User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Playoff Profit sharing...
Page:
 
MrMoose
offline
Link
 
Home team gets 50% + Concessions
Away team gets 30%
Non playoff teams get 20%

So, lets say the top 4 teams made 5 mil in ticket sales in the playoffs.

Home team would get 2.5 mil
Away team would get 1.5 mil
League would get 1 mil x4 split between the non playoff teams, so 500k for each non playoff team.

I would benefit greatly from no revenue sharing, especially with the way my team's season is going. However, I do support it to a degree. Just so long as the home team still gets the largest benefit.
 
Sao
offline
Link
 
Crushr, You are telling me that 25% of your capacity on a 19000 seat stadium (yours) at game 17 fan support pricing is less than 100K? Seriously?

So rounding down even, 4,500 seats x $100.00 ++ sideline = what again?
 
valakar
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by canes30
I think it should be home team gets 70% away gets 30%.

This is more balanced, but still makes you want to be a top 4 team.


I did not read through the entire thread but I have been a supporter of revenue sharing for quite some time now. My team looks to be a home playoff team this year and thus would benefit more from the old system. However, the old system (current system actually) is flawed and broken. The proposal of 70/30 split with all concession money going to home team still gives a financial advantage for finishing higher seed thus making regular season still worthwhile.

It is no secret that profit sharing promotes parity which promotes more interest and more competition through better balance. The gutted or cpu teams will not make it to top 8 and if they do that is the reason Bort wants a one-time full reallignment (or not saying he wants it but why it is an option on the poll).

You take the realignment combined with profit sharing and overall the product is improving.

So if you make 600k in concession and an additional 2.4mil in ticket sales instead you would make 600k in concessions and 1.68mil in ticket sales

With this 3mil a game scenario you have the following:

3mil a game (current system)
2.28mil a game (with a 70/30 split of ticket sales with concessions going to home team)

That is only a decrease of 720k. This number will be more or less depending on ticket sales total but overall reduction is not huge but this money will help the away teams be more competitive in future seasons in free agency with their own stadium etc. The more they can stay competitive this will result in less sold/gutted teams and less 100-0 or 255-0 games and more competitive games. All of this should increase the interest in following a league or set of games thus should increase activity in the forums for those league because more teams feel they have a chance in future seasons. To me seems like a win/win so anyone against this either A) were on the wrong side of the way financials were/are handled and now stand to be the one to benefit so now would rather it stay the same or they have always been the beneficiary and have no interest in equality or the 'big picture' issues of GLB but are only concerned with padding their own stats both on the field and financially.

Bottom line the longer it takes to come up with a plan like this the larger the divide between the haves and the have nots. The larger this gap the more people that lose interest and the more people that lose interest the higher probability some of these people just go away all together.
 
Crushr
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by McGruffHawk
Originally posted by Tito716

Originally posted by McGruffHawk


Originally posted by Sao



It shouldn't be this hard.

Allow the visitor to perform 1 day playoff sales on THEIR stadium but at 25% of capacity. Make the visiting owner strategize on the ticket price which gets them involved be it a good choice of price or bad...it's on them.

Leave the Home Team's revenue stream alone. Don't allow visitors to piggy back on a larger (or even smaller) stadium than their opponent. Keeping the share independent of the home team can prevent any visitors complaining "their stadium is smaller than ours. The 7th seed got more than me because they played a team with a larger stadium" argument.

You want more money for playoffs? Get into the top 4 and construct stadiums smartly. If you do those things, you will reap the benefits.


FOr the sake of realism, why is the away team selling tickets to their stadium for a game that won't be played there?


Ok. What about my plan of giving each of the away playoff teams their average $ amount of consessions to simulate merchandise sales? No tickets...


In fact, In think this should be posted in the suggestions forum as a viable alternative to revenue sharing.


-1

Doesn't do much at all. What are you expecting the revenue to be? Unless its 500k, its just not going to even the $ out enough at all.
 
valakar
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by MrMoose
Home team gets 50% + Concessions
Away team gets 30%
Non playoff teams get 20%

So, lets say the top 4 teams made 5 mil in ticket sales in the playoffs.

Home team would get 2.5 mil
Away team would get 1.5 mil
League would get 1 mil x4 split between the non playoff teams, so 500k for each non playoff team.

I would benefit greatly from no revenue sharing, especially with the way my team's season is going. However, I do support it to a degree. Just so long as the home team still gets the largest benefit.


I am not in support of non-playoff teams getting part of this. I am in support of profit sharing during the playoff game because some of the revenue is generated by visiting teams fans. If you are going to include the 8 non-playoff teams must have a much more elaborate suggestion because with this proposal the 8 teams that do not make it get money from each playoff game and thus that is a ridiculous amount of money for finishing 16th.
 
