User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Problem with Stamina/Substitution/Depth?
Page:
 
Whatsdafus
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by BobJoeJim
Originally posted by hud

#4 realism is overated. You want everything real, then you would lose a player you spent good money to boost to a career ending injury.

It happens. It sucks when it does. But you'll get 70% of the flex points you spent on him back, to start your next player. Most players have a shelf life of 10-15 years, depending on how long you keep them around after they begin declining. If 10-20% of players only last 3, 5, or 7 years, before an injury forces them into early retirement, though, that wouldn't bother me. It would make the game more interesting, and when it eventually happened to me I'd start a new player up to replace the hurt guy, and that's fine.

Originally posted by

you would have teams that have far better players and tactics lose to sucky teams because it happens.

I should hope this can happen in the game. If there are no upsets what's the point of sports?

Originally posted by

You would have cities paying taxes for stadium builds.

I'd love to see the financial sim side of this game get more complex, with city levies, television and ad revenue, etcetera. That would add some awesome extra strategic levels to the game.

Originally posted by

you would have Agents taking 30% of your players salary.

Only if they were also providing a service and helping you get your player into the best position possible. If agents were available, I think most new players would GREATLY benefit from them, even if they charged a lot more than 30%.

Originally posted by

there would be T.O.'s that kill a great team.

I saw a lot of cool threads in the suggestions forum earlier this season about player personality ideas, and having both "leaders" who made their team better and "disruptions" that made their team worse (though perhaps brought in more money to the team due to the draw of their "star power"). What happened to those threads, they seem to have disappeared, which is too bad. Some of those ideas were very good.

Originally posted by

You would have your players have stretches where they get no stats and dont perform to their abilities due to family problems.

Yeah, slumps happen. Actually, slumps already happen, though right now due to random variance, which in my opinion is much more likely to be the cause of most slumps in real life than "family problems" or anything qualitative like that. So this already is realistic.

Originally posted by

the whole game would suck next season due to the sophmore jinx.

The sophomore jinx is a media myth propagated by people who don't understand the statistical concept of regression to the mean. Calls for realism would dictate NOT programming it into the game.

Originally posted by

your players would get suspended from GLB for off field antics, your top ranked QB would be in prison after you spent 50 bucks on him in 5 seasons.

Suspensions would be great. Extreme cases like a Pro Bowl caliber QB getting sent to jail, ending his career, only happen once every 15-20 seasons or so in real life, so programming them "realistically" into GLB would have a pretty negligible effect. Shorter suspensions though would be great. If any given player had a 5% annual chance of getting suspended for 1 game at some point, a 3% chance of getting suspended for 3 games, and a 1% chance of getting hit with a 6 game suspension, that would give a team with a 50 man roster an average of 10 player-games lost due to suspension across their roster. This wouldn't be crippling, would increase the need for depth, and would make the game more interesting.

Originally posted by

I could go on.

Please do, most of these are good ideas.

Originally posted by

Realism is not the real complaint. No one wants realism.

Some (most?) of us actually do.

Originally posted by

We want to play a game that does some things like the real sport and some things like a game.

If the game is a "sim", which this is supposed to be, then those goals are one and the same.

Originally posted by

The complaint is that someone lost or someone isnt getting enough PT. the complaint is what someone thought the game should play like didnt happen.

Yep, that is the complaint. We thought it was a realistic football sim, we wanted it to be a realistic sim, and then in at least this one major area, we realized it's not even remotely realistic.

Originally posted by

I personally think that practice and timing is what makes a team great, not just skill. And some chemisty bar isnt gonna fix that.

I agree the chemistry bar isn't a perfect representation of how playing well together actually benefits a team, and it could get more complex, more realistic, and be better. It's a good step in the right direction though.

Originally posted by

But it would make this game boring and cumbersum as would finding 2-3 players at every position.

Finding 2-3 players at every position is boring and cumbersome for you? You probably shouldn't be an owner then. The entire point of being an owner is to try to build the best team you can, and the difficulty (see, difficulties or challenges are what make games interesting, it gives you something to overcome) is in dealing with human controlled players, and convincing them to sign with you, and keeping them happy and active.

Originally posted by

Let me ask it this way? If there were enough teams and good owners that we could have teams with 32 active players per team that got more PT and leveled up faster, wouldn't that be more fun that finding 52 players so you could have some sit the bench and hope to get 25% of the plays so he could level 25% as fast as the starters? Wouldnt be more ideal for all players to have 70-90 plays, than some having 60 while other hope to get 20 a game? That's a game, not reality.

