User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Prestige Attributes - A way to reduce the "stagnation plateau" for higher level players and add more differentiation among cookie cutter builds
Page:
 
Dannyg28
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Nefari
Originally posted by Dannyg28

Originally posted by Nefari


Originally posted by Dannyg28



Originally posted by Nefari




One question. How would this work for players who have already passed the point (whatever it may be, 23, 31 etc). Would they get points for the exp they missed out on or would newer players have an advantage over them, essentially pressuring them to retire because of the missed skill points. Just a question


your prestige(or w/e they end up calling it) level would level up the same as your normal levels. Like at prestige level 1 your prestige would level up as quickly as you did when you were level 1


I know, i think you missed my point. The problem would lie in the fact that if or when this is implemented, if a player was already, say, 38, he would have missed out on 7 lvls worth of prestige points. Another player that was at lvl 30 when this was implemented would end up with 7 extra lvls of gaining prestige points


everyone would start out at the same point and would level prestige wise at about the same rate, so not seeing how they would gain an advantage?


Because a player at lvl 38 when this is implemented would have 0 prestige points as opposed to a player who started at lvl 31 and worked his way up to 38, gaining points along the way.


don't normal levels not effect the prestige levels?

He would be better at level 38 than you were at level 38 but you'll be level 45 and have the same prestige level as him so he doesn't gain an advantage on you or anything.
Last edited Aug 26, 2008 19:50:06
 
OttawaShane
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GG
Hypothetically, if that '200' idea or something similar, was done first, that would then allow the ideas in this thread (bells and whistles for vets) to be implemented. Just means '200' ideas are a safety-net underneath not creating further disparity.

Also, Bort already has a bunch of updates to come that do focus on adding more bells and whistles for vet players. That attention to the vet players and making their experience worthwhile and challenging WOULD still be there and I agree that vets need stuff because the leveling process currently is killing their interest.

I just have flashbacks to all the posts i wrote back in april/may where i touched on all these problems and everyone mocking me at the time but it's all pertinent today.

Bort knows best, and many people (like drifter) come up with awesome ideas etc. But there's that saying about building a stable foundation before you build a house. Or about throwing seeds on rocky soil instead of fertile soil.


GG, your basic suggestions a couple of months ago were really solid - I remember now that it was you who suggested the "buffet" approach to SAs, allowing a player to choose any SAs they feel would help their build, regardless of position.

I'm hoping that can happen with these "veteran" or "prestige" attributes.
 
GG
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Dannyg28

how would that idea help newbies? wouldn't a level 20(or w/e) still be significantly better than a level 1 with daily training and much increased SA?


A noob today starts off as a child with 11 strength, 11 vision, etc. A level 1 player is a child beaten silly by a level 10 player. A level 10 player is a child beaten silly by a level 20 player. The disparity is based on attributes, because the process to developing, the bottom-floor, is made out to be so anemic and child-like.

200 idea addresses that because from day 1, a total noob player would be considered an adult like level 20 players. So they wont get pancaked 800 times in a game etc. Remember, in the 200 idea, every time you level up, your training increases your attributes. So a level 1 player might have 200 pts total there, but a level 20 player might have 220 over time due to training. Also, the new-SAs idea was making player development focus more on refinement of skills.

So a level 1 player would have 200 vs level 20 player 200 basically. So at the core level it's adult vs adult. But the difference is that a level 1 player would be like a rookie. Because they have 0 pts in sticky hands, route running, turn shoulder, one handed catch, etc. All the kinds of things that veteran footballers would have acquired over time. So the game WOULD BE enhancing vet players over time but at all times the noobs are treated as rookies not as 10 year old kids. Remember, a noob player is supposedly a 300 lb 6 foot 5 inch DE, yet he has only 11 strength, 11 speed???



 
trog
offline
Link
 
I think it's a great idea. It gives the players something to look forward to, and gives the high level players something to do since as the levels get higher 5 skill points isn't much to assign.
 