McGruffHawk
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Crushr
Originally posted by McGruffHawk

Originally posted by Tito716


Originally posted by McGruffHawk



Originally posted by Sao




It shouldn't be this hard.

Allow the visitor to perform 1 day playoff sales on THEIR stadium but at 25% of capacity. Make the visiting owner strategize on the ticket price which gets them involved be it a good choice of price or bad...it's on them.

Leave the Home Team's revenue stream alone. Don't allow visitors to piggy back on a larger (or even smaller) stadium than their opponent. Keeping the share independent of the home team can prevent any visitors complaining "their stadium is smaller than ours. The 7th seed got more than me because they played a team with a larger stadium" argument.

You want more money for playoffs? Get into the top 4 and construct stadiums smartly. If you do those things, you will reap the benefits.


FOr the sake of realism, why is the away team selling tickets to their stadium for a game that won't be played there?


Ok. What about my plan of giving each of the away playoff teams their average $ amount of consessions to simulate merchandise sales? No tickets...


In fact, In think this should be posted in the suggestions forum as a viable alternative to revenue sharing.


-1

Doesn't do much at all. What are you expecting the revenue to be? Unless its 500k, its just not going to even the $ out enough at all.


It's been a while since I've been in lower leagues, and given our success, this probably isn't indicative of all teams, but this season we're making between $1.7 and $1.8 million per game in concessions.

I can remember in our second and third seasons being around $800,000. Is that far off for most playoff teams, even in lower leagues?
 
valakar
offline
Link
 
Most lower leagues get about 500k until after you can finish lower bowl and get a level 200 sideline then would increase to 800 to 900k and up from there.
 
Sao
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Crushr
Originally posted by McGruffHawk

Originally posted by Tito716


Originally posted by McGruffHawk



Originally posted by Sao




It shouldn't be this hard.

Allow the visitor to perform 1 day playoff sales on THEIR stadium but at 25% of capacity. Make the visiting owner strategize on the ticket price which gets them involved be it a good choice of price or bad...it's on them.

Leave the Home Team's revenue stream alone. Don't allow visitors to piggy back on a larger (or even smaller) stadium than their opponent. Keeping the share independent of the home team can prevent any visitors complaining "their stadium is smaller than ours. The 7th seed got more than me because they played a team with a larger stadium" argument.

You want more money for playoffs? Get into the top 4 and construct stadiums smartly. If you do those things, you will reap the benefits.


FOr the sake of realism, why is the away team selling tickets to their stadium for a game that won't be played there?


Ok. What about my plan of giving each of the away playoff teams their average $ amount of consessions to simulate merchandise sales? No tickets...


In fact, In think this should be posted in the suggestions forum as a viable alternative to revenue sharing.


-1

Doesn't do much at all. What are you expecting the revenue to be? Unless its 500k, its just not going to even the $ out enough at all.



You still haven't done the math. But that's OK. Don't let suggstion minutiae deter your whining.

 
McGruffHawk
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by valakar
Originally posted by MrMoose

Home team gets 50% + Concessions
Away team gets 30%
Non playoff teams get 20%

So, lets say the top 4 teams made 5 mil in ticket sales in the playoffs.

Home team would get 2.5 mil
Away team would get 1.5 mil
League would get 1 mil x4 split between the non playoff teams, so 500k for each non playoff team.

I would benefit greatly from no revenue sharing, especially with the way my team's season is going. However, I do support it to a degree. Just so long as the home team still gets the largest benefit.


I am not in support of non-playoff teams getting part of this. I am in support of profit sharing during the playoff game because some of the revenue is generated by visiting teams fans. If you are going to include the 8 non-playoff teams must have a much more elaborate suggestion because with this proposal the 8 teams that do not make it get money from each playoff game and thus that is a ridiculous amount of money for finishing 16th.


I'm willing to risk a gutted team getting a couple of million, if it also means a the legitimate rebuilds also get a chance to be more competitive.

Its amazing to me how much this conversation mirrors real life leagues. The retention of individual team income versus the betterment of the league parity.
 
Crushr
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sao
Crushr, You are telling me that 25% of your capacity on a 19000 seat stadium (yours) at game 17 fan support pricing is less than 100K? Seriously?

So rounding down even, 4,500 seats x $100.00 ++ sideline = what again?


First off, I never said it was less. In fact, I stated just the opposite. Re read the post.. LMFAO!
 
Nats Kule
offline
Link
 
I never understood why the away team got nothing. (100k is less than a days salary). Without the away team there is no game, so the visitors play the game for free? Of course the away team should get something, without them there is no game and the home team makes nothing.
 
valakar
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by McGruffHawk
Originally posted by valakar

Originally posted by MrMoose


Home team gets 50% + Concessions
Away team gets 30%
Non playoff teams get 20%

So, lets say the top 4 teams made 5 mil in ticket sales in the playoffs.

