User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Test Server Discussion
Page:
 
dpell
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tpaterniti
As I said, yes I can make a HB with 10 in Juke. But why am I making it? You guys assume I am making him to see if it works so I can go make my own HB with 10 in Juke on GLB and dominate. In fact I am making him so I can see if 1.) a HB with 10 in juke is not really that good so bort can balance out HBs and make sure the points you spent on Juke were not wasted or 2.) make sure a HB with 10 in Juke is not super powered so bort can balance out HBs and make sure the 60 points you put into tackling + the 67 points you put into agility were not wasted. That is what we are really doing on the test server.


And when you find that 10 juke nets an elusive back a 30% gain in ypc over 5 games, but a 10 in headfake only gets him 12%, and Bort says "that's how I want it to work", you have an incredibly useful piece of information the rest of us don't have.

If you say "What the hell does Strong Base even do" and run 5 sims without it, then give the entire OL 10 in it, now you have an idea what it does.

I'm not saying your intentions are bad Tpat, I'm saying that nobody playing the game should have secret knowledge to this. My players have had to play teams your players are on. If you tell them based on my example above "Juke is way better than headfake" and I don't have that info, my team is at a disadvantage. I'm really not sure why Bort and Thorn are being so intentionally obtuse about this.
 
cbarge
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GeneralMakaveli
If this testing is taking place then why the hell does Returning still suck.


Super elusive?
 
Gart888
things!
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by The Duff Man
Originally posted by tpaterniti

As I said, yes I can make a HB with 10 in Juke. But why am I making it? You guys assume I am making him to see if it works so I can go make my own HB with 10 in Juke on GLB and dominate. In fact I am making him so I can see if 1.) a HB with 10 in juke is not really that good so bort can balance out HBs and make sure the points you spent on Juke were not wasted or 2.) make sure a HB with 10 in Juke is not super powered so bort can balance out HBs and make sure the 60 points you put into tackling + the 67 points you put into agility were not wasted. That is what we are really doing on the test server.


So if you find out that Juke is great, the next time you boost your HB are you going to be putting points into Juke? You have inside information about the relative strength of skills and SAs to each other. Regardless of your intent in doing the testing, it is impossible to not use that info.

So you just found out confidence does nothing. Will you be boosting confidence anytime soon? While the rest of the population is left guessing at whether or not it is useful.


The fact that we even need to explain this to the admins/mods is very depressing.
 
TerrellOwns
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Like I said earlier, though, to be quite honest, some of our testers are pretty burned out playing competitively on the game, and have told me as such, and would rather spend their time trying to help improve it. I'm sure some of you know the feeling.


So if they are "burned out" playing competitively, why not have them forfeit their accounts or put them on hold while they are testing? Why not have them sign an NDA? This argument makes no sense and just shows how pervasive the atmosphere of dishonesty is in the administration of this game.
 
Luzod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by The Duff Man
Originally posted by tpaterniti

As I said, yes I can make a HB with 10 in Juke. But why am I making it? You guys assume I am making him to see if it works so I can go make my own HB with 10 in Juke on GLB and dominate. In fact I am making him so I can see if 1.) a HB with 10 in juke is not really that good so bort can balance out HBs and make sure the points you spent on Juke were not wasted or 2.) make sure a HB with 10 in Juke is not super powered so bort can balance out HBs and make sure the 60 points you put into tackling + the 67 points you put into agility were not wasted. That is what we are really doing on the test server.


So if you find out that Juke is great, the next time you boost your HB are you going to be putting points into Juke? You have inside information about the relative strength of skills and SAs to each other. Regardless of your intent in doing the testing, it is impossible to not use that info.

So you just found out confidence does nothing. Will you be boosting confidence anytime soon? While the rest of the population is left guessing at whether or not it is useful.


As tpat make the guide to create players, I don't think it's a problem to have him knowing such thing. I'm more worried about the other guys there tbh.
 
Binestar
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cbarge
Originally posted by Binestar

Originally posted by tpaterniti


As I said, yes I can make a HB with 10 in Juke. But why am I making it? You guys assume I am making him to see if it works so I can go make my own HB with 10 in Juke on GLB and dominate. In fact I am making him so I can see if 1.) a HB with 10 in juke is not really that good so bort can balance out HBs and make sure the points you spent on Juke were not wasted or 2.) make sure a HB with 10 in Juke is not super powered so bort can balance out HBs and make sure the 60 points you put into tackling + the 67 points you put into agility were not wasted. That is what we are really doing on the test server.


That's all fine and dandy. But you're also seeing what is "not crap" and can avoid those builds. The min/maxer in any gamer will notice that yeah, 10 in Juke is pretty good, but 10 in spin sucks, but Bort thinks it's balanced and isn't going to change it this season.

Now you know to avoid spin on live, whereas no one outside of the testing does.


Except those who are decently informed and astute.


Let me rephrase that:

"Now you KNOW to avoid spin, whereas people outside of testing can only GUESS to avoid spin" It's a degree of difference that can be key in an otherwise equal game.
 
HootyHoo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort

Like I said earlier, though, to be quite honest, some of our testers are pretty burned out playing competitively on the game, and have told me as such, and would rather spend their time trying to help improve it. I'm sure some of you know the feeling.


