User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Test Server Discussion
Page:
 
Binestar
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tpaterniti
As I said, yes I can make a HB with 10 in Juke. But why am I making it? You guys assume I am making him to see if it works so I can go make my own HB with 10 in Juke on GLB and dominate. In fact I am making him so I can see if 1.) a HB with 10 in juke is not really that good so bort can balance out HBs and make sure the points you spent on Juke were not wasted or 2.) make sure a HB with 10 in Juke is not super powered so bort can balance out HBs and make sure the 60 points you put into tackling + the 67 points you put into agility were not wasted. That is what we are really doing on the test server.


That's all fine and dandy. But you're also seeing what is "not crap" and can avoid those builds. The min/maxer in any gamer will notice that yeah, 10 in Juke is pretty good, but 10 in spin sucks, but Bort thinks it's balanced and isn't going to change it this season.

Now you know to avoid spin on live, whereas no one outside of the testing does.
 
The Duff Man
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tpaterniti
As I said, yes I can make a HB with 10 in Juke. But why am I making it? You guys assume I am making him to see if it works so I can go make my own HB with 10 in Juke on GLB and dominate. In fact I am making him so I can see if 1.) a HB with 10 in juke is not really that good so bort can balance out HBs and make sure the points you spent on Juke were not wasted or 2.) make sure a HB with 10 in Juke is not super powered so bort can balance out HBs and make sure the 60 points you put into tackling + the 67 points you put into agility were not wasted. That is what we are really doing on the test server.


So if you find out that Juke is great, the next time you boost your HB are you going to be putting points into Juke? You have inside information about the relative strength of skills and SAs to each other. Regardless of your intent in doing the testing, it is impossible to not use that info.

So you just found out confidence does nothing. Will you be boosting confidence anytime soon? While the rest of the population is left guessing at whether or not it is useful.
 
Hukton Vioxx
offline
Link
 
I can't really see it being fair for anyone to have an advantage like that, especially against paying customers that have spent thousands of hours building their teams the hard way.

You should probably create a league for those teams run by testers where they all have that advantage if there are that many, or create a league for testing and add some testers to fill it out.

Having them compete against other teams who lack that advantage is just not fair. Find some way around it.

 
jeffpap
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort


Like I said earlier, though, to be quite honest, some of our testers are pretty burned out playing competitively on the game, and have told me as such, and would rather spend their time trying to help improve it. I'm sure some of you know the feeling.


Then isn't the solution for them NOT to play the game competitively anymore. Problem solved...everyone is happy
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Zickzack
Originally posted by jrry32

but the main concern is that people will exploit this and create players to test out how they could improve their builds the most before they boost or that these people will get to know what updates are being made(say Power RBs are being weakened) before the general population, thus giving them a jump on fixing their builds up. Can those things happen?


Even if it could happen, this would be exactly the reason not to give everyone access to the test server as some have "demanded" here. The point of the testing should be to find possible exploits and work with Bort on fixing them rather than trying to use them to your own advantage. Of course one would and has to hope that Bort would grant access to the test server on the base that he trusts the people he gives access to do just that, otherwise such a server would be pretty much pointless for him.

Saying that, I am sure that a lot of people on here will doubt exactly that just based on the fact that they themselves are not included (yet?). But the fact that so many people cry "oh they will abuse exploits for their own benefit" rather than "great, that will help to fix possible exploits" shows that many have not truly understood the purpose of the server nor would most of those people be fit to be involved in any kind of testing because they just don't seem to possess the mindset required.


Actually if everyone had access, everyone is on an equal playing field instead of having 10-20 members with access who have the ability to do this while everyone is SOL. No, the fact everyone here is "crying" they will abuse it shows that we have a lack of trust that people will only to use this to help the game instead of themselves which during GLB's tenure, this lack of trust has almost always been proven to be correct. I don't want it made public to everyone, I want the results made public and allow people to watch the testing WHILE only having 10-20 people being able to actually CONDUCT it.
 
scfan04
offline
Link
 
can i have my casual team now bort?
 
Binestar
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort

Like I said earlier, though, to be quite honest, some of our testers are pretty burned out playing competitively on the game, and have told me as such, and would rather spend their time trying to help improve it. I'm sure some of you know the feeling.


