User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Test Server Discussion
Page:
 
Link
 
Originally posted by dpell
Originally posted by Bort


Yes, we can create player prototypes to add them to test teams. Hmm...let's see. Somehow we are supposed to test the game without being able to create players and know what their abilities are? How in the heck would that work?


This is why people are upset. You've given a small group of people the ability to essentially test and determine what the optimum build is. If you really don't get why there are 120 pages of complaining here, you're not that bright.

This game pits player versus player. Build information and knowing what the best builds are is at least half the battle. I've seen entire Pro teams go from elite to cellar-dwellers with one season worth of your SIM updates. Sometimes those builds can be fixed with boosting SP and equipment moves, other times they can't. We all thought until today that at least that was a level playing field. Now it isn't. You've given a select group of people who also play this game, probably at it's highest levels, insights that the rest of us can't and don't have. You've fought requests since day 1 to tell us how SA's work and what the formulas are. These people have the ability to go in and see what happens if they take a build with 0 in an SA and then max it out to 11. The rest of us don't have that. They can run the same SIM probably 3-4 times to make sure the result isn't a fluke. I can't do that.

You could fix a lot of this if all the sims run on the test server were publicly viewable. Make them downloadable with all the player builds participating in the SIM viewable too. At least then everyone would have the ability to see what's happening.


+++
 
The Duff Man
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Luzod
Originally posted by The Duff Man

Originally posted by tpaterniti


As I said, yes I can make a HB with 10 in Juke. But why am I making it? You guys assume I am making him to see if it works so I can go make my own HB with 10 in Juke on GLB and dominate. In fact I am making him so I can see if 1.) a HB with 10 in juke is not really that good so bort can balance out HBs and make sure the points you spent on Juke were not wasted or 2.) make sure a HB with 10 in Juke is not super powered so bort can balance out HBs and make sure the 60 points you put into tackling + the 67 points you put into agility were not wasted. That is what we are really doing on the test server.


So if you find out that Juke is great, the next time you boost your HB are you going to be putting points into Juke? You have inside information about the relative strength of skills and SAs to each other. Regardless of your intent in doing the testing, it is impossible to not use that info.

So you just found out confidence does nothing. Will you be boosting confidence anytime soon? While the rest of the population is left guessing at whether or not it is useful.


As tpat make the guide to create players, I don't think it's a problem to have him knowing such thing. I'm more worried about the other guys there tbh.


Yeah I am not singling him out at all. I said "you" because I was responding to his post, but it should have read "a tester".
 
CS481
offline
Link
 
First let me say i don't post often almost never, but i have read this thread from page1 to page 123.
At the end of the day i do feel cheated. I feel bad for all the hard working agents out there (myself inc) busting ass and spending cash to see what works and what don't. Just the fact that "testers" can do this in minutes what takes us Months and hundreds of dollars is VERY discouraging. It's foolish to think that when they find something that works on the test site that they will not carry it over on the live site. While they may not share the findings with the GLB community they will rearrange gear or retie and start with a winning build from level 1.
I just feel that outside teasers would have been MUCH better in this case. Just knowing that one of my agents teams is going up against a team with "tester agents" is very discouraging.
Just my opinion but i don't like it at all...
 
Link
 
Originally posted by cbarge
Originally posted by GeneralMakaveli

If this testing is taking place then why the hell does Returning still suck.


Super elusive?


I still bet returning will be just as poor as it has been in the past 7 seasons. I had to move my Returning down from the Pros to AA so I can get some stats and have him act like a returner.
 
Nuge20
offline
Link
 
Only solution is 2000 FP bonus for all who are affected...like Dong Energy Scandal
lol
 
Link
 
I think it gives the tester an unfair advantage. I'm not going to look back through 125 pages so could we at learn who the "testers" are so we can ask them some questions about it? If someone has already posted who the testers are please show me that post. Thanks.
 
panther17
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by panther17
Originally posted by Deathblade



It isn't about the exploits. I think most people have faith in the testers to report those, and have them fixed.

The problem a lot of people have with it is the things that are NOT exploits. It is knowing the intricacies of every attribute and SA in the game within an hour or so of testing.




I would like to see this addressed. Sorry posting it again and quoting myself quoting Deathblade.
 
whoshotjr
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dpell


I'm not saying your intentions are bad Tpat, I'm saying that nobody playing the game should have secret knowledge to this. My players have had to play teams your players are on. If you tell them based on my example above "Juke is way better than headfake" and I don't have that info, my team is at a disadvantage. I'm really not sure why Bort and Thorn are being so intentionally obtuse about this.


I have to agree with this. Even if all the testers are above board, this type of knowledge is kind of hard to "unsee".
 
PierreThomas
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by gart888
Originally posted by The Duff Man

Originally posted by tpaterniti


As I said, yes I can make a HB with 10 in Juke. But why am I making it? You guys assume I am making him to see if it works so I can go make my own HB with 10 in Juke on GLB and dominate. In fact I am making him so I can see if 1.) a HB with 10 in juke is not really that good so bort can balance out HBs and make sure the points you spent on Juke were not wasted or 2.) make sure a HB with 10 in Juke is not super powered so bort can balance out HBs and make sure the 60 points you put into tackling + the 67 points you put into agility were not wasted. That is what we are really doing on the test server.


