User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
Mike Rogers
Lead Tester
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by RAPB

It would be crap if any offense (even those NOT specialized on the run) can run it down for 3.5 yards/run constantly.


I agree - that's what I was worried about with my earlier post. I don't want to see every single back running for 5+ ypc every single game, regardless of the defense. If the other side sets to stop the run, I'd like to see the run get stopped, and the pass game be available, etc. Balancing act!



Agreed, balance must be maintained.

But its not designed to be a balanced play, it should be horrible against a strong D-Line that stand their ground, and make their tackles.

But the Off Tackle play is designed specifically to attack a pass rush LDE (or undersized Speed Def unit).


If you build a LDE to be a pure pass rusher, you should get a natural advantage against a RT build, but be susceptable to the Power Running game.

Still focussing on the Off Tackle play, its attacking a very specific part of the defense, and by taking the LDE out of the play, its whole point is to make a LB make the tackle, so where he is dictates the gain.

If the LB backs off, it should gain 5+ yards, if he plays normal then it should be 4 yards, and if he crowds the line, its 2 yards.

If he does blitz the 4 gap then its a TfL.

If he stands the FB up then its a no gainer inside.

The theme from the games I have watched (parts of 6 games now) is the first Tackle.
If the tackle is made then its a short gain or no gain, if its missed though, it leads to a fairly large gain.

I dont know if anything can fix that except having a better tackling defense???
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mike Rogers
I dont know if anything can fix that except having a better tackling defense???


Not sure that it needs to be fixed, then, except by the players who are missing the tackles. If making tackles = small gain or loss, and not making tackles = big gain, then it's working as intended.
 
Mike Rogers
Lead Tester
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Not a terrible idea, though boost to what? Break blocks? If I'm doing that, I might as well just update the run blocking code in general, since it's only called on run plays.


What about Block Avoiding???

As a CB if your downfield and the WR wants to put his hands on you, your pretty damn sure its a run block (or offensive interference )

So maybe if the Defense is 'Expecting the run' the WR is x% less likely to engage the block?

Just enough that the WR needs to have spent something in Blocking to help break a big Run?

Would that work.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
So, basically just a penalty for WR's to engage/hold their block on outside run plays?
 
TtD
offline
Link
 
Will keep an eye out for this over the next few games then Bort as my team is primarily an offtackle team, it's our bread and butter play and there have been few teams able to handle it and we've upgraded again to make it more effective so will be interested how the changes work out.

Will be happy if plays like this the HB hits the gap again
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=188197&pbp_id=726298
Last edited Sep 21, 2008 08:01:45
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TtD
Will keep an eye out for this over the next few games then Bort as my team is primarily an offtackle team, it's our bread and butter play and there have been few teams able to handle it and we've upgraded again to make it more effective so will be interested how the changes work out.


Interested to hear your results then, for sure!
 
TtD
offline
Link
 
You'll have to wait probably until end of week for true results as we've got a cupcake game or two up first, but have some closer games set up for weeks end.
 
Mike Rogers
Lead Tester
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
So, basically just a penalty for WR's to engage/hold their block on outside run plays?


That sounds a bit harsh, but really thats how it would be in real life.

The WR could do everything perfectly, but just because the CB is thinking 'Run' he never gets to engage the block.
Last edited Sep 21, 2008 08:08:58
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Hmm, I will think about it and do some tests, especially if we see pitch plays being too good.
 
TtD
offline
Link
 
Might be an idea to post up a before and after note for the changes Bort in the announcements btw, may avoid some complaints later. Just trying to find a before and after of a similar play for ya.

Closest I can find so far, same off tackle play.

Before
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=188197&pbp_id=730064

After
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=163768&pbp_id=1003784
 
TtD
offline
Link
 
And yeah, sorting the WR blocking is going to be tricky, as the mismatches at the position can be so excessive, at least around the line most players either side of the ball have solid strength and match up well, at the WR/CB the difference can be very large, might be an idea simply to give the CB a % bonus to shed block on run plays, if they have run focus, % bonus to avoid fake, or some other coverage related skill when on pass focus, and similar +/- bonus for WR with their focus (say + % to hold block for run focus, + % to fake for pass focus).

Balance though due to the build mismatches would be really really tricky and I don't envy you the challenge.
 
Mike Rogers
Lead Tester
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Hmm, I will think about it and do some tests, especially if we see pitch plays being too good.


Originally posted by TtD
And yeah, sorting the WR blocking is going to be tricky, as the mismatches at the position can be so excessive, at least around the line most players either side of the ball have solid strength and match up well, at the WR/CB the difference can be very large, might be an idea simply to give the CB a % bonus to shed block on run plays, if they have run focus, % bonus to avoid fake, or some other coverage related skill when on pass focus, and similar +/- bonus for WR with their focus (say + % to hold block for run focus, + % to fake for pass focus).

Balance though due to the build mismatches would be really really tricky and I don't envy you the challenge.


Yeah either/or. Both going to be pretty tough to get right though.

Some pretty good teams/leagues simming soon so better evaluation shortly I think.

Last edited Sep 21, 2008 08:26:29
 
jordan274
offline
Link
 
What would cause the HB to hit this hole?

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=153711&pbp_id=1067924
 
TtD
offline
Link
 
Best guess would be he see's the SS/LOLB coming on the strong side, the first choice for the play (following the FB), and instead goes for the one on one matchup with the MLB, which is the sensible play i'd say, he beats the LB he makes a big gain, had he followed the FB he's reliant on the FB picking up at least one of the blitzers.

Basically, if he beats the LB, cuts outside, the WR only has to block the CB a second and it's a TD, for that reason I kinda like the play, why run into an obvious short gain situation when you have the chance of getting clear.
Last edited Sep 21, 2008 09:01:43
 
datongw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jordan274
What would cause the HB to hit this hole?

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=153711&pbp_id=1067924


My guess is that the HB sees the NT to the right. This is not a bad cut, if he cuts to the right, he might have to deal with NT (who is been blocked to the right) and the LOLB, with the SS right behind the LOLB.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.