That would not be more fun. Not for me. I take pride in my nickle back coming off the bench, and helping the team by giving the starters a needed rest while holding down the position solidly. If he was "just another starting CB" that would genuinely be less interesting to me.

Originally posted by

Everyone wants to play, not support a team from the bench. Im not investing time (or money) into a game to watch you. And seriously, building players through PT is what drives this game, so lets get the team to player balance right and then worry about changing stamina. Until that happens, live with it.

Some people do want to support a team from the bench, if it's a winning team and they enjoy the company of their teammates and the forum is active. I know because there are people like that on my team. If you want to play (by which you appear to mean you want to start) then that's fine, find a crappy team you can start for, since you clearly don't care about the team any way so it doesn't matter if they're not winning. Then you'll get your PT. Or, if you prefer, you're welcome not to invest time or money into the game.

Originally posted by

Thats my essay and Im stickin to it.

And I'm sticking to my responses.


i never thought i would say this to a person named BobJoeJim but your my personal hero. lol nice responses
 
tpaterniti
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Check 3 pages back when I basically said the exact same things to his quotes (and more)!
 
Whatsdafus
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tpaterniti
Check 3 pages back when I basically said the exact same things to his quotes (and more)!


But i expect those answers from you.... not from someone named bobjoejim
 
BobJoeJim
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tpaterniti
Check 3 pages back when I basically said the exact same things to his quotes (and more)!


I read and greatly enjoyed your post. There was some crossover, but I don't feel you said the exact same things...
 
Beefcake
offline
Link
 
I think if it is balanced properly, XP gain and performance should both be logarithmic. This would give starters plenty of PT at fairly minimal performance hit and max XP gain, but also encourage teams carrying backups, who would also get some PT and a pretty good chunk of XP.

Example
snap %max XP % of max performance
1 2.0% 100.0%
2 3.9% 100.0%
3 5.9% 99.9%
4 7.8% 99.9%
5 9.7% 99.8%
6 11.6% 99.7%
7 13.4% 99.7%
8 15.3% 99.6%
9 17.1% 99.4%
10 18.9% 99.3%
.
20 35.8% 97.4%
.
30 50.8% 94.3%
.
50 74.8% 85.2%
.
60 83.8% 79.5%
.
70 90.8% 73.2%
.
80 95.8% 66.6%
.
90 98.9% 59.8%
.
100 100.0% 53.1%
101 100.0% 52.4%

So if the typical game is 100 plays, and your starter plays 70 of those, he will get 90% of the max XP to be earned in a game. the backup plays 30 and gets about 50% of the max XP possible.

Sure the NFL has backups mostly because of injuries and the like, and they may not play much in reality. This is a MMO game not the NFL, so have just enough realism that the team needs backups to be effective, however the backups here should get more PT in the interest of keeping the game fun for everyone.
 
Teddy KGB
offline
Link
 
I don't have any new ideas to offer here. I just want the developers to know there are some great ideas on this thread, and I hope they implement most of them. Count me in as one that would appreciate as much realism as possible.

Penalties are a must have.
Injuries are a must have.
The whole idea of checking in for team practice is genius in my opinion!
Stamina must play a very important part, especially over the course of the season. I'm really disappointed this wasn't the case. I dumped a lot of effort and SP into bumping up my player stamina.
Having agents sounds fun.
Having municipalities and tax money to further stadium expansion sounds very intriguing.
The idea of having team leaders and/or a T.O. type really sounds fun too.

I think the developers have done a wonderful job so far. Keep up the good work!


 
Donner
offline
Link
 
Some of the most fun I have had in football sims is beating down a team becuase my players are better conditioned or wearing opposing teams out over the course of a season because my players were better conditioned. I'd like to see stamina set up so that if a player rushes 50 times a game at this early stage, he is crawling for the last 10.
 
Link
 
A Roster minium alone will not help. There need to be more changes.

Even a minimum of 2 players on every position on the DC will not help. Teams who want to run a one player strategie will sign cpu players and low level humans, put them as backups on the dc and set the sub % in a way that they almost never see the field. In the end it will be the same as it is now.

Stamina and energy must become real factors, there is no way a RB can have 50 + rushes per game or players will play 100 plays per game and even perform good.

