User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Players Looking for Teams > ATTN: Tying Flex Points to Contracts as an Incentive or Condition
Page:
 
crzyblue
offline
Link
 
Ok java.... lets put you in the shoes of an owner that only has the money to buy a team. you're team is almost complete except for DT and NT. You're trying your hardest to find decent material but everytime you come acrossed someone good and try to sign them... they say "Sorry I can't do it unless you can offer me more FP then billyjoe over there"... knowing that you can't offer any FP because you don't have the money for them, How would it make you feel? How would it make you feel if you were only able to sign lvl 3 guys with 20 kicking when they're DTs? How would you feel know that a team you're going to face is better because they offered FPs for a player and you were stuck the cream of the crop that no one wanted because either to low & don't boost, or just have plain sucky stats?
 
LithoMan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
Originally posted by Vilita

Its funny.

The only reason this is an issue, is because boosting has such a dramatic difference on a players ability to be competitive in the game.

All this trouble, when all you have to do is get rid of boosting and let people pay for other things like the ability to watch the matches live, the ability to run teams, custom equipment, etc.


But nope, never going to happen so theres always going to be trouble no matter what is done because when you make it absolutely impossible for someone to play the game competitively without paying for it, there are always going to be people finding ways to get around that regardless.

This is why every other game I've ever seen only charges for EXTRAS not for things that are essentially required to have a good player in the game.

The only other game I've ever heard of that offers raw skill points in return for cash is CyberDunk, and I never had any interest to play that game to begin with because of all the referral spam it produces.

And oh my. why is there so much referrals spam? BACK TO THE TOP!

Boosting rocks. Not.



You are correct. They want people to pay to win, but not pay so much that they have an advantage. Can't have it both ways.

Like I said, the biggest advantage are the guys who own 50 players. Those players haven't hit the highest levels yet, but once they do, they are going to be impossible to beat...


Ya, if I got to tone down my Flex Point buying on my Army, then both of you need toned down on your day trading.
 
kmart
Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
And that is actually another way to catch people with multiple accounts. All of them would be linked together by the name on the payment.

Get rid of paypal altogether have have the payments go directly to GLB.

Problem solved. Right?


Didn't read the rest of the thread to see if this has been addressed...

But do you realize what an incredibly BAD idea it would be to stop using paypal? I would rather risk there being shady contract negotiations than risk having my identity stolen because someone hacked into the site's database (and there almost assuredly would be attempts). Paypal may allow these transactions to go down, but it protects everyone from losing money.
 
valakar
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kmart
Originally posted by SteelersInsider

And that is actually another way to catch people with multiple accounts. All of them would be linked together by the name on the payment.

Get rid of paypal altogether have have the payments go directly to GLB.

Problem solved. Right?


Didn't read the rest of the thread to see if this has been addressed...

But do you realize what an incredibly BAD idea it would be to stop using paypal? I would rather risk there being shady contract negotiations than risk having my identity stolen because someone hacked into the site's database (and there almost assuredly would be attempts). Paypal may allow these transactions to go down, but it protects everyone from losing money.


I agree that this would be a bad idea. Paypal is protected and works. There has to be other ways to police this activity if that is what the mod and admin want or need to do.
 
oldskool
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by crzyblue
Q: So what is the difference between having an unfair advantage because you can afford to create and boost 40 players, and having an unfair advantage because you can afford to pay for someone else's player with a good build to boost?

A: ???
A1: The difference is, that it levels the playing field for all recruiters to recruit players that can't spend money to offer flex points <point 1 shut down please try again>

Uh, no it doesn't. If my team's better than yours, I have an easier time recruiting. If I'm smarter than you, I have an easier time recruiting. If my team is better off in-game financially, I have an easier time recruiting.

Should we ban good teams, smart players & level all team finances to a singular pool of cash to "level the playing field for ALL recruiters", or should we just admit that there are ways some people have advantages over others and that eliminating them would be completely stupid, ineffective and a waste of time?

Originally posted by crzyblue via Rage
POINT 2
Q: How are you going to stop people from offering to pay for someone else's fp to boost?
A: If it is in PM or message board history.

Q: What if the offer is made through an outside source?
A: It can't be verified that the offer was actually made so nothing will be done about it.

