User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Season 4 changes ARE going to cost this game alot of dedicated players.
Page:
 
AirMcMVP
Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by RunningMn9
Originally posted by sjmay

Bort taking 40 different teams and running them through a test server when he makes changes,


The difference is that Bort taking 40 different teams and running them through a test server hasn't done jack shit to shake out bugs in the sim, has it? It's acceptable for a programmer to unit test his code - you NEVER, EVER have a programmer function/system test his own code unless it's an absolute necessity.

You need other fingers and eyes in there looking for things that you wouldn't think of. The difference between letting testers do it, and letting the general population do it is that testers can test at a higher frequency. Run two games a day instead of a game every two days. Run a season a day. Have testers that look through and watch the PBP of every game that is simmed on the test server. People that know how to find and characterize bugs in more detailed ways than "I DIDN'T WIN, THE SIM MUST BE BUGGED!!".

I don't know whether or not you do this for a living, but I do. The current methodology doesn't work in theory - and it certainly isn't working in practice as HUGE and obvious bugs routinely escape whatever initial testing Bort is doing.


As a SQL developer myself, I agree with this statement. Its almost impossible to test your own code and find every bug in it. HOWEVER, the GLB community is ripe with conspiracy theorists. Already, mods and alpha testers are looked at as having inside information. Adding true beta testers would only add to that problem.

Season 5 is the make or break season of this game. Why? Someone else said it...NFL and NCAA football.

If the game can survive the opening weekend of both levels of real football, I think it'll be around for the long haul. The whole issue of beta vs non-beta will play only a small role in it.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by datongw
Originally posted by Ken1

Originally posted by ShakeNBake


I like the changes, bad builds finally caught up to people


Quit whining and leave already


Or fix your build. But quit whining because you didn't put enough tackling into your player and now he can't tackle.


Fortunately for me most of my guys are balanced and most of them are in the teen levels so they can still adjust. But I can totally understand people complaining with their players in the mid 20 levels. It's much harder to change when you are level 25. It took 3 seasons for people to build these guys, you don't just change the rules drastically one day and tell them to scrap it or adjust. Instead of just flaming people, people needs to understand where everyone is coming from. I believe most of us posting here are trying to make the game better.


I think those who are opposing changes largely because their player was hurt are whining over that, not trying to make the game better as in reflective of real football, but to make it better for themselves.

Some, like the one who posted in suggestions about gang tackling, really are trying to improve the game; they just don't realize that, with half the LB's in the game built more like CB's, that power backs should be doing at least as well as they are.
 
kevindurant35
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by kevindurant35

i will just like a heads up when you are "nerfing" stuff


Bort posted for at least the last half of Season 3 that Speed would lose its acceleration function to Agility, and that Wrap-Up would be nerfed.

If you didn't read anything he posted, I wouldn't call it anyone's fault but yours.


i wasnt talking about the agility stuff. im talking about stuff he's changing now
 
bigpimpin123
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bigpimpin123
Solution:

Uncheck the box enabling advanced AI settings. Happy? Things are back to normal. When you hear that all is well give it another shot.

That wasn't so hard


There's other stuff that are still pretty bad, but this is what I read about in the OP. If the "Old" settings worked, use them!
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kevindurant35
Originally posted by Ken1

Originally posted by kevindurant35


i will just like a heads up when you are "nerfing" stuff


Bort posted for at least the last half of Season 3 that Speed would lose its acceleration function to Agility, and that Wrap-Up would be nerfed.

If you didn't read anything he posted, I wouldn't call it anyone's fault but yours.


i wasnt talking about the agility stuff. im talking about stuff he's changing now


Like what? Everything he's done for this season has made the game more like real life.
 
Doug_Plank
offline
Link
 
Bort needs to chill and stop making changes every freakin day.. it's getting out of hand
 
bigpimpin123
offline
Link
 
I say we pause the regular season, have scrimmages every day (no XP at all) focusing on fixing only one thing assigned each day, and once all is well we continue the season.
Last edited Aug 7, 2008 23:39:54
 
AirMcMVP
Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Doug_Plank
Bort needs to chill and stop making changes every freakin day.. it's getting out of hand


The changes that are being made on a daily basis are in response to bugs/issues brought up in this forum. If people are already looking at season 4 as a throwaway season, might as well cram all the changes into it.
 
deez11010
offline
Link
 
It was said on page 1.

THIS GAME IS IN BETA

For those thats never been involved in open beta TESTING, there will be changes, daily, multiple times a day, sometimes servers are taken down for hours/days at a time to fix some bugs.

THIS IS BETA

THIS SHOULD BE EXPECTED

THIS IS THE ENTIRE POINT OF OPEN BETA

Find the bugs, and get them fixed before the game goes live. We all had that blue announcement box, did you ever read the bottom of it?

"Thank you for your patience with this BETA"

Yes, I skipped from page one to page 12. I dont know and dont care how many times its been said since. People should just be happy to be involved in the game instead of waiting for the finished product. We are getting an advantage over those that arent taking part of this beta. We will have all the knowledge and know the quirks and what works with what doesnt. They will be starting with no clue.

One last time, this game is in BETA, there will be changes and updates on a constant basis until it works as perfectly as possible to the designer/admins expectations.
 
Doug_Plank
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by AirMcMVP
Originally posted by Doug_Plank

Bort needs to chill and stop making changes every freakin day.. it's getting out of hand


The changes that are being made on a daily basis are in response to bugs/issues brought up in this forum. If people are already looking at season 4 as a throwaway season, might as well cram all the changes into it.


So people are already looking at season 4 as a throwaway season? boosts should be free this season then
 
DigitalDaggers
Admin
offline
Link
 
we are making the game as real/balanced/fair as possible.

we can't please everyone, but we are trying to please the majority.

we will continue to make changes to the game as we work to complete beta.
 
deez11010
offline
Link
 
DD, you didnt say it right. its BETA. They might get it if you emphasise that its BETA.

 
DigitalDaggers
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by deez11010
DD, you didnt say it right. its BETA. They might get it if you emphasise that its BETA.



*clears throat*



BETA


(i pictured it like conan o'brien's "ass" stamp)
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by DigitalDaggers
Originally posted by deez11010

DD, you didnt say it right. its BETA. They might get it if you emphasise that its BETA.



*clears throat*



BETA


(i pictured it like conan o'brien's "ass" stamp)


Gotta underline it and add some flavor man!

BETA BITCHES
 
datongw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by deez11010
It was said on page 1.

THIS GAME IS IN BETA

For those thats never been involved in open beta TESTING, there will be changes, daily, multiple times a day, sometimes servers are taken down for hours/days at a time to fix some bugs.

THIS IS BETA

THIS SHOULD BE EXPECTED

THIS IS THE ENTIRE POINT OF OPEN BETA

Find the bugs, and get them fixed before the game goes live. We all had that blue announcement box, did you ever read the bottom of it?

"Thank you for your patience with this BETA"

Yes, I skipped from page one to page 12. I dont know and dont care how many times its been said since. People should just be happy to be involved in the game instead of waiting for the finished product. We are getting an advantage over those that arent taking part of this beta. We will have all the knowledge and know the quirks and what works with what doesnt. They will be starting with no clue.

One last time, this game is in BETA, there will be changes and updates on a constant basis until it works as perfectly as possible to the designer/admins expectations.


Next time try to read the whole thing before making idiotic remarks.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.