User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Test Server Discussion
Page:
 
Gart888
things!
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Nuge20
Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by wombat killer


Originally posted by Bort



Originally posted by Catullus 16




Originally posted by Bort





- We have basically set up a bunch of prototype built players, and we've been running test games to find plays that cause problems with the current blocking AI and such. It's been helpful to find problems and address them, especially since I can be proactive and try ideas and get feedback on a daily basis from a group of people who are mature and helpful.


just to clarify: are you saying testers can't create their own test builds?

this would alleviate quite a bit of the concern, although by no means all...


Sorta...we basically have a bunch of test teams with different prototypes we've set up, and we play them against each other with various AI settings and versions of sim code I upload.



Sorta? Yes or no. Can testers build or adjust players?


Yes, we can create player prototypes to add them to test teams. Hmm...let's see. Somehow we are supposed to test the game without being able to create players and know what their abilities are? How in the heck would that work?


I see no issue with this, if an exploit is found by a tester it is fixed so the testers arent really getting an advantage


O_o

Come on man, you've gotta be smarter than that.
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Yes, we can create player prototypes to add them to test teams. Hmm...let's see. Somehow we are supposed to test the game without being able to create players and know what their abilities are? How in the heck would that work?


do the testers know the specific builds of the prototypes they're working with?

i understand that they could tell which players are faster by context, but are they just reporting to you what happened when Team #1 and Team #10 played each other? or are they telling you that a specific SA is overpowered, etc?
 
ress5609
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort

Yes, we can create player prototypes to add them to test teams. Hmm...let's see. Somehow we are supposed to test the game without being able to create players and know what their abilities are? How in the heck would that work?


Well then do you mind addressing this concern?

Originally posted by Deathblade
Originally posted by Bort

Sorta...we basically have a bunch of test teams with different prototypes we've set up, and we play them against each other with various AI settings and versions of sim code I upload.


The main problem is the thought that for example, someone can try a player with 0 shock block, then try the same exact player in the same sim with 15 shock block, and know exactly what it is and how it works. Now they can do that with every SA in the game, and every attribute for every position.

That gives a HUGE advantage over normal people that it would take 8 months and several thousands of dollars to try it, and still not get an accurate answer.

 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by wombat killer

Originally posted by Bort


Originally posted by Catullus 16



Originally posted by Bort




- We have basically set up a bunch of prototype built players, and we've been running test games to find plays that cause problems with the current blocking AI and such. It's been helpful to find problems and address them, especially since I can be proactive and try ideas and get feedback on a daily basis from a group of people who are mature and helpful.


just to clarify: are you saying testers can't create their own test builds?

this would alleviate quite a bit of the concern, although by no means all...


Sorta...we basically have a bunch of test teams with different prototypes we've set up, and we play them against each other with various AI settings and versions of sim code I upload.



Sorta? Yes or no. Can testers build or adjust players?


Yes, we can create player prototypes to add them to test teams. Hmm...let's see. Somehow we are supposed to test the game without being able to create players and know what their abilities are? How in the heck would that work?


No need to be condescending towards your customers but the main concern is that people will exploit this and create players to test out how they could improve their builds the most before they boost or that these people will get to know what updates are being made(say Power RBs are being weakened) before the general population, thus giving them a jump on fixing their builds up. Can those things happen?

 
TerrellOwns
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by DrkSandman
Originally posted by jamz

Originally posted by DrkSandman



Why? We got beat down in the conference finals. Good thing that inside knowledge helped us, right?

/sarcasm


Curiousity, I already know of 2. I could care less either way we went 8-8. It's just interesting to me is all. PM me if you like, I'm not implying anything.


Oh, I know bro. But, as Bort said - releasing the names of the testers right now would just lead to flaming, massive PMs, etc.

Which, is really shitty because I'm telling you that some of these guys have been busting their asses to do good for the game.

That's why I'm so irritated. I understand people's concerns, but they really have nothing to worry about.


And in exchange for "busting their asses", they get an unfair, unknown advantage for their teams. Even under the most naive, most innocent of assumptions these players have a big advantage. How can any result be taken seriously when potentially just about anyone could be a "tester"?
 
the man of doom
Miracles happen
offline
Link
 
so is an annoucement coming up about this?
 
