User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
anthon9283
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Doggg4
Maybe I am thinking too simplistic, but last year power backs seemed like they were breaking 20 tackles a game. Defensive players as a whole had neglected tackling as a relavent stat. So as a counter a lot of defensive players last year went to wrap up tackling. So last year, low tackiling + wrap up = less fumbles. Now this year, defensive players have had the chance to boost 6 levels, plus natural leveling and at least I know with my guys, pumped a lot into tackling. So this year, defensive players have much higher tackling and a lot are back on to power tackling, so that would equal a greater chance of fumbles. I think RB's are now on the other side of the equation, carrying is the stat that got left behind and what the guides say, or what people thought was a good amount, really isn't.


The problem is what is a good number for carrying? From the looks of it.. nothing in the 40s seems to help. Is that negelecting carrying? I don't think so. Does a back have to have 60+ carry to limit fumbles now? I'm sure most don't have tackling that high on defense.. for players around the mid-upper 20s anyways.
Last edited Oct 14, 2008 04:11:11
 
manx
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by anthon9283
Originally posted by Doggg4

Maybe I am thinking too simplistic, but last year power backs seemed like they were breaking 20 tackles a game. Defensive players as a whole had neglected tackling as a relavent stat. So as a counter a lot of defensive players last year went to wrap up tackling. So last year, low tackiling + wrap up = less fumbles. Now this year, defensive players have had the chance to boost 6 levels, plus natural leveling and at least I know with my guys, pumped a lot into tackling. So this year, defensive players have much higher tackling and a lot are back on to power tackling, so that would equal a greater chance of fumbles. I think RB's are now on the other side of the equation, carrying is the stat that got left behind and what the guides say, or what people thought was a good amount, really isn't.


The problem is what is a good number for carrying? From the looks of it.. nothing in the 40s seems to help. Is that negelecting carrying? I don't think so. Does a back have to have 60+ carry to limit fumbles now? I'm sure most don't have tackling that high on defense.. for players around the mid-upper 20s anyways.


almost every safety, LB, and Lineman has 50+ tackling on my lvl 20's team.
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
My 15 strength level 21 cornerback has caused 3 fumbles this year, all on high speed collisions during kickoff coverage, so I think that speed at contact is being factored in somehow. If so, I think that's great, but it has made returns somewhat problematic since I don't dare put a CB (or anyone else without high carrying) in as a returner anymore.
 
Synovia
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Didn't touch fumbles since last season. Maybe your opponent was extra strong, or had lots of fumble forcing SA's or some +fumble % gear? You could be tired, have low morale, just get bad rolls, etc.


Bort, numbers are way up league wide. Somethign you did is definitely effecting this, and the gear doesn't do enough to have these effects.
 
Synovia
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Zickzack
Well, you think I am ignoring something, I think you you are ignoring the fact that last seasons stats have no relevance whatsoever to this seasons, not because Bort made any changes, but because player builds have changed on both sides of the ball, and because something called a random number generator is involved in anything related to gameplay in GLB.




Do you really think that the use of a random number generator invalidates his point? If theres supposed to be a 5% chance of fumbling, and 50% of carries are being fumbled, its not the generator, its a problem with the algorithm. You can still have statistical significance when random numbers are involved.
 
Zickzack
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Synovia
Do you really think that the use of a random number generator invalidates his point? If theres supposed to be a 5% chance of fumbling, and 50% of carries are being fumbled, its not the generator, its a problem with the algorithm. You can still have statistical significance when random numbers are involved.

Exaggerating much?

The point is, although there are players who see their fumbles increased by a good margin (with other possible reasons already having been pointed out) there are others who will have seen them go down or stay the same, just that those players are far less likely to be vocal on the board, as they of course will attribute it to their build or whatever, whereas those on the other side of the equation (i.e. those that have less luck with the RNG this season) will say it can't possibly be their build but has to be a change to the engine.

People in this thread seem to assume that just because they had a low number of fumbles last season they are entitled to have just as few this season, which is at best a very bold assumption, especially considering there is a RNG involved, not to mention adjusted builds on the defensive side of the ball.

 
Synovia
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Zickzack
Originally posted by Synovia

Do you really think that the use of a random number generator invalidates his point? If theres supposed to be a 5% chance of fumbling, and 50% of carries are being fumbled, its not the generator, its a problem with the algorithm. You can still have statistical significance when random numbers are involved.