Q: So only stupid people who are obvious about it in GLB are going to be busted, meanwhile most people who have the intelligence needed to be able to afford to do this will never get caught?
A: Correct

Q: So why is this rule in place
A: ????
A2: because most people don't have others aim, or what not... they only have GLB and I'm sure if a mod saw a pm history of asking for an outside source of communication and then saw FPs bought by a person who uses that information on another account it will be dealt with then <point 2 shut down please try again>

Uh, no it wouldn't. Without the logs from the outside source they can't prove anything was premeditated, let alone that contact was even made. If you get robbed the police do not arrest every person aware of what house you live in. They arrest after they have enough evidence to PROVE that someone knew where your house was, knew when you would be gone, was in the area, has no alibi, etc.

Lots of teams have "post your email" threads so they can get a hold of inactive players if they need to, because there's no way to get a hold of them through the game if they aren't logging in.

Listening to your rhetoric would mean every player that EVER posted in one of those threads could be banned if the owner, any GM, or any other player on the team ever buys FP! Do you not see how incredibly moronic that stance is?
 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by crzyblue
Ok java.... lets put you in the shoes of an owner that only has the money to buy a team. you're team is almost complete except for DT and NT. You're trying your hardest to find decent material but everytime you come acrossed someone good and try to sign them... they say "Sorry I can't do it unless you can offer me more FP then billyjoe over there"... knowing that you can't offer any FP because you don't have the money for them, How would it make you feel? How would it make you feel if you were only able to sign lvl 3 guys with 20 kicking when they're DTs? How would you feel know that a team you're going to face is better because they offered FPs for a player and you were stuck the cream of the crop that no one wanted because either to low & don't boost, or just have plain sucky stats?



Why is that different than having every good player say, sorry you don't play in USA. Or sorry, I don't like the league you are in? Why is that different from losing to other teams because they created 30 players and traded them for cash and other players to make their team better than yours?

I can't afford to give people FP to join my team either. I can't even afford to give players on my team who don't boost the money so they can. I wish I could because there are some really good players on my team that would be outstanding players if they boosted. In fact, I wouldn't even be recruiting at all if I could afford to pay them all to boost.

I guess my point is that this rule only gives people the illusion that they are recruiting in a "fair" market. I don't want to recruit under an illusion. I want to know every reason I have to send out 200 offers to land 1 good recruit. I want to know that I am facing an uphill battle and the deck is stacked against me. It makes me know I have to work that much harder, and it keeps me going when offer after offer is rejected.
 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by valakar
Originally posted by kmart

Originally posted by SteelersInsider


And that is actually another way to catch people with multiple accounts. All of them would be linked together by the name on the payment.

Get rid of paypal altogether have have the payments go directly to GLB.

Problem solved. Right?


Didn't read the rest of the thread to see if this has been addressed...

But do you realize what an incredibly BAD idea it would be to stop using paypal? I would rather risk there being shady contract negotiations than risk having my identity stolen because someone hacked into the site's database (and there almost assuredly would be attempts). Paypal may allow these transactions to go down, but it protects everyone from losing money.


I agree that this would be a bad idea. Paypal is protected and works. There has to be other ways to police this activity if that is what the mod and admin want or need to do.



I'm sorry, but there are 1000's of companies and games online that sell directly and they have secure payment. Just because someone doesn't use paypal to receive payments doesn't mean it isn't secure. Have you ever bought airline tickts online through travelocity, cheaptickets, etc? They don't use paypal, but 1000's of people buy tickets through them every month. The issue is how much money would have to be spent for GLB to have its own secure payment system and does development feel it is worth it.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Rage Kinard
Originally posted by valakar

Originally posted by kmart


Originally posted by SteelersInsider



And that is actually another way to catch people with multiple accounts. All of them would be linked together by the name on the payment.

Get rid of paypal altogether have have the payments go directly to GLB.

Problem solved. Right?


Didn't read the rest of the thread to see if this has been addressed...

But do you realize what an incredibly BAD idea it would be to stop using paypal? I would rather risk there being shady contract negotiations than risk having my identity stolen because someone hacked into the site's database (and there almost assuredly would be attempts). Paypal may allow these transactions to go down, but it protects everyone from losing money.