For me the must be the following fixes:
- the value of stamina must be increased
- energy must have a bigger impact in player perfomances
- a roster minimum of 40-45
- a minimum 2 deep DC
- a 10% spread betwenn sub in and sub out % to make sure that backups will play (if you dont want to play your backups you must increase stamina at high rate)
- some injuries

For me there is absolutly no need for players charakters or something like this. On my team I have 52 human players from 40 different people. Thats more than enough charakters to handle. It make no sense to put some random charakter issues in, In our team we have a great team feeling, nobody wants big money, nobody complains about starting cause everyone gets enough playing time and even the backups allready agreed to extend contracts for fair salary to stay with the team. Why should some dice rolls disrupt what we build? In the end every player is his own agent and has his own charakter, so absolutly no need for some wheels of furtune here.

 
TrevJo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by thehazyone
And honestly all these "you can't play football with only one backup at each position" posts are completely wrong.

QB = never come out
RB = backup might get 25% the snaps the starter does. #3 very seldom.
WR = many teams only carry 4-5 WR's (one backup at each position, get on field in 3/4 WR sets)
TE = many teams only carry 2
OL = seldom will the starters ever come out
DL/LB = one spot where subs occur more frequently but even then it's usually 2 people on the bench rotating in
Secondary = seldom come out, subs come in to act as 3rd/4th DB in nickel/dime situations.


Sorry for bringing up an old post, but I had to respond to this.
The problem with the way season 1 was (for Beta) is that these guys were also playing special teams on top of every snap of offense or defense. It doesn't make sense to have these same RB/WR/TE/OL making up your entire return units, or the same FS/SS/LB/DE that are playing the whole game make up your entire coverage units.
 
xeef
offline
Link
 
Im sorry, but is it really smart to change the game because it doesent work the way people assumed it was going to?

Just because people beleived the first thing they read and therefore all jumped on the "stamina is the most important thing" bandwagon before they understood anything about the game, doesent mean that stamina has to be changed to *BE* the most important thing.

oh well, too late now, I suppose.
 
xeef
offline
Link
 
I guess what I mean is in football, what is going to impact a play more, someone being tired, or someone being three times as fast?
 
FBGProfessor
offline
Link
 
GREAT POST!!!!
Can someone update this situation? I am trying to plan substitution percentage for the first game in the next season and I have NO IDEA how much Stamina or depth matter. I really don't care how it is: but I think it is only fair that we all know so that the people 'in the know' who alpha tested don't have an advantage.Originally posted by tpaterniti
Originally posted by hud

#1 it was the alpha players who were telling everyone to pump skill points into stamina. We learned in the first season that stamina was by FAR the MOST important stat. Sounds like a real fun way to build, huh? We had no idea, no special insight, that it was gonna work like this.


This was exactly the problem. The only people who knew anything about the game kept telling us newcomers that stamina was SO IMPORTANT so we did what one would logically do in that situation. We pumped stamina and signed depth. Then at the end of the season we see that it was the people telling us stamina was SO IMPORTANT who disregarded it, signed minimal teams, and dominated their leagues. This seems a little shady to me.

Originally posted by hud

Let me ask it this way? If there were enough teams and good owners that we could have teams with 32 active players per team that got more PT and leveled up faster, wouldn't that be more fun that finding 52 players so you could have some sit the bench and hope to get 25% of the plays so he could level 25% as fast as the starters? Wouldnt be more ideal for all players to have 70-90 plays, than some having 60 while other hope to get 20 a game?


My answer to all of this is NO, it wouldn't be more fun. Maybe to you, but the huge outcry against these types of teams underscores the fact that most people would rather have the realism. And a note on realism, basically your argument against it centers on off-the-field issues and injuries, whereas most of our complaints are about on-the-field issues. You can have a realistic simulation of the actual football game and the tactics involved without injuries and off-the-field stuff. To say that because of one small aspect of the football experience, injuries and things that happen off-the-field, we should give up all hope of a realistic on-the-field simulation just doesn't compute.

Here is the best solution I have come up with, which involves combining several good ideas proposed by myself and others.

I think the best suggestions are to combine the following:

1.) Decrease the max plays for XP from 90 to 40-50. NFL games are typically 55-65 plays so 90 is WAY too many. If there were no XP incentive to playing your guys more than 40-50 plays, there would be more depth.

2.) Change the in-game energy-to-effectiveness ratio. it doesn't have to be 1 to 1, but some ratio. It could be a parabolic curve where you lose little at the top and as you drop you lose more and more.

3.) Change the post-game energy situation. You should be able to lose more than 30 energy in a game. It shouldn't be 1 to 1, but again like a parabolic curve where the lower your in-game energy goes the more it affects how much or little you will have after the game.