I know the feeling. Does that mean I get to be on the test server?
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jeffpap
Originally posted by Bort



Like I said earlier, though, to be quite honest, some of our testers are pretty burned out playing competitively on the game, and have told me as such, and would rather spend their time trying to help improve it. I'm sure some of you know the feeling.


Then isn't the solution for them NOT to play the game competitively anymore. Problem solved...everyone is happy


I agree with Jeff. If they want to play again, just let them quit testing then.
 
Koncorde
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jeffpap
Originally posted by Bort



Like I said earlier, though, to be quite honest, some of our testers are pretty burned out playing competitively on the game, and have told me as such, and would rather spend their time trying to help improve it. I'm sure some of you know the feeling.


Then isn't the solution for them NOT to play the game competitively anymore. Problem solved...everyone is happy


Apart from those who still wantto play....
 
cbarge
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Binestar
Originally posted by tpaterniti

As I said, yes I can make a HB with 10 in Juke. But why am I making it? You guys assume I am making him to see if it works so I can go make my own HB with 10 in Juke on GLB and dominate. In fact I am making him so I can see if 1.) a HB with 10 in juke is not really that good so bort can balance out HBs and make sure the points you spent on Juke were not wasted or 2.) make sure a HB with 10 in Juke is not super powered so bort can balance out HBs and make sure the 60 points you put into tackling + the 67 points you put into agility were not wasted. That is what we are really doing on the test server.


That's all fine and dandy. But you're also seeing what is "not crap" and can avoid those builds. The min/maxer in any gamer will notice that yeah, 10 in Juke is pretty good, but 10 in spin sucks, but Bort thinks it's balanced and isn't going to change it this season.

Now you know to avoid spin on live, whereas no one outside of the testing does.


Except those who are decently informed and astute.
 
aneksi
offline
Link
 
Beta is all about testing. The only problem was not letting the WHOLE glb community to have the ability to test. I could care less who they are and what they can do. What i do care about is never getting said chance. What makes them better then anyone else who plays this game? And if they are testing they in essence are playing the game for free with no boundries what so ever. Doesn't make sense to me.
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tpaterniti
As I said, yes I can make a HB with 10 in Juke. But why am I making it? You guys assume I am making him to see if it works so I can go make my own HB with 10 in Juke on GLB and dominate. In fact I am making him so I can see if 1.) a HB with 10 in juke is not really that good so bort can balance out HBs and make sure the points you spent on Juke were not wasted or 2.) make sure a HB with 10 in Juke is not super powered so bort can balance out HBs and make sure the 60 points you put into tackling + the 67 points you put into agility were not wasted. That is what we are really doing on the test server.


this is fine, but it doesn't address a point i brought up earlier.

since fixes take a while to rollout, what do you do when someone on one of your teams asks whether they should put their SP into juke? if you know it's underpowered or about to be nerfed, wouldn't that effect your answer? if it does, isn't that unethical?
 
wombat killer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by The Duff Man
Originally posted by tpaterniti

As I said, yes I can make a HB with 10 in Juke. But why am I making it? You guys assume I am making him to see if it works so I can go make my own HB with 10 in Juke on GLB and dominate. In fact I am making him so I can see if 1.) a HB with 10 in juke is not really that good so bort can balance out HBs and make sure the points you spent on Juke were not wasted or 2.) make sure a HB with 10 in Juke is not super powered so bort can balance out HBs and make sure the 60 points you put into tackling + the 67 points you put into agility were not wasted. That is what we are really doing on the test server.


So if you find out that Juke is great, the next time you boost your HB are you going to be putting points into Juke? You have inside information about the relative strength of skills and SAs to each other. Regardless of your intent in doing the testing, it is impossible to not use that info.

So you just found out confidence does nothing. Will you be boosting confidence anytime soon? While the rest of the population is left guessing at whether or not it is useful.


Exactly. It doesn't matter why things are being tested. The fact is certain knowledge is gained by the testing. It doesn't matter what the initial intent was.
 
Link
 
If this testing is taking place then why the hell does Returning still suck.
 
tycoon34
offline
Link
 
If what tpat's latest post and bort's latest are indeed true, then I'm sure that would make GLBers very happy. But with the bullshit going on in GLB right now and in the past (Tim Harper, some unfair modding stuff, etc), it's not hard to believe that something fishy could be going on. Not to accuse or anything, but there's always that possiblities when you let game testers/developers play the game that they are testing/developing.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.