User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > "Missing" Intense Training Combos
Page:
 
Libbie
offline
Link
 
Now that you say it..... it's probably true....

What was intended to make the game more interesting and have people log in everyday might backfire.


But then, at least people have to log in every a few days.
 
RAPB
offline
Link
 
Just in case noone else figured out...

Here are your (only) choices depending on the main attribute you like to train:

strength: + blocking/jumping /throwing
blocking: +strength/agility
speed: +agility/tackling
tackling: +speed
agility: +blocking/stamina/speed
jumping: +strength/vision
throwing: +strength/vision
catching: +carrying
stamina: +agility
carrying: +confidence/catching
vision +confidence/jumping /throwing, punting, kicking
kicking: +vision
punting: +vision
confidence: +vision/carrying

So most guys will have no choice at all (tackling, catching, stamina, speed of offensive players). Others have to decide between bad (little to no effect) and worse (little gains).
Last edited Sep 17, 2008 07:40:23
 
Ethaan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TreMetal

??: +stamina +confidence


Late-Night Loving?
 
confab
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by RAPB
Talk about cookie cutter builds in the future: It's obvious that you'll need to build players around the new training options.

So basically, the new intense training combinations result in:

- players having LESS TO DO - for they need to save up training points first
- players having LESS TO DECIDE - for options are very limited and "force" the player to train one or two combinations given
- players SEEING LESS RESULTS of their training: you just have to wait till the whole point is trained, otherwise you'll see nothing

This was my initial impression too, but I guess we'll have to wait until the season gets underway to see how things play out. Some more training options would be welcome, but for what it's worth I'd really prefer to see two drop down menus or some variation on SCACE's excellent suggestion.
 
Doug_Plank
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by RAPB
Just in case noone else figured out...

Here are your (only) choices depending on the main attribute you like to train:

strength: + blocking/jumping /throwing
blocking: +strength/agility
speed: +agility/tackling
tackling: +speed
agility: +blocking/stamina/speed
jumping: +strength/vision
throwing: +strength/vision
catching: +carrying
stamina: +agility
carrying: +confidence/catching
vision +confidence/jumping /throwing, punting, kicking
kicking: +vision
punting: +vision
confidence: +vision/carrying

So most guys will have no choice at all (tackling, catching, stamina, speed of offensive players). Others have to decide between bad (little to no effect) and worse (little gains).


 
semisober
offline
Link
 
A broader inclusion of key secondaries (vision, confidence) that are useful to everyone will give people a fine option. Not everyone can get their two key attributes together, but things like vision / speed would be useful to a lot of different people.
 
Sunsfan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SunsFan
for me DE< i would like to do strength and agility, that will help for the DEs


as I said earlier, the agility and strength combo would be a nice addition as well
 
GG
offline
Link
 
I support the idea instead to have a drop down for Training #1, which lists all the 14 attributes. And another drop down for Training #2, which lists all the 14 attributes.

Allowing freedom to choose what they want (there's no reason to prevent that) and no "funky" names like Sled Drill etc which isnt necessary.

Functionality should come before aesthetics.

If there are combinations that Bort doesnt want people to do, well, they can still do that thru two training days.

Eg: If Speed and Agility is a "forbidden" combination. One can easily train Speed and Strength on day one, and then Agility and Vision on day two. Hence, Speed and Agility got trained. People will say, but you therefore had to do Vision and Strength. And one would say, so what? Maybe one would want to do speed-agility and every now and then do vision-strength too. It didnt prevent anything.

There's no reason to prevent people the freedom to train any two attributes. And it would make it far easier to just have two drop down menus listing only 14 attributes, rather than having drop downs that list 8,254 possible combinations and trying to come up with "funky" names for the drills.

Last edited Sep 18, 2008 00:38:51
 
Link
 
Originally posted by datongw
How about just half the time on one drill and half the time on another to get any combination of 2 abilities? Do we really need to sit here and come up with 196 exercises that will cover all possible combinations? I'm sure if we tried hard enough we could, but is it really necessary?

Can't we just replace the current "selection regimen" combo box with two combo boxes (1 for 1st attribute trained and 1 for 2nd attribute trained)?


-100
 
GG
offline
Link
 
I might add...what happened to the idea of allowing people a sense of freedom to build players how they want? Why is everything have to be about forcing people to a cookie cutter build, cookie cutter training regimens, cookie cutter choices?

Why cant someone choose to train speed and speed if they want? Let them. Let people develop players how they choose.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GG
I might add...what happened to the idea of allowing people a sense of freedom to build players how they want? Why is everything have to be about forcing people to a cookie cutter build, cookie cutter training regimens, cookie cutter choices?

Why cant someone choose to train speed and speed if they want? Let them. Let people develop players how they choose.


Because otherwise there is NO drawback to intense training at all, and normal becomes completely worthless, since the total points gained is the same. If you want the two dropdowns, intense would have to cost three times as much, or give a smaller bonus or something.

Limited choices for intense means that, beyond adding some realism to training, if you want bonus tokens you have to make a choice between training exactly what you want, or getting the bonus tokens, but you can't have both.
 
El_Windex
Baby Executive
offline
Link
 
I totally called it. I knew it was a tradeoff.
 
thunderdoozer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by GG

I might add...what happened to the idea of allowing people a sense of freedom to build players how they want? Why is everything have to be about forcing people to a cookie cutter build, cookie cutter training regimens, cookie cutter choices?

Why cant someone choose to train speed and speed if they want? Let them. Let people develop players how they choose.


Because otherwise there is NO drawback to intense training at all, and normal becomes completely worthless, since the total points gained is the same. If you want the two dropdowns, intense would have to cost three times as much, or give a smaller bonus or something.

Limited choices for intense means that, beyond adding some realism to training, if you want bonus tokens you have to make a choice between training exactly what you want, or getting the bonus tokens, but you can't have both.


Still, there needs to be at least two dozen options.

The fact that there is only one option for tackling, stamina, and catching is outrageous.
Last edited Sep 18, 2008 01:28:41
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by thunderdoozer
Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by GG


I might add...what happened to the idea of allowing people a sense of freedom to build players how they want? Why is everything have to be about forcing people to a cookie cutter build, cookie cutter training regimens, cookie cutter choices?

Why cant someone choose to train speed and speed if they want? Let them. Let people develop players how they choose.


Because otherwise there is NO drawback to intense training at all, and normal becomes completely worthless, since the total points gained is the same. If you want the two dropdowns, intense would have to cost three times as much, or give a smaller bonus or something.

Limited choices for intense means that, beyond adding some realism to training, if you want bonus tokens you have to make a choice between training exactly what you want, or getting the bonus tokens, but you can't have both.


Still, there needs to be at least two dozen options.

The fact that there is only one option for tackling, stamina, and catching is outrageous.


Check out the new list. Some new stuff in there.
 
bigpimpin123
offline
Link
 
hmmm looks good...nightly processing is exactly what I wanted to see haha
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.