User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Test Server Discussion
Page:
 
tpaterniti
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ress5609
Originally posted by Catullus 16

Originally posted by tpaterniti


As I said, yes I can make a HB with 10 in Juke. But why am I making it? You guys assume I am making him to see if it works so I can go make my own HB with 10 in Juke on GLB and dominate. In fact I am making him so I can see if 1.) a HB with 10 in juke is not really that good so bort can balance out HBs and make sure the points you spent on Juke were not wasted or 2.) make sure a HB with 10 in Juke is not super powered so bort can balance out HBs and make sure the 60 points you put into tackling + the 67 points you put into agility were not wasted. That is what we are really doing on the test server.


this is fine, but it doesn't address a point i brought up earlier.

since fixes take a while to rollout, what do you do when someone on one of your teams asks whether they should put their SP into juke? if you know it's underpowered or about to be nerfed, wouldn't that effect your answer? if it does, isn't that unethical?


Quoted for we can has answer plz?


If it is super overpowered then probably it is about to get fixed. I tell people if you do this it will do that. I will say right now it is effective but attribute x will likely be more important in the near future so consider that in your decision.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PierreThomas
Why is it such a big deal to open the testing to the public, even if it is just the results. We all know just how much separates some of the better teams in the better leagues. If one guy has just a bit of an advantage it really isn't fair which completely negates the entire purpose of the game.

Open the test data, open the player builds and nobody has a problem, actually it would likely garner quite the opposite response. People would probably be raving about you finally getting some testing done and not releasing an untested product and making changes mid season. I love the fact you are testing stuff, just not that my competition is getting an unfair advantage. No matter what you do it will be in the back of people's heads if this stuff isn't open for all to see.



I think that might cause more problems...it would turn into the public scouring over the test data to try and find exploits instead of us just trying to squash them.

So...It seems likely that the only way people are going to not be upset is if all testers are employees, and do not play the game competitively, or everyone and their brother gets in. Everyone getting in is obviously not going to happen, just because of the sheer headache it would cause, and the test server could never handle that much traffic anyway. I cannot afford 50 QA guys to test everything, so everybody cannot be an employee.

Even if all testers are publicly known, people will still be upset because somebody will feel left out, or somebody will not be liked by somebody else, etc.

So...is the only real solution: no test server except for me, and we go back to the way it was with things being missed because I cannot possibly watch 9000000 sims per day?
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tpaterniti
Ideally the goal is for there to be lots of different paths to success and SAs should actually do what they say they do - if it says it makes yu force more fumbles it should. After that it should be your choice if you want to go that route when building your players. Above all else we are trying to make sure things work the way they should, not just trying to find the "best" build possible. How can you trust us? I don't know. How can you trust any of the people you know? Most of us have been around GLB for a long time or written guides or things of that nature. I can't speak for others but I genuinely like helping people out and that is why I wrote a guide, am updating it, and keep all my players open. Also I get a lot of questions about player building and I answer people indiscriminately as honestly as I can.


tpat, i trust you... and do believe what you're saying here. but there have been several players put in positions of authority that i flat-out do not trust.

additionally, i can't help but think this puts you in awkward ethical gray areas, whether you like it or not... which is troubling to the rest of us, no matter how upstanding you are.
 
Bukowski
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tpaterniti

As I said, yes I can make a HB with 10 in Juke. But why am I making it? You guys assume I am making him to see if it works so I can go make my own HB with 10 in Juke on GLB and dominate. In fact I am making him so I can see if 1.) a HB with 10 in juke is not really that good so bort can balance out HBs and make sure the points you spent on Juke were not wasted or 2.) make sure a HB with 10 in Juke is not super powered so bort can balance out HBs and make sure the 60 points you put into tackling + the 67 points you put into agility were not wasted. That is what we are really doing on the test server.




Give me a break.

So you're telling me, if you see that Juke is more effective than Head Fake and Spin, that you're still going to be putting your points into Head Fake and Spin?

Of course you're not.

Everything that you learn on the test server, is knowledge that is going to go directly into your player builds, whether that's your intention or not. And just think, maybe everyone else on the test-server isn't quite as honest as you are, then why do you think they're doing with their information?

It really wouldn't take too many people, to really cause a mass problem with this secret information. I'm sure these people are passing the information along, they just don't say exactly where they got it from. Then the one person that they tell, tells two other people, then those two people tell four people, and so on and so on.

