Yeah you're right... Who is gonna opt-out and keep their dot around? No-one.....
Voltron
offline
offline
Originally posted by SteelersFanatic
Yeah you're right... Who is gonna opt-out and keep their dot around? No-one.....
They'll opt-out and retire their dot, so that they can use the flex and not have to buy anymore.
Yeah you're right... Who is gonna opt-out and keep their dot around? No-one.....
They'll opt-out and retire their dot, so that they can use the flex and not have to buy anymore.
Stray Doug
offline
offline
I thought the 5% decline lock-in was more balanced between age 480 players and age 440 players for next couple seasons.
2.5% is better than nothing to at least restore SOME sense of balance, but why was this changed? I didn't see the explanation. Or was it just massive whining? (I also didn't see that, haven't been reading daily... but wouldn't be surprised either)
2.5% is better than nothing to at least restore SOME sense of balance, but why was this changed? I didn't see the explanation. Or was it just massive whining? (I also didn't see that, haven't been reading daily... but wouldn't be surprised either)
Voltron
offline
offline
Originally posted by Stray Doug
I thought the 5% decline lock-in was more balanced between age 480 players and age 440 players for next couple seasons.
2.5% is better than nothing to at least restore SOME sense of balance, but why was this changed? I didn't see the explanation. Or was it just massive whining? (I also didn't see that, haven't been reading daily... but wouldn't be surprised either)
With a 2.5% decline 480 players won't be able to compete with 440 players, so most will probably be retired so the flex can be used on other players.
I thought the 5% decline lock-in was more balanced between age 480 players and age 440 players for next couple seasons.
2.5% is better than nothing to at least restore SOME sense of balance, but why was this changed? I didn't see the explanation. Or was it just massive whining? (I also didn't see that, haven't been reading daily... but wouldn't be surprised either)
With a 2.5% decline 480 players won't be able to compete with 440 players, so most will probably be retired so the flex can be used on other players.
WiSeIVIaN
offline
offline
Originally posted by Voltron
Originally posted by Stray Doug
I thought the 5% decline lock-in was more balanced between age 480 players and age 440 players for next couple seasons.
2.5% is better than nothing to at least restore SOME sense of balance, but why was this changed? I didn't see the explanation. Or was it just massive whining? (I also didn't see that, haven't been reading daily... but wouldn't be surprised either)
With a 2.5% decline 480 players won't be able to compete with 440 players, so most will probably be retired so the flex can be used on other players.
They won't be able to compete?
1st year decline players have been competing extremely successfully in the World League for years. This 2.5% = worthless stuff is asinine....
Originally posted by Stray Doug
I thought the 5% decline lock-in was more balanced between age 480 players and age 440 players for next couple seasons.
2.5% is better than nothing to at least restore SOME sense of balance, but why was this changed? I didn't see the explanation. Or was it just massive whining? (I also didn't see that, haven't been reading daily... but wouldn't be surprised either)
With a 2.5% decline 480 players won't be able to compete with 440 players, so most will probably be retired so the flex can be used on other players.
They won't be able to compete?
1st year decline players have been competing extremely successfully in the World League for years. This 2.5% = worthless stuff is asinine....
Dpride59
offline
offline
Originally posted by Voltron
With a 2.5% decline 480 players won't be able to compete with 440 players, so most will probably be retired so the flex can be used on other players.
This just isn't true
With a 2.5% decline 480 players won't be able to compete with 440 players, so most will probably be retired so the flex can be used on other players.
This just isn't true
nyfoot2003
offline
offline
Originally posted by WiSeIVIaN
They won't be able to compete?
1st year decline players have been competing extremely successfully in the World League for years. This 2.5% = worthless stuff is asinine....
They are taking away the additional vet points as well. I'm not saying 2.5%=worthless, but i just don't see the point in them having it, since it was proven that when you take away the vet points, Season 5 dots are not at any advantage.
They won't be able to compete?
1st year decline players have been competing extremely successfully in the World League for years. This 2.5% = worthless stuff is asinine....
They are taking away the additional vet points as well. I'm not saying 2.5%=worthless, but i just don't see the point in them having it, since it was proven that when you take away the vet points, Season 5 dots are not at any advantage.
Dpride59
offline
offline
Originally posted by nyfoot2003
They are taking away the additional vet points as well. I'm not saying 2.5%=worthless, but i just don't see the point in them having it, since it was proven that when you take away the vet points, Season 5 dots are not at any advantage.
when you add in the 150 bt, and do the math that they are able to add +6 to a piece of aeq ask yourself is +6 throwing, and 6% pq worth losing 2.5% str and 1.25% vis conf throw. I think it is..