I agree that this would be a bad idea. Paypal is protected and works. There has to be other ways to police this activity if that is what the mod and admin want or need to do.



I'm sorry, but there are 1000's of companies and games online that sell directly and they have secure payment. Just because someone doesn't use paypal to receive payments doesn't mean it isn't secure. Have you ever bought airline tickts online through travelocity, cheaptickets, etc? They don't use paypal, but 1000's of people buy tickets through them every month. The issue is how much money would have to be spent for GLB to have its own secure payment system and does development feel it is worth it.


Agreed.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Rage Kinard
POINT 1

Q: Why is it illegal to offer to offer fp as part of a contract offer?

A: Because it is unfair to those owners who can't afford to pay for the FP of other players.

Q: Then why is it fair for an owner to be able to build 100 players and put the best 40 on his own team, and farm out the others, or sign and sell them to other teams?

A: Because that is one person paying for their own players, and they buy a lot of fp which goes a long way to supporting GLB

Q: How is that fair to owners that can't afford to spend enough money to stock their own team and boost every player?

A: It isn't, but owners who create 40 players pay for that advantage. If you can not afford to pay for that advantage, you have to go out and try and recruit other players who are willing to boost every season.

Q: So what is the difference between having an unfair advantage because you can afford to create and boost 40 players, and having an unfair advantage because you can afford to pay for someone else's player with a good build to boost?

A: ???


POINT 2
Q: How are you going to stop people from offering to pay for someone else's fp to boost?
A: If it is in PM or message board history.

Q: What if the offer is made through an outside source?
A: It can't be verified that the offer was actually made so nothing will be done about it.

Q: So only stupid people who are obvious about it in GLB are going to be busted, meanwhile most people who have the intelligence needed to be able to afford to do this will never get caught?
A: Correct

Q: So why is this rule in place
A: ????




100% correct
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Intimnasc
Originally posted by SteelersInsider

Originally posted by ry31


Its not against the rules to buy flex points for guys on your team though? Just when signing guys?


How can you distinguish between someone "on your team" and a "FA". Techincally the FA would have to be "on your team" before getting the FP's anyway.

Personally, I would like to see all FP's transactions monitored and outlawed unless you are buying them for your own use.

Otherwise, what are you going to have....a rule that says they have to be on your team for X number of days before you can buy them flex points?

Do we make a special rule for some people (oh - that person is my brother/cousin/buddy from work..... so it's ok for me to buy them)?


I don't care what the rule is, but make it uniform and equal for everyone. The first step of that is to make in KNOWN which is what this thread is attempting to do.

Let's just make it clear that no FP's can be purchased for another player for any reason.....



This don't work either my son and I play on separate acounts in the same house and I buy FP for both accounts.


It wouldn't work for YOU, but if the site wants to crack down on people who buy points for other people, then there is no way they can differentiate between you and your son and 2 guys who don't know either other at all. That is my point.

Either have to allow both or neither. It is too hard to try to determine "intent".... and that is really what they are doing.
 
yello1
Preacher
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
And that is actually another way to catch people with multiple accounts. All of them would be linked together by the name on the payment.

Get rid of paypal altogether have have the payments go directly to GLB.

Problem solved. Right?


Given the haxxoring issues not too long ago, I am happy about the paypal use myself.

 
Link
 
Originally posted by oldskool
Originally posted by norsemanvike

Originally posted by SteelersInsider


All he has to say is: "so and so offered me flex points over yahoo to come to the team and I didn't get them. Ban him!"



Stop leaving loopholes!


Of all the problems with this policy, *THIS* is the biggest one.

They just made a way for any unhappy player to get out of his contract at *any* time. All they need to do now is to send the owner an email saying, "I'm going to tell them that you promised me flex points to sign" or "I'm going to tell them that you paid for my flex points to sign with you.........so....RELEASE ME NOW!"

Owners will be getting banned left and right.....

The power between owner and player has just taken a HUUUUUUUUUGE swing towards the players having all the power now.

SMART players will now sign with a team and then wait to be on the team to ask for flex points (because the mod said it is OK then).....then if the owner doesn't buy them flex points, then they demand to be released....then sign with another owner...and repeat the process. GUARANTEED way to get your flex points paid for.