So if you find out that Juke is great, the next time you boost your HB are you going to be putting points into Juke? You have inside information about the relative strength of skills and SAs to each other. Regardless of your intent in doing the testing, it is impossible to not use that info.

So you just found out confidence does nothing. Will you be boosting confidence anytime soon? While the rest of the population is left guessing at whether or not it is useful.


The fact that the mods are acting stupid and forcing us to explain every little detail out is very depressing


Fixed that for you.

 
ress5609
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dpell
Originally posted by tpaterniti

As I said, yes I can make a HB with 10 in Juke. But why am I making it? You guys assume I am making him to see if it works so I can go make my own HB with 10 in Juke on GLB and dominate. In fact I am making him so I can see if 1.) a HB with 10 in juke is not really that good so bort can balance out HBs and make sure the points you spent on Juke were not wasted or 2.) make sure a HB with 10 in Juke is not super powered so bort can balance out HBs and make sure the 60 points you put into tackling + the 67 points you put into agility were not wasted. That is what we are really doing on the test server.


And when you find that 10 juke nets an elusive back a 30% gain in ypc over 5 games, but a 10 in headfake only gets him 12%, and Bort says "that's how I want it to work", you have an incredibly useful piece of information the rest of us don't have.

If you say "What the hell does Strong Base even do" and run 5 sims without it, then give the entire OL 10 in it, now you have an idea what it does.

I'm not saying your intentions are bad Tpat, I'm saying that nobody playing the game should have secret knowledge to this. My players have had to play teams your players are on. If you tell them based on my example above "Juke is way better than headfake" and I don't have that info, my team is at a disadvantage. I'm really not sure why Bort and Thorn are being so intentionally obtuse about this.


Quoted for the main issue that has still gone unanswered
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by UsCtRoJaNs1820
I think it gives the tester an unfair advantage. I'm not going to look back through 125 pages so could we at learn who the "testers" are so we can ask them some questions about it? If someone has already posted who the testers are please show me that post. Thanks.


They aren't going to tell us.
 
HootyHoo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cbarge
Originally posted by krwynn

Originally posted by Bort



Like I said earlier, though, to be quite honest, some of our testers are pretty burned out playing competitively on the game, and have told me as such, and would rather spend their time trying to help improve it. I'm sure some of you know the feeling.


It's not the game that burns us out. It's the back room stuff and the unequal treatment of paying customers. From builds to forum posting, nothing and no one is treated equally. That's what burns us out.



So you're a tester?


Absolutely 100% no.
 
PP
offline
Link
 
I got a ?...If as Bort says that these testers are burnt out and don't care about being competitive, only about the good of the game, is it safe to assume that none of them will boost? I mean, why the hell would they. They don't care about winning.

Anyway you look at it, every "answer" that is given, this absolutely stinks of BS
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dpell
Originally posted by tpaterniti

As I said, yes I can make a HB with 10 in Juke. But why am I making it? You guys assume I am making him to see if it works so I can go make my own HB with 10 in Juke on GLB and dominate. In fact I am making him so I can see if 1.) a HB with 10 in juke is not really that good so bort can balance out HBs and make sure the points you spent on Juke were not wasted or 2.) make sure a HB with 10 in Juke is not super powered so bort can balance out HBs and make sure the 60 points you put into tackling + the 67 points you put into agility were not wasted. That is what we are really doing on the test server.


And when you find that 10 juke nets an elusive back a 30% gain in ypc over 5 games, but a 10 in headfake only gets him 12%, and Bort says "that's how I want it to work", you have an incredibly useful piece of information the rest of us don't have.

If you say "What the hell does Strong Base even do" and run 5 sims without it, then give the entire OL 10 in it, now you have an idea what it does.

I'm not saying your intentions are bad Tpat, I'm saying that nobody playing the game should have secret knowledge to this. My players have had to play teams your players are on. If you tell them based on my example above "Juke is way better than headfake" and I don't have that info, my team is at a disadvantage. I'm really not sure why Bort and Thorn are being so intentionally obtuse about this.


What if TPat made a point of reporting the info that he and other testers found, if it was not going to be changed for balance or exploit purposes, putting it in his guide, frequently updating it?

That would seem to allow the testing so we aren't doing the testing on this site, and still allow everyone to get more info?
 
Gart888
things!
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PierreThomas
Originally posted by gart888

Originally posted by The Duff Man


Originally posted by tpaterniti



As I said, yes I can make a HB with 10 in Juke. But why am I making it? You guys assume I am making him to see if it works so I can go make my own HB with 10 in Juke on GLB and dominate. In fact I am making him so I can see if 1.) a HB with 10 in juke is not really that good so bort can balance out HBs and make sure the points you spent on Juke were not wasted or 2.) make sure a HB with 10 in Juke is not super powered so bort can balance out HBs and make sure the 60 points you put into tackling + the 67 points you put into agility were not wasted. That is what we are really doing on the test server.


So if you find out that Juke is great, the next time you boost your HB are you going to be putting points into Juke? You have inside information about the relative strength of skills and SAs to each other. Regardless of your intent in doing the testing, it is impossible to not use that info.

So you just found out confidence does nothing. Will you be boosting confidence anytime soon? While the rest of the population is left guessing at whether or not it is useful.


The fact that the mods are acting stupid and forcing us to explain every little detail out is very depressing


Fixed that for you.



quality fix.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.