Don't tell me it's impossible, and don't even tell me it's hard to fathom - because I could almost guarantee that something like this has already happened, and will most likely happen again. These people doing the testing are trying to be competitive just like everything else, of course they're going to use the information for their benefit - and their friends benefit - and their friends' friends benefit.

You guys can avoid and dodge the questions all you want, but the GLB masses aren't as naive as the people in charge were hoping.

 
dmfa41
offline
Link
 
I am really not concerned by this...just saying. I think it all comes out in the wash.

If these people have L40+ players, their builds are pretty much set. If those agents take what they learn from running tests and apply them to newly-created players, people will be able to see them and how they work, and things will spread about the community like the speed-DE power-back craze did. That's assuming the build is open, which it likely wouldn't be if they're the team's owner or the owner doesn't require they open the build.

I think people love adding "-gate" to the end of things.
 
The Duff Man
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tpaterniti
How can you trust us?


We don't know who you are. The option to trust you or not was never given to us, which in many people breeds suspicion and doubt from the get go.
 
Animalmother
offline
Link
 
As I understand it I am paying to play vs people with the added adv of being able to test specific situations/builds/va's/sa's.
I wasnt informed of this BEFORE I invested my money here.
I can respect the need to test the game, were all paying to do it in fact. What I can't accept is that the playing field that I've invested $1000 in cash in gives select people an adv over my money. Essentially its my money vs borts team or someone with borts full understanding of mechanics if others are allowed to test at will for free.

Its nice to assume people arnt going to take advantage of this or havent already but we all know thats not the case
 
tpaterniti
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
I think Pierre that you know more about player building than me.
 
Chester101
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by UsCtRoJaNs1820
I think it gives the tester an unfair advantage. I'm not going to look back through 125 pages so could we at learn who the "testers" are so we can ask them some questions about it? If someone has already posted who the testers are please show me that post. Thanks.


Cliff notes.

All mods have played on the test system for at least 2 weeks.
Outsiders have not spoken (not enough)
Peeps mad
Bort answers
People think bort "juked" em with his answer
People still mad
We wait still
 
TerrellOwns
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by PierreThomas

Why is it such a big deal to open the testing to the public, even if it is just the results. We all know just how much separates some of the better teams in the better leagues. If one guy has just a bit of an advantage it really isn't fair which completely negates the entire purpose of the game.

Open the test data, open the player builds and nobody has a problem, actually it would likely garner quite the opposite response. People would probably be raving about you finally getting some testing done and not releasing an untested product and making changes mid season. I love the fact you are testing stuff, just not that my competition is getting an unfair advantage. No matter what you do it will be in the back of people's heads if this stuff isn't open for all to see.



I think that might cause more problems...it would turn into the public scouring over the test data to try and find exploits instead of us just trying to squash them.

So...It seems likely that the only way people are going to not be upset is if all testers are employees, and do not play the game competitively, or everyone and their brother gets in. Everyone getting in is obviously not going to happen, just because of the sheer headache it would cause, and the test server could never handle that much traffic anyway. I cannot afford 50 QA guys to test everything, so everybody cannot be an employee.

Even if all testers are publicly known, people will still be upset because somebody will feel left out, or somebody will not be liked by somebody else, etc.

So...is the only real solution: no test server except for me, and we go back to the way it was with things being missed because I cannot possibly watch 9000000 sims per day?


This is a Beta game. The live servers are test servers. If you didn't take peoples' money in exchange for testing your game, there would be no outrage.
 
atingwald
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by PierreThomas

Why is it such a big deal to open the testing to the public, even if it is just the results. We all know just how much separates some of the better teams in the better leagues. If one guy has just a bit of an advantage it really isn't fair which completely negates the entire purpose of the game.

Open the test data, open the player builds and nobody has a problem, actually it would likely garner quite the opposite response. People would probably be raving about you finally getting some testing done and not releasing an untested product and making changes mid season. I love the fact you are testing stuff, just not that my competition is getting an unfair advantage. No matter what you do it will be in the back of people's heads if this stuff isn't open for all to see.



I think that might cause more problems...it would turn into the public scouring over the test data to try and find exploits instead of us just trying to squash them.

So...It seems likely that the only way people are going to not be upset is if all testers are employees, and do not play the game competitively, or everyone and their brother gets in. Everyone getting in is obviously not going to happen, just because of the sheer headache it would cause, and the test server could never handle that much traffic anyway. I cannot afford 50 QA guys to test everything, so everybody cannot be an employee.

Even if all testers are publicly known, people will still be upset because somebody will feel left out, or somebody will not be liked by somebody else, etc.

