User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Seems like we have both sides of the coin arguing. There's the "DE's can't do anything" people and then there's the "DE's are too good" people. Which is it?
 
nightstar289
offline
Link
 
Let's see...

http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=1135601

I'm guessing that Madcow is the a-hole here
 
nightstar289
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Seems like we have both sides of the coin arguing. There's the "DE's can't do anything" people and then there's the "DE's are too good" people. Which is it?


DEs are getting waaayyyyyy too many sacks right now, but the DE builds that aren't perfect aren't getting any sacks either (balanced/containment builds), and that's not right either. Maybe nerf speed DEs so the average maximum is around 20 sacks in a season, while making the balanced/containment DEs better (getting around 5 sacks per season).
 
Voltron
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Seems like we have both sides of the coin arguing. There's the "DE's can't do anything" people and then there's the "DE's are too good" people. Which is it?


Not really, just people still think 50 agility with 30 speed is going to cut it.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Seems like we have both sides of the coin arguing. There's the "DE's can't do anything" people and then there's the "DE's are too good" people. Which is it?


Glad to see Bort chiming in on this thread. Let me say first of all that I am all in favor of realistic stats. But the fact is, it will never be perfect as it would be super hard to code it so the stats stay on an even keel regardless of the competition you face.

I think the new addidions to the offensive AI will allow teams to stop a monster pass rusher. I can tell you if I had to face a DE with Wyatt's history, I'd roll the TE to his side, AND hold in a back to block.

Madcow's failure to do so is his own fault. And the fact he blames it on the sim is laughable since he didn't use all the tools at his disposal.

FACT - DEs built purely on speed and agility are much less effective now.

FACT - people who built their guys to be solid all around DEs are not seeing a drop of in production.


IMO everything is working as intended.
 
SWVAHoo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Seems like we have both sides of the coin arguing. There's the "DE's can't do anything" people and then there's the "DE's are too good" people. Which is it?


I think it's more a third category for me, TBH. I'll call it the "Upgrade Offensive Line Algorithm" crowd. Here's why.

As I've said before, an offensive line customarily shifts toward the direction from which the stiffest blitz is coming from. If you blitz an OLB, this OLB should path outside the DE on the overload blitz. A decent O-Line will slide over to protect the weak side. Here's an example of what typically happens in RL football, and what happens in GLB football.

RL: LT slide to block OLB, LG slide to block DE, C slide to block DT, RG slide to block NT, sack generally more difficult to come by
GLB: LT slides slightly to block OLB *or* DE, LG does NOT slide and blocks DT, C basically stands there, RG blocks NT, DE or OLB gets easy sack

The only complaint I have about builds is that blocking isn't being utilized nearly enough in the O-line equation. If people are content to build their DEs like SSs, then an OT should be able to block the DE like he would a SS. The algorithm is too far slanted toward pure strength/speed/agility for DEs, while an O-linemen as it currently stands has to beef up on vision, confidence, speed, agility, and blocking just to counteract this mixture for DEs. I believe that an OT with 80 strength, 30 blocking, 30 speed, 30 agility should have to suffer the consequences of a bad build, but I also believe that an OT with 65 strength, 70 blocking, 50 speed and 50 agility shouldn't have to give up sack after sack after sack, either.

That's how I feel, go ahead and rip it apart if it's not sound. I'm not a computer whiz, so it really might not be.
Last edited Nov 11, 2008 23:57:09
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Maybe blocking should give the player a higher radius at which he can engage the block? Right now it just determines how well you can hold it when you do engage, but everyone's distance to engage is the same.

That would seem to make some sense, no?

Other idea: Maybe guys with 8 vision shouldn't get the instant jump on the snap, either. I could easily extend the "snap delay" code to D-line guys on pass plays.
 
SWVAHoo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Maybe blocking should give the player a higher radius at which he can engage the block? Right now it just determines how well you can hold it when you do engage, but everyone's distance to engage is the same.

That would seem to make some sense, no?

Other idea: Maybe guys with 8 vision shouldn't get the instant jump on the snap, either. I could easily extend the "snap delay" code to D-line guys on pass plays.


Both of those make quite a bit of sense, really.

For the first, I like your blocking idea. Either this, or is there any way you could make this co-dependent upon vision?
For the second, this would likewise be optimum. Any player with high speed/agility can juke and jive, but that initial point of attack is important, and vision would seem to be to be the best place for it.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cdcollins
For the first, I like your blocking idea. Either this, or is there any way you could make this co-dependent upon vision?


Yeah, it could be based on an average or something I guess. Vision is already used to see if you will even try to block a guy who's farther away than a couple yards, though, so I don't know if it would be needed in that idea.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Maybe blocking should give the player a higher radius at which he can engage the block? Right now it just determines how well you can hold it when you do engage, but everyone's distance to engage is the same.

