Originally posted by Asheme
Originally posted by Catullus 16
that's an interesting view. i'm sure if i knew as much about the test server as you apparently do, i'd probably agree.
but i don't. that's the point.
Therein lies the rub. I don't know anything about the test server, or didn't before this whole made-up fiasco. What I know is how the moderation/administration structure operates, and what the decision-making process is like. Thus the entire situation seemed innocuous to me from jumpstreet.
and that's perfectly valid -- like i've said before, this entire situation is built on trust. even if the admins/mods/testers all completely trust each other, that doesn't mean the customers share that trust.
if we do away with the secrecy aspect (and i hope we have), that will calm quite a few fears about why there was secrecy in the first place. it would be great to know to our satisfaction that there actually wasn't anything to hide, but rebuilding that level of trust requires information... not raw claims from testers. at this point, the userbase deserves facts.
also, none of this really addresses any ethical concerns. things can be as "innocuous" as ever, but that doesn't mean that key people are recognizing deep ethical issues. they may think they're innocent -- we customers can legitimately disagree.
Last edited Feb 15, 2009 20:55:44