast HB, WR, or CB.


Why? They have very comparable 40 times.
 
al0x
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by robelder
I like it, especially sense I made a similar suggestion last week.

I think that no fast DT should ever be able to compete in a foot race with a fast HB, WR, or CB.



I believe the DT should be able to, but he would have to weigh a similar amount to them, for example the DT would be at most 220lbs. He would have very little strength, but would be as fast.
 
alexiusmyth
offline
Link
 
Weight should matter because it matters in football.

It's as simple as that really.
 
TheInfinity
offline
Link
 
Going to put it out there again because no one seems to frickin' understand.

Defensive Ends are Heavy in the NFL because they Need Strength. They NEED IT.

Defensive Ends are Fast in Goalline Blitz because they Don't Need Strength.

If you make them Need Strength, you will Slow Them Down.

Take for example a Defensive End. You can build him to have 30 Strength, 90 Speed, 60 Agility or some other speed-type build. Why? Because he's not hindered by the fact that he has 30 Strength. If a guy with 30 Strength was unable to break blocks too well and the blocking mechanic worked properly such that Offensive Tackles usually got a hand on them you would see Defensive Ends starting to sacrifice Speed/Agility for Strength and the builds starting to look more "realistic".

All this weight stuff does is make the Defensive Ends say "hey, I can get a bonus to my Speed/Agility by lowering my weight" and the Offensive Tackle say "hey, I can get a bonus to my strength by gaining weight" so what you've done is made the Defensive End faster and the Offensive Tackle slower! Now those Offensive Tackles have no hope of getting their hands on the Defensive Ends unless they also become small dudes. Passers everywhere will get killed.

Again, this is like sweeping the dirt under the rug. The problem is certain aspects of the game mechanic, the value of everything relative to speed and the constant catering to whiners. This is not a solution to any of that, its a cover up that will-not-work if put in as its described.

You get slow giant power backs able to run people over which leads to complaints again (either OMG my RB is so slow now! or OMG my DB can't make a tackle so I made him heavy now he gets toasted in coverage!), you exacerbate the Speed/Agility difference at positions where one can specialize and the other can't (i.e. Cornerbacks need to spend on vision and be able to make tackles in the open field while Wide Receivers will now be even faster and harder to deal with) (Offensive Tackles need to be big to block while Defensive Ends can just get smaller and get around those Offensive Tackles who have taken a hit to speed/agility due to weight.)

And you eliminate the freaks from the game. Sometimes you have a 260lb. guy thats both big and fast. Julius Peppers, Jevon Kearse for good football examples at Defensive End. Or tremendously strong hitters who are smaller guys. Rod Woodson, Ronnie Lott are good examples for that at the Safety position. Granted, these guys are rarities in the NFL, but if people want to try and mimic their builds they should have the ability to. However, keep in mind that Julius Peppers is not Deion Sanders and thats not due to size (size stands out but its not the issue!) its because Julius Peppers needs strength (sort of like spending SP in strength) while Deion Sanders doesn't (sort of like not spending SP in strength and spending on speed/agility instead).

In Goalline Blitz though, everyone can get away with being Deion Sanders instead of Julius Peppers because Strength is not working properly. Thats the problem.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Coach P
If you lose weight to get faster, shouldnt you also lose a hair or two of strength?


not really, you can lose weght but still be able to bench the same, and things like that

I really like the idea, because having dt's be able to stay with hb's and wr's for more than a few yds is pretty lame, and not realistic in anyway
 
Link
 
I think Bort's original post is good as a "starting point" and he can see how that works, then adjust accordingly. Definately a topic I've been thinking about how to approach... ( I've always believed those 300+ lb people should NOT be moving as fast as the 180 lb people - I don't care what their Speed is at) And the training to lower weight idea is a good one as well. Should definately give people an option to lower- thru Agility/Speed training ( or INCREASE-through strength/stamina training) their weight.
GOOD IDEA BORT! + 1000 * Edit* Isn't this an "Epic" suggestion? lol
Last edited Nov 24, 2008 14:15:07
 
arcadecowboy
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by alexiusmyth
Weight should matter because it matters in football.

It's as simple as that really.


Originally posted by TheInfinity
Going to put it out there again because no one seems to frickin' understand.

Defensive Ends are Heavy in the NFL because they Need Strength. They NEED IT.

Defensive Ends are Fast in Goalline Blitz because they Don't Need Strength.

If you make them Need Strength, you will Slow Them Down.

(edit: you can read the missing parts above )

In Goalline Blitz though, everyone can get away with being Deion Sanders instead of Julius Peppers because Strength is not working properly. Thats the problem.



I really like the concept behind Bort's suggestion.

Physics need to be accounted for. Take two players. One is 170 lbs, the other is 230 lbs. They both have the same speed ratings, strength ratings, etc. In fact, they are identical in every measurement *except size.* If these two meet in a head on collision , and keep in mind everything is equal, including technique and velocity, the 230 lb player should win.

I also agree with TheInfinity in part because I also think Strength is not working properly. I don't think this should be a *fix* for that issue, and that it should be examined and adjusted separately. However, I still would like to see this implemented.

 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.