User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Test Server Discussion
Page:
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by PierreThomas
Why is it such a big deal to open the testing to the public, even if it is just the results. We all know just how much separates some of the better teams in the better leagues. If one guy has just a bit of an advantage it really isn't fair which completely negates the entire purpose of the game.
Open the test data, open the player builds and nobody has a problem, actually it would likely garner quite the opposite response. People would probably be raving about you finally getting some testing done and not releasing an untested product and making changes mid season. I love the fact you are testing stuff, just not that my competition is getting an unfair advantage. No matter what you do it will be in the back of people's heads if this stuff isn't open for all to see.


I think that might cause more problems...it would turn into the public scouring over the test data to try and find exploits instead of us just trying to squash them.

So...It seems likely that the only way people are going to not be upset is if all testers are employees, and do not play the game competitively, or everyone and their brother gets in. Everyone getting in is obviously not going to happen, just because of the sheer headache it would cause, and the test server could never handle that much traffic anyway. I cannot afford 50 QA guys to test everything, so everybody cannot be an employee.

Even if all testers are publicly known, people will still be upset because somebody will feel left out, or somebody will not be liked by somebody else, etc.

So...is the only real solution: no test server except for me, and we go back to the way it was with things being missed because I cannot possibly watch 9000000 sims per day?


other solutions include deathblade's idea of just posting the results of tests...

or my idea/question of having the testers not see the specific builds they're testing...

or my idea of dismissing this current group of testers and then bringing testers back on only if they're willing to be public...
 
tshizzle
offline
Link
 
bort man, you REALLY need to stop thinking like a n00b developer and start thinking like a businessman

quit with this shady, terribly handled way you have run things the last couple years and HIRE A GODDAMN STAFF


1) INFORMATION - people are PAYING money to play this game, a bullshit announcement 4 or 5 hours before something happens is just stupid. I mean come on man, to be smart enough to create and program this game, you have to have some common sense and realize the lack of transparency and knowledge to your customers is SEVERELY lacking


2) Get a real support/customer service team in here. Making some 15yr old kid a mod is not support or customer service. You need to model this after real developers - Blizzard, Valve, EA, etc. Spend some money - get a PR team, get some mature, adult moderators, and give them the knowledge and ability to actually do something with someones problem. Its been almost 24 hours since the whole new teams debacle, and still not even a single announcement, mass PM, forum sticky, NOTHING - addressing the 100s of complaints you have. Same thing happens everytime you just post some change here in a forum that probably 10-15% of the users in the game ever even look at. Bro, come on, the same 50 or so players that post in nearly every damn thread dont count - stop catering to this tiny group.


3) Fix the damn balance here. The league brackets are a great start. Now assign/hire a few people to each respective region. After you promote/delegate/create all the teams and new teams in the offseason, have these people go through each and every league and look for obviously unbalanced teams (too high, too low). Then do a few manual readjustments to get everyone in teh same level range.


I mean we're talking basic business/customer support 101. This leads to ALOT more money in your pocket as more and more people join, and eventually investors come to the party and want to make you a rich man.


its just so damn frustrating seeing something with SO MUCH potential getting bashed and being hammered by constant newbie moves by its creator and staff. I hate seeing smart people do dumb things and make dumb mistakes, I really do man...
 
Bukowski
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tpaterniti

Ideally the goal is for there to be lots of different paths to success and SAs should actually do what they say they do - if it says it makes yu force more fumbles it should. After that it should be your choice if you want to go that route when building your players. Above all else we are trying to make sure things work the way they should, not just trying to find the "best" build possible. How can you trust us? I don't know. How can you trust any of the people you know? Most of us have been around GLB for a long time or written guides or things of that nature. I can't speak for others but I genuinely like helping people out and that is why I wrote a guide, am updating it, and keep all my players open. Also I get a lot of questions about player building and I answer people indiscriminately as honestly as I can.


Why would it take 7 seasons to figure out if the SAs work or not?

And why did it take from Season 3 to Season 7, to figure out that Head Fake and Juke weren't working properly?

I thought this is what was being tested on the test server?
 
Nuge20
offline
Link
 
ITT: TerrellOwns is wrong
 
The Duff Man
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tpaterniti


If it is super overpowered then probably it is about to get fixed. I tell people if you do this it will do that. I will say right now it is effective but attribute x will likely be more important in the near future so consider that in your decision.


You have just said you do the very thing that everyone is afraid that testers are doing! Unless this info is available on a public forum, you have just given someone an unfair advantage over everyone else.

 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gary_Hughes
Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by PierreThomas


Why is it such a big deal to open the testing to the public, even if it is just the results. We all know just how much separates some of the better teams in the better leagues. If one guy has just a bit of an advantage it really isn't fair which completely negates the entire purpose of the game.

Open the test data, open the player builds and nobody has a problem, actually it would likely garner quite the opposite response. People would probably be raving about you finally getting some testing done and not releasing an untested product and making changes mid season. I love the fact you are testing stuff, just not that my competition is getting an unfair advantage. No matter what you do it will be in the back of people's heads if this stuff isn't open for all to see.



I think that might cause more problems...it would turn into the public scouring over the test data to try and find exploits instead of us just trying to squash them.

So...It seems likely that the only way people are going to not be upset is if all testers are employees, and do not play the game competitively, or everyone and their brother gets in. Everyone getting in is obviously not going to happen, just because of the sheer headache it would cause, and the test server could never handle that much traffic anyway. I cannot afford 50 QA guys to test everything, so everybody cannot be an employee.

Even if all testers are publicly known, people will still be upset because somebody will feel left out, or somebody will not be liked by somebody else, etc.

So...is the only real solution: no test server except for me, and we go back to the way it was with things being missed because I cannot possibly watch 9000000 sims per day?


