User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > GLB Insider: The truth behind all the teams leaving.
Page:
 
Link
 
Originally posted by drifter
Lots of reasons. Here are what I think the ones that need to be addressed are:

League imbalances - No one likes spending half your schedule winning by 100 pts or more. Teams on the other end of the spectrum don't like having to go 2 seasons of getting beat up before they land among their peers.

Overexpansion - Everybody and their mom wanted a team. Now Mom finds out it's not as fun as she thought and is leaving. Maintain strong demand for teams and don't overexpand and this doesn't happen. Some type of Qualifying for teams would help.

Boredom and Expense at higher levels - Levelling up twice a season (not counting boosts) doesn't keep people checking back in on their Center. Also NEEDING to boost your entire stable at higher levels to stay competitive (2.x level gain vs 5.x level gain per season). Boosting should cut off after your fourth season, encouraging people to create new players. Combined with my idea for Prestige Attributes beginning at Level 30, you'll keep Agents fresh and interested.


The first two are "meh" but the last point is interesting. As long as it's cut off for everyone at or around year 5, I could see it being viable.
 
drifter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
Originally posted by drifter

Lots of reasons. Here are what I think the ones that need to be addressed are:

League imbalances - No one likes spending half your schedule winning by 100 pts or more. Teams on the other end of the spectrum don't like having to go 2 seasons of getting beat up before they land among their peers.

Overexpansion - Everybody and their mom wanted a team. Now Mom finds out it's not as fun as she thought and is leaving. Maintain strong demand for teams and don't overexpand and this doesn't happen. Some type of Qualifying for teams would help.

Boredom and Expense at higher levels - Levelling up twice a season (not counting boosts) doesn't keep people checking back in on their Center. Also NEEDING to boost your entire stable at higher levels to stay competitive (2.x level gain vs 5.x level gain per season). Boosting should cut off after your fourth season, encouraging people to create new players. Combined with my idea for Prestige Attributes beginning at Level 30, you'll keep Agents fresh and interested.


The first two are "meh" but the last point is interesting. As long as it's cut off for everyone at or around year 5, I could see it being viable.


I guarantee you #1 is not meh. Teams are leaving because it's no fun playing in an imbalanced league.
 
Tito716
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by drifter
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder

Originally posted by drifter


Lots of reasons. Here are what I think the ones that need to be addressed are:

League imbalances - No one likes spending half your schedule winning by 100 pts or more. Teams on the other end of the spectrum don't like having to go 2 seasons of getting beat up before they land among their peers.

Overexpansion - Everybody and their mom wanted a team. Now Mom finds out it's not as fun as she thought and is leaving. Maintain strong demand for teams and don't overexpand and this doesn't happen. Some type of Qualifying for teams would help.

Boredom and Expense at higher levels - Levelling up twice a season (not counting boosts) doesn't keep people checking back in on their Center. Also NEEDING to boost your entire stable at higher levels to stay competitive (2.x level gain vs 5.x level gain per season). Boosting should cut off after your fourth season, encouraging people to create new players. Combined with my idea for Prestige Attributes beginning at Level 30, you'll keep Agents fresh and interested.


The first two are "meh" but the last point is interesting. As long as it's cut off for everyone at or around year 5, I could see it being viable.


I guarantee you #1 is not meh. Teams are leaving because it's no fun playing in an imbalanced league.


I doubt very strongly that the teams winning by 100 every week have as much of a problem with it as the teams losing by 100 every week.
 
LionsLover
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder


Originally posted by


The deck is stacked. Have you looked at free agency threads? Every 'B' quality player or better has countless offers thrown at them. If you settle for lesser players, guess what? You lose! All season. Then relegate and no one wants to be on your team, free agent or otherwise.

It's a vicious cycle.


Yeah, it seems like you might indeed be paying too much for your players. Anything more then the min. required for training and equip is wasting money. If they ask for it, just tell them no.



And then you go into the season with no roster. I have a good team, and it's impossible for me to sign anyone of a decent level for a decent price. The closest I had to signing a decent player was offering him double the minimum salary I usually offer and double the SB he needed for his next upgrades. And he still didn't sign.
 
Otega
12th MIManITW
offline
Link
 
The reality is, the system currently in place, for leagues, is inherently flawed. And there is no good solution to fix it.

