User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Test Server Discussion
Page:
 
panther17
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade


It isn't about the exploits. I think most people have faith in the testers to report those, and have them fixed.

The problem a lot of people have with it is the things that are NOT exploits. It is knowing the intricacies of every attribute and SA in the game within an hour or so of testing.


 
Nuge20
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by gart888
Originally posted by Nuge20

Originally posted by Bort


Originally posted by wombat killer



Originally posted by Bort




Originally posted by Catullus 16





Originally posted by Bort






- We have basically set up a bunch of prototype built players, and we've been running test games to find plays that cause problems with the current blocking AI and such. It's been helpful to find problems and address them, especially since I can be proactive and try ideas and get feedback on a daily basis from a group of people who are mature and helpful.


just to clarify: are you saying testers can't create their own test builds?

this would alleviate quite a bit of the concern, although by no means all...


Sorta...we basically have a bunch of test teams with different prototypes we've set up, and we play them against each other with various AI settings and versions of sim code I upload.



Sorta? Yes or no. Can testers build or adjust players?


Yes, we can create player prototypes to add them to test teams. Hmm...let's see. Somehow we are supposed to test the game without being able to create players and know what their abilities are? How in the heck would that work?


I see no issue with this, if an exploit is found by a tester it is fixed so the testers arent really getting an advantage


o_O

Come on man, you've gotta be smarter than that.


I understand what people are saying but as a team owner, OC, and agent I dont see how knowing the difference between 0 and 15 shock block is beneficial if it is not super powerful...it will help slightly but for the most part the testing is for extreme cases (140 throwing QBs or 100 vision HBs etc)
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by gart888
Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by DrkSandman


Originally posted by jamz



Originally posted by DrkSandman





Why? We got beat down in the conference finals. Good thing that inside knowledge helped us, right?

/sarcasm


Curiousity, I already know of 2. I could care less either way we went 8-8. It's just interesting to me is all. PM me if you like, I'm not implying anything.


Oh, I know bro. But, as Bort said - releasing the names of the testers right now would just lead to flaming, massive PMs, etc.

Which, is really shitty because I'm telling you that some of these guys have been busting their asses to do good for the game.

That's why I'm so irritated. I understand people's concerns, but they really have nothing to worry about.


I agree 100%. Some of the guys involved have really been putting in a lot of time and effort to try and help me out as I try different stuff, and I really don't want to see them get dumped on.


How can you guys say this with any degree of certainty?

If i just came out and told you that one of the testers has been leaking me information would that make you take this seriously?


It should and it wouldn't surprise me if one of the testers had more motives for doing it then just helping the game.

 
Saris
offline
Link
 
In some games it's a player's coordination, reaction time and skill that sets them apart, in this game it's ALL about information.

For a typical player to test something it can take months and an obscene amount of FP's/$... and that's just to test one concept. Or if we wanted to test something on an existing player, well the player is toast and getting retired if the test didn't go as planned.

The best comparison I can make would be if you were playing an FPS and ran into a select group who could move at 3x your speed. If it was impossible to retroactively slow them down, you'd have to speed everyone else up. So the best solution would be either a public test server or a major disclosure of game info, ie what exactly do the different SA's do, what plays into different coefficients etc. If they're so concerned with balancing the game and eliminating potential exploits wouldn't it go 1000000x faster if the thousands of players currently playing knew a little more about the game and had the ability to help in the testing?


 
ress5609
offline
Link
 
blarg. so hard to get a specific question answered.
 
The Duff Man
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by gart888


How can you guys say this with any degree of certainty?

If i just came out and told you that one of the testers has been leaking me information would that make you take this seriously?


Ouch

 
Nuge20
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by panther17
Originally posted by Deathblade



It isn't about the exploits. I think most people have faith in the testers to report those, and have them fixed.

The problem a lot of people have with it is the things that are NOT exploits. It is knowing the intricacies of every attribute and SA in the game within an hour or so of testing.




this actually makes sense
 
Link
 
Originally posted by krwynn
Originally posted by Brutus Buckeye

This has turned into the biggest cluster F* I have ever seen. WOW People see conspiracy around every corner.

Bort and the testers I commend you for trying to do things right.


Thank you for your Mod/Admin/Tester application. It will be reviewed at a later time. Thanks again for applying.


Should have expected that. Not applying for anything. I enjoy playing the game and unlike a lot of people on here I know that things have to be tested, you would have to be a naive fool to think that people on here are not doing some of the testing. But I will let you conspiracy theorists get back to your work. Hey after this is over maybe we can figure out who shot Kennedy, I think Bort and Thorn were on the grassy knoll!
 
TerrellOwns
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by DrkSandman

Originally posted by jamz


Originally posted by DrkSandman




Why? We got beat down in the conference finals. Good thing that inside knowledge helped us, right?

/sarcasm


Curiousity, I already know of 2. I could care less either way we went 8-8. It's just interesting to me is all. PM me if you like, I'm not implying anything.


Oh, I know bro. But, as Bort said - releasing the names of the testers right now would just lead to flaming, massive PMs, etc.

Which, is really shitty because I'm telling you that some of these guys have been busting their asses to do good for the game.