4.) Add complexity to the offensive and defensive depth charts and game plan to allow for player specialization. Having 3rd down backs, Goalline backs, nickle and dime DBs, pash rush specialists, etc. actually gives owners a reason to have depth that is strategic and meaningful rather than just so it seems more realistic or fair.

Originally posted by hud

Filling up a roster, worring about more inactives, balancing PT isn't fun to me.


What are you saying? If you hate these things don't be an owner or get a GM to do it for you, because that is what the game is. That would be like saying, "I want to have lots of players, but I hate managing them and their training and their skill points. That just isn't fun to me." It doesn't make any sense. As I have written elsewhere this is a Mass Multiplayer Online game, not a Mass Singleplayer Online game. Dealing with other people, and lots of them (cf. "Mass" in Mass Multiplayer...) is kind of part of the deal. If you hate that, then no one is twisting your arm and making you be an owner. I get tired of all this stuff too. So I went out and got talented GMs to help me.

Originally posted by hud

I play Madden and I adjust the staminas importance so I can play the stars. I want to see T.O. on the field, not Patric Crayton.


You sound like a very casual football fan who just likes to watch the stars and who cares very little about the rest. People like you don't realize that without the Patrick Craytons of the world, the TOs of the world wouldn't be that exciting. Also there are many, many people who are pretty dedicated football fans who follow teams and rosters and watch games for more than just seeing one or two stars play. I assure you there are lots of Cowboys fans, and even I, who am not a Cowboys fan, enjoy watching guys like Patrick Crayton and Sam Hurd and Tony Fasano and other guys who are not top 5 in their position. There is nothing wrong with your mindset oer se, but as I said, it would be a mistake to assume that everyone is as casual a fan as you make yourself seem.


Originally posted by hud

New casual players want to see their guy in and growing, not sitting and building comrodary[sic].


I simply couldn't disagree with you more. I own six teams and deal with tons and tons of players every day and the biggest three concerns they have are whether they will get playing time (not necessarily starting), will they be on a winning team, and will the team be a fun group of players they can intract with. I have never once heard a player say, "You know, I don't care about winning or being with cool people, or contributing to my team. I just want to see that little number by his name go up." I am sure there are people like this, but I would say they are less than 10% of the people I interact with, which is a substantial number. You have to realize that the number is just a number. If it doesn't somehow translate to more fun for you, who cares whether your DE is level 18 or 88? I think you assume (as many people do) that others think the same way as you and have the same values, when in reality this is rarely the case.

Edit: See the poster below me. He certainly doesn't seem to be the type of person who only wantsOriginally posted by hud

to see their guy in and growing, not sitting and building comrodary[sic].
The more people who post, the more it will become evident just how cynical and atypical your approach is.


 
FBGProfessor
offline
Link
 
I see that Jed's team is still a team with virtually NO BACKUPS. I hope this doesn't mean that the proposed changes to stamina and injuries are really minimal and that the teams I GM shouldn't have gone to the trouble of signing all those backups who needed teams.

Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Jed

Just catching up here. If I remember correctly (and it's been a long time), the biggest problem I had in Alpha was that we were all level 1-4 and trying to play the game. By the 4th quarter, it was just pathetic, guys on both teams couldn't even move.

At this point? Sure, we have enough higher level people to handle starting and lower level people to back people up.

The only thing I ask is, after it's announced exactly what is going to happen, give us a LOT of notice. At least a week real time before it goes into effect. Many times, mine included, will need some serious adjustments to work with a drastic change in the Stamina system, and I just want a chance to keep up with that change.

I'd also suggest, if a system like this is put into place, to use this as a time to lower the point where the "max exp" a good deal. It would make sense and put that in place as well to further discourage constant starters at all positions.


I was thinking of doing the changes gradually over a week or two to let people have time to adjust.

I'll look at the XP formulas too...I agree that 90 plays is a pretty high cutoff. Sure makes those min/maxers happy though.


 
claystone
offline
Link
 
NFL Plays avg 55 to 60 plays a game, not 90. This where the stamina should be based upon.
 
PS3
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by xeef
Im sorry, but is it really smart to change the game because it doesent work the way people assumed it was going to?

Just because people beleived the first thing they read and therefore all jumped on the "stamina is the most important thing" bandwagon before they understood anything about the game, doesent mean that stamina has to be changed to *BE* the most important thing.

oh well, too late now, I suppose.


Haha that's what I said, they need to increase energy loss rate considerably if they actually want stamina to be an impact. Apparently a couple people posting over and over again consistute a "majority" opinion.


 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.