All it would take is 2 unhappy players out of 50 and they could conspire to get an owner permantly banned.

Last edited Jul 12, 2008 15:52:05
 
Link
 
Originally posted by yello1
Originally posted by SteelersInsider

And that is actually another way to catch people with multiple accounts. All of them would be linked together by the name on the payment.

Get rid of paypal altogether have have the payments go directly to GLB.

Problem solved. Right?


Given the haxxoring issues not too long ago, I am happy about the paypal use myself.



Any system can be broken into (including paypal). Monster.com had their system broken into and they didn't even have the balls to tell their customers that it was broken into.

Many sites have lost credit info and just not reported. Just because you have a number doesn't mean you can do a whole lot with it. If the site just immediately erased the credit card numbers coming in, it would be safe.

Anytime you pay for a meal at TGIF or Applebees or buy a drink at any bar on your credit card, you just gave 10 people access to have all that info.

And if it is proven that you didn't make those purchases anyway, then you don't have to pay it. So I don't even worry about it. If you want to take my credit card and risk 5-10 years in jail.....then go for it.

The super high rates that many people pay on their credit card covers all the lost and fraudulent purchases....

 
oldskool
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
Originally posted by oldskool
Originally posted by norsemanvike
Originally posted by SteelersInsider

All he has to say is: "so and so offered me flex points over yahoo to come to the team and I didn't get them. Ban him!"


Stop leaving loopholes!

Of all the problems with this policy, *THIS* is the biggest one.

They just made a way for any unhappy player to get out of his contract at *any* time. All they need to do now is to send the owner an email saying, "I'm going to tell them that you promised me flex points to sign" or "I'm going to tell them that you paid for my flex points to sign with you.........so....RELEASE ME NOW!"

Owners will be getting banned left and right.....

The power between owner and player has just taken a HUUUUUUUUUGE swing towards the players having all the power now.

SMART players will now sign with a team and then wait to be on the team to ask for flex points (because the mod said it is OK then).....then if the owner doesn't buy them flex points, then they demand to be released....then sign with another owner...and repeat the process. GUARANTEED way to get your flex points paid for.

All it would take is 2 unhappy players out of 50 and they could conspire to get an owner permantly banned.


1) If it was done outside the game, as you yourself stated, they can't do anything about it. They don't have authority to get logs from instant messengers or email clients, and their use is inadmissible due to tampering by whoever "supplies" it.

2) norsemanvike edited his post, and then edited mine (which is the one you quoted). Originally he summarized what I said in point one, but when morgan3 and myself called him on it he revoked his statement and struck it from the record so he wouldn't look foolish.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by oldskool
Originally posted by SteelersInsider

Originally posted by oldskool

Originally posted by norsemanvike

Originally posted by SteelersInsider


All he has to say is: "so and so offered me flex points over yahoo to come to the team and I didn't get them. Ban him!"


Stop leaving loopholes!

Of all the problems with this policy, *THIS* is the biggest one.

They just made a way for any unhappy player to get out of his contract at *any* time. All they need to do now is to send the owner an email saying, "I'm going to tell them that you promised me flex points to sign" or "I'm going to tell them that you paid for my flex points to sign with you.........so....RELEASE ME NOW!"

Owners will be getting banned left and right.....

The power between owner and player has just taken a HUUUUUUUUUGE swing towards the players having all the power now.

SMART players will now sign with a team and then wait to be on the team to ask for flex points (because the mod said it is OK then).....then if the owner doesn't buy them flex points, then they demand to be released....then sign with another owner...and repeat the process. GUARANTEED way to get your flex points paid for.

All it would take is 2 unhappy players out of 50 and they could conspire to get an owner permantly banned.


1) If it was done outside the game, as you yourself stated, they can't do anything about it. They don't have authority to get logs from instant messengers or email clients, and their use is inadmissible due to tampering by whoever "supplies" it.

2) norsemanvike edited his post, and then edited mine (which is the one you quoted). Originally he summarized what I said in point one, but when morgan3 and myself called him on it he revoked his statement and struck it from the record so he wouldn't look foolish.


I dunno. Since this policy was a witchhunt to get me.... I bet that all it would take is a couple of accusations against me and I would be banned. Proof or not....
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.