They are taking away the additional vet points as well. I'm not saying 2.5%=worthless, but i just don't see the point in them having it, since it was proven that when you take away the vet points, Season 5 dots are not at any advantage.
when you add in the 150 bt, and do the math that they are able to add +6 to a piece of aeq ask yourself is +6 throwing, and 6% pq worth losing 2.5% str and 1.25% vis conf throw. I think it is..
Edited by Dpride59 on Jun 27, 2010 21:16:52
nyfoot2003
offline
offline
Originally posted by Dpride59
when you add in the 150 bt, and do the math that they are able to add +6 to a piece of aeq ask yourself is +6 throwing, and 6% pq worth losing 2.5% str and 1.25% vis conf throw. I think it is..
LOL. I was one of the three people who actually did the math. Everyone else (including you, bort, DD/whoever) is going on the incorrect assumption that somehow season 5 players magically got 150 extra bonus bonus tokens.
Here is the math, AGAIN, as can be found on pages 100-112 on this thread. What bothers me isn't the 2.5% decline, but more the fact that Bort/DD make changes without actually doing the math. THey just do it randomly. I bet if they were more careful, their "fixes" of the sim and of this decline wouldn't be so counterintuitive.
Right now, every dot has had 1 season in the new training system. So a 5.0 dot has had 11 in the old, a 6.0 10, a 7.0 9.
With this plateau when each dot will have entered their extended plateau:
5.0 has 1 season new, 11 old
6.0 has 1 season new, 10 old
7.0 eventually has 2 seasons new, 9 old
8.0 3 new, 8 old
So 5.0 has one extra season of old training.
This is from jrry:
Here is the math of BTs earned in a career, I only multiplied it by 40 day seasons(even though most seasons were 56 days):
5.0 has 1 season new, 11 old = 1*120(new) + 11 * 48(old) = 648 BTs
6.0 has 1 season new, 10 old = 1*120(new) + 10 * 48(old) = 600 BTs
7.0 eventually has 2 seasons new, 9 old = 2*120(new) + 9 * 48(old) = 672 BTs
8.0 3 new, 8 old 3*120(new) + 8 * 48(old) = 744 BTs
So the advantage gained by S5 on S6 is negligible(it's like 6-10 SPs) while S7 and on have an advantage that just grows.
Now that you have read the math, could somebody please explain to me why we have this 2.5 percent decline when season 6 dots only have a 48 bonus token advantage on season 5s and are at a bonus token disadvantage to season 7s?
when you add in the 150 bt, and do the math that they are able to add +6 to a piece of aeq ask yourself is +6 throwing, and 6% pq worth losing 2.5% str and 1.25% vis conf throw. I think it is..
LOL. I was one of the three people who actually did the math. Everyone else (including you, bort, DD/whoever) is going on the incorrect assumption that somehow season 5 players magically got 150 extra bonus bonus tokens.
Here is the math, AGAIN, as can be found on pages 100-112 on this thread. What bothers me isn't the 2.5% decline, but more the fact that Bort/DD make changes without actually doing the math. THey just do it randomly. I bet if they were more careful, their "fixes" of the sim and of this decline wouldn't be so counterintuitive.
Right now, every dot has had 1 season in the new training system. So a 5.0 dot has had 11 in the old, a 6.0 10, a 7.0 9.
With this plateau when each dot will have entered their extended plateau:
5.0 has 1 season new, 11 old
6.0 has 1 season new, 10 old
7.0 eventually has 2 seasons new, 9 old
8.0 3 new, 8 old
So 5.0 has one extra season of old training.
This is from jrry:
Here is the math of BTs earned in a career, I only multiplied it by 40 day seasons(even though most seasons were 56 days):
5.0 has 1 season new, 11 old = 1*120(new) + 11 * 48(old) = 648 BTs
6.0 has 1 season new, 10 old = 1*120(new) + 10 * 48(old) = 600 BTs
7.0 eventually has 2 seasons new, 9 old = 2*120(new) + 9 * 48(old) = 672 BTs
8.0 3 new, 8 old 3*120(new) + 8 * 48(old) = 744 BTs
So the advantage gained by S5 on S6 is negligible(it's like 6-10 SPs) while S7 and on have an advantage that just grows.