Home team would get 2.5 mil
Away team would get 1.5 mil
League would get 1 mil x4 split between the non playoff teams, so 500k for each non playoff team.

I would benefit greatly from no revenue sharing, especially with the way my team's season is going. However, I do support it to a degree. Just so long as the home team still gets the largest benefit.


I am not in support of non-playoff teams getting part of this. I am in support of profit sharing during the playoff game because some of the revenue is generated by visiting teams fans. If you are going to include the 8 non-playoff teams must have a much more elaborate suggestion because with this proposal the 8 teams that do not make it get money from each playoff game and thus that is a ridiculous amount of money for finishing 16th.


I'm willing to risk a gutted team getting a couple of million, if it also means a the legitimate rebuilds also get a chance to be more competitive.

Its amazing to me how much this conversation mirrors real life leagues. The retention of individual team income versus the betterment of the league parity.


Betterment of league parity is exactly what I am for. If you want the teams that did not make playoffs to get 100k per playoff week (so 400k total) as their share of the playoff profits so be it I am okay with that. But saying they get 20% of each game. Lets put math on that for a second. In each 16 team division their are 7 games not including championship game. So 20% divided by 8 teams is roughly 2.5% a game times the 7 games is roughly 17.5% of the entire total. So again lets assume (which we no it varies) but each game is 3mil in profits so 21mil they get 17.5% or about 3.675mil. Lets assume this does not include concessions and those go completely to the home teams that is still way too much for being an inferior product.

EDIT: Actually you would have to take into consideration teams that lost in first round of playoffs. So the first round losers (4 teams) would be added to the not in playoff pool. So round two would be dived by 12 teams and round 3 by 14 teams. My numbers are based on 8 teams in and 8 teams out. Still too much money imo. A simple 100k per team per playoff week minimum. Everybody gets that the winners get the 'bonus' 100k, 200k, 300k, etc. The home concessions go to home team (100%) and the ticket sales are either a 70/30 split between home/away or a 65/30/5 split between home/visitor/rest of league
Last edited Sep 30, 2008 13:04:57
 
Crushr
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sao
Originally posted by Crushr

Originally posted by McGruffHawk


Originally posted by Tito716



Originally posted by McGruffHawk




Originally posted by Sao





It shouldn't be this hard.

Allow the visitor to perform 1 day playoff sales on THEIR stadium but at 25% of capacity. Make the visiting owner strategize on the ticket price which gets them involved be it a good choice of price or bad...it's on them.

Leave the Home Team's revenue stream alone. Don't allow visitors to piggy back on a larger (or even smaller) stadium than their opponent. Keeping the share independent of the home team can prevent any visitors complaining "their stadium is smaller than ours. The 7th seed got more than me because they played a team with a larger stadium" argument.

You want more money for playoffs? Get into the top 4 and construct stadiums smartly. If you do those things, you will reap the benefits.


FOr the sake of realism, why is the away team selling tickets to their stadium for a game that won't be played there?


Ok. What about my plan of giving each of the away playoff teams their average $ amount of consessions to simulate merchandise sales? No tickets...


In fact, In think this should be posted in the suggestions forum as a viable alternative to revenue sharing.


-1

Doesn't do much at all. What are you expecting the revenue to be? Unless its 500k, its just not going to even the $ out enough at all.



You still haven't done the math. But that's OK. Don't let suggstion minutiae deter your whining.



Well, I DID do the math but I am not assuming that I can sell $100 tickets( forgive me since my team has not been in the playoffs yet) So my assumption was that the avg would be about $40 per ticket avg much like my regular season. Do the math with that number and its certainly not much! Additionally, I am NOT whining. I am simply stating that I believe there should be some sort of rev sharing and it needs to be fair..Is it whining simply because it differs from your opinion?
 
JeffSteele
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Crushr
Well, I DID do the math but I am not assuming that I can sell $100 tickets( forgive me since my team has not been in the playoffs yet) So my assumption was that the avg would be about $40 per ticket avg much like my regular season. Do the math with that number and its certainly not much!
ah well Sao's an Alice Springs GM and i'm a Newcastle GM and we'll both tell you that at minimum you'll get 2x expected price for the first playoff home game.
 
Crushr
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SyedAshrafulla
Originally posted by Crushr

Well, I DID do the math but I am not assuming that I can sell $100 tickets( forgive me since my team has not been in the playoffs yet) So my assumption was that the avg would be about $40 per ticket avg much like my regular season. Do the math with that number and its certainly not much!
ah well Sao's an Alice Springs GM and i'm a Newcastle GM and we'll both tell you that at minimum you'll get 2x expected price for the first playoff home game.



Well that helps.. It makes that plan a little more appealing than if I had to keep reg season prices..
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.