Painmaker
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Nefari
Originally posted by Painmaker

Originally posted by Nefari



The problem would lie in the fact that if or when this is implemented, if a player was already, say, 38, he would have missed out on 7 lvls worth of prestige points. Another player that was at lvl 30 when this was implemented would end up with 7 extra lvls of gaining prestige points


Just make it so when the change takes effect, the guys above level 30 (or whatever level it would be implemented at) have the amount of points they would have earned to that point.


If I understood correctly, the OP wanted the pretige points to be gained in the same way as regular SP, based on playing time. Would Bort give all the players higher than 31 the amount of prestige points they would have gotten with max PT? That might give those players a bonus as not everyone gets max xp. I know its trivial, I'm just trying to sort this out because, tbh, I love this idea.


There's no reason I see for the game curve for prestige XP to be different than the curve for normal XP, just multiplied by different values depending on player level (e.g. level 31 player getting 75% XP in a game would get 450 prestige XP and 75 normal XP). So it would be relatively easy to reconstruct automatically.
 
Dannyg28
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GG
Originally posted by Dannyg28


how would that idea help newbies? wouldn't a level 20(or w/e) still be significantly better than a level 1 with daily training and much increased SA?


A noob today starts off as a child with 11 strength, 11 vision, etc. A level 1 player is a child beaten silly by a level 10 player. A level 10 player is a child beaten silly by a level 20 player. The disparity is based on attributes, because the process to developing, the bottom-floor, is made out to be so anemic and child-like.

200 idea addresses that because from day 1, a total noob player would be considered an adult like level 20 players. So they wont get pancaked 800 times in a game etc. Remember, in the 200 idea, every time you level up, your training increases your attributes. So a level 1 player might have 200 pts total there, but a level 20 player might have 220 over time due to training. Also, the new-SAs idea was making player development focus more on refinement of skills.

So a level 1 player would have 200 vs level 20 player 200 basically. So at the core level it's adult vs adult. But the difference is that a level 1 player would be like a rookie. Because they have 0 pts in sticky hands, route running, turn shoulder, one handed catch, etc. All the kinds of things that veteran footballers would have acquired over time. So the game WOULD BE enhancing vet players over time but at all times the noobs are treated as rookies not as 10 year old kids. Remember, a noob player is supposedly a 300 lb 6 foot 5 inch DE, yet he has only 11 strength, 11 speed???





don't at the higher end of the SA the multipliers get insanely high? Level 1 corner versus level x WR . Both have similar speed/agility but the WR has 10/10 in first step and 9/10 in route running. He is going to accelerate and be so much faster than the corner.
Last edited Aug 26, 2008 19:58:42
 
Painmaker
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GG

200 idea
...
200 idea
...
200 idea
...
200 idea


Maybe start another thread instead of insisting on derailing this one? Then we could examine the potential of "prestige attributes" here while repeating all the reasons we hate "200" separately. You could even dig for a bit to find the old thread and resurrect it with all the points already made.
 
GG
offline
Link
 
The life of a real footballer, his development, is really in refinement and acquirement of skills. Not about a 6'5" 300 lbs player starting off as a child in EVERY mental, physical and football attribute and becoming stronger, faster, etc. Instead, they're always essentially physically the same and the difference between a rookie and vet is expertize of football skills.

Rookies come into the NFL faster or stronger than vets. Some dont, some do. But they all have to learn how to carry the ball better (McFadden learning to fix his fumbles). Chris Johnson learning how to block. Malcolm Kelly learning how to run routes better. Donnie Avery learning how to beat the jam. Chris Long learning how to shed blocks.

That's what GLB should be focusing on in player-creation, the road from rookie to vet should be centered on those principles....

* leveling the playing field between noobs and vets.
* developing true customization and process of refinement
* in-game tactics and game-planning have far more say in game results.