It's not the game that burns us out. It's the back room stuff and the unequal treatment of paying customers. From builds to forum posting, nothing and no one is treated equally. That's what burns us out.

 
Bill Jack
offline
Link
 
Some players are more equal than others.. That's life so just get used to it.
 
ress5609
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Catullus 16
Originally posted by tpaterniti

As I said, yes I can make a HB with 10 in Juke. But why am I making it? You guys assume I am making him to see if it works so I can go make my own HB with 10 in Juke on GLB and dominate. In fact I am making him so I can see if 1.) a HB with 10 in juke is not really that good so bort can balance out HBs and make sure the points you spent on Juke were not wasted or 2.) make sure a HB with 10 in Juke is not super powered so bort can balance out HBs and make sure the 60 points you put into tackling + the 67 points you put into agility were not wasted. That is what we are really doing on the test server.


this is fine, but it doesn't address a point i brought up earlier.

since fixes take a while to rollout, what do you do when someone on one of your teams asks whether they should put their SP into juke? if you know it's underpowered or about to be nerfed, wouldn't that effect your answer? if it does, isn't that unethical?


Quoted for we can has answer plz?
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by gart888

Originally posted by Bort


Originally posted by DrkSandman



Originally posted by jamz




Originally posted by DrkSandman






Why? We got beat down in the conference finals. Good thing that inside knowledge helped us, right?

/sarcasm


Curiousity, I already know of 2. I could care less either way we went 8-8. It's just interesting to me is all. PM me if you like, I'm not implying anything.


Oh, I know bro. But, as Bort said - releasing the names of the testers right now would just lead to flaming, massive PMs, etc.

Which, is really shitty because I'm telling you that some of these guys have been busting their asses to do good for the game.

That's why I'm so irritated. I understand people's concerns, but they really have nothing to worry about.


I agree 100%. Some of the guys involved have really been putting in a lot of time and effort to try and help me out as I try different stuff, and I really don't want to see them get dumped on.


How can you guys say this with any degree of certainty?

If i just came out and told you that one of the testers has been leaking me information would that make you take this seriously?


I would ask that you share that info with me and I will take action accordingly. I've made it pretty clear to the test crew that the point of the test site is to find bugs or exploits with new code and report it. If somebody's attempting to feed random info to other folks, then I need to have a talk with them and remove them from the test crew.

Like I said earlier, though, to be quite honest, some of our testers are pretty burned out playing competitively on the game, and have told me as such, and would rather spend their time trying to help improve it. I'm sure some of you know the feeling.


Ok Bort, don't take this the wrong way but I take that response as a little naive. Gart just told you that one of your testers is feeding him info, now does that not tell you that they may not all have completely innocent motives here? And if 1 is doing it, is it not feasible that all might be doing it or half?

 
PierreThomas
offline
Link
 
Bort, serious question.

Since you are so confident that the testers will not use this to their advantage will you give us a reassurance of a full refund if they do? I don't think it is asking that much since you are asking people to spend money with the assurance that they will not abuse it.

 
cbarge
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by krwynn
Originally posted by Bort


Like I said earlier, though, to be quite honest, some of our testers are pretty burned out playing competitively on the game, and have told me as such, and would rather spend their time trying to help improve it. I'm sure some of you know the feeling.


It's not the game that burns us out. It's the back room stuff and the unequal treatment of paying customers. From builds to forum posting, nothing and no one is treated equally. That's what burns us out.



So you're a tester?
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Binestar
"Now you KNOW to avoid spin, whereas people outside of testing can only GUESS to avoid spin" It's a degree of difference that can be key in an otherwise equal game.


you also know if spin is about to be nerfed... whereas everyone else still thinks it's a good idea and keep investing in it.
 
TerrellOwns
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dpell
I'm really not sure why Bort and Thorn are being so intentionally obtuse about this.


I don't either, but I'm guessing it comes from a misguided attempt to make the game seem more mysterious and complex than it actually is.
 
tpaterniti
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PierreThomas
Originally posted by tpaterniti

As I said, yes I can make a HB with 10 in Juke. But why am I making it? You guys assume I am making him to see if it works so I can go make my own HB with 10 in Juke on GLB and dominate. In fact I am making him so I can see if 1.) a HB with 10 in juke is not really that good so bort can balance out HBs and make sure the points you spent on Juke were not wasted or 2.) make sure a HB with 10 in Juke is not super powered so bort can balance out HBs and make sure the 60 points you put into tackling + the 67 points you put into agility were not wasted. That is what we are really doing on the test server.


So in other words, every single attribute and every single SA will be just as effective? Come on now, we understand the point of testing, just don't like the lack of transparency. It really isn't this difficult.


Ideally the goal is for there to be lots of different paths to success and SAs should actually do what they say they do - if it says it makes yu force more fumbles it should. After that it should be your choice if you want to go that route when building your players. Above all else we are trying to make sure things work the way they should, not just trying to find the "best" build possible. How can you trust us? I don't know. How can you trust any of the people you know? Most of us have been around GLB for a long time or written guides or things of that nature. I can't speak for others but I genuinely like helping people out and that is why I wrote a guide, am updating it, and keep all my players open. Also I get a lot of questions about player building and I answer people indiscriminately as honestly as I can.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.