User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Canadian AAA Leagues > Canada AAA #2 > Canada AAA#2 West Power Rankings
Page:
 
BobJoeJim
offline
Link
 
OFFICIAL RANKINGS 5/19

1. North American NDL'ers (7-4, 95.6 [82.9 + 12.7])
2. Forumopolis Fighting Llamas (8-2-1, 92.9 [87.1 + 5.8])
3. Yukon Gold Rush (9-1-1, 92.1 [89.4 + 2.7])
4. Mooresville Anglers (6-5, 86.7 [90.7 - 4.0])
5. Saskatoon Raiders (8-3, 86.7 [91.8 - 5.1])
6. Thunder Bay Storm (9-1-1, 84.0 [90.6 - 6.6])
7. Sudbury Spurs (3-7-1, 83.6 [79.0 + 4.6])
8. Phoenixville Kings (5-6, 82.8 [80.7 + 2.1])
9. Abbotsford Miners (2-9, 81.9 [77.1 + 4.8])
10. Mt. Oread Hawk Stars (8-3, 81.3 [92.6 - 11.3])
11. TSW Titans (5-6, 80.8 [77.3 + 3.5])
12. Blacksburg Ballers (7-4, 80.4 [84.8 - 4.4])
13. Moose Knuckle Island Sofa Kings (5-6, 78.3 [83.1 - 4.8])
14. San Francisco Sucka Free's (2-9, 73.5)
15. Ottawa Chiefs (1-10, 70.4 [63.6 + 6.8])
16. Strathmore Devils (1-10, 27.2 [34.0 - 6.8])

This conference is definitely demonstrating that the upset adjustments can get out of hand. The 7-4 NDL'ers really shouldn't be #1, any more than Mt. Oread should be #10. I'm still not 100% sure what change I'll make in the rankings next season to fix things, but something will change. In the meantime, enjoy these numbers that the current formula spits out!
 
Motiak
offline
Link
 
I would say maybe do upset adjustments based on the formulated number, not the base number. That way teams with strong rosters that may have lost a few still have a chance to work their way up even if roster-wise they aren't technically upsets.
 
BobJoeJim
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Motiak
I would say maybe do upset adjustments based on the formulated number, not the base number. That way teams with strong rosters that may have lost a few still have a chance to work their way up even if roster-wise they aren't technically upsets.


Yeah, I've argued vociferously against this idea since the beginning, but my rationale is starting to break down, as the rankings diverge from where I feel they should be. This very well could be the fix I institute.
 
godsize
offline
Link
 
I would agree that the adjustment modifier may be a bit screwy. I'm glad to see Abbotsford break the top ten, as we have made several moves and have grown as a team. We continue to try to get better each game.

However, 5 out of the 7 team below us already beat us this year, by an combined 105-21. Granted, those 5 losses were in our first 6 games and we were horrible. Also, we beat the top team in the rankings, who I agree may not deserve to be up at #1.

I enjoy seeing the rankings though, keep working on them.

 
Daw1git
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by BIGmike61985
Originally posted by Bob Probert

gg NDLers

GG.


GG

 
Link
 
Originally posted by BobJoeJim
Originally posted by Motiak

I would say maybe do upset adjustments based on the formulated number, not the base number. That way teams with strong rosters that may have lost a few still have a chance to work their way up even if roster-wise they aren't technically upsets.


Yeah, I've argued vociferously against this idea since the beginning, but my rationale is starting to break down, as the rankings diverge from where I feel they should be. This very well could be the fix I institute.


Why? The base ranking is purely statistical, while the upset ranking is a rough approximation of how well a team gameplans or how deep it is.

Calculating upsets off of the adjusted number muddies what are, as of now, pretty clear waters.
 
JibJabz
offline
Link
 
If you want to maintain the system of calculating upsets based on the base ranking I think you can, you just need to look into also adding points for non-upset wins.

Really _your_ teams' ranking probably shouldn't factor into how many points you get when you win/lose. Basically if you beat a good team you get a lot of pts, if you beat a bad team you get a few. If you lose to a good team you lose a few pts, if you lose to a bad team you lose a lot of pts.

In this way the win/loss adjustments are purely based on performance and they will modify the base rankings which are purely based on talent.
 
BobJoeJim
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
Originally posted by BobJoeJim

Originally posted by Motiak


I would say maybe do upset adjustments based on the formulated number, not the base number. That way teams with strong rosters that may have lost a few still have a chance to work their way up even if roster-wise they aren't technically upsets.