 
Dannyg28
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GG
The life of a real footballer, his development, is really in refinement and acquirement of skills. Not about a 6'5" 300 lbs player starting off as a child in EVERY mental, physical and football attribute and becoming stronger, faster, etc. Instead, they're always essentially physically the same and the difference between a rookie and vet is expertize of football skills.

Rookies come into the NFL faster or stronger than vets. Some dont, some do. But they all have to learn how to carry the ball better (McFadden learning to fix his fumbles). Chris Johnson learning how to block. Malcolm Kelly learning how to run routes better. Donnie Avery learning how to beat the jam. Chris Long learning how to shed blocks.

That's what GLB should be focusing on in player-creation, the road from rookie to vet should be centered on those principles....

* leveling the playing field between noobs and vets.
* developing true customization and process of refinement
* in-game tactics and game-planning have far more say in game results.



i just don't agree that you particular idea really closes the gap all that much for newbies, at the higher levels of the SAs, the multipliers are huge and will essentially create the same gap that there is now. Unless you want to lessen how much SA help.
Last edited Aug 26, 2008 20:05:16
 
drifter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Nefari
One question. How would this work for players who have already passed the point (whatever it may be, 23, 31 etc). Would they get points for the exp they missed out on or would newer players have an advantage over them, essentially pressuring them to retire because of the missed skill points. Just a question


I'd say you would need to figure out how much VP those people got and apply them all at once.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
I beg you, GG, not to hijack a thread which is looking good for adding variety and making higher levels more fun to play, which I know you agree is something of value, to promote an idea that Bort doesn't like, won't do, and that most players probably don't want, either.
 
GG
offline
Link
 
People can disagree with me, that's cool. Dannyg28, the difference between a player with 200 base vs 200 base but him having 0/10 sticky hands vs 10/10 sticky hands would be a LOT less is the point. Look, today you have teams who are all level 25 vs teams who are all level 25. But the games are pretty good, close, still 20 yard runs, pancakes, intercepts, broken coverage etc. Ends up 24-20 score and stats look realistic. That's what '200' would end up creating MORE of.

The solution is to level the playing field. That's what everyone wants! No one wants 100-0 scores, 150 pancakes a game, 1,000 yards rushing by one player in a game etc. Having noobs and vets all on a level playing field is NOT bad for anyone! Vets WILL have more skill that they win but it wont be 100-0 etc.

Also, the new-SAs were maxing out at 100 not 10.

And, about bringing this thread back on topic....yes, that's fine. But my presence in this thread is relevant to the topic because I disagree about creating more disparity and the process of that as discussed in some of the ideas mentioned in this thread. That it would be remiss of GLB to implement these ideas BEFORE addressing (re-doing) the foundation first. But I will tone down my '200' talk in here.
 
Xiong Yoshi
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GG
The life of a real footballer, his development, is really in refinement and acquirement of skills. Not about a 6'5" 300 lbs player starting off as a child in EVERY mental, physical and football attribute and becoming stronger, faster, etc. Instead, they're always essentially physically the same and the difference between a rookie and vet is expertize of football skills.

Rookies come into the NFL faster or stronger than vets. Some dont, some do. But they all have to learn how to carry the ball better (McFadden learning to fix his fumbles). Chris Johnson learning how to block. Malcolm Kelly learning how to run routes better. Donnie Avery learning how to beat the jam. Chris Long learning how to shed blocks.

That's what GLB should be focusing on in player-creation, the road from rookie to vet should be centered on those principles....

* leveling the playing field between noobs and vets.
* developing true customization and process of refinement
* in-game tactics and game-planning have far more say in game results.



I agree with you on every point except one - That's what GLB should be focusing on...