-Leveling from 1-21 is too fast
-Leveling from 25 + is too slow
-There is little to no separation from AA to AAA to Pro, in terms of levels (with the exception of teams with players who have played since day 1, in essence giving them a level advantage that cannot be overcome due to the way you level at 25+)
-Expansion teams starting, at basically level 13.9, has killed any chance to relieve that lack of separation.
-There is no real motivation to get from AA to the Pro's, other than E-Fame.

The sad truth is that the entire game would need a serious overhaul in order to fix the problems it currently has. And that is something that I would assume 90% of the players would rage against.

But, if it were to happen, this is how it would need to be, IMHO
-No D leagues
-Expansion teams start with players at level 1, and are not allowed to boost in season 1 until the end of the regular season. This would put a premium on managing depth charts, playing time, etc IE LEARNING THE GAME.
-Depth Chats on those teams would be required to have a minimum of 1 starter and 1 backup, thus forcing teams to a) fill out their roster in the proper fashion of a football team and b) not allow for making maxing xp, and not winning, the goal.
-Gutted/sold teams would move down to the "A" level, while MORE than just the conference champions would be allowed to move up, creating better competition and parity at the higher levels by filling the voids. This is something that is sorely needed at this point.
-Owners would be forced to have multiple GM's, thus voiding out the "inactive" owner issues when it comes to teams getting stuck with no chance to keep their team winning because they can't change the AUI for O/D/, DC, etc.
-Gm's would stay as GM's, if a team is sold and taken over by the CPU, and have all the privileges they had previous, in order to work to keep the team afloat.
-Interim owners would be allowed, again, in the same fashion of the GM's.
-There would need to be more than monetary compensation for winning your league. I dunno what the motivation could be, but something other than a small trophy on your bio page (after all, there are tons of guys who deserve that trophy, then tons of people who had absolutely nothing to do with the team that won one, IE scotch cocks)
-League names need to be changed. No offense, but any reasonable adult can see that it's utterly ridiculous to think that somehow, any team in a league with "USA" are somehow automatically better than teams in other leagues.


Other than all that, i dunno what else can be done to keep people interested. When i search around the different forums, the one good thing I see is that there are a TON of owners and agents alike, who are passionate about football and about this sim. And that's the telling sign that a lot of people aren't just going to leave. But at the same time, steps need to be taken to insure long-term success and playability.

Just my humble opinions.

 
Link
 
Originally posted by drifter
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder

Originally posted by drifter


Lots of reasons. Here are what I think the ones that need to be addressed are:

League imbalances - No one likes spending half your schedule winning by 100 pts or more. Teams on the other end of the spectrum don't like having to go 2 seasons of getting beat up before they land among their peers.

Overexpansion - Everybody and their mom wanted a team. Now Mom finds out it's not as fun as she thought and is leaving. Maintain strong demand for teams and don't overexpand and this doesn't happen. Some type of Qualifying for teams would help.

Boredom and Expense at higher levels - Levelling up twice a season (not counting boosts) doesn't keep people checking back in on their Center. Also NEEDING to boost your entire stable at higher levels to stay competitive (2.x level gain vs 5.x level gain per season). Boosting should cut off after your fourth season, encouraging people to create new players. Combined with my idea for Prestige Attributes beginning at Level 30, you'll keep Agents fresh and interested.


The first two are "meh" but the last point is interesting. As long as it's cut off for everyone at or around year 5, I could see it being viable.


I guarantee you #1 is not meh. Teams are leaving because it's no fun playing in an imbalanced league.


And that's why it's "meh", there's nothing that can be done about it. As soon as we start moving teams around at random, people will get pissed because their league isn't stable. I know it'd be pissed if we suddendly got a bunch of random teams in my league.

Are we going to move them the moment they get gutted? Does the owner have to apply or does Bort have to patrol each league and arbitrarily decide when teams qualify for the gutting "dump"?

There are far too many variables here.
 
Tito716
offline
Link
 
Double Post - Sorry.

I'm curious about how many people would stay on the wait list if bort announced there would be no NEW teams this offseason.