Yeah, I've argued vociferously against this idea since the beginning, but my rationale is starting to break down, as the rankings diverge from where I feel they should be. This very well could be the fix I institute.


Why? The base ranking is purely statistical, while the upset ranking is a rough approximation of how well a team gameplans or how deep it is.

Calculating upsets off of the adjusted number muddies what are, as of now, pretty clear waters.


That's the argument I've been using all season. The counterargument I'm currently piecing together is that a team's adjusted rating at any given time represents my best effort to capture their "true" talent level. If an upset occurs based on adjusted ratings, then clearly the teams weren't adjusted enough yet, and I can adjust again to correct for it.

If in the first game a 90 gets upset and drops to 85, while an 85 wins in an upset and moves to 90, and then those teams play each other in week 2, I'm already saying that the second team is "better" and I've already adjusted the rankings to account for it. I'm not sure anymore that it's right to give the second team an ADDITIONAL boost, and the first team an additional penalty, if the expected win happens...

Right now the system puts the team with the highest roster rating in a VERY awkward position since they can NEVER earn upset credit, so if someone upsets them and knocks them out of the top spot, there is nothing they can ever do to get that place back, even if they end up with the best record in the league. A team with the best record AND best roster rating should be ranked #1 in almost all circumstances, or else the rankings have a flaw, and right now the odds of that team being ranked #1 are low, unless they go undefeated. Additionally, teams like the NDL'ers in this league, and the Brown Trout (Trout IMO) in the East, who start out ranked low, get a huge advantage simply by having so many more *opportunities* for upset wins. At the very least, once a team in that position has won enough upset games to climb to first place, they should probably stop getting upset credit for continuing to win. It's no longer a surprise at that point.
 
BobJoeJim
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by JibJabz
If you want to maintain the system of calculating upsets based on the base ranking I think you can, you just need to look into also adding points for non-upset wins.

Really _your_ teams' ranking probably shouldn't factor into how many points you get when you win/lose. Basically if you beat a good team you get a lot of pts, if you beat a bad team you get a few. If you lose to a good team you lose a few pts, if you lose to a bad team you lose a lot of pts.

In this way the win/loss adjustments are purely based on performance and they will modify the base rankings which are purely based on talent.


If I *don't* go with the option of using current ratings, this is another alternative I've considered. Win/loss bonuses outside of "upset" situations could help alleviate the problem of top teams getting overly penalized, since it gives them an additional way to get their ranking back up. The danger I see though, is that it would also exacerbate the issue where initially underrated teams can become overrated. Now not only would they get upset credit they don't necessarily deserve for some of their later wins, they are ALSO getting a generic win bonus? I'm not sure I like the consequences of that...

A final thing I'm considering that should help with these problems is to account for depth in the ratings. Right now you're rated based on your starting lineup, but those starters aren't going to be on the field 100% of the time (or if they are, they won't be playing at 100% of their talent level the whole time). Instead of basing the rushing rating on the starting RB, I could base it on a weighted average of the starting RB and the backup. This isn't a solution to the upset adjustment issues per se, but it's a way of making the initial rankings more accurate (presumably) which will hopefully reduce the number of "upsets" that occur, thus reducing the impact of any flaws in the upset adjustment system as a secondary effect.
 
redskins0756
offline
Link
 
Last edited May 19, 2008 15:10:23
 
redskins0756
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by
Yeah, I've argued vociferously against this idea since the beginning, but my rationale is starting to break down, as the rankings diverge from where I feel they should be. This very well could be the fix I institute.


0_o
Last edited May 19, 2008 15:09:49
 
BobJoeJim
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by redskins0756
Originally posted by

Yeah, I've argued vociferously against this idea since the beginning, but my rationale is starting to break down, as the rankings diverge from where I feel they should be. This very well could be the fix I institute.


o_O


http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/vociferously

What?
 
nottom
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by BobJoeJim

Yeah, I've argued vociferously against this idea since the beginning, but my rationale is starting to break down, as the rankings diverge from where I feel they should be. This very well could be the fix I institute.


I'd like to think my PMs about this may have influenced your thoughts at least a little bit.
 
BobJoeJim
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by nottom
Originally posted by BobJoeJim


Yeah, I've argued vociferously against this idea since the beginning, but my rationale is starting to break down, as the rankings diverge from where I feel they should be. This very well could be the fix I institute.


I'd like to think my PMs about this may have influenced your thoughts at least a little bit.


They have indeed, you argued your point well
 
cdoink
offline
Link
 
Abbotsford has actually improved their team by leaps and bounds this season. I stand corrected.
Last edited May 20, 2008 09:12:23
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.