Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by PierreThomas
Why is it such a big deal to open the testing to the public, even if it is just the results. We all know just how much separates some of the better teams in the better leagues. If one guy has just a bit of an advantage it really isn't fair which completely negates the entire purpose of the game.
Open the test data, open the player builds and nobody has a problem, actually it would likely garner quite the opposite response. People would probably be raving about you finally getting some testing done and not releasing an untested product and making changes mid season. I love the fact you are testing stuff, just not that my competition is getting an unfair advantage. No matter what you do it will be in the back of people's heads if this stuff isn't open for all to see.
I think that might cause more problems...it would turn into the public scouring over the test data to try and find exploits instead of us just trying to squash them.
So...It seems likely that the only way people are going to not be upset is if all testers are employees, and do not play the game competitively, or everyone and their brother gets in. Everyone getting in is obviously not going to happen, just because of the sheer headache it would cause, and the test server could never handle that much traffic anyway. I cannot afford 50 QA guys to test everything, so everybody cannot be an employee.
Even if all testers are publicly known, people will still be upset because somebody will feel left out, or somebody will not be liked by somebody else, etc.
So...is the only real solution: no test server except for me, and we go back to the way it was with things being missed because I cannot possibly watch 9000000 sims per day?
other solutions include deathblade's idea of just posting the results of tests...
or my idea/question of having the testers not see the specific builds they're testing...
or my idea of dismissing this current group of testers and then bringing testers back on only if they're willing to be public...
Originally posted by PierreThomas
Why is it such a big deal to open the testing to the public, even if it is just the results. We all know just how much separates some of the better teams in the better leagues. If one guy has just a bit of an advantage it really isn't fair which completely negates the entire purpose of the game.
Open the test data, open the player builds and nobody has a problem, actually it would likely garner quite the opposite response. People would probably be raving about you finally getting some testing done and not releasing an untested product and making changes mid season. I love the fact you are testing stuff, just not that my competition is getting an unfair advantage. No matter what you do it will be in the back of people's heads if this stuff isn't open for all to see.
I think that might cause more problems...it would turn into the public scouring over the test data to try and find exploits instead of us just trying to squash them.
So...It seems likely that the only way people are going to not be upset is if all testers are employees, and do not play the game competitively, or everyone and their brother gets in. Everyone getting in is obviously not going to happen, just because of the sheer headache it would cause, and the test server could never handle that much traffic anyway. I cannot afford 50 QA guys to test everything, so everybody cannot be an employee.
Even if all testers are publicly known, people will still be upset because somebody will feel left out, or somebody will not be liked by somebody else, etc.
So...is the only real solution: no test server except for me, and we go back to the way it was with things being missed because I cannot possibly watch 9000000 sims per day?
other solutions include deathblade's idea of just posting the results of tests...
or my idea/question of having the testers not see the specific builds they're testing...
or my idea of dismissing this current group of testers and then bringing testers back on only if they're willing to be public...






























