User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Game Changes Discussion > Announced Changes > Change to Age Based League Structures Discussion Thread
Page:
 
bigtisme
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bobaganoosh

Lastly, it sounds to me that Bort and Co think that the non-boosters and boosters will separate themselves from one another x seasons down the road. If this is the goal they are trying to achieve then why in the hell don't they just make a boosters league and a non-boosters league? It makes ZERO sense.

Does everybody understand now or do I need to dumb it down more than it already is?


can you say it while being less of a douche?

Do you seriously not understand why they aren't going to create a nonboosting league ( a league designed to earn less money). I'd be ok with a nonboosting league set up as long as it cost 5-10 times as much for player creation or something like that.

And boosters should be able to win every season if they're the best players/coaches. I dont think you can disagree with that?
 
foofighter24
jumpin da snark
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bigtisme
Well I guess if this is always happening then maybe there is no problem I assumed most teams usualy hit a cap where they struggled in the current set up.


Well, we had to recruit some new dots along the way and let the non-boosters go, especially by the third title. Also, we started the run with every single player below the level cap and were not SSB.
 
foofighter24
jumpin da snark
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bigtisme


And boosters should be able to win every season if they're the best players/coaches. I dont think you can disagree with that?


They normally aren't the best gameplanners and their dots are not as good for that level.
 
bigtisme
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by foofighter24
They normally aren't the best gameplanners and their dots are not as good for that level.


then they wont win. But SOMEONE has the best gameplans and still has boosting players...and they should be winning year in and year out.
 
foofighter24
jumpin da snark
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bigtisme
then they wont win. But SOMEONE has the best gameplans and still has boosting players...and they should be winning year in and year out.


They can win any season already.


Let me ask you this, two boosting teams are playing in a 30 cap league. They have equal gameplanning skills, but one team decides to give up their end game potential by applying SPs and training differently to win now. Who is likely to win? Is that unfair?
 
Bobaganoosh
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bigtisme
can you say it while being less of a douche?

Do you seriously not understand why they aren't going to create a nonboosting league ( a league designed to earn less money). I'd be ok with a nonboosting league set up as long as it cost 5-10 times as much for player creation or something like that.

And boosters should be able to win every season if they're the best players/coaches. I dont think you can disagree with that?


Sure can and have but it doesn't seem to get through that thick skull you boosters seem to possess. I notice that you responded which means I accomplished what I wanted. It's kind of sad that I need to resort to being a 'douche' for it to be acknowledged but that's the way the cookie crumbles.

I understand fully why they won't create a non-boosting league but do you not understand that, in essence, that is exactly what Bort and Co. are trying to do without officially opening a non-boosting league?

And booster COULD win every season if they didn't build for the future. How is it the non-boosters fault that they decide to build for the now and dominate because the boosters build for the future and get demolished? You realize that the highest level a non-booster can achieve is level 41 right? And you also realize that there are caps in which these non-boosters will never reach right? And you also realize that it is at that point that most booster builds begin to round out right? And you also realize that that is the point in which boosting teams become competitive. So please, stop blaming the non-boosters for playing their game while you continue to play yours.
Edited by Bobaganoosh on Oct 26, 2010 21:54:56
 
Daver
offline
Link
 
Well I have read a ton of this threads and the one thing that continually comes up and goes back and forth is that "Boosters" known as Gods in there own minds, think Non Boosters have an advantage at lower and mid levels. This is because they don't build good enough dots to play later in the "Gods Chosen Ones" League stricktly for the mid level sucky players who are going on to stardom 5-6 seasons from now. So that's how Boosters feel.

Non-Boosters are livin life large and playin for the I wanna win now crowd. Why is it that Boosters would even want to be in the same league as Non Boosters then. Its so flippin simple, have two leagues. Lets see, there are PeeWees and the are low life scum I'm sure in the minds of Boosters. There are Casual leagues, these must be guys who forgot to or don't know how to retire there dots from PeeWee's, is what the Boosters think too. Then there are the D leagues, noobs and lazy dot builders as well think the Boosters. We get to the minors, just a place for boosters to go to get to the big house i guess... Not everyone plays to get to the pro or World leagues and if they did then the leagues should look like an upside down pyramid right now....

The answer is simple, two tiers between every league they have now, Boosters and Non Boosters... Here is another option, leave the current system as is or make a slight change to effective level leagues instead of just level leagues...

 
bigtisme
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bobaganoosh
Sure can and have but it doesn't seem to get through that thick skull you boosters seem to possess. I notice that you responded which means I accomplished what I wanted. It's kind of sad that I need to resort to being a 'douche' for it to be acknowledged but that's the way the cookie crumbles.


trolling at its best. I give my credit up to you.

foofighter I'm ok if that team wins who applies SP differently at level 30 no problem from me.
 
JuniorV1
offline
Link
 
I've seen some people say that boosters should have an advantage or win most of the time, may I ask why?
 
foofighter24
jumpin da snark
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bigtisme


foofighter I'm ok if that team wins who applies SP differently at level 30 no problem from me.


And how is that different from non-boosting?
 
bigtisme
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by JuniorV1
I've seen some people say that boosters should have an advantage or win most of the time, may I ask why?


because they've paid for the chance to win every season?
 
bigtisme
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by foofighter24
And how is that different from non-boosting?


one is paying 300-900FP per season to compete at their level. The other is playing (with no extra cost and full refund) against dots far younger than their own.
 
LionsLover
offline
Link
 
Quite simply this is a bad idea. I don't see how any sane person could think that alienating nonboosters is good for business. If this is a last ditch cash grab before GLB shuts down, coolness. But for long term stability you want all kinds of players to be competitive. And having nonboosters play against dots 20-30 levels higher is not a way for them to be competitive. Some nonboosters DO spend money, on CE or on more dots. One way or another, nonboosters are getting completely screwed on this system. They win Cap X minors? Go up to Cap X competitive and be crushed. Not exactly fun to have a season of dominating and then a season of being dominated. You will lose more customers this way.

The ONLY system that will work is to sort by Effective level and Normal Level and age. You can't just pick one and expect it to be ok. Here is a quick rundown of why: Sort by level, and the bad builds with super low ELs get crushed. Sort by Effective level, and nonboosters with 60+ VAs will crush similar ELs. Sort by age and day 400 nonboosters play and lose to day 400 level 73 or 74s. You can't do just one.

What I suggest is doing a point system not completely unlike the MVP system, only much better executed. A suggestion could be:

Level + Effective Level + VA points/4 (A Level 40 nonbooster with an EL of 50 and 60 VA points [15 for the formula] would be in the same league as a level 50 booster with an EL of 50 with 20 [5 formula points] VA points). Not perfect, but much better than a level 40 dot playing a level 73 dot.

Edit: There would be cap ranges of course, so a team could be in an 80 point league, and the range would be 80-100
Edited by LionsLover on Oct 26, 2010 22:02:38
 
JuniorV1
offline
Link
 
And as I've stated I've spent an average of $19.67 a month not a season since I started. I've boosted some players and kept two teams for a while. One team is all my players is that enough to entitle me to win.
 
tonylieu
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bigtisme
because they've paid for the chance to win every season?


now there you go. That is the mark of a good game design. Who cares about skill of players? Here is my 5000 flexies GLB, now give give me my lol gif trophy
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.