User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Game Changes Discussion > Archived Changes > Extended Plateau Discussion
Page:
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Dpride59
Originally posted by jrry32

I don't think you get it, it's not crying. It's saying there should be no decline put on S5 players, just remove VAs and be done with it considering they only gained 48 BTs on S6 builds and are down BTs to S7 builds.


You don't get it, the s5 players are already declined and are getting a very lucky break that bort is knocking it in half. S5 dots are still awesome, and will still have a slight edge vs the s6 dots IMO


I fail to see the luck here and they have no edge on the S6 dots who are not seeing any decline, they are at a large disadvantage.
 
EagleOtto
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by varhamur
Pay to compete - GLB has become the Yankees... Non-boosters - you'll have no chance.


You hear this a lot and it makes no sense, non-boosters were not going to make it up to the top leagues anyways, which is the only thing the extended plateau is really targetted at.

A non-booster will be able to switch teams every offseason to stay in an appropriate cap and still have a slight advantage over everyone else in those leagues, just don't expect to make it over level 40-42. (which is how its always been)

You'll still have a good amount of seasons enjoying a slight training advantage in the leagues your in.

Non-boosters will continually get TPs and VAs as they won't hit plateau and still get a few extra seasons in the cap 38-42 leagues.


This new plateau idea is benefits boosters and doesn't penalize non-boosters in my opinion.

Edited by EagleOtto on Jun 29, 2010 03:11:53
 
rocomo
offline
Link
 
Non-boosters are always gonna be 2nd class citizens!
 
JJHardy
offline
Link
 
i still think there should be a Brett Favre option
 
jamz
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jrry32
Originally posted by Dpride59

Originally posted by jrry32


I don't think you get it, it's not crying. It's saying there should be no decline put on S5 players, just remove VAs and be done with it considering they only gained 48 BTs on S6 builds and are down BTs to S7 builds.


You don't get it, the s5 players are already declined and are getting a very lucky break that bort is knocking it in half. S5 dots are still awesome, and will still have a slight edge vs the s6 dots IMO


I fail to see the luck here and they have no edge on the S6 dots who are not seeing any decline, they are at a large disadvantage.


The luck is that they weren't left out entirely, they could continue declining instead.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by beenlurken
Originally posted by Jack Kilbourne

Originally posted by foshizzel17


Originally posted by Jack Kilbourne



My point is the purpose of aging has been completely obliterated with this ill-conceived plan to extend the ages of players by 3 seasons.

Why not extend the point they start to age to 13, if three more seasons is what the loudest people want right now?

I'm really wondering if this change was trotted out to sooth people that whined about the new training system. I can imagine it.

Whiner - "This new system sux, I'm leaving!"
Bort - "Wait! I'll let you keep your player 3 more seasons, rot free!"
Whiner - "ok"

I'm tellin ya, folks, this will make the game less interesting and overall worse. Fewer people will come to the game, and more will go away. I am certain of this. Less incoming flex, more outgoing people, a whole lot fewer logins.

I guarantee you'll see this after one season of this new change, two at most. the time it takes for those people who started in about season 8 or 9 to realize they need to wait even longer to get on the upper tier teams. They wont buy teams, they wont buy more flex for players, at the least. Probably will quit boosting once they realize that due to the farm teams out there, even if they did get into the 1st or 2nd plateau season, they will still probably not get signed to a team higher than AA.

Boring game = game people move on from. Databases should breathe a sigh of relief, but the game will suffer. Mark my words, Bort.

Jack



uh.....no.


no? that's a heck of an argument. how can I possibly overcome your logic? heh.

Come on people. Wake up. This change is happening to mollify a few, not help the many. I imagine it might be to help "ease" people that whined about the new training system. If we keep their old farts around for 3 more seasons, they at least might try to figure it out on their younger ones and not throw their hands up in attention defecit despair. Did I come close to the mark?

Aging is a factor that adds to the flavor of this game. does it make it harder? Only if you dont want to log into the game.

It makes it more interesting and competetive. Owners and GMs have to do something once in a while. Players have to keep track of their player so they dont lose training points.

a three month break from the game, for anyone who has just old players on their rosters, no penalty, and they could come back and find three trophies on their players. oooh fun game.

Jack


the whiner is oblivious to the fact that he is the whiner... that said, technically Bort didnt cater to the whiner


I have tons of players who will benefit, i.e. most of my older players were made season 5. and I wont have to recruit at all. it helps me, more than alot. the few I might recruit will be plateau guys. at the least, 400 day guys. I'll probably cut my 360 day guys, if I plan to be competetive. Bet theyy'll be happy to be cut loose, and have to wait 2 or 3 more seasons before having another shot at a Pro team.

I'm looking beyond myself to other people and the bigger picture. Pretty selfish of me, huh?

Competetiveness and the point of having an aging rule at all. Those are the issues here. They picked 10 seasons a loooong time ago, for a reason. Why not 12, or 15? Beats me. 10 was the rule, and now we "bend" it.. and for what purpose? I stil have yet to see a good reason, in all this.