Exaggerating much?


No, because I wasn't referring to numbers. I was talking about statistical significance in numbers with random elements.

If you went from 0 fumbles to 10 fumbles, its statistically significant. The increase we've seen is statistically significant. That means its not the generator. (unless the RNG is broken now, or was broken)
 
Barnsie
offline
Link
 
Fumbles are up, period.
 
Themuffinman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Barnsie
Fumbles are up, period.


 
Zickzack
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Synovia

No, because I wasn't referring to numbers. I was talking about statistical significance in numbers with random elements.

If you went from 0 fumbles to 10 fumbles, its statistically significant. The increase we've seen is statistically significant. That means its not the generator. (unless the RNG is broken now, or was broken)


So "50% of carries are being fumbled" is not trying to put an (exaggerated) number out there? Way to spin things ...

And as already was said repeatedly, and you chose to completely ignore, there are other possible (and likely) factors that could lead to an increased number of fumbles. Better builds on defenders being the most likely explanation. Also there are likely a number of HBs out there who fumble less this season, but of course won't chime in in these kind of discussions.

So if one HB goes from 0 to 10 fumbles but another goes from 10 to 0, you will only hear the first one whine and of course believe that something was changed, if in fact it is at best incidental evidence unless you can prove that across the board fumbles per carry are up significantly, and even then there might be other explanations than changes to the engine, which most of you seem to simply ignore no matter how often it is laid out to you.
 
Schaffer05
offline
Link
 
Power backs don't seem to be fumbling... My HB hasn't fumbled yet this season, neither has my buddies Power HB on my team. My Elusive back has only fumbled once I think all season. We were told at the end of last season that if you didn't have your carrying and str up you would fumble. I've seen WRs fumble a little more, but mainly WRs that neglect to put up their Str and carrying. My WR hasn't fumbled this season and he has avg to high str and carrying.
 
Schaffer05
offline
Link
 
^^Ok the elusive back on my team has 4 fumbles, but the power backs and my WR have 0. It's all about player build. decide to get a quick agile but weak HB you risk the chance of him fumbling against strong sure tackling defenders.
 
Barnsie
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Schaffer05
^^Ok the elusive back on my team has 4 fumbles, but the power backs and my WR have 0. It's all about player build. decide to get a quick agile but weak HB you risk the chance of him fumbling against strong sure tackling defenders.


Why do you assume elusive HBs have no carrying ability? That's not true at all, and if you read the thread, most of the people have carrying above 40, even in level 19-22 range.
Last edited Oct 14, 2008 17:38:28
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
1) There is a lot more involved in the fumbling equation than just carrying.
2) Powerbacks running wild last year caused an increase in strength and tackling on the defensive side.
3) Fumbles are not a bug. Unless they happen to my team
 
Schaffer05
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Barnsie
Originally posted by Schaffer05

^^Ok the elusive back on my team has 4 fumbles, but the power backs and my WR have 0. It's all about player build. decide to get a quick agile but weak HB you risk the chance of him fumbling against strong sure tackling defenders.


Why do you assume elusive HBs have no carrying ability? That's not true at all, and if you read the thread, most of the people have carrying above 40, even in level 19-22 range.


I don't assume a HB has no carrying ability, But what I do know is that STR+Carrying=less chance of fumbling. So with an elusive back, they neglect str, as well as carrying to an extent. They may have 48 carrying, but 30 str while a power back may have 70 Str and 40 carrying, he's still going to fumble less.

Ex1--Strength: 70.13+Carrying: 36.59+3Coverup=0 Fumbles on the season
Ex2--Strength: 40.27+Carrying: 32.87 +2Coverup=4 Fumbles on the season
Ex3--Strength: 85.77 + Carrying: 33.3 +2Coverup=0 Fumbles on the season

Those are all against the same competition

Now Just to prove my point even more so I'll go to WRs who generally don't do shit with carrying or Str.
Ex1--Strength: 28.17 + Carrying: 33.94 =0 Fumbles this season
Ex2--Strength: 23 +Carrying: 30.13 = 0 Fumbles
Ex3--Strength: 13 +Carrying: 23.02 = 1 fumble


Again all against the same competition. Bottom line is Elusive backs neglect key components to ball control because it doesn't "fit" in their building plans.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.