Now that you have read the math, could somebody please explain to me why we have this 2.5 percent decline when season 6 dots only have a 48 bonus token advantage on season 5s and are at a bonus token disadvantage to season 7s?
Jack Kilbourne
offline
offline
Terrible move.
This completely wipes out the purpose of aging, i.e., making room for younger players to build up to the higher levels and be included in the "end game".
It also removes the need for owners and recruiters to go looking for younger talent, or at least postpones if for up to months...
If you think this is a good thing, then you have completely missed the meaning of aging players being a factor that ADDS to the game. it keeps it in flux so no one can "own" the game for seasons on end.
Take a team with 440 day old players at the end of this season. if I read it right, they can "opt-in" and basically get a free reset to all their VA. they wont train or get more VA for a period up to 120 days... that is 4 months where they lose nothing for not logging in at all, for those players, other than not being up on recent team personal tactics changes. heh.
How is this good for the game, exactly? Especially for those positions that rarely have a real tactics change.
A player around 320 days is beginning to be good enough, if built well, to play at AA level, these days. They wont have a chance, if this goes through. Even AA teams will be filling up with "plateaued" players, maybe even players dumped off AAA and Pro teams because they are a little worse than that next "plateaued" guy in line because they are higher level and NOT rotting, like they should be..
Younger players having to wait 2, 4, even 5 more seasons before being included in even AA, as this progresses. how is this good for the game?
All it does, at this point in time, is pander to those teams with super strong rosters in large farm systems who dont want to fiddle with having to actually do the work of an owner. that is, figure in chemistry lost for replacing aging players wtih new ones, and the possible drop in performance and consequently changes in tactics until they get up to snuff. Huge difference in time spent on the game, in the end, and again, how is that better? People logging in less, on a computer game. Heh heh.
Changes should improve the game and make it more interesting, not less, for those that want to log in and fiddle with things. We shouldnt be trying to make is less interesting and well, boring. Boring is bad for computer games.
Allowing these changes will make it a complete waste of time for some team owners that dont have a roster of guys all at the same age to log in and even try. Mark my words. This game will suffer, not only from vastly fewer people logging on, but fewer people talking about the game to their friends and getting THEM interested. Who talks about a game you only log in once every 3 months on. Granted that is worse case scenario...
Aging makes an average team have a better shot at the end of the season, figuring in chemistry increases from them signing youger players and losing chem at the beginning, and and old teams with the same old roster rotting away and getting worse.
Wasn't that the point of aging?
I cant even believe this is being contemplated. I really am flabbergasted. This will take sooo much out of what it actually takes to be an owner in this game. I own two teams, and if these changes become law, I very well may forget to renew ownership of my teams and let my jillion flex paying players rot in inactive hell.
Don't do this. It will hurt the game, period.
Jack
This completely wipes out the purpose of aging, i.e., making room for younger players to build up to the higher levels and be included in the "end game".
It also removes the need for owners and recruiters to go looking for younger talent, or at least postpones if for up to months...
If you think this is a good thing, then you have completely missed the meaning of aging players being a factor that ADDS to the game. it keeps it in flux so no one can "own" the game for seasons on end.
Take a team with 440 day old players at the end of this season. if I read it right, they can "opt-in" and basically get a free reset to all their VA. they wont train or get more VA for a period up to 120 days... that is 4 months where they lose nothing for not logging in at all, for those players, other than not being up on recent team personal tactics changes. heh.
How is this good for the game, exactly? Especially for those positions that rarely have a real tactics change.
A player around 320 days is beginning to be good enough, if built well, to play at AA level, these days. They wont have a chance, if this goes through. Even AA teams will be filling up with "plateaued" players, maybe even players dumped off AAA and Pro teams because they are a little worse than that next "plateaued" guy in line because they are higher level and NOT rotting, like they should be..
Younger players having to wait 2, 4, even 5 more seasons before being included in even AA, as this progresses. how is this good for the game?
All it does, at this point in time, is pander to those teams with super strong rosters in large farm systems who dont want to fiddle with having to actually do the work of an owner. that is, figure in chemistry lost for replacing aging players wtih new ones, and the possible drop in performance and consequently changes in tactics until they get up to snuff. Huge difference in time spent on the game, in the end, and again, how is that better? People logging in less, on a computer game. Heh heh.
Changes should improve the game and make it more interesting, not less, for those that want to log in and fiddle with things. We shouldnt be trying to make is less interesting and well, boring. Boring is bad for computer games.