Bort gets to decide what GLB is focusing upon. I 100% agree that a football sim should be built with the ideals you lay out.. and though I haven't read your 200 idea (I saw it and dismissed it as "never going to happen because Bort has invested a lot of programing energy into the current game", and much like the Agent who refuses to retire a level 25 QB just because it has 54 Stamina - Bort will refuse to start GLB over until it has reached it's peak.. it's human nature to not want to throw away things which you have invested effort into, even if you know there are other better designs for those things).. though I haven't read your idea - it sounds like something that I would support conceptually.


EDIT - and before anyone gets the wrong idea - I actually have a fair amount of respect for Bort's programming skills. His game design might have 101 fatal flaws, but it is apparent that he spends a lot of time working on the sim engine, route running, the physics of the game - and I'll admit it.. it is the physics of the game which prevent me from even attempting to create my own game.

Fake Edit2 - Also, a good design that is completed is usually better than a great design that is left unfinished... something to always consider in these kinds of discussions.
Last edited Aug 26, 2008 20:20:04
 
Painmaker
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GG
The life of a real footballer, his development, is really in refinement and acquirement of skills. Not about a 6'5" 300 lbs player starting off as a child in EVERY mental, physical and football attribute and becoming stronger, faster, etc. Instead, they're always essentially physically the same and the difference between a rookie and vet is expertize of football skills.

Rookies come into the NFL faster or stronger than vets. Some dont, some do. But they all have to learn how to carry the ball better (McFadden learning to fix his fumbles). Chris Johnson learning how to block. Malcolm Kelly learning how to run routes better. Donnie Avery learning how to beat the jam. Chris Long learning how to shed blocks.

That's what GLB should be focusing on in player-creation, the road from rookie to vet should be centered on those principles....

* leveling the playing field between noobs and vets.
* developing true customization and process of refinement
* in-game tactics and game-planning have far more say in game results.



Rookies are absolutely not as strong as, nor do they have the stamina of, veterans. I'll grant that they are generally close to their max speed when they reach the league, but they still work on technique such as footwork and hip control to improve their agility. Same can be said for throwing, punting, kicking, catching, blocking, and tackling technique. Same for vision and confidence.

In a game where players plateau after 10 seasons, decline, and eventually retire, everyone is renewed. The will be a constant stream of players at various levels of capability. This is not a noob agent vs veteran agent problem because even the veteran agents must return through the cycle of new players. Once the leagues become more regularly stratified with the many strong teams toward the top and the even larger number of weaker teams towards the bottom, it will become readily apparent where the new players can compete and have fun. That gets fixed by addressing the "gutting" or "team turnover" problem, not by changing the structure to make players "the same except different."

The Prestige Attributes suggestion does nothing to harm the vet-noob balance because the vet-noob balance isn't a problem. Having gutted teams in high-level leagues while other strong teams are in low-level leagues is a problem. That will require a different suggestion to sort out. And sorry, but I haven't got the answer. Maybe doubling the rate of promotion/relegation for a few seasons will help get things closer to where they should be.
 
GG
offline
Link
 
You guys go ahead and discuss the OP, and Bort will ignore me or mock my ideas or whatever and instead like ideas that he likes instead that suit his timetable and propensity. It's outta my hands. I can only implore so much. Whatever happens happens.

But this will all come round full circle in time like it did from april/may to now if the result is always still creating disparity instead of lessening disparity. The customization ideas we all have and all ideas around customization thru SAs or other means are essentially fine.

Just to re-iterate tho....200 itself was not an over-haul at all. Nothing changed. All it meant was re-specing everyone. New-SAs WAS an over-haul. And it'd be false to say these ideas in here were NOT a similar overhaul. If admin want to put my new-SA down as being too much programming then it'd be facetious to say this OP ideas wasnt.

Im all for customization, etc. Nothing against Drifter himself, because he's a fine poster/suggestor. I hate repeating myself but i often do because i fall on deaf ears. But I do think it's insincere to "only listen" to Drifter, sticky his threads, and implement his ideas, while many other threads and ideas (mine or others) often get unnoticed, neglected, etc.


Last edited Aug 26, 2008 20:28:44
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.