This should solve the problems I think.


And cause the games here to be buggy. I often said there needed to be a test server. So, simply have TPat report results (except for those that will never see this server), or something similar to that.
Last edited Feb 13, 2009 19:07:19
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tpaterniti
I think Pierre that you know more about player building than me.


imagine if he had access to the test server...
 
Link
 
Originally posted by PP
I got a ?...If as Bort says that these testers are burnt out and don't care about being competitive, only about the good of the game, is it safe to assume that none of them will boost? I mean, why the hell would they. They don't care about winning.

Anyway you look at it, every "answer" that is given, this absolutely stinks of BS


Agree with you 100% and if they are so "burnt out" then why not let us know who they are. This is definately giving them a definate advantage and whoever else plays on their teams as they can tell them "hey this is what works so lets start putting our points in these attributes" and gives them an unfair advantage.

 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by PierreThomas

Why is it such a big deal to open the testing to the public, even if it is just the results. We all know just how much separates some of the better teams in the better leagues. If one guy has just a bit of an advantage it really isn't fair which completely negates the entire purpose of the game.

Open the test data, open the player builds and nobody has a problem, actually it would likely garner quite the opposite response. People would probably be raving about you finally getting some testing done and not releasing an untested product and making changes mid season. I love the fact you are testing stuff, just not that my competition is getting an unfair advantage. No matter what you do it will be in the back of people's heads if this stuff isn't open for all to see.



I think that might cause more problems...it would turn into the public scouring over the test data to try and find exploits instead of us just trying to squash them.

So...It seems likely that the only way people are going to not be upset is if all testers are employees, and do not play the game competitively, or everyone and their brother gets in. Everyone getting in is obviously not going to happen, just because of the sheer headache it would cause, and the test server could never handle that much traffic anyway. I cannot afford 50 QA guys to test everything, so everybody cannot be an employee.

Even if all testers are publicly known, people will still be upset because somebody will feel left out, or somebody will not be liked by somebody else, etc.

So...is the only real solution: no test server except for me, and we go back to the way it was with things being missed because I cannot possibly watch 9000000 sims per day?



Like I just said, why not allow all GLBers to watch the test sims but only the select few you choose can conduct them? So it's fair if say 4-5 out of your say 20 testers decided they want to help themselves and start exploiting stuff they found while doing it is worse than having all of GLB on the same level playing field and trying to exploit the same things that are reported to them before you fix it? How is the first option better?
 
Binestar
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tpaterniti
I think Pierre that you know more about player building than me.


But with access to the test server you have the tools to learn more about player building than him, just by building certain builds and seeing what they do. You have access to a lot more information than Pierre.
 
ress5609
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Ken1

Originally posted by dpell


Originally posted by tpaterniti



As I said, yes I can make a HB with 10 in Juke. But why am I making it? You guys assume I am making him to see if it works so I can go make my own HB with 10 in Juke on GLB and dominate. In fact I am making him so I can see if 1.) a HB with 10 in juke is not really that good so bort can balance out HBs and make sure the points you spent on Juke were not wasted or 2.) make sure a HB with 10 in Juke is not super powered so bort can balance out HBs and make sure the 60 points you put into tackling + the 67 points you put into agility were not wasted. That is what we are really doing on the test server.


And when you find that 10 juke nets an elusive back a 30% gain in ypc over 5 games, but a 10 in headfake only gets him 12%, and Bort says "that's how I want it to work", you have an incredibly useful piece of information the rest of us don't have.

If you say "What the hell does Strong Base even do" and run 5 sims without it, then give the entire OL 10 in it, now you have an idea what it does.

I'm not saying your intentions are bad Tpat, I'm saying that nobody playing the game should have secret knowledge to this. My players have had to play teams your players are on. If you tell them based on my example above "Juke is way better than headfake" and I don't have that info, my team is at a disadvantage. I'm really not sure why Bort and Thorn are being so intentionally obtuse about this.


What if TPat made a point of reporting the info that he and other testers found, if it was not going to be changed for balance or exploit purposes, putting it in his guide, frequently updating it?

That would seem to allow the testing so we aren't doing the testing on this site, and still allow everyone to get more info?


Or some sort of tester blog?


That is a request that has been made several times earlier in the thread with regards to transparency. In a nutshell "if you don't want everyone being able to test, at least make the results visible to everyone"
 
Skeptikal
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by The Duff Man
Originally posted by tpaterniti



If it is super overpowered then probably it is about to get fixed. I tell people if you do this it will do that. I will say right now it is effective but attribute x will likely be more important in the near future so consider that in your decision.


You have just said you do the very thing that everyone is afraid that testers are doing! Unless this info is available on a public forum, you have just given someone an unfair advantage over everyone else.



 
chrisko
offline
Link
 
I just think testers should be banned from regular competitive leagues until they are removed from the test crew for 2 seasons. It keeps the advantage out of the regular leagues and allows enough time to pass so they will no longer have an advantage.

If a person is selected to the test team, they must retire all active players for 100% FP return, but agree that their FP spending abilities will be locked during testing and for two seasons following. Problem Solved.
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by The Duff Man
Originally posted by tpaterniti



If it is super overpowered then probably it is about to get fixed. I tell people if you do this it will do that. I will say right now it is effective but attribute x will likely be more important in the near future so consider that in your decision.


You have just said you do the very thing that everyone is afraid that testers are doing! Unless this info is available on a public forum, you have just given someone an unfair advantage over everyone else.



Time to panic?
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by atingwald
Originally posted by Bort
So...is the only real solution: no test server except for me, and we go back to the way it was with things being missed because I cannot possibly watch 9000000 sims per day?

you don't have a computer program that can run sims for you???


he would still have to watch the sims...
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.