Skeptikal
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by wombat killer
Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by wombat killer


Originally posted by Bort



Originally posted by Catullus 16




Originally posted by Bort





- We have basically set up a bunch of prototype built players, and we've been running test games to find plays that cause problems with the current blocking AI and such. It's been helpful to find problems and address them, especially since I can be proactive and try ideas and get feedback on a daily basis from a group of people who are mature and helpful.


just to clarify: are you saying testers can't create their own test builds?

this would alleviate quite a bit of the concern, although by no means all...


Sorta...we basically have a bunch of test teams with different prototypes we've set up, and we play them against each other with various AI settings and versions of sim code I upload.



Sorta? Yes or no. Can testers build or adjust players?


Yes, we can create player prototypes to add them to test teams. Hmm...let's see. Somehow we are supposed to test the game without being able to create players and know what their abilities are? How in the heck would that work?


You are missing the point. No one has issues with testing. Its who is testing and what knowledge they can gain. Is that really so hard to understand?


 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Koncorde
Originally posted by awesome

Originally posted by Bort
Yes, we can create player prototypes to add them to test teams. Hmm...let's see. Somehow we are supposed to test the game without being able to create players and know what their abilities are? How in the heck would that work?


It wouldn't work. The question is why is the information gleaned from this testing kept secret from the rest of the paying userbase?


Because nothing has been found yet that can be used?


It isn't about the exploits. I think most people have faith in the testers to report those, and have them fixed.

The problem a lot of people have with it is the things that are NOT exploits. It is knowing the intricacies of every attribute and SA in the game within an hour or so of testing.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by DrkSandman
Originally posted by jamz

Originally posted by DrkSandman



Why? We got beat down in the conference finals. Good thing that inside knowledge helped us, right?

/sarcasm


Curiousity, I already know of 2. I could care less either way we went 8-8. It's just interesting to me is all. PM me if you like, I'm not implying anything.


Oh, I know bro. But, as Bort said - releasing the names of the testers right now would just lead to flaming, massive PMs, etc.

Which, is really shitty because I'm telling you that some of these guys have been busting their asses to do good for the game.

That's why I'm so irritated. I understand people's concerns, but they really have nothing to worry about.


Agreed, but it the perception that those testers can make notes on what they tested and take from the "TEST" environment to the "PRODUCTION" environment. This is what I think most are upset about. It is that these "chosen" few have the ability to circumvent the playing field.
 
CinTex
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by DrkSandman


Oh, I know bro. But, as Bort said - releasing the names of the testers right now would just lead to flaming, massive PMs, etc.

Which, is really shitty because I'm telling you that some of these guys have been busting their asses to do good for the game.

That's why I'm so irritated. I understand people's concerns, but they really have nothing to worry about.


Easy for you to say, you are on the inside... why don't you let the mob pick one tester and let them tell us whether we should worry or not?....
 
Gart888
things!
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by DrkSandman

Originally posted by jamz


Originally posted by DrkSandman




Why? We got beat down in the conference finals. Good thing that inside knowledge helped us, right?

/sarcasm


Curiousity, I already know of 2. I could care less either way we went 8-8. It's just interesting to me is all. PM me if you like, I'm not implying anything.


Oh, I know bro. But, as Bort said - releasing the names of the testers right now would just lead to flaming, massive PMs, etc.

Which, is really shitty because I'm telling you that some of these guys have been busting their asses to do good for the game.

That's why I'm so irritated. I understand people's concerns, but they really have nothing to worry about.


I agree 100%. Some of the guys involved have really been putting in a lot of time and effort to try and help me out as I try different stuff, and I really don't want to see them get dumped on.


How can you guys say this with any degree of certainty?

If i just came out and told you that one of the testers has been leaking me information would that make you take this seriously?
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by DrkSandman
Oh, I know bro. But, as Bort said - releasing the names of the testers right now would just lead to flaming, massive PMs, etc.
Which, is really shitty because I'm telling you that some of these guys have been busting their asses to do good for the game.
That's why I'm so irritated. I understand people's concerns, but they really have nothing to worry about.