That would seem to make some sense, no?

Other idea: Maybe guys with 8 vision shouldn't get the instant jump on the snap, either. I could easily extend the "snap delay" code to D-line guys on pass plays.



I think all you need to do is explain to people that agility doesn't cause them to move at all. People think 50 agility is enough regardless of what speed is. They mistakenly think that speed is 40 yard dash speed, but forget that speed also involves how quickly they drop back in pass blocking - even it that is only moving 3-4 yards in either direction.

Just the fact that you limited the range of how far a DE can go around a OT now and I haven't seen any of the inside moves that got half of the sacks last year should have been enough. Then to have the TE and RB being able to stay in now will GREATLY cut down the sacks.

Let's just see how this goes for a couple weeks. Teams haven't had enough time to see it all in action yet.

The best pass rushers in the NFL are regularly double teamed. There is no reason why that shouldn't be the case in GLB also.
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Eric the Great of Antarctica
Originally posted by Bort

Seems like we have both sides of the coin arguing. There's the "DE's can't do anything" people and then there's the "DE's are too good" people. Which is it?


Glad to see Bort chiming in on this thread. Let me say first of all that I am all in favor of realistic stats. But the fact is, it will never be perfect as it would be super hard to code it so the stats stay on an even keel regardless of the competition you face.

I think the new addidions to the offensive AI will allow teams to stop a monster pass rusher. I can tell you if I had to face a DE with Wyatt's history, I'd roll the TE to his side, AND hold in a back to block.

Madcow's failure to do so is his own fault. And the fact he blames it on the sim is laughable since he didn't use all the tools at his disposal.

FACT - DEs built purely on speed and agility are much less effective now.

FACT - people who built their guys to be solid all around DEs are not seeing a drop of in production.


IMO everything is working as intended.


+1
 
TheRooster
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Madcow8me
Originally posted by Motiak

What's your agility and how much do you have in protector?


Agility is low 50s, and i have 4 in protector, 80 blocking...


I won't tell you what's wrong with your build, but it's not right.
 
SWVAHoo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by cdcollins

For the first, I like your blocking idea. Either this, or is there any way you could make this co-dependent upon vision?


Yeah, it could be based on an average or something I guess. Vision is already used to see if you will even try to block a guy who's farther away than a couple yards, though, so I don't know if it would be needed in that idea.


Since that's the case, I don't think vision would be as essential as blocking in determining the engage distance.
If there's just one thing I'd like to see improved, this would be it. I know this is the "Bugs" forum, but this thread's taken on a life of its own. But I digress. I think this would be a great fix to many of the ills seen in this thread. Great DEs would still be great, bad O-Linemen would still be exposed, but there'd be a much happier medium, as it were.
 
ron2288
offline
Link
 
you know I guess since the OP wants to complain about his Ot not being a superman giving up sacks..I guess i could complain why the level 30 OT shut down my level 36 speed DE

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=223987&pbp_id=1410559

*start sarcasm*

now I did get some sacks..but I should had this sack..it is no fair..I should had a 100 sacks this game

end sarcasm

hmm..I know why this Ot blew up my DE...my guy is a speed guy,,,got locked up with a guy that has more strength..hmmm

so the Op wants to cry...well there is proof against his whining and crying

a level 30 OT takeing out a level 36 DE...dam whn you put speed on strength and the guys with speed does what he supposed to..run around the stronger guy..then yea..the ot gets beat

but if the stronger OT gets his hands on the speedy weak de..then well the speedy little De looks foolish like mine did

so now enough with the whining and crying...dam it is getting old...GLB has turn into a cry feast to see who can cry the loudest to get their way...it is supposed to be a challenge.. not well since this is to hard to figuer out..i cry like a 2 year old to get my way....jezzzzz..it is getting old

 
Talon
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Maybe blocking should give the player a higher radius at which he can engage the block? Right now it just determines how well you can hold it when you do engage, but everyone's distance to engage is the same.

That would seem to make some sense, no?

Other idea: Maybe guys with 8 vision shouldn't get the instant jump on the snap, either. I could easily extend the "snap delay" code to D-line guys on pass plays.


On your first thought, I always thought that was part of blocking. The fundamental problem right now appears to be the stat itself having no apparent counterpart for the defensive players. Meaning, what is 'anti-blocking'? The OP's complaint was that the Speed/Agility DE ran right by him, and people responded he needed more Speed/Agility. So if the LOTs start training Speed and Agility, they neglect Blocking. If a defender concentrates on Speed and Agility, he loses little right now.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.