There are a tremendous amount of potential owners that want nothing to do with a resold team. How many of them would stay on the list. Would they eventually give up on a NEW team and take a resold team, or would they give up on ownership altogether?
 
drhoades
offline
Link
 
Didn't read the entire thread because its facking long. A couple of my problems with the game are:

1. Once your players get to a certain level there isn't much to do.
2. Leveling slows way down in the 20s and by this time if you have messed up your build or if changes are made to the game, there isn't much you can do to change your build.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by LionsLover
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder



Originally posted by



The deck is stacked. Have you looked at free agency threads? Every 'B' quality player or better has countless offers thrown at them. If you settle for lesser players, guess what? You lose! All season. Then relegate and no one wants to be on your team, free agent or otherwise.

It's a vicious cycle.


Yeah, it seems like you might indeed be paying too much for your players. Anything more then the min. required for training and equip is wasting money. If they ask for it, just tell them no.



And then you go into the season with no roster. I have a good team, and it's impossible for me to sign anyone of a decent level for a decent price. The closest I had to signing a decent player was offering him double the minimum salary I usually offer and double the SB he needed for his next upgrades. And he still didn't sign.


Yep, def an issue with players. That sucks that you didn't find any good ones, keep looking I guess.
 
F8n4tune
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Tito716
Originally posted by drifter

Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder


Originally posted by drifter



Lots of reasons. Here are what I think the ones that need to be addressed are:

League imbalances - No one likes spending half your schedule winning by 100 pts or more. Teams on the other end of the spectrum don't like having to go 2 seasons of getting beat up before they land among their peers.

Overexpansion - Everybody and their mom wanted a team. Now Mom finds out it's not as fun as she thought and is leaving. Maintain strong demand for teams and don't overexpand and this doesn't happen. Some type of Qualifying for teams would help.

Boredom and Expense at higher levels - Levelling up twice a season (not counting boosts) doesn't keep people checking back in on their Center. Also NEEDING to boost your entire stable at higher levels to stay competitive (2.x level gain vs 5.x level gain per season). Boosting should cut off after your fourth season, encouraging people to create new players. Combined with my idea for Prestige Attributes beginning at Level 30, you'll keep Agents fresh and interested.


The first two are "meh" but the last point is interesting. As long as it's cut off for everyone at or around year 5, I could see it being viable.


I guarantee you #1 is not meh. Teams are leaving because it's no fun playing in an imbalanced league.


I doubt very strongly that the teams winning by 100 every week have as much of a problem with it as the teams losing by 100 every week.


I for one have a HB that got like 9 td's in game and had several others with crazy td totals and i'll tell you it sucks ass. I have offered the back up to play in games like those. It's stupid and anyone who likes to be a part of those type games is not having fun and aren't into competition imho.

 
Outlaw Dogs
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by supp0007


2.) A person should only be allowed to GM for one team


first I saw this and wanted to comment on it without reading any farther. I am a GM of two teams, the first, BLPP is where I cut my teeth and then when a fellow teammate acquired a team I have since went to work for him, but still maintain most of my work with BLPP. Now if I'm doing a job for both teams, why should that not warrant GM status for both? I am spending a lot of my time to help out these guys, and maybe this is their way of saying I'm important.
 
drifter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Tito716
Originally posted by drifter

Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder


Originally posted by drifter



Lots of reasons. Here are what I think the ones that need to be addressed are:

League imbalances - No one likes spending half your schedule winning by 100 pts or more. Teams on the other end of the spectrum don't like having to go 2 seasons of getting beat up before they land among their peers.

Overexpansion - Everybody and their mom wanted a team. Now Mom finds out it's not as fun as she thought and is leaving. Maintain strong demand for teams and don't overexpand and this doesn't happen. Some type of Qualifying for teams would help.

Boredom and Expense at higher levels - Levelling up twice a season (not counting boosts) doesn't keep people checking back in on their Center. Also NEEDING to boost your entire stable at higher levels to stay competitive (2.x level gain vs 5.x level gain per season). Boosting should cut off after your fourth season, encouraging people to create new players. Combined with my idea for Prestige Attributes beginning at Level 30, you'll keep Agents fresh and interested.


The first two are "meh" but the last point is interesting. As long as it's cut off for everyone at or around year 5, I could see it being viable.


I guarantee you #1 is not meh. Teams are leaving because it's no fun playing in an imbalanced league.