I have learned to think for myself, regardless of how it helps my current dots. and I can see this change hurting the game in the end.

Tired of this. Go for it, lemmings.

Jack
 
Pebbles28
offline
Link
 
Great idea, but a dot with full 120 eligibility will have plateau put off til Day 560. A dot at 481 can still benefit hugely from this but is not being allowed to take advantage of it.

Way to reward your long-time loyal customers!
 
codegod8
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gart888

yeah, as much as i think dpride is a jerk, i'll be the first to admit that he does have game balance in mind when he makes game suggestions.


qf jerk

Now I wonder what he had in mind during +10 gate? I mean outside of winning the WL.
 
madmal
Prez SWO
offline
Link
 
I'm confused:

1st announcement: "If your player is <= 480 days old at season 17's start, then they will be awarded the extended plateau and will have their decline removed. If 481 days or older at season 17's start, unfortunately, they will not be eligible for the extended plateau."

2nd announcement: "The player will be locked into HALF of whatever state of decline he was in when opting in, and this will be applied throughout his extra plateau seasons. For 480 day old players, this is -2.5% to physical attributes and -1.25% to other attributes, and for 441 day old players it is 0%, with other ages in between being HALF of the values outlined in http://goallineblitz.com/decline_faq.html."

Is announcement 2 only if you use the Opt-In option?

If you don't Opt-In you have your players decline totally removed and keep the VAs you have without a reset. Is this correct?
 
Jethroz
Q & A Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by madmal
I'm confused:

1st announcement: "If your player is <= 480 days old at season 17's start, then they will be awarded the extended plateau and will have their decline removed. If 481 days or older at season 17's start, unfortunately, they will not be eligible for the extended plateau."

2nd announcement: "The player will be locked into HALF of whatever state of decline he was in when opting in, and this will be applied throughout his extra plateau seasons. For 480 day old players, this is -2.5% to physical attributes and -1.25% to other attributes, and for 441 day old players it is 0%, with other ages in between being HALF of the values outlined in http://goallineblitz.com/decline_faq.html."

Is announcement 2 only if you use the Opt-In option?

If you don't Opt-In you have your players decline totally removed and keep the VAs you have without a reset. Is this correct?


No need to be confused. Your answer is posted at the end of the second announcement:
Originally posted by http://goallineblitz.com/game/announcement.pl?id=378

This is entirely optional, and if you choose not to opt in, the player will continue declining at the old rate.

Edited by Jethroz on Jul 1, 2010 16:08:15
 
wsdp
offline
Link
 
Question, does a S4, D40 player (470 days old today on S16, D30) qualify as a S5? I always the CUTOFF was D40 and D41 qualified as a player from the next season... dumb question but 470 + 10 days left in season means he'll finish at 480 and be eligible, right?
 
Plankton
OPL4Lyfe
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by wsdp
Question, does a S4, D40 player (470 days old today on S16, D30) qualify as a S5? I always the CUTOFF was D40 and D41 qualified as a player from the next season... dumb question but 470 + 10 days left in season means he'll finish at 480 and be eligible, right?


The announcement says less than or equal to 480 days, so you should be fine.
 
wsdp
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Plankton
Originally posted by wsdp

Question, does a S4, D40 player (470 days old today on S16, D30) qualify as a S5? I always the CUTOFF was D40 and D41 qualified as a player from the next season... dumb question but 470 + 10 days left in season means he'll finish at 480 and be eligible, right?


The announcement says less than or equal to 480 days, so you should be fine.


It says on D1 next season, doesn't it? Can an admin please confirm this?
 
Plankton
OPL4Lyfe
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by wsdp
It says on D1 next season, doesn't it? Can an admin please confirm this?


It says "at Season 17 start". That is probably day -8, but either way, you should be fine. Just thought I would point that out in case an Admin is slow to respond, or misses your question.
 
madmal
Prez SWO
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jethroz
Originally posted by madmal

I'm confused:

1st announcement: "If your player is <= 480 days old at season 17's start, then they will be awarded the extended plateau and will have their decline removed. If 481 days or older at season 17's start, unfortunately, they will not be eligible for the extended plateau."

2nd announcement: "The player will be locked into HALF of whatever state of decline he was in when opting in, and this will be applied throughout his extra plateau seasons. For 480 day old players, this is -2.5% to physical attributes and -1.25% to other attributes, and for 441 day old players it is 0%, with other ages in between being HALF of the values outlined in http://goallineblitz.com/decline_faq.html."

Is announcement 2 only if you use the Opt-In option?

If you don't Opt-In you have your players decline totally removed and keep the VAs you have without a reset. Is this correct?


No need to be confused. Your answer is posted at the end of the second announcement:
Originally posted by http://goallineblitz.com/game/announcement.pl?id=378

This is entirely optional, and if you choose not to opt in, the player will continue declining at the old rate.



Then why don't they straighten out the 1st announcement rather then having 2 conflicting announcements. Would that be too difficult????
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.