So...is the only real solution: no test server except for me, and we go back to the way it was with things being missed because I cannot possibly watch 9000000 sims per day?


you don't have a computer program that can run sims for you???
 
Binestar
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort

So...is the only real solution: no test server except for me, and we go back to the way it was with things being missed because I cannot possibly watch 9000000 sims per day?


allow non-testers to watch the replays with open builds for every player in each tested game.
 
CinTex
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by PierreThomas

Why is it such a big deal to open the testing to the public, even if it is just the results. We all know just how much separates some of the better teams in the better leagues. If one guy has just a bit of an advantage it really isn't fair which completely negates the entire purpose of the game.

Open the test data, open the player builds and nobody has a problem, actually it would likely garner quite the opposite response. People would probably be raving about you finally getting some testing done and not releasing an untested product and making changes mid season. I love the fact you are testing stuff, just not that my competition is getting an unfair advantage. No matter what you do it will be in the back of people's heads if this stuff isn't open for all to see.



I think that might cause more problems...it would turn into the public scouring over the test data to try and find exploits instead of us just trying to squash them.

So...It seems likely that the only way people are going to not be upset is if all testers are employees, and do not play the game competitively, or everyone and their brother gets in. Everyone getting in is obviously not going to happen, just because of the sheer headache it would cause, and the test server could never handle that much traffic anyway. I cannot afford 50 QA guys to test everything, so everybody cannot be an employee.

Even if all testers are publicly known, people will still be upset because somebody will feel left out, or somebody will not be liked by somebody else, etc.

So...is the only real solution: no test server except for me, and we go back to the way it was with things being missed because I cannot possibly watch 9000000 sims per day?


So there are 50 testers?
 
Gary.
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by PierreThomas

Why is it such a big deal to open the testing to the public, even if it is just the results. We all know just how much separates some of the better teams in the better leagues. If one guy has just a bit of an advantage it really isn't fair which completely negates the entire purpose of the game.

Open the test data, open the player builds and nobody has a problem, actually it would likely garner quite the opposite response. People would probably be raving about you finally getting some testing done and not releasing an untested product and making changes mid season. I love the fact you are testing stuff, just not that my competition is getting an unfair advantage. No matter what you do it will be in the back of people's heads if this stuff isn't open for all to see.



I think that might cause more problems...it would turn into the public scouring over the test data to try and find exploits instead of us just trying to squash them.

So...It seems likely that the only way people are going to not be upset is if all testers are employees, and do not play the game competitively, or everyone and their brother gets in. Everyone getting in is obviously not going to happen, just because of the sheer headache it would cause, and the test server could never handle that much traffic anyway. I cannot afford 50 QA guys to test everything, so everybody cannot be an employee.

Even if all testers are publicly known, people will still be upset because somebody will feel left out, or somebody will not be liked by somebody else, etc.

So...is the only real solution: no test server except for me, and we go back to the way it was with things being missed because I cannot possibly watch 9000000 sims per day?


This should solve the problems I think.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by dpell

Originally posted by tpaterniti


As I said, yes I can make a HB with 10 in Juke. But why am I making it? You guys assume I am making him to see if it works so I can go make my own HB with 10 in Juke on GLB and dominate. In fact I am making him so I can see if 1.) a HB with 10 in juke is not really that good so bort can balance out HBs and make sure the points you spent on Juke were not wasted or 2.) make sure a HB with 10 in Juke is not super powered so bort can balance out HBs and make sure the 60 points you put into tackling + the 67 points you put into agility were not wasted. That is what we are really doing on the test server.


And when you find that 10 juke nets an elusive back a 30% gain in ypc over 5 games, but a 10 in headfake only gets him 12%, and Bort says "that's how I want it to work", you have an incredibly useful piece of information the rest of us don't have.

If you say "What the hell does Strong Base even do" and run 5 sims without it, then give the entire OL 10 in it, now you have an idea what it does.

I'm not saying your intentions are bad Tpat, I'm saying that nobody playing the game should have secret knowledge to this. My players have had to play teams your players are on. If you tell them based on my example above "Juke is way better than headfake" and I don't have that info, my team is at a disadvantage. I'm really not sure why Bort and Thorn are being so intentionally obtuse about this.


What if TPat made a point of reporting the info that he and other testers found, if it was not going to be changed for balance or exploit purposes, putting it in his guide, frequently updating it?

That would seem to allow the testing so we aren't doing the testing on this site, and still allow everyone to get more info?


Or some sort of tester blog?
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.