That's why I'm so irritated. I understand people's concerns, but they really have nothing to worry about.


I agree 100%. Some of the guys involved have really been putting in a lot of time and effort to try and help me out as I try different stuff, and I really don't want to see them get dumped on.


How would this really injure them? If anything, they would be more sought after for their secret information. Until then, any long-time player who fits your description will be under suspicion. Either keep the "testers" out of the real game, or let everyone know who they are and reap the consequences.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by wombat killer

Originally posted by Bort


Originally posted by Catullus 16



Originally posted by Bort




- We have basically set up a bunch of prototype built players, and we've been running test games to find plays that cause problems with the current blocking AI and such. It's been helpful to find problems and address them, especially since I can be proactive and try ideas and get feedback on a daily basis from a group of people who are mature and helpful.


just to clarify: are you saying testers can't create their own test builds?

this would alleviate quite a bit of the concern, although by no means all...


Sorta...we basically have a bunch of test teams with different prototypes we've set up, and we play them against each other with various AI settings and versions of sim code I upload.



Sorta? Yes or no. Can testers build or adjust players?


Yes, we can create player prototypes to add them to test teams. Hmm...let's see. Somehow we are supposed to test the game without being able to create players and know what their abilities are? How in the heck would that work?


Dont get snotty when you use words like sorta. You open yourself up to that sort of question.
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Nuge20
Originally posted by gart888

Originally posted by Nuge20


Originally posted by Bort



Originally posted by wombat killer




Originally posted by Bort





Originally posted by Catullus 16






Originally posted by Bort







- We have basically set up a bunch of prototype built players, and we've been running test games to find plays that cause problems with the current blocking AI and such. It's been helpful to find problems and address them, especially since I can be proactive and try ideas and get feedback on a daily basis from a group of people who are mature and helpful.


just to clarify: are you saying testers can't create their own test builds?

this would alleviate quite a bit of the concern, although by no means all...


Sorta...we basically have a bunch of test teams with different prototypes we've set up, and we play them against each other with various AI settings and versions of sim code I upload.



Sorta? Yes or no. Can testers build or adjust players?


Yes, we can create player prototypes to add them to test teams. Hmm...let's see. Somehow we are supposed to test the game without being able to create players and know what their abilities are? How in the heck would that work?


I see no issue with this, if an exploit is found by a tester it is fixed so the testers arent really getting an advantage


o_O

Come on man, you've gotta be smarter than that.


I understand what people are saying but as a team owner, OC, and agent I dont see how knowing the difference between 0 and 15 shock block is beneficial if it is not super powerful...it will help slightly but for the most part the testing is for extreme cases (140 throwing QBs or 100 vision HBs etc)


Say they find out that 10 SAs that most people think are fairly useless, are great and let their teammates know...do you honestly think they aren't getting an edge on the competition?

 
DrkSandman
Baseballs
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by The Duff Man

To clarify. They CAN'T do this. Or they AREN'T doing this. Because there is a big difference. And if the answer is AREN'T how do you know? And hopefully the answer isn't "because they are upstanding members of the GLB community who would never try to take advantage of this situation"


I pay quite a bit of attention to what the other testers are doing. There aren't that many, tbh, so it isn't really hard to do.

That still doesn't prove anything to you, so I dunno what to tell you bro.
 
awesome
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by panther17
Originally posted by Deathblade



It isn't about the exploits. I think most people have faith in the testers to report those, and have them fixed.

The problem a lot of people have with it is the things that are NOT exploits. It is knowing the intricacies of every attribute and SA in the game within an hour or so of testing.




Why are they refusing to address the main issue?
 
tantrix
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
Originally posted by Koncorde

Originally posted by awesome


Originally posted by Bort

Yes, we can create player prototypes to add them to test teams. Hmm...let's see. Somehow we are supposed to test the game without being able to create players and know what their abilities are? How in the heck would that work?


It wouldn't work. The question is why is the information gleaned from this testing kept secret from the rest of the paying userbase?


Because nothing has been found yet that can be used?


It isn't about the exploits. I think most people have faith in the testers to report those, and have them fixed.

The problem a lot of people have with it is the things that are NOT exploits. It is knowing the intricacies of every attribute and SA in the game within an hour or so of testing.


exactly
 
tycoon34
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by wombat killer

Originally posted by Bort


Originally posted by Catullus 16



Originally posted by Bort




- We have basically set up a bunch of prototype built players, and we've been running test games to find plays that cause problems with the current blocking AI and such. It's been helpful to find problems and address them, especially since I can be proactive and try ideas and get feedback on a daily basis from a group of people who are mature and helpful.


just to clarify: are you saying testers can't create their own test builds?

this would alleviate quite a bit of the concern, although by no means all...


Sorta...we basically have a bunch of test teams with different prototypes we've set up, and we play them against each other with various AI settings and versions of sim code I upload.



Sorta? Yes or no. Can testers build or adjust players?


Yes, we can create player prototypes to add them to test teams. Hmm...let's see. Somehow we are supposed to test the game without being able to create players and know what their abilities are? How in the heck would that work?


Im so glad the owner of the game we put a ton of money it gives us answers like this. Dude--you evaded the question until someone asked you directly and then you gave them shit for it?
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.