I doubt very strongly that the teams winning by 100 every week have as much of a problem with it as the teams losing by 100 every week.


True enough but I'm on several teams winning by 100 or more several times a season and it's boring. I'm about 25 years past where I liked to play games without competition.
Last edited Aug 29, 2008 11:37:46
 
papabear
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by LionsLover
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder



Originally posted by



The deck is stacked. Have you looked at free agency threads? Every 'B' quality player or better has countless offers thrown at them. If you settle for lesser players, guess what? You lose! All season. Then relegate and no one wants to be on your team, free agent or otherwise.

It's a vicious cycle.


Yeah, it seems like you might indeed be paying too much for your players. Anything more then the min. required for training and equip is wasting money. If they ask for it, just tell them no.



And then you go into the season with no roster. I have a good team, and it's impossible for me to sign anyone of a decent level for a decent price. The closest I had to signing a decent player was offering him double the minimum salary I usually offer and double the SB he needed for his next upgrades. And he still didn't sign.


weeding out unwise players goes pretty fast. Paying a person over intense training level for his level is pointless. He will not train on intense everyday, his energy level will not allow it.

based on what i am seeing now, is it the players who are to blame for the teams collapsing? Are we killing ourselves by eating our weeks food supply in one day then complaining there is nothing to eat later?
Last edited Aug 29, 2008 11:36:42
 
drifter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
Originally posted by drifter

Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder


Originally posted by drifter



Lots of reasons. Here are what I think the ones that need to be addressed are:

League imbalances - No one likes spending half your schedule winning by 100 pts or more. Teams on the other end of the spectrum don't like having to go 2 seasons of getting beat up before they land among their peers.

Overexpansion - Everybody and their mom wanted a team. Now Mom finds out it's not as fun as she thought and is leaving. Maintain strong demand for teams and don't overexpand and this doesn't happen. Some type of Qualifying for teams would help.

Boredom and Expense at higher levels - Levelling up twice a season (not counting boosts) doesn't keep people checking back in on their Center. Also NEEDING to boost your entire stable at higher levels to stay competitive (2.x level gain vs 5.x level gain per season). Boosting should cut off after your fourth season, encouraging people to create new players. Combined with my idea for Prestige Attributes beginning at Level 30, you'll keep Agents fresh and interested.


The first two are "meh" but the last point is interesting. As long as it's cut off for everyone at or around year 5, I could see it being viable.


I guarantee you #1 is not meh. Teams are leaving because it's no fun playing in an imbalanced league.


And that's why it's "meh", there's nothing that can be done about it. As soon as we start moving teams around at random, people will get pissed because their league isn't stable. I know it'd be pissed if we suddendly got a bunch of random teams in my league.

Are we going to move them the moment they get gutted? Does the owner have to apply or does Bort have to patrol each league and arbitrarily decide when teams qualify for the gutting "dump"?

There are far too many variables here.


You don't move by "random" at all. You do a one time restructuring and you put something in place to deal with major relegation for gutted teams. Problem solved at the expense of a one time shakeup. THe shake up wouldn't even screw with things that much since you 'd still remain in the league with your best competition.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by papabear
Originally posted by LionsLover

Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder




Originally posted by




The deck is stacked. Have you looked at free agency threads? Every 'B' quality player or better has countless offers thrown at them. If you settle for lesser players, guess what? You lose! All season. Then relegate and no one wants to be on your team, free agent or otherwise.

It's a vicious cycle.


Yeah, it seems like you might indeed be paying too much for your players. Anything more then the min. required for training and equip is wasting money. If they ask for it, just tell them no.



And then you go into the season with no roster. I have a good team, and it's impossible for me to sign anyone of a decent level for a decent price. The closest I had to signing a decent player was offering him double the minimum salary I usually offer and double the SB he needed for his next upgrades. And he still didn't sign.


weeding out unwise players goes pretty fast. Paying a person over intense training level for his level is pointless. He will not train on intense everyday, his energy level will not allow it.

based on what i am seeing now, is it the players who are to blame for the teams collapsing? Are we killing ourselves by eating our weeks food supply in one day then complaining there is nothing to eat later?


Those kinds of players are hurting the game, but so are bad owners that overspend. This will be a moot point in the near future when the economy gets its overhaul, but until then...
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.