Allowing these changes will make it a complete waste of time for some team owners that dont have a roster of guys all at the same age to log in and even try. Mark my words. This game will suffer, not only from vastly fewer people logging on, but fewer people talking about the game to their friends and getting THEM interested. Who talks about a game you only log in once every 3 months on. Granted that is worse case scenario...
Aging makes an average team have a better shot at the end of the season, figuring in chemistry increases from them signing youger players and losing chem at the beginning, and and old teams with the same old roster rotting away and getting worse.
Wasn't that the point of aging?
I cant even believe this is being contemplated. I really am flabbergasted. This will take sooo much out of what it actually takes to be an owner in this game. I own two teams, and if these changes become law, I very well may forget to renew ownership of my teams and let my jillion flex paying players rot in inactive hell.
Don't do this. It will hurt the game, period.
Jack
Edited by Jack Kilbourne on Jun 27, 2010 23:49:30
Edited by Jack Kilbourne on Jun 27, 2010 23:48:46
More players available at higher levels instead of retiring an replacing with 360 day old builds leaving 300 day old builds in AA is NOT mo bad!
The MORE these top teams keep their plateau'd players the GREATER chance AAA and AA have to fill rosters with 50+ builds instead of competing with Pro/WL teams recruiting who would need a roster reset every 2 seasons in the current system.
The MORE these top teams keep their plateau'd players the GREATER chance AAA and AA have to fill rosters with 50+ builds instead of competing with Pro/WL teams recruiting who would need a roster reset every 2 seasons in the current system.
Hagalaz
offline
offline
Originally posted by nyfoot2003
What bothers me isn't the 2.5% decline, but more the fact that Bort/DD make changes without actually doing the math. THey just do it randomly.
This right here is the biggest problem GLB design ever had, and will always have since they aren't interested in changing. It's a pity though. The game could be so much better...
What bothers me isn't the 2.5% decline, but more the fact that Bort/DD make changes without actually doing the math. THey just do it randomly.
This right here is the biggest problem GLB design ever had, and will always have since they aren't interested in changing. It's a pity though. The game could be so much better...
Dpride59
offline
offline
Originally posted by nyfoot2003
So the advantage gained by S5 on S6 is negligible(it's like 6-10 SPs) while S7 and on have an advantage that just grows.
lol... The s7's will only be there for 1 season vs the s5's.... Also s8 will only have 1 more season in the new system then the s7's so on and so on. They balanced it pretty well, but the fact is those s7's while getting some relief aren't going to be OMG So much better than anyone,
Originally posted by nyfoot2003
season 6 dots only have a 48 bonus token advantage on season 5s and are at a bonus token disadvantage to season 7s
Because every dot going forward is going to be at a slight disadvantage vs the next seasons dots because GLB rolled out a new training system, seriously cry less plz
So the advantage gained by S5 on S6 is negligible(it's like 6-10 SPs) while S7 and on have an advantage that just grows.
lol... The s7's will only be there for 1 season vs the s5's.... Also s8 will only have 1 more season in the new system then the s7's so on and so on. They balanced it pretty well, but the fact is those s7's while getting some relief aren't going to be OMG So much better than anyone,
Originally posted by nyfoot2003
season 6 dots only have a 48 bonus token advantage on season 5s and are at a bonus token disadvantage to season 7s
Because every dot going forward is going to be at a slight disadvantage vs the next seasons dots because GLB rolled out a new training system, seriously cry less plz
codegod8
offline
offline
dpride and Kai defending this move because it will benefit Blaze/Kai... dont get your vision clouded here anyone. These guys dont do anything for the better of GLB.
Dpride59
offline
offline
Originally posted by codegod8
dpride and Kai defending this move because it will benefit Blaze/Kai... dont get your vision clouded here anyone. These guys dont do anything for the better of GLB.
Lol!!! I was the loudest person bashing the 1st proposal which would have benefited me more than anyone.... I was fighting hard for a system that would have staggered training points to every player in the game for 100% mathematical balance, if you weren't a complete troll you would read this thread and see that all I wanted was balance
dpride and Kai defending this move because it will benefit Blaze/Kai... dont get your vision clouded here anyone. These guys dont do anything for the better of GLB.
Lol!!! I was the loudest person bashing the 1st proposal which would have benefited me more than anyone.... I was fighting hard for a system that would have staggered training points to every player in the game for 100% mathematical balance, if you weren't a complete troll you would read this thread and see that all I wanted was balance
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.






























