User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > An Admin-Selected Suggestion Screener
Page:
 
Knick
Sknickers
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dmfa41
I am very tired of seeing excellent suggestions deflated by garbage Flex Point threads and threads regarding problems with the moderators.

Also, since I can't "bump," "+1," or "QFT" threads anymore, I have to take my time during lecture to reiterate the OP and why I like it just to keep the valid threads (or ones I see as such) at the top of the forum where they're visible.


just do it anyway. Not like mods are in here unless you start a thread about how you hate them.

Voltron and some people argued for about an hour yesterday before another mod saw it and locked it because it wasnt suggestion (bigt is the shit)

Forbin said something about how mods sucked at their job, Voltron quoted him and said "yeah mods suck" and there was a suggestion RIGHT UNDER IT to "look at my build and sign me". it remained
Last edited Oct 7, 2008 11:20:06
 
Jed
offline
Link
 
I don't know if Bort's going to do it, but there was some talk on the Mod forum for there to be an Announcements-style forum as a Suggestions sub-forum for the really good ones any Mod or Admin finds. No threads could be started there, only posted to, and it would give an easier place for Bort to see the ones which Mods/other Admins have already found and thought were good.
 
Knick
Sknickers
offline
Link
 
haha yeah, Bones said something about it the other day.

Patiently waiting for it
 
Jed
offline
Link
 
me, too
 
Knick
Sknickers
offline
Link
 
What would be the penalty for derailing a thread in there though?

With that some people would really get a chuckle about turning a great suggestion into a flame war. And I know the mods can't be in all places at once... So there needs to be pretty strict guidelines for that imo.
 
dmfa41
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jed
I don't know if Bort's going to do it, but there was some talk on the Mod forum for there to be an Announcements-style forum as a Suggestions sub-forum for the really good ones any Mod or Admin finds. No threads could be started there, only posted to, and it would give an easier place for Bort to see the ones which Mods/other Admins have already found and thought were good.


This is exactly the kind of solution for which this thread was conceived. Thanks.

Originally posted by Knick
With that some people would really get a chuckle about turning a great suggestion into a flame war. And I know the mods can't be in all places at once... So there needs to be pretty strict guidelines for that imo.


Post limit, say 1/day? Flame wars usually take place over the span of a few minutes and many [F5]s, I'd imagine. Would you really want to protract being an internet antagonist over a week or so? I hope the people who cause problems like that aren't that devoted to something that pointless.
 
Knick
Sknickers
offline
Link
 
That would kill discussions.

There just needs to ALWAYS be a Mod on duty.
 
Knick
Sknickers
offline
Link
 
Maybe posted in a thread in Suggestion forum for X days to post in sub-forum (X=21).

My guess would be people who would flame probably hang out in FFA or other places than suggestions. So limiting posters to people here a lot would result in a limited flaming, along with less newbie posts , thread whoring (hey this idea is way better + link), etc.

Also it doesn't allow someone to just go to every thread and +1 to get in, because it would take TIME to get there, and experience is usually based off time.

I'm not a fan of limiting ideas in this forum, but this is going to be really hard to keep clean.

Also maybe like a 3 strikes no more posting in there rule?
 
dmfa41
offline
Link
 
New viewers:

Sub-forums are included in this thread too; refer to the previous several posts by Knick and Jed. Thumb through it. We've got so many different threads saying the same (or very similar) things.
 
ProfessionalKop
Gangstalicious
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dmfa41
New viewers:

Sub-forums are included in this thread too; refer to the previous several posts by Knick and Jed. Thumb through it. We've got so many different threads saying the same (or very similar) things.


im to lazy to look through this whole thread. cant join in when there are already 13 pages.
 
dmfa41
offline
Link
 
I know, I just wanted to make it known that the idea of sub-forums does exist and is not a new discovery. It should be added in the OP. People really do need to update their OPs when major ideas are reached within.
 
dmfa41
offline
Link
 
Latest reiteration of OP (10/7 13:46 CDT)

This thread suggests the creation of an Admin-appointed "custodian of suggestions" whose ultimate function is to pare down the hundreds of suggestions to the few pertinent ones to be relayed to the Admins.

This could be accomplished by:
- A moderator who locks/removes poor suggestion threads to ease Admins' browsing
- A liaison who screens the threads and directly submits them to the Admins
- Revising moderators' responsibilities to specific forums
- An extended sub-forum structure
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Moderator/Admin opinions:
Originally posted by Jed
I don't know if Bort's going to do it, but there was some talk on the Mod forum for there to be an Announcements-style forum as a Suggestions sub-forum for the really good ones any Mod or Admin finds. No threads could be started there, only posted to, and it would give an easier place for Bort to see the ones which Mods/other Admins have already found and thought were good.

 
Knick
Sknickers
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dmfa41
I know, I just wanted to make it known that the idea of sub-forums does exist and is not a new discovery. It should be added in the OP. People really do need to update their OPs when major ideas are reached within.


haha for being fairly new in here you've got a good handle on how this forum works best
 
dmfa41
offline
Link
 
Every time I press F5 I want to bump this to the top. I'd reiterate the OP, but it's just two posts up.

There are three or four suggestions on how to minimize the frivolity of this forum circulating now. I think I'll just start bumping all three.
 
Knick
Sknickers
offline
Link
 
I just mentioned this, so did DMFA
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.