I agree 100%. Some of the guys involved have really been putting in a lot of time and effort to try and help me out as I try different stuff, and I really don't want to see them get dumped on.


given the tenor of this thread, i agree.

but perhaps this current group of testers should be dismissed, and then a new group brought on that's willing to have their status made public.
 
HootyHoo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TerrellOwns

And in exchange for "busting their asses", they get an unfair, unknown advantage for their teams. Even under the most naive, most innocent of assumptions these players have a big advantage. How can any result be taken seriously when potentially just about anyone could be a "tester"?


Exactly.

 
tantrix
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by McGrai37
Originally posted by Bort

We have basically set up a bunch of prototype built players, and we've been running test games to find plays that cause problems with the current blocking AI and such. It's been helpful to find problems and address them, especially since I can be proactive and try ideas and get feedback on a daily basis from a group of people who are mature and helpful.


So testers aren't able to tinker with builds, only AI/playbooks?


Originally posted by Pariah
Originally posted by AgentTBC

Originally posted by Norsemanvike


Originally posted by tpaterniti



Originally posted by ress5609




Originally posted by AgentTBC





Well, yeah, obviously at this point the most necessary thing is transparency: People need to know exactly what these testers can do. Specifically, the following:

1) Can testers see the builds of other players in the game?
2) Can testers create players with whatever stats they want and test them in games?
3) Can testers set up scrimmage games with existing GLB teams, modify the offense/defensive tactics, and see the results?

Those three things are critical knowledge. Any of them are just begging for abuse; all of them would be disastrous from a PR standpoint.


this imo. i don't care who the testers were. i just want to know IF they're truly being given an unfair advantage or not.



1. No, absolutely not.
2. Yes wouldn't be much of a test site otherwise
3. No, absolutely not.



Confirmed.


Excellent, thanks.

I posted in another thread that I've been involved in online games (MMORPGs, etc) in one way or another for most of two decades. Some of that was in a dev-like environment where I had access to the game code and such. With that background, I can guarantee you that you're underestimating how many people are using knowledge they are getting to their advantage.

I'm not saying they're going out of their way to cheat or anything; I'm saying that they will have done things like test two players with virtually the same stats except one has 30 more vision or 30 more confidence than the other, and they will have seen how much better the guy with extra vision plays. Then they'll have mentioned to their friends, in passing, "hey vision really is underrated/overrated" at that position", and their friends will know they're basing this on first-hand knowledge.

Is that absolutely game-breaking? No. Are you underplaying the potential and actuality of abuse? Almost certainly. It doesn't matter how honest the testers are; if they're also players they'll use it to their advantage, in a major way or a minor one.

The way to lessen than is to keep logs of all the tests they run. Somebody constantly testing how players with 200 strength, agility, and speed will break the game are not finding advantages. Testers who are running a lot of sims where players are similar but some have slightly higher of various stats ARE finding advantages. It's not that hard to tell; take it from me, I used to find people doing similar things.

My guess is that nobody is bothering to do that sort of oversight.



Good info, thx.
..................
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Nuge20
Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by wombat killer


Originally posted by Bort



Originally posted by Catullus 16




Originally posted by Bort





- We have basically set up a bunch of prototype built players, and we've been running test games to find plays that cause problems with the current blocking AI and such. It's been helpful to find problems and address them, especially since I can be proactive and try ideas and get feedback on a daily basis from a group of people who are mature and helpful.


just to clarify: are you saying testers can't create their own test builds?

this would alleviate quite a bit of the concern, although by no means all...


Sorta...we basically have a bunch of test teams with different prototypes we've set up, and we play them against each other with various AI settings and versions of sim code I upload.



Sorta? Yes or no. Can testers build or adjust players?


Yes, we can create player prototypes to add them to test teams. Hmm...let's see. Somehow we are supposed to test the game without being able to create players and know what their abilities are? How in the heck would that work?


I see no issue with this, if an exploit is found by a tester it is fixed so the testers arent really getting an advantage


Yes, that's the whole friggin' point. I want to test and fix stuff BEFORE it goes live so the rest of the membership base doesn't have to be testers, which